Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1707.06910 · American Journal of Physics

Twelve years before the quantum no-cloning theorem

Juan Ortigoso

Published Feb 20, 2018• 57 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The celebrated quantum no-cloning theorem establishes the impossibility of making a perfect copy of an unknown quantum state. The discovery of this important theorem for the field of quantum information is currently dated 1982. I show here that an article published in 1970 [J. L. Park, Found. Phys. 1, 23–33 (1970)] contained an explicit mathematical proof of the impossibility of cloning quantum states. I analyze Park's demonstration in the light of published explanations concerning the genesis of the better-known papers on no-cloning.

DOI
10.1119/1.5021356

Related papers

The no-cloning theorem

William K. Wootters, Wojciech Hubert Zurek

People gather, copy, and distribute information all the time. But in the quantum world, the laws of physics impose a severe restriction on copying: It is impossible to make a perfect copy of an unknown state.

Physics Today•Apr 1, 2025•4 citations

The no-cloning theorem

William K. Wootters, Wojciech Hubert Zurek

People gather, copy, and distribute information all the time. But in the quantum world, the laws of physics impose a severe restriction on copying: It is impossible to make a perfect copy of an unknown state.

Physics Today•Feb 1, 2009•115 citations

Questioning the correctness of quantum no-cloning theorem

Yong Wang

The paper queries correctness of quantum no-cloning theorem that is very imporant in the quantum information technology and the whole quantum mechanics.The proof of quantum no-cloning theorem is very simple and it can’t exclude all kinds of possible cloning.Some parts of the proof are doubtful and not very clearly proved.While quantum mechanics is very complex and not completely known,the principle of complementarity shows that it is incorrect to explain everything in a simple way.The development of science tells us many things such as measurement and copy of a particle that are thought to be impossible in a stage,may be possible when the more profound,precise and tiny characteristics is found out.If it is possible to measure in an indirect way that can’t change the measured quantum state,the quantum cloning is possible.The wave-particle duality and uncertainty relation in quantum mechanics are very hard to imagine,but they are very similar to the phenomenon of the society and human in which copy and cloning is possible.If the quantum state has something like gene,it is possible to cloning a quantum state.

Infrared and Laser Engineering•Jan 1, 2007•1 citation

Quantum cloning

Valerio Scarani, S. Iblisdir, Nicolas Gisin +1 more

The impossibility of perfectly copying (or cloning) an unknown quantum state is one of the basic rules governing the physics of quantum systems. The processes that perform the optimal approximate cloning have been found in many cases. These ``quantum cloning machines'' are important tools for studying a wide variety of tasks, e.g., state estimation and eavesdropping on quantum cryptography. This paper provides a comprehensive review of quantum cloning machines both for discrete-dimensional and for continuous-variable quantum systems. In addition, it presents the role of cloning in quantum cryptography, the link between optimal cloning and light amplification via stimulated emission, and the experimental demonstrations of optimal quantum cloning.

arXiv:quant-ph/0511088•Reviews of Modern Physics•Nov 8, 2005•615 citations

No-cloning with unitary scaling

Dafa Li

It is known that the classical information like strings of bits can be copied. In 1982, Wootters and Zurek proposed the quantum no-cloning principle. No-cloning principle says that it is impossible to make an identical copy of an arbitrary unknown quantum pure state by using unitary evolution. In this paper, we call U $|ψ>$, where U is any unitary operator, a U-copy of the state $|ψ>$ and show it is impossible to make a U-copy of an arbitrary unknown quantum pure state by using unitary evolution.

quant-pharXiv:2604.22960•Apr 28, 2026•0 citations

Universal quantum cloning beyond noncontextual theory

Min Namkung, Hyang-Tag Lim

Quantum theory fundamentally forbids the perfect copying of an arbitrary unknown quantum state, according to a principle known as the no-cloning theorem. Nevertheless, it is possible to construct a deterministic quantum map that produces multiple approximate copies of an unknown quantum state. This task is referred to as universal quantum cloning, further facilitating numerous quantum technologies such as quantum cryptography and quantum communication. In this work, we theoretically verify that the universal quantum cloning cannot be realized within a noncontextual theory, highlighting its intrinsically nonclassical nature. Our verification first {focuses on revealing that} $1\rightarrow2$ cloning scenario {is fully contextual}, and {further covers general examples to observe the contextual behavior of} $N\rightarrow M$ scenario. We believe that our results regarding quantum cloning serve a key role for understanding both quantum foundation and application.

quant-pharXiv:2607.05959•Jul 8, 2026•0 citations
The celebrated quantum no-cloning theorem establishes the impossibility of making a perfect copy of an unknown quantum state. The discovery of this important theorem for the field of quantum information is currently dated 1982. I show here that an article published in 1970 [J. L. Park, Found. Phys. 1, 23–33 (1970)] contained an explicit mathematical proof of the impossibility of cloning quantum states. I analyze Park's demonstration in the light of published explanations concerning the genesis of the better-known papers on no-cloning.
The paper queries correctness of quantum no-cloning theorem that is very imporant in the quantum information technology and the whole quantum mechanics.The proof of quantum no-cloning theorem is very simple and it can’t exclude all kinds of possible cloning.Some parts of the proof are doubtful and not very clearly proved.While quantum mechanics is very complex and not completely known,the principle of complementarity shows that it is incorrect to explain everything in a simple way.The development of science tells us many things such as measurement and copy of a particle that are thought to be impossible in a stage,may be possible when the more profound,precise and tiny characteristics is found out.If it is possible to measure in an indirect way that can’t change the measured quantum state,the quantum cloning is possible.The wave-particle duality and uncertainty relation in quantum mechanics are very hard to imagine,but they are very similar to the phenomenon of the society and human in which copy and cloning is possible.If the quantum state has something like gene,it is possible to cloning a quantum state.
The impossibility of perfectly copying (or cloning) an unknown quantum state is one of the basic rules governing the physics of quantum systems. The processes that perform the optimal approximate cloning have been found in many cases. These ``quantum cloning machines'' are important tools for studying a wide variety of tasks, e.g., state estimation and eavesdropping on quantum cryptography. This paper provides a comprehensive review of quantum cloning machines both for discrete-dimensional and for continuous-variable quantum systems. In addition, it presents the role of cloning in quantum cryptography, the link between optimal cloning and light amplification via stimulated emission, and the experimental demonstrations of optimal quantum cloning.
It is known that the classical information like strings of bits can be copied. In 1982, Wootters and Zurek proposed the quantum no-cloning principle. No-cloning principle says that it is impossible to make an identical copy of an arbitrary unknown quantum pure state by using unitary evolution. In this paper, we call U ∣ψ>|ψ>∣ψ>, where U is any unitary operator, a U-copy of the state ∣ψ>|ψ>∣ψ> and show it is impossible to make a U-copy of an arbitrary unknown quantum pure state by using unitary evolution.
Quantum theory fundamentally forbids the perfect copying of an arbitrary unknown quantum state, according to a principle known as the no-cloning theorem. Nevertheless, it is possible to construct a deterministic quantum map that produces multiple approximate copies of an unknown quantum state. This task is referred to as universal quantum cloning, further facilitating numerous quantum technologies such as quantum cryptography and quantum communication. In this work, we theoretically verify that the universal quantum cloning cannot be realized within a noncontextual theory, highlighting its intrinsically nonclassical nature. Our verification first {focuses on revealing that} 1→21\rightarrow21→2 cloning scenario {is fully contextual}, and {further covers general examples to observe the contextual behavior of} N→MN\rightarrow MN→M scenario. We believe that our results regarding quantum cloning serve a key role for understanding both quantum foundation and application.