Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1706.01568 · SciPost Physics

Bulk Renormalization Group Flows and Boundary States in Conformal Field Theories

John Cardy

Published Aug 12, 2017• 52 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We propose using smeared boundary states e^{-\tau H}|\cal B\rangle as variational approximations to the ground state of a conformal field theory deformed by relevant bulk operators. This is motivated by recent studies of quantum quenches in CFTs and of the entanglement spectrum in massive theories. It gives a simple criterion for choosing which boundary state should correspond to which combination of bulk operators, and leads to a rudimentary phase diagram of the theory in the vicinity of the RG fixed point corresponding to the CFT, as well as rigorous upper bounds on the universal amplitude of the free energy. In the case of the 2d minimal models explicit formulae are available. As a side result we show that the matrix elements of bulk operators between smeared Ishibashi states are simply given by the fusion rules of the CFT.

DOI
10.21468/scipostphys.3.2.011

Related papers

Entropy of conformal perturbation defects

Anatoly Konechny, Cornelius Schmidt-Colinet

We consider perturbation defects obtained by perturbing a 2D conformal field theory (CFT) by a relevant operator on a half-plane.If the perturbed bulk theory flows to an infrared fixed point described by another CFT, the defect flows to a conformal defect between the ultraviolet and infrared fixed point CFTs.For short bulk renormalization group flows connecting two fixed points which are close in theory space we find a universal perturbative formula for the boundary entropy of the corresponding conformal perturbation defect.We compare the value of the boundary entropy that our formula gives for the flows between nearby Virasoro minimal models  m with the boundary entropy of the defect constructed by Gaiotto (2012 J. High Energy Phys. JHEP12(2012) 103) and find a match at the first two orders in the m 1 expansion.

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Nov 11, 2014•12 citations

RG boundaries and Cardy’s variational ansatz for multiple perturbations

Anatoly Konechny

Abstract We consider perturbations of 2D CFTs by multiple relevant operators. The massive phases of such perturbations can be labeled by conformal boundary conditions. Cardy’s variational ansatz approximates the vacuum state of the perturbed theory by a smeared conformal boundary state. In this paper we study the limitations and propose generalisations of this ansatz using both analytic and numerical insights based on TCSA. In particular we analyse the stability of Cardy’s ansatz states with respect to boundary relevant perturbations using bulk-boundary OPE coefficients. We show that certain transitions between the massive phases arise from a pair of boundary RG flows. The RG flows start from the conformal boundary on the transition surface and end on those that lie on the two sides of it. As an example we work out the details of the phase diagram for the Ising field theory and for the tricritical Ising model perturbed by the leading thermal and magnetic fields. For the latter we find a pair of novel transition lines that correspond to pairs of RG flows. Although the mass gap remains finite at the transition lines, several one-point functions change their behaviour. We discuss how these lines fit into the standard phase diagram of the tricritical Ising model. We show that each line extends to a two-dimensional surface ξσ,c in a three coupling space when we add perturbations by the subleading magnetic field. Close to this surface we locate symmetry breaking critical lines leading to the critical Ising model. Near the critical lines we find first order phase transition lines describing two-phase coexistence regions as predicted in Landau theory. The surface ξσ,c is determined from the CFT data using Cardy’s ansatz and its properties are checked using TCSA numerics.

arXiv:2306.13719•Journal of High Energy Physics•Nov 2, 2023•7 citations

Entropy of conformal perturbation defects

Anatoly Konechny, Cornelius Schmidt-Colinet

We consider perturbation defects obtained by perturbing a 2D conformal field theory (CFT) by a relevant operator on a half-plane. If the perturbed bulk theory flows to an infrared fixed point described by another CFT, the defect flows to a conformal defect between the ultraviolet and infrared fixed point CFTs. For short bulk renormalization group flows connecting two fixed points which are close in theory space we find a universal perturbative formula for the boundary entropy of the corresponding conformal perturbation defect. We compare the value of the boundary entropy that our formula gives for the flows between nearby Virasoro minimal models Mm with the boundary entropy of the defect constructed by Gaiotto in [1] and find a match at the first two orders in the 1/m expansion.

arXiv:1407.6444•Jul 24, 2014•3 citations

Gauging or extending bulk and boundary conformal field theories: Application to bulk and domain wall problem in topological matter and their descriptions by mock modular covariant

Yoshiki Fukusumi

We formulate the ${Z}_{N}$ group gauging operations (or group extensions) in (smeared) boundary conformal field theories (BCFTs) and bulk conformal field theories, and study their applications to various phenomena in topologically ordered systems. We apply the resultant theories to analyze the correspondence between the renormalization group (RG) flow of CFTs and the classification of topological quantum field theories using the testable information of general classes of partition functions. One can obtain the bulk topological properties of the $2+1$ dimensional topological ordered phase corresponding to the massive RG flow of the $1+1$ dimensional systems equivalent to the smeared BCFT. We present an obstruction to mass condensation for the smeared BCFT analogous to the Lieb-Shultz-Mattis theorem for noninvertible symmetry. Corresponding to the bulk topological degeneracies in $2+1$ dimensions and gapped quantum phases in $1+1$ dimensions, we construct a new series of BCFT. We also study the implications of the massless RG flow of the $1+1$ dimensional CFTs corresponding to the domain wall or coupling problem in $2+1$ dimensional topological orders, which corresponds to the earlier proposal by L. Kong and H. Zheng [Nucl. Phys. B 966, 115384 (2021)] closely related to the integer-spin simple current by Schellekens and Gato-Rivera. We reveal that two distinct kinds of massless RG flow exist, coming from anomaly cancellation and anomaly matching related to Witt equivalence of bulk CFTs. The anomaly cancellation flows produce a new series of modular invariants as coupled models, and the anomaly matching flows produce nontrivial domain walls changing the chirality of anyons. Our paper gives a unified direction for future theoretical and numerical studies of the topological phase based on the established data of classifications of conformal field theories or modular invariants (and the corresponding category theories).

arXiv:2412.19577•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Aug 8, 2025•5 citations

A bootstrap study of minimal model deformations

António Antunes, Edoardo Lauria, Balt C. van Rees

For QFTs in AdS the boundary correlation functions remain conformal even if the bulk theory has a scale. This allows one to constrain RG flows with numerical conformal bootstrap methods. We apply this idea to flows between two-dimensional CFTs, focusing on deformations of the tricritical and ordinary Ising model. We provide non-perturbative constraints for the boundary correlation functions of these flows and compare them with conformal perturbation theory in the vicinity of the fixed points. We also reproduce a completely general constraint on the sign of the $T\bar T$ deformation in two dimensions.

arXiv:2401.06818•Journal of High Energy Physics•Jan 1, 2023•1 citation

A bootstrap study of minimal model deformations

António Antunes, Edoardo Lauria, Balt C. van Rees

A bstract For QFTs in AdS the boundary correlation functions remain conformal even if the bulk theory has a scale. This allows one to constrain RG flows with numerical conformal bootstrap methods. We apply this idea to flows between two-dimensional CFTs, focusing on deformations of the tricritical and ordinary Ising model. We provide non-perturbative constraints for the boundary correlation functions of these flows and compare them with conformal perturbation theory in the vicinity of the fixed points. We also reproduce a completely general constraint on the sign of the $$T\overline{T }$$ deformation in two dimensions.

Journal of High Energy Physics•May 3, 2024•7 citations
We propose using smeared boundary states e^{-\tau H}|\cal B\rangle as variational approximations to the ground state of a conformal field theory deformed by relevant bulk operators. This is motivated by recent studies of quantum quenches in CFTs and of the entanglement spectrum in massive theories. It gives a simple criterion for choosing which boundary state should correspond to which combination of bulk operators, and leads to a rudimentary phase diagram of the theory in the vicinity of the RG fixed point corresponding to the CFT, as well as rigorous upper bounds on the universal amplitude of the free energy. In the case of the 2d minimal models explicit formulae are available. As a side result we show that the matrix elements of bulk operators between smeared Ishibashi states are simply given by the fusion rules of the CFT.
We consider perturbation defects obtained by perturbing a 2D conformal field theory (CFT) by a relevant operator on a half-plane.If the perturbed bulk theory flows to an infrared fixed point described by another CFT, the defect flows to a conformal defect between the ultraviolet and infrared fixed point CFTs.For short bulk renormalization group flows connecting two fixed points which are close in theory space we find a universal perturbative formula for the boundary entropy of the corresponding conformal perturbation defect.We compare the value of the boundary entropy that our formula gives for the flows between nearby Virasoro minimal models  m with the boundary entropy of the defect constructed by Gaiotto (2012 J. High Energy Phys. JHEP12(2012) 103) and find a match at the first two orders in the m 1 expansion.
Abstract We consider perturbations of 2D CFTs by multiple relevant operators. The massive phases of such perturbations can be labeled by conformal boundary conditions. Cardy’s variational ansatz approximates the vacuum state of the perturbed theory by a smeared conformal boundary state. In this paper we study the limitations and propose generalisations of this ansatz using both analytic and numerical insights based on TCSA. In particular we analyse the stability of Cardy’s ansatz states with respect to boundary relevant perturbations using bulk-boundary OPE coefficients. We show that certain transitions between the massive phases arise from a pair of boundary RG flows. The RG flows start from the conformal boundary on the transition surface and end on those that lie on the two sides of it. As an example we work out the details of the phase diagram for the Ising field theory and for the tricritical Ising model perturbed by the leading thermal and magnetic fields. For the latter we find a pair of novel transition lines that correspond to pairs of RG flows. Although the mass gap remains finite at the transition lines, several one-point functions change their behaviour. We discuss how these lines fit into the standard phase diagram of the tricritical Ising model. We show that each line extends to a two-dimensional surface ξσ,c in a three coupling space when we add perturbations by the subleading magnetic field. Close to this surface we locate symmetry breaking critical lines leading to the critical Ising model. Near the critical lines we find first order phase transition lines describing two-phase coexistence regions as predicted in Landau theory. The surface ξσ,c is determined from the CFT data using Cardy’s ansatz and its properties are checked using TCSA numerics.
We consider perturbation defects obtained by perturbing a 2D conformal field theory (CFT) by a relevant operator on a half-plane. If the perturbed bulk theory flows to an infrared fixed point described by another CFT, the defect flows to a conformal defect between the ultraviolet and infrared fixed point CFTs. For short bulk renormalization group flows connecting two fixed points which are close in theory space we find a universal perturbative formula for the boundary entropy of the corresponding conformal perturbation defect. We compare the value of the boundary entropy that our formula gives for the flows between nearby Virasoro minimal models Mm with the boundary entropy of the defect constructed by Gaiotto in [1] and find a match at the first two orders in the 1/m expansion.
We formulate the ZN{Z}_{N}ZN​ group gauging operations (or group extensions) in (smeared) boundary conformal field theories (BCFTs) and bulk conformal field theories, and study their applications to various phenomena in topologically ordered systems. We apply the resultant theories to analyze the correspondence between the renormalization group (RG) flow of CFTs and the classification of topological quantum field theories using the testable information of general classes of partition functions. One can obtain the bulk topological properties of the 2+12+12+1 dimensional topological ordered phase corresponding to the massive RG flow of the 1+11+11+1 dimensional systems equivalent to the smeared BCFT. We present an obstruction to mass condensation for the smeared BCFT analogous to the Lieb-Shultz-Mattis theorem for noninvertible symmetry. Corresponding to the bulk topological degeneracies in 2+12+12+1 dimensions and gapped quantum phases in 1+11+11+1 dimensions, we construct a new series of BCFT. We also study the implications of the massless RG flow of the 1+11+11+1 dimensional CFTs corresponding to the domain wall or coupling problem in 2+12+12+1 dimensional topological orders, which corresponds to the earlier proposal by L. Kong and H. Zheng [Nucl. Phys. B 966, 115384 (2021)] closely related to the integer-spin simple current by Schellekens and Gato-Rivera. We reveal that two distinct kinds of massless RG flow exist, coming from anomaly cancellation and anomaly matching related to Witt equivalence of bulk CFTs. The anomaly cancellation flows produce a new series of modular invariants as coupled models, and the anomaly matching flows produce nontrivial domain walls changing the chirality of anyons. Our paper gives a unified direction for future theoretical and numerical studies of the topological phase based on the established data of classifications of conformal field theories or modular invariants (and the corresponding category theories).
For QFTs in AdS the boundary correlation functions remain conformal even if the bulk theory has a scale. This allows one to constrain RG flows with numerical conformal bootstrap methods. We apply this idea to flows between two-dimensional CFTs, focusing on deformations of the tricritical and ordinary Ising model. We provide non-perturbative constraints for the boundary correlation functions of these flows and compare them with conformal perturbation theory in the vicinity of the fixed points. We also reproduce a completely general constraint on the sign of the TTˉT\bar TTTˉ deformation in two dimensions.
A bstract For QFTs in AdS the boundary correlation functions remain conformal even if the bulk theory has a scale. This allows one to constrain RG flows with numerical conformal bootstrap methods. We apply this idea to flows between two-dimensional CFTs, focusing on deformations of the tricritical and ordinary Ising model. We provide non-perturbative constraints for the boundary correlation functions of these flows and compare them with conformal perturbation theory in the vicinity of the fixed points. We also reproduce a completely general constraint on the sign of the TT‾T\overline{T }TT deformation in two dimensions.