Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1704.03015 · Physical review. D/Physical review. D.

Tensor network simulation of QED on infinite lattices: Learning from (1+1) d , and prospects for (2+1) d

Kai Zapp, Román Orús

Published Jun 20, 2017• 33 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The simulation of lattice gauge theories with tensor network (TN) methods is becoming increasingly fruitful. The vision is that such methods will, eventually, be used to simulate theories in ($3+1$) dimensions in regimes difficult for other methods. So far, however, TN methods have mostly simulated lattice gauge theories in ($1+1$) dimensions. The aim of this paper is to explore the simulation of quantum electrodynamics (QED) on infinite lattices with TNs, i.e., fermionic matter fields coupled to a $U(1)$ gauge field, directly in the thermodynamic limit. With this idea in mind we first consider a gauge-invariant infinite density matrix renormalization group simulation of the Schwinger model---i.e., QED in $(1+1)\text{ }\mathrm{d}$. After giving a precise description of the numerical method, we benchmark our simulations by computing the subtracted chiral condensate in the continuum, in good agreement with other approaches. Our simulations of the Schwinger model allow us to build intuition about how a simulation should proceed in ($2+1$) dimensions. Based on this, we propose a variational ansatz using infinite projected entangled pair states (PEPS) to describe the ground state of $(2+1)\text{ }\mathrm{d}$ QED. The ansatz includes $U(1)$ gauge symmetry at the level of the tensors, as well as fermionic (matter) and bosonic (gauge) degrees of freedom both at the physical and virtual levels. We argue that all the necessary ingredients for the simulation of $(2+1)\text{ }\mathrm{d}$ QED are, a priori, already in place, paving the way for future upcoming results.

DOI
10.1103/physrevd.95.114508

Related papers

Finding the ground state of a lattice gauge theory with fermionic tensor networks: A 2+1D Z2 demonstration

Patrick Emonts, Ariel Kelman, Umberto Borla +3 more

Tensor network states, and in particular projected entangled pair states (PEPS) have been a strong ansatz for the variational study of complicated quantum many-body systems, thanks to their built-in entanglement entropy area law. In this work, we use a special kind of PEPS---gauged Gaussian fermionic PEPS (GGFPEPS)---to find the ground state of $2+1$ dimensional pure ${\mathbb{Z}}_{2}$ lattice gauge theories for a wide range of coupling constants. We do so by combining PEPS methods with Monte-Carlo computations, allowing for efficient contraction of the PEPS and computation of correlation functions. Previously, such numerical computations involved the calculation of the Pfaffian of a matrix scaling with the system size, forming a severe bottleneck; in this work we show how to overcome this problem. This paves the way for applying the method we propose and benchmark here to other gauge groups, higher dimensions, and models with fermionic matter, in an efficient, sign-problem-free way.

arXiv:2211.00023•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•Jan 4, 2023•27 citations

Accurate Gauge-Invariant Tensor-Network Simulations for Abelian Lattice Gauge Theory in ( 2 + 1 ) D : Ground-State and Real-Time Dynamics

Yantao Wu, Wen-Yuan Liu

We propose a novel tensor-network method to achieve accurate and efficient simulations of Abelian lattice gauge theories (LGTs) in (2+1)D for both ground-state and real-time dynamics. The first key is to identify a gauge canonical form of gauge-invariant tensor-network states, which already simplifies existing algorithms for (1+1)D LGTs. The second key is to employ the gauge canonical form of a projected entangled-pair state (PEPS) combining with variational Monte Carlo, enabling efficient computations for (2+1)D LGTs. We demonstrate the versatile capability of this approach for accurate ground-state simulation of pure Z_{2}, Z_{3}, and Z_{4} gauge theory, odd-Z_{2} gauge theories, and Z_{2} gauge theory coupled to hard-core bosons, on square lattices up to 32×32. Furthermore, we demonstrate that it allows for accurate simulations of real-time dynamics up to long time, exemplified by the dynamics of elementary excitations of the deconfined Z_{2} gauge field at 10×10. This is also the first example of simulating the real-time dynamics of PEPS with variational Monte Carlo, whose impact may extend beyond gauge theory. Our Letter establishes gauge-invariant PEPS as a powerful approach for both ground-state and dynamical simulations, opening up a new avenue for nonperturbatively studying (2+1)D LGTs.

arXiv:2503.20566•Physical Review Letters•Sep 2, 2025•4 citations

Quantum simulation and topological phases in Lattice Gauge Theories

Giuseppe Magnifico

Simulating quantum-mechanical systems is a very challenging issue due to the high computational costs. The main reason for this is related to the dimension of the Hilbert space that grows exponentially with the number of degrees of freedom, making an exact implementation impossible even for the most powerful today’s supercomputers. \nOn this ground it appears clear the need of a new simulation method, i.e. quantum simulation. The general idea is very simple: using a controllable quantum system, called quantum simulator, to emulate and to analyze another quantum system that usually results less controllable or accessible. Quantum simulation is currently a growing and multidisciplinary physical area that involves theoretical and experimental research. From the theoretical side, the main focus is on the study of simulation-models that create a mapping between the target physics and the simulator. \nIn the first two parts of this thesis, we explore these ideas by studying the ground-state properties and the real-time dynamics of a class of Zn lattice gauge theories in 1+1 dimensions, in which the gauge fields are coupled to fermionic matter. These models can be considered as quantum simulation-models of lattice 1+1 Quantum Electrodynamics (QED), which is the simplest gauge theory that shows non-trivial phenomena, like confinement, that are also observed in more complicated gauge theories, such as 3+1 Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD). \nIn the third part of this thesis, we unveil an interesting interplay of symmetry and topology by demonstrating the existence of symmetry-protected topological (SPT) phases in the presence of gauge interactions. More specifically, we introduce an alternative discretization of the Schwinger model leading to a new type of topological-QED. We use bosonization and Density-Matrix Renormalization Group (DMRG) techniques to analyze the phase diagram of the model, opening an interesting route to study topological phases of matter in the context of gauge theories.

•Jan 1, 2020•0 citations

Gauged Gaussian projected entangled pair states: A high dimensional tensor network formulation for lattice gauge theories

Ariel Kelman, Umberto Borla, Itay Gomelski +4 more

Gauge theories form the basis of our understanding of modern physics—ranging from the description of quarks and gluons to effective models in condensed matter physics. In the nonperturbative regime, gauge theories are conventionally treated discretely as lattice gauge theories. The resulting systems are evaluated with path-integral based Monte Carlo methods. These methods, however, can suffer from the sign problem and do not allow for a direct evaluation of real-time dynamics. In this work, we present a unified and comprehensive framework for gauged Gaussian projected entangled pair states (PEPS), a variational ansatz based on tensor networks. We review the construction of Hamiltonian lattice gauge theories, explain their similarities to PEPS, and detail the construction of the ansatz state. The estimation of ground states is based on a variational Monte Carlo procedure with the PEPS as an ansatz state. This sign-problem-free ansatz can be efficiently evaluated in any dimension with arbitrary gauge groups, and can include dynamical fermionic matter, suggesting new options for the simulation of nonperturbative regimes of gauge theories, including quantum chromodynamics. Published by the American Physical Society 2024

arXiv:2404.13123•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•Sep 20, 2024•10 citations

Quantum Computing 2+1-dimensional Quantum Electrodynamics

Arianna Crippa

This thesis investigates advances in quantum simulation methods for lattice gauge theories, with a focus on (2+1)-dimensional quantum electrodynamics (QED), which shares important features with (3+1)-dimensional quantum chromodynamics (QCD), such as confinement and asymptotic freedom. Two main projects are developed. The first project investigates the ongoing coupling in a compact pure U(1) gauge theory using a step-scaling function approach. A quantum variational method allows calculations over a wide range of couplings. Plaquette expectation value results are compared with classical Monte Carlo simulations to obtain, in principle, the physical value of the lattice spacing. This method can potentially be extended to the study of QED, which also includes fermionic matter. The second project investigates the static potential between two charges, analyzing the Coulomb, confining, and string-breaking regimes. It involves the development of a tailored variational approach that incorporates system symmetries and mutual information to represent fermionic degrees of freedom. Results from a trapped-ion quantum device agree well with classical simulations, validating the method. Furthermore, this work evaluates superconducting quantum devices, noting issues with noise but also demonstrating improvements in hardware and potential through error limitation. Overall, this work underscores the feasibility of variational quantum algorithms for lattice gauge theory simulations and demonstrates their promise for advancing theoretical physics with quantum computers. This thesis explores advancements in quantum simulation methods for lattice gauge theories, focusing on (2+1)-dimensional Quantum Electrodynamics (QED), which shares key features with (3+1)-dimensional Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD), such as confinement and asymptotic freedom. Two main projects are developed. The first investigates the running coupling in a compact U(1) pure gauge theory using a step scaling function approach. A quantum variational method enables computation across a wide range of couplings. The plaquette expectation value is matched with classical Monte Carlo simulations to obtain, in principle, the physical value of the lattice spacing. This method can be eventually extended to study QED, where fermionic matter is included. The second project examines the static potential between two charges, analyzing Coulomb, confining, and string-breaking regimes. It involves developing a custom variational Ansatz that incorporates system symmetries and mutual information to represent fermionic degrees of freedom. Results from a trapped-ion quantum device align well with exact classical simulations, validating the method. Additionally, the thesis evaluates superconducting devices, identifying noise challenges but noting improvements in hardware and the potential of error mitigation. Overall, this work highlights the viability of variational quantum algorithms for lattice gauge theory simulations and demonstrates their promise for advancing theoretical physics with quantum computing.

•Dec 4, 2025•0 citations

Variational Monte Carlo simulation with tensor networks of a pure Z3 gauge theory in (2+1)D

Patrick Emonts, Mari Carmen Bañuls, J. I. Cirac +1 more

Variational minimization of tensor network states enables the exploration of low energy states of lattice gauge theories. However, the exact numerical evaluation of high-dimensional tensor network states remains challenging in general. In [E. Zohar and J. I. Cirac, Phys. Rev. D 97, 034510 (2018)] it was shown how, by combining gauged Gaussian projected entangled pair states with a variational Monte Carlo procedure, it is possible to efficiently compute physical observables. In this paper we demonstrate how this approach can be used to investigate numerically the ground state of a lattice gauge theory. More concretely, we explicitly carry out the variational Monte Carlo procedure based on such contraction methods for a pure gauge Kogut-Susskind Hamiltonian with a ${\mathbb{Z}}_{3}$ gauge field in two spatial dimensions. This is a first proof of principle to the method, which provides an inherent way to increase the number of variational parameters and can be readily extended to systems with physical fermions.

arXiv:2008.00882•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•Oct 1, 2020•36 citations
The simulation of lattice gauge theories with tensor network (TN) methods is becoming increasingly fruitful. The vision is that such methods will, eventually, be used to simulate theories in (3+13+13+1) dimensions in regimes difficult for other methods. So far, however, TN methods have mostly simulated lattice gauge theories in (1+11+11+1) dimensions. The aim of this paper is to explore the simulation of quantum electrodynamics (QED) on infinite lattices with TNs, i.e., fermionic matter fields coupled to a U(1)U(1)U(1) gauge field, directly in the thermodynamic limit. With this idea in mind we first consider a gauge-invariant infinite density matrix renormalization group simulation of the Schwinger model---i.e., QED in (1+1) d(1+1)\text{ }\mathrm{d}(1+1) d. After giving a precise description of the numerical method, we benchmark our simulations by computing the subtracted chiral condensate in the continuum, in good agreement with other approaches. Our simulations of the Schwinger model allow us to build intuition about how a simulation should proceed in (2+12+12+1) dimensions. Based on this, we propose a variational ansatz using infinite projected entangled pair states (PEPS) to describe the ground state of (2+1) d(2+1)\text{ }\mathrm{d}(2+1) d QED. The ansatz includes U(1)U(1)U(1) gauge symmetry at the level of the tensors, as well as fermionic (matter) and bosonic (gauge) degrees of freedom both at the physical and virtual levels. We argue that all the necessary ingredients for the simulation of (2+1) d(2+1)\text{ }\mathrm{d}(2+1) d QED are, a priori, already in place, paving the way for future upcoming results.
Tensor network states, and in particular projected entangled pair states (PEPS) have been a strong ansatz for the variational study of complicated quantum many-body systems, thanks to their built-in entanglement entropy area law. In this work, we use a special kind of PEPS---gauged Gaussian fermionic PEPS (GGFPEPS)---to find the ground state of 2+12+12+1 dimensional pure Z2{\mathbb{Z}}_{2}Z2​ lattice gauge theories for a wide range of coupling constants. We do so by combining PEPS methods with Monte-Carlo computations, allowing for efficient contraction of the PEPS and computation of correlation functions. Previously, such numerical computations involved the calculation of the Pfaffian of a matrix scaling with the system size, forming a severe bottleneck; in this work we show how to overcome this problem. This paves the way for applying the method we propose and benchmark here to other gauge groups, higher dimensions, and models with fermionic matter, in an efficient, sign-problem-free way.
We propose a novel tensor-network method to achieve accurate and efficient simulations of Abelian lattice gauge theories (LGTs) in (2+1)D for both ground-state and real-time dynamics. The first key is to identify a gauge canonical form of gauge-invariant tensor-network states, which already simplifies existing algorithms for (1+1)D LGTs. The second key is to employ the gauge canonical form of a projected entangled-pair state (PEPS) combining with variational Monte Carlo, enabling efficient computations for (2+1)D LGTs. We demonstrate the versatile capability of this approach for accurate ground-state simulation of pure Z_{2}, Z_{3}, and Z_{4} gauge theory, odd-Z_{2} gauge theories, and Z_{2} gauge theory coupled to hard-core bosons, on square lattices up to 32×32. Furthermore, we demonstrate that it allows for accurate simulations of real-time dynamics up to long time, exemplified by the dynamics of elementary excitations of the deconfined Z_{2} gauge field at 10×10. This is also the first example of simulating the real-time dynamics of PEPS with variational Monte Carlo, whose impact may extend beyond gauge theory. Our Letter establishes gauge-invariant PEPS as a powerful approach for both ground-state and dynamical simulations, opening up a new avenue for nonperturbatively studying (2+1)D LGTs.
Simulating quantum-mechanical systems is a very challenging issue due to the high computational costs. The main reason for this is related to the dimension of the Hilbert space that grows exponentially with the number of degrees of freedom, making an exact implementation impossible even for the most powerful today’s supercomputers. \nOn this ground it appears clear the need of a new simulation method, i.e. quantum simulation. The general idea is very simple: using a controllable quantum system, called quantum simulator, to emulate and to analyze another quantum system that usually results less controllable or accessible. Quantum simulation is currently a growing and multidisciplinary physical area that involves theoretical and experimental research. From the theoretical side, the main focus is on the study of simulation-models that create a mapping between the target physics and the simulator. \nIn the first two parts of this thesis, we explore these ideas by studying the ground-state properties and the real-time dynamics of a class of Zn lattice gauge theories in 1+1 dimensions, in which the gauge fields are coupled to fermionic matter. These models can be considered as quantum simulation-models of lattice 1+1 Quantum Electrodynamics (QED), which is the simplest gauge theory that shows non-trivial phenomena, like confinement, that are also observed in more complicated gauge theories, such as 3+1 Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD). \nIn the third part of this thesis, we unveil an interesting interplay of symmetry and topology by demonstrating the existence of symmetry-protected topological (SPT) phases in the presence of gauge interactions. More specifically, we introduce an alternative discretization of the Schwinger model leading to a new type of topological-QED. We use bosonization and Density-Matrix Renormalization Group (DMRG) techniques to analyze the phase diagram of the model, opening an interesting route to study topological phases of matter in the context of gauge theories.
Gauge theories form the basis of our understanding of modern physics—ranging from the description of quarks and gluons to effective models in condensed matter physics. In the nonperturbative regime, gauge theories are conventionally treated discretely as lattice gauge theories. The resulting systems are evaluated with path-integral based Monte Carlo methods. These methods, however, can suffer from the sign problem and do not allow for a direct evaluation of real-time dynamics. In this work, we present a unified and comprehensive framework for gauged Gaussian projected entangled pair states (PEPS), a variational ansatz based on tensor networks. We review the construction of Hamiltonian lattice gauge theories, explain their similarities to PEPS, and detail the construction of the ansatz state. The estimation of ground states is based on a variational Monte Carlo procedure with the PEPS as an ansatz state. This sign-problem-free ansatz can be efficiently evaluated in any dimension with arbitrary gauge groups, and can include dynamical fermionic matter, suggesting new options for the simulation of nonperturbative regimes of gauge theories, including quantum chromodynamics. Published by the American Physical Society 2024
This thesis investigates advances in quantum simulation methods for lattice gauge theories, with a focus on (2+1)-dimensional quantum electrodynamics (QED), which shares important features with (3+1)-dimensional quantum chromodynamics (QCD), such as confinement and asymptotic freedom. Two main projects are developed. The first project investigates the ongoing coupling in a compact pure U(1) gauge theory using a step-scaling function approach. A quantum variational method allows calculations over a wide range of couplings. Plaquette expectation value results are compared with classical Monte Carlo simulations to obtain, in principle, the physical value of the lattice spacing. This method can potentially be extended to the study of QED, which also includes fermionic matter. The second project investigates the static potential between two charges, analyzing the Coulomb, confining, and string-breaking regimes. It involves the development of a tailored variational approach that incorporates system symmetries and mutual information to represent fermionic degrees of freedom. Results from a trapped-ion quantum device agree well with classical simulations, validating the method. Furthermore, this work evaluates superconducting quantum devices, noting issues with noise but also demonstrating improvements in hardware and potential through error limitation. Overall, this work underscores the feasibility of variational quantum algorithms for lattice gauge theory simulations and demonstrates their promise for advancing theoretical physics with quantum computers. This thesis explores advancements in quantum simulation methods for lattice gauge theories, focusing on (2+1)-dimensional Quantum Electrodynamics (QED), which shares key features with (3+1)-dimensional Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD), such as confinement and asymptotic freedom. Two main projects are developed. The first investigates the running coupling in a compact U(1) pure gauge theory using a step scaling function approach. A quantum variational method enables computation across a wide range of couplings. The plaquette expectation value is matched with classical Monte Carlo simulations to obtain, in principle, the physical value of the lattice spacing. This method can be eventually extended to study QED, where fermionic matter is included. The second project examines the static potential between two charges, analyzing Coulomb, confining, and string-breaking regimes. It involves developing a custom variational Ansatz that incorporates system symmetries and mutual information to represent fermionic degrees of freedom. Results from a trapped-ion quantum device align well with exact classical simulations, validating the method. Additionally, the thesis evaluates superconducting devices, identifying noise challenges but noting improvements in hardware and the potential of error mitigation. Overall, this work highlights the viability of variational quantum algorithms for lattice gauge theory simulations and demonstrates their promise for advancing theoretical physics with quantum computing.
Variational minimization of tensor network states enables the exploration of low energy states of lattice gauge theories. However, the exact numerical evaluation of high-dimensional tensor network states remains challenging in general. In [E. Zohar and J. I. Cirac, Phys. Rev. D 97, 034510 (2018)] it was shown how, by combining gauged Gaussian projected entangled pair states with a variational Monte Carlo procedure, it is possible to efficiently compute physical observables. In this paper we demonstrate how this approach can be used to investigate numerically the ground state of a lattice gauge theory. More concretely, we explicitly carry out the variational Monte Carlo procedure based on such contraction methods for a pure gauge Kogut-Susskind Hamiltonian with a Z3{\mathbb{Z}}_{3}Z3​ gauge field in two spatial dimensions. This is a first proof of principle to the method, which provides an inherent way to increase the number of variational parameters and can be readily extended to systems with physical fermions.