Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1707.08830 · Physical review. B./Physical review. B

Surprising robustness of particle-hole symmetry for composite-fermion liquids

G. J. Sreejith, Yuhe Zhang, Jainendra K. Jain

Published Sep 25, 2017• 20 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We report on fixed phase diffusion Monte Carlo calculations that show that, even for a large amount of Landau level mixing, the energies of the Pfaffian and anti-Pfaffian phases remain very nearly the same, as also do the excitation gaps at $1/3$ and $2/3$. These results, combined with previous theoretical and experimental investigations, indicate that particle hole (PH) symmetry for fully spin polarized composite fermion states is much more robust than a priori expected, emerging even in models that explicitly break PH symmetry. We provide insight into this fact by showing that the low energy physics of a generic repulsive 3-body interaction is captured, to a large extent and over a range of filling factors, by a mean field approximation that maps it into a PH symmetric 2-body interaction. This explains why Landau level mixing, which effectively generates such a generic 3-body interaction, is inefficient in breaking PH symmetry. As a byproduct, our results provide a systematic construction of a 2-body interaction which produces, to a good approximation, the Pfaffian wave function as its ground state.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.96.125149

Related papers

Is the composite fermion a dirac particle?

Dam Thanh Son

We propose a particle-hole symmetric theory of the Fermi-liquid ground state of a half-filled Landau level. This theory should be applicable for a Dirac fermion in the magnetic field at charge neutrality, as well as for the v = 1/2 quantum Hall ground state of nonrelativistic fermions in the limit of negligible inter-Landau-level mixing. We argue that when particle-hole symmetry is exact, the composite fermion is a massless Dirac fermion, characterized by a Berry phase of π around the Fermi circle. We write down a tentative effective field theory of such a fermion and discuss the discrete symmetries, in particular, C P. The Dirac composite fermions interact through a gauge, but non-Chern-Simons, interaction. The particle-hole conjugate pair of Jain-sequence states at filling factors n/(2n + 1) and (n + 1)/(2n + 1), which in the conventional composite fermion picture corresponds to integer quantum Hall states with different filling factors, n and n + 1, is now mapped to the same half-integer filling factor n + 1/2 of the Dirac composite fermion. The Pfaffian and anti-Pfaffian states are interpreted as d -wave Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer paired states of the Dirac fermion with orbital angular momentum of opposite signs, while s -wave pairing would give rise to a particle-hole symmetric non-Abelian gapped phase. When particle-hole symmetry is not exact, the Dirac fermion has a C P -breaking mass. The conventional fermionic Chern-Simons theory is shown to emerge in the nonrelativistic limit of the massive theory.

•Jan 1, 2015•398 citations

Numerical exploration of trial wave functions for the particle-hole-symmetric Pfaffian

Ryan V. Mishmash, David F. Mross, Jason Alicea +1 more

We numerically assess model wave functions for the recently proposed particle-hole-symmetric Pfaffian (``PH-Pfaffian'') topological order, a phase consistent with the recently reported thermal Hall conductance [M. Banerjee et al., Nature 559, 205 (2018)] at the ever enigmatic $\ensuremath{\nu}=5/2$ quantum Hall plateau. We find that the most natural Moore-Read-inspired trial state for the PH-Pfaffian, when projected into the lowest Landau level, exhibits a remarkable numerical similarity on accessible system sizes with the corresponding (compressible) composite Fermi liquid. Consequently, this PH-Pfaffian trial state performs reasonably well energetically in the half-filled lowest Landau level, but is likely not a good starting point for understanding the $\ensuremath{\nu}=5/2$ ground state. Our results suggest that the PH-Pfaffian model wave function either encodes anomalously weak $p$-wave pairing of composite fermions or fails to represent a gapped, incompressible phase altogether.

arXiv:1804.01107•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Aug 10, 2018•45 citations

Paired states at 5/2: Particle-hole Pfaffian and particle-hole symmetry breaking

L. Antonić, J. Vučičević, Milica V. Milovanović

We study Cooper pairing in the Dirac composite fermion (CF) system. The presence of the mass term in the Dirac CF description (which may simulate Landau level mixing), i.e., breaking of particle-hole (PH) symmetry in this system, is a necessary condition for the existence of a PH Pfaffian-like topological state. In the scope of the random-phase approximation (RPA) and hydrodynamic approach, we find some signatures of pairing at finite frequencies. Motivated by this insight, we extend our analysis to the case of a different but still Dirac quasiparticle (CF) representation, appropriate in the presence of a mass term, and discuss the likelihood of PH Pfaffian and Pfaffian pairings in general. On the basis of gauge field effects, we find for a small Dirac mass, an anti-Pfaffian or Pfaffian instability depending on the sign of mass, while for large mass (Landau level mixing), irrespective of its sign, we find a PH Pfaffian-like instability.

arXiv:1807.09428•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Sep 5, 2018•30 citations

Particle-hole symmetry for composite fermions: An emergent symmetry in the fractional quantum Hall effect

Ajit Coimbatore Balram, Jainendra K. Jain

The particle-hole (PH) symmetry of electrons is an exact symmetry of the electronic Hamiltonian confined to a specific Landau level, and its interplay with the formation of composite fermions has attracted much attention of late. We investigate an emergent symmetry in the fractional quantum Hall effect, namely, the PH symmetry of composite fermions, which relates states at composite fermion filling factors ${\ensuremath{\nu}}^{*}=n+\overline{\ensuremath{\nu}}$ and ${\ensuremath{\nu}}^{*}=n+1\ensuremath{-}\overline{\ensuremath{\nu}}$, where the integer $n$ is the $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Lambda}}$-level index and $0\ensuremath{\le}\overline{\ensuremath{\nu}}\ensuremath{\le}1$. Detailed calculations using the microscopic theory of composite fermions demonstrate the following for low-lying $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Lambda}}$ levels (small $n$): (i) The two-body interaction between composite-fermion particles is very similar, apart from a constant additive term and an overall scale factor, to that between composite-fermion holes in the same $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Lambda}}$ level; and (ii) the three-body interaction for composite fermions is an order of magnitude smaller than the two-body interaction. Taken together, these results imply an approximate PH symmetry for composite fermions in low $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Lambda}}$ levels, which is also supported by exact-diagonalization studies and available experiments. This symmetry, which relates states at electron filling factors $\ensuremath{\nu}=\frac{n+\overline{\ensuremath{\nu}}}{2(n+\overline{\ensuremath{\nu}})\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}1}$ and $\ensuremath{\nu}=\frac{n+1\ensuremath{-}\overline{\ensuremath{\nu}}}{2(n+1\ensuremath{-}\overline{\ensuremath{\nu}})\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}1}$, is not present in the original Hamiltonian and owes its existence entirely to the formation of composite fermions. With increasing $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Lambda}}$-level index, the two-body and three-body pseudopotentials become comparable, but at the same time they both diminish in magnitude, indicating that the interaction between composite fermions becomes weak as we approach $\ensuremath{\nu}=1/2$.

arXiv:1711.01771•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Dec 29, 2017•18 citations

Particle-hole-symmetric model for a paired fractional quantum Hall state in a half-filled Landau level

William Hutzel, John J. McCord, Peter Raum +4 more

The fractional quantum Hall effect (FQHE) observed at half filling of the second Landau level is believed to be caused by a pairing of composite fermions captured by the Moore-Read Pfaffian wave function. The generating Hamiltonian for the Moore-Read Pfaffian is a purely three-body model that breaks particle-hole symmetry and lacks other properties, such as dominate two-body repulsive interactions, expected from a physical model of the FQHE. We use exact diagonalization to study the low-energy states of a more physical two-body generator model derived from the three-body model. We find that the two-body model exhibits the essential features expected from the Moore-Read Pfaffian: pairing, non-Abelian anyon excitations, and a neutral fermion mode. The model also satisfies constraints expected for a physical model of the FQHE at half-filling because it is short range, spatially decaying, particle-hole symmetric, and supports a roton mode with a robust spectral gap in the thermodynamic limit. Hence, this two-body model offers a bridge between artificial three-body generator models for paired states and the physical Coulomb interaction and can be used to further explore properties of non-Abelian physics in the FQHE.

arXiv:1811.02646•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Jan 14, 2019•10 citations

Stabilization of the Particle-Hole Pfaffian Order by Landau-Level Mixing and Impurities That Break Particle-Hole Symmetry

Philip Zucker, Dima E. Feldman

Numerical results suggest that the quantum Hall effect at ν=5/2 is described by the Pfaffian or anti-Pfaffian state in the absence of disorder and Landau-level mixing. Those states are incompatible with the observed transport properties of GaAs heterostructures, where disorder and Landau-level mixing are strong. We show that the recent proposal of a particle-hole (PH)-Pfaffian topological order by Son is consistent with all experiments. The absence of particle-hole symmetry at ν=5/2 is not an obstacle to the existence of the PH-Pfaffian order since the order is robust to symmetry breaking.

arXiv:1603.03754•Physical Review Letters•Aug 22, 2016•109 citations
We report on fixed phase diffusion Monte Carlo calculations that show that, even for a large amount of Landau level mixing, the energies of the Pfaffian and anti-Pfaffian phases remain very nearly the same, as also do the excitation gaps at 1/31/31/3 and 2/32/32/3. These results, combined with previous theoretical and experimental investigations, indicate that particle hole (PH) symmetry for fully spin polarized composite fermion states is much more robust than a priori expected, emerging even in models that explicitly break PH symmetry. We provide insight into this fact by showing that the low energy physics of a generic repulsive 3-body interaction is captured, to a large extent and over a range of filling factors, by a mean field approximation that maps it into a PH symmetric 2-body interaction. This explains why Landau level mixing, which effectively generates such a generic 3-body interaction, is inefficient in breaking PH symmetry. As a byproduct, our results provide a systematic construction of a 2-body interaction which produces, to a good approximation, the Pfaffian wave function as its ground state.
We propose a particle-hole symmetric theory of the Fermi-liquid ground state of a half-filled Landau level. This theory should be applicable for a Dirac fermion in the magnetic field at charge neutrality, as well as for the v = 1/2 quantum Hall ground state of nonrelativistic fermions in the limit of negligible inter-Landau-level mixing. We argue that when particle-hole symmetry is exact, the composite fermion is a massless Dirac fermion, characterized by a Berry phase of π around the Fermi circle. We write down a tentative effective field theory of such a fermion and discuss the discrete symmetries, in particular, C P. The Dirac composite fermions interact through a gauge, but non-Chern-Simons, interaction. The particle-hole conjugate pair of Jain-sequence states at filling factors n/(2n + 1) and (n + 1)/(2n + 1), which in the conventional composite fermion picture corresponds to integer quantum Hall states with different filling factors, n and n + 1, is now mapped to the same half-integer filling factor n + 1/2 of the Dirac composite fermion. The Pfaffian and anti-Pfaffian states are interpreted as d -wave Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer paired states of the Dirac fermion with orbital angular momentum of opposite signs, while s -wave pairing would give rise to a particle-hole symmetric non-Abelian gapped phase. When particle-hole symmetry is not exact, the Dirac fermion has a C P -breaking mass. The conventional fermionic Chern-Simons theory is shown to emerge in the nonrelativistic limit of the massive theory.
We numerically assess model wave functions for the recently proposed particle-hole-symmetric Pfaffian (``PH-Pfaffian'') topological order, a phase consistent with the recently reported thermal Hall conductance [M. Banerjee et al., Nature 559, 205 (2018)] at the ever enigmatic $\ensuremath{\nu}=5/2$ quantum Hall plateau. We find that the most natural Moore-Read-inspired trial state for the PH-Pfaffian, when projected into the lowest Landau level, exhibits a remarkable numerical similarity on accessible system sizes with the corresponding (compressible) composite Fermi liquid. Consequently, this PH-Pfaffian trial state performs reasonably well energetically in the half-filled lowest Landau level, but is likely not a good starting point for understanding the $\ensuremath{\nu}=5/2$ ground state. Our results suggest that the PH-Pfaffian model wave function either encodes anomalously weak ppp-wave pairing of composite fermions or fails to represent a gapped, incompressible phase altogether.
We study Cooper pairing in the Dirac composite fermion (CF) system. The presence of the mass term in the Dirac CF description (which may simulate Landau level mixing), i.e., breaking of particle-hole (PH) symmetry in this system, is a necessary condition for the existence of a PH Pfaffian-like topological state. In the scope of the random-phase approximation (RPA) and hydrodynamic approach, we find some signatures of pairing at finite frequencies. Motivated by this insight, we extend our analysis to the case of a different but still Dirac quasiparticle (CF) representation, appropriate in the presence of a mass term, and discuss the likelihood of PH Pfaffian and Pfaffian pairings in general. On the basis of gauge field effects, we find for a small Dirac mass, an anti-Pfaffian or Pfaffian instability depending on the sign of mass, while for large mass (Landau level mixing), irrespective of its sign, we find a PH Pfaffian-like instability.
The particle-hole (PH) symmetry of electrons is an exact symmetry of the electronic Hamiltonian confined to a specific Landau level, and its interplay with the formation of composite fermions has attracted much attention of late. We investigate an emergent symmetry in the fractional quantum Hall effect, namely, the PH symmetry of composite fermions, which relates states at composite fermion filling factors ${\ensuremath{\nu}}^{*}=n+\overline{\ensuremath{\nu}}$ and ${\ensuremath{\nu}}^{*}=n+1\ensuremath{-}\overline{\ensuremath{\nu}}$, where the integer nnn is the $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Lambda}}$-level index and $0\ensuremath{\le}\overline{\ensuremath{\nu}}\ensuremath{\le}1$. Detailed calculations using the microscopic theory of composite fermions demonstrate the following for low-lying $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Lambda}}$ levels (small nnn): (i) The two-body interaction between composite-fermion particles is very similar, apart from a constant additive term and an overall scale factor, to that between composite-fermion holes in the same $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Lambda}}$ level; and (ii) the three-body interaction for composite fermions is an order of magnitude smaller than the two-body interaction. Taken together, these results imply an approximate PH symmetry for composite fermions in low $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Lambda}}$ levels, which is also supported by exact-diagonalization studies and available experiments. This symmetry, which relates states at electron filling factors $\ensuremath{\nu}=\frac{n+\overline{\ensuremath{\nu}}}{2(n+\overline{\ensuremath{\nu}})\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}1}$ and $\ensuremath{\nu}=\frac{n+1\ensuremath{-}\overline{\ensuremath{\nu}}}{2(n+1\ensuremath{-}\overline{\ensuremath{\nu}})\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}1}$, is not present in the original Hamiltonian and owes its existence entirely to the formation of composite fermions. With increasing $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Lambda}}$-level index, the two-body and three-body pseudopotentials become comparable, but at the same time they both diminish in magnitude, indicating that the interaction between composite fermions becomes weak as we approach $\ensuremath{\nu}=1/2$.
The fractional quantum Hall effect (FQHE) observed at half filling of the second Landau level is believed to be caused by a pairing of composite fermions captured by the Moore-Read Pfaffian wave function. The generating Hamiltonian for the Moore-Read Pfaffian is a purely three-body model that breaks particle-hole symmetry and lacks other properties, such as dominate two-body repulsive interactions, expected from a physical model of the FQHE. We use exact diagonalization to study the low-energy states of a more physical two-body generator model derived from the three-body model. We find that the two-body model exhibits the essential features expected from the Moore-Read Pfaffian: pairing, non-Abelian anyon excitations, and a neutral fermion mode. The model also satisfies constraints expected for a physical model of the FQHE at half-filling because it is short range, spatially decaying, particle-hole symmetric, and supports a roton mode with a robust spectral gap in the thermodynamic limit. Hence, this two-body model offers a bridge between artificial three-body generator models for paired states and the physical Coulomb interaction and can be used to further explore properties of non-Abelian physics in the FQHE.
Numerical results suggest that the quantum Hall effect at ν=5/2 is described by the Pfaffian or anti-Pfaffian state in the absence of disorder and Landau-level mixing. Those states are incompatible with the observed transport properties of GaAs heterostructures, where disorder and Landau-level mixing are strong. We show that the recent proposal of a particle-hole (PH)-Pfaffian topological order by Son is consistent with all experiments. The absence of particle-hole symmetry at ν=5/2 is not an obstacle to the existence of the PH-Pfaffian order since the order is robust to symmetry breaking.