© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

Terms Privacy Legal Notice

arXiv:1704.06114 · Physical Review A

Experimental observation of anomalous trajectories of single photons

Zong‐Quan Zhou, Xiao Liu, Yaron Kedem, Jin-Min Cui, Zongfeng Li, Yi-Lin Hua, Chuan‐Feng Li, Guang‐Can Guo

Published Apr 18, 2017• 34 citations

Abstract

A century after its conception, quantum mechanics still hold surprises that contradict many ``common sense'' notions. The contradiction is especially sharp in case one consider trajectories of truly quantum objects such as single photons. From a classical point of view, trajectories are well defined for particles, but not for waves. The wave-particle duality forces a breakdown of this dichotomy and quantum mechanics resolves this in a remarkable way: Trajectories can be well defined, but they are utterly different from classical trajectories. Here, we give an operational definition to the trajectory of a single photon by introducing a technique to mark its path using its spectral composition. The method demonstrates that the frequency degree of freedom can be used as a bona fide quantum measurement device (meter). The analysis of a number of setups, using our operational definition, leads to anomalous trajectories which are noncontinuous and in some cases do not even connect the source of the photon to where it is detected. We carried out an experimental demonstration of these anomalous trajectories using a nested interferometer. We show that the two-state vector formalism provides a simple explanation for the results.

DOI: 10.1103/physreva.95.042121

Related papers

Asking Photons Where They Have Been

Ariel Danan, Demitry Farfurnik, Shimshon Bar-Ad +1 more

We present surprising experimental evidence regarding the past of photons passing through an interferometer. The information about the positions through which the photons pass in the interferometer is retrieved from modulations of the detected signal at the vibration frequencies of mirrors the photons bounce off. From the analysis we conclude that the past of the photons is not represented by continuous trajectories, although a "common sense" analysis adopted in various welcher weg measurements, delayed-choice which-path experiments, and counterfactual communication demonstrations yields a single trajectory. The experimental results have a simple explanation in the framework of the two-state vector formalism of quantum theory.

Physical Review Letters•Dec 9, 2013•198 citations

Asking photons where have they been

Danan, Ariel, Demitry Farfurnik, Shimshon Bar-Ad +1 more

Quantum mechanics does not provide a clear answer to the question: What was the past of a photon which went through an interferometer? Various welcher weg measurements, delayed-choice which-path experiments and weak-measurements of photons in interferometers presented the past of a photon as a trajectory or a set of trajectories. We have carried out experimental weak measurements of the paths of photons going through a nested Mach-Zehnder interferometer which show a different picture: the past of a photon is not a set of continuous trajectories. The photons tell us that they have been in the parts of the interferometer which they could not have possibly reached! Our results lead to rejection of a "common sense" approach to the past of a quantum particle. On the other hand, they have a simple explanation within the framework of the two-state vector formalism of quantum theory.

arXiv:1304.7469•Apr 28, 2013•1 citation

Asking Photons "Where Have They Been?"

Lev Vaidman A

Quantum mechanics does not provide a clear answer to the question: What was the past of a photon which went through an interferometer? Various welcher weg measurements, delayed-choice which-path experiments and weak-measurements of photons in interferometers presented the past of a photon as a trajectory or a set of trajectories. We have carried out experimental weak measurements of the paths of photons going through a nested Mach-Zehnder interferometer which show a different picture: the past of a photon is not a set of continuous trajectories. The photons tell us that they have been in the parts of the interferometer which they could not have possibly reached! Our results lead to rejection of a ``common sense'' approach to the past of a quantum particle. On the other hand, they have a simple explanation within the framework of the two-state vector formalism of quantum theory.

The Rochester Conferences on Coherence and Quantum Optics and the Quantum Information and Measurement meeting•Jan 1, 2013•6 citations

Past of a quantum particle revisited

Berthold‐Georg Englert, Kelvin Horia, Jibo Dai +2 more

We analyze Vaidman's three-path interferometer with weak path marking [L. Vaidman, Phys. Rev. A 87, 052104 (2013)] and find that common sense yields correct statements about the particle's path through the interferometer. This disagrees with the original claim that the particles have discontinuous trajectories at odds with common sense. In our analysis, ``the particle's path'' has operational meaning as acquired by a path-discriminating measurement. For a quantum-mechanical experimental demonstration of the case, one should perform a single-photon version of the experiment by Danan et al. [A. Danan, D. Farfurnik, S. Bar-Ad, and L. Vaidman, Phys. Rev. Lett. 111, 240402 (2013)] with unambiguous path discrimination. We present a detailed proposal for such an experiment.

arXiv:1704.03722•Physical Review A•Aug 21, 2017•53 citations

Observing the Average Trajectories of Single Photons in a Two-Slit Interferometer

Sacha Kocsis, Boris Braverman, Sylvain Ravets +4 more

A consequence of the quantum mechanical uncertainty principle is that one may not discuss the path or "trajectory" that a quantum particle takes, because any measurement of position irrevocably disturbs the momentum, and vice versa. Using weak measurements, however, it is possible to operationally define a set of trajectories for an ensemble of quantum particles. We sent single photons emitted by a quantum dot through a double-slit interferometer and reconstructed these trajectories by performing a weak measurement of the photon momentum, postselected according to the result of a strong measurement of photon position in a series of planes. The results provide an observationally grounded description of the propagation of subensembles of quantum particles in a two-slit interferometer.

Science•Jun 3, 2011•649 citations

Single- and two-photon wave-particle superpositions: Theory and experiment

Qing-Feng Xue, Xu-Cai Zhuang, Nguyen Ba An +6 more

Simultaneous observation of the wave and particle natures of a quantum object under one experimental arrangement represents the latest development regarding wave-particle duality. In this work, we propose a simple scheme using linear-optics devices to observe either the particle nature or wave nature or the wave-particle superposition (WPS) of photons by controlling a relevant classical parameter. Our setup consists of two stages, the preparation and measurement stages, with the latter stage containing an additional classical variable whose value will be given only after the first stage in order to avoid any possible communication between the two stages and thus rule out the classical hidden-variable model. We not only develop the theory but also perform the corresponding experiments. The experimental observations perfectly agree with the theoretical predictions. Our findings are the following. The frequency (wavelength) of both single- and two-photon systems is independent of whether the photon(s) is wavelike or in a WPS state, with the common fact being that the frequency (wavelength) of two photons as a whole entity is twice (half) that of a single photon. As for the interference-pattern visibility, it is always lower in the case of WPS than in the case of a wavelike state for a single photon as well as for two photons. Remarkably, with a given value of the control parameter, the interference visibility in the case of WPS is always higher in the single-photon scenario than in the two-photon one. Although here we are dealing with photons, the obtained results apply equally well to matter particles.

Physical Review A•Aug 29, 2023•2 citations

A century after its conception, quantum mechanics still hold surprises that contradict many ``common sense'' notions. The contradiction is especially sharp in case one consider trajectories of truly quantum objects such as single photons. From a classical point of view, trajectories are well defined for particles, but not for waves. The wave-particle duality forces a breakdown of this dichotomy and quantum mechanics resolves this in a remarkable way: Trajectories can be well defined, but they are utterly different from classical trajectories. Here, we give an operational definition to the trajectory of a single photon by introducing a technique to mark its path using its spectral composition. The method demonstrates that the frequency degree of freedom can be used as a bona fide quantum measurement device (meter). The analysis of a number of setups, using our operational definition, leads to anomalous trajectories which are noncontinuous and in some cases do not even connect the source of the photon to where it is detected. We carried out an experimental demonstration of these anomalous trajectories using a nested interferometer. We show that the two-state vector formalism provides a simple explanation for the results.

We present surprising experimental evidence regarding the past of photons passing through an interferometer. The information about the positions through which the photons pass in the interferometer is retrieved from modulations of the detected signal at the vibration frequencies of mirrors the photons bounce off. From the analysis we conclude that the past of the photons is not represented by continuous trajectories, although a "common sense" analysis adopted in various welcher weg measurements, delayed-choice which-path experiments, and counterfactual communication demonstrations yields a single trajectory. The experimental results have a simple explanation in the framework of the two-state vector formalism of quantum theory.

Quantum mechanics does not provide a clear answer to the question: What was the past of a photon which went through an interferometer? Various welcher weg measurements, delayed-choice which-path experiments and weak-measurements of photons in interferometers presented the past of a photon as a trajectory or a set of trajectories. We have carried out experimental weak measurements of the paths of photons going through a nested Mach-Zehnder interferometer which show a different picture: the past of a photon is not a set of continuous trajectories. The photons tell us that they have been in the parts of the interferometer which they could not have possibly reached! Our results lead to rejection of a "common sense" approach to the past of a quantum particle. On the other hand, they have a simple explanation within the framework of the two-state vector formalism of quantum theory.

Quantum mechanics does not provide a clear answer to the question: What was the past of a photon which went through an interferometer? Various welcher weg measurements, delayed-choice which-path experiments and weak-measurements of photons in interferometers presented the past of a photon as a trajectory or a set of trajectories. We have carried out experimental weak measurements of the paths of photons going through a nested Mach-Zehnder interferometer which show a different picture: the past of a photon is not a set of continuous trajectories. The photons tell us that they have been in the parts of the interferometer which they could not have possibly reached! Our results lead to rejection of a ``common sense'' approach to the past of a quantum particle. On the other hand, they have a simple explanation within the framework of the two-state vector formalism of quantum theory.

We analyze Vaidman's three-path interferometer with weak path marking [L. Vaidman, Phys. Rev. A 87, 052104 (2013)] and find that common sense yields correct statements about the particle's path through the interferometer. This disagrees with the original claim that the particles have discontinuous trajectories at odds with common sense. In our analysis, ``the particle's path'' has operational meaning as acquired by a path-discriminating measurement. For a quantum-mechanical experimental demonstration of the case, one should perform a single-photon version of the experiment by Danan et al. [A. Danan, D. Farfurnik, S. Bar-Ad, and L. Vaidman, Phys. Rev. Lett. 111, 240402 (2013)] with unambiguous path discrimination. We present a detailed proposal for such an experiment.

A consequence of the quantum mechanical uncertainty principle is that one may not discuss the path or "trajectory" that a quantum particle takes, because any measurement of position irrevocably disturbs the momentum, and vice versa. Using weak measurements, however, it is possible to operationally define a set of trajectories for an ensemble of quantum particles. We sent single photons emitted by a quantum dot through a double-slit interferometer and reconstructed these trajectories by performing a weak measurement of the photon momentum, postselected according to the result of a strong measurement of photon position in a series of planes. The results provide an observationally grounded description of the propagation of subensembles of quantum particles in a two-slit interferometer.

Simultaneous observation of the wave and particle natures of a quantum object under one experimental arrangement represents the latest development regarding wave-particle duality. In this work, we propose a simple scheme using linear-optics devices to observe either the particle nature or wave nature or the wave-particle superposition (WPS) of photons by controlling a relevant classical parameter. Our setup consists of two stages, the preparation and measurement stages, with the latter stage containing an additional classical variable whose value will be given only after the first stage in order to avoid any possible communication between the two stages and thus rule out the classical hidden-variable model. We not only develop the theory but also perform the corresponding experiments. The experimental observations perfectly agree with the theoretical predictions. Our findings are the following. The frequency (wavelength) of both single- and two-photon systems is independent of whether the photon(s) is wavelike or in a WPS state, with the common fact being that the frequency (wavelength) of two photons as a whole entity is twice (half) that of a single photon. As for the interference-pattern visibility, it is always lower in the case of WPS than in the case of a wavelike state for a single photon as well as for two photons. Remarkably, with a given value of the control parameter, the interference visibility in the case of WPS is always higher in the single-photon scenario than in the two-photon one. Although here we are dealing with photons, the obtained results apply equally well to matter particles.