Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1703.08209

The absence of the selfaveraging property of the entanglement entropy of disordered free fermions

Leonid Andreevich Pastur, Victor V. Slavin

Published Mar 23, 2017• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We consider the macroscopic system of free lattice fermions in one dimension assuming that the one-body Hamiltonian of the system is the one dimensional discrete Schrödinger operator with independent identically distributed random potential. We show analytically and numerically that the variance of the entanglement entropy of the segment $[-M,M]$ of the system is bounded away from zero as $M\rightarrow \infty $. This manifests the absence of the selfaveraging property of the entanglement entropy in our model, meaning that in the one-dimensional case the complete description of the entanglement entropy is provided by its whole probability distribution. This also may be contrasted the case of dimension two or more, where the variance of the entanglement entropy per unit surface area vanishes as $% M\rightarrow \infty $ \cite{El-Co:17}, thereby guaranteeing the representativity of its mean for large $M$ in the multidimensional case.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.1703.08209

Related papers

Area Law Scaling for the Entropy of Disordered Quasifree Fermions

Leonid Andreevich Pastur, Victor V. Slavin

We study theoretically and numerically the entanglement entropy of the $d$-dimensional free fermions whose one-body Hamiltonian is the Anderson model. Using the basic facts of the exponential Anderson localization, we show first that the disorder averaged entanglement entropy $⟨{S}_{\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Lambda}}}⟩$ of the $d$ dimension cube $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Lambda}}$ of side length $l$ admits the area law scaling $⟨{S}_{\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Lambda}}}⟩\ensuremath{\sim}{l}^{(d\ensuremath{-}1)},l\ensuremath{\gg}1$, even in the gapless case, thereby manifesting the area law in the mean for our model. For $d=1$ and $l\ensuremath{\gg}1$ we obtain then asymptotic bounds for the entanglement entropy of typical realizations of disorder and use them to show that the entanglement entropy is not self-averaging, i.e., has nonvanishing random fluctuations even if $l\ensuremath{\gg}1$.

arXiv:1408.2570•Physical Review Letters•Oct 9, 2014•54 citations

Area Law for the Entanglement Entropy of Free Fermions in Nonrandom Ergodic Field

Leonid Andreevich Pastur, Mira Shamis

The paper deals with the asymptotic behavior of a widely used correlation characteristic in large quantum systems. The correlation is quantum entanglement, the characteristic is entanglement entropy, and the system is an ideal gas of lattice fermions. If the one-body Hamiltonian of fermions is an ergodic finite difference operator with an exponentially decaying spectral projection, then the large-block form of the entanglement entropy is the so-called area law. However, the only class of one-body Hamiltonians for which this spectral condition was verified consists of discrete Schrödinger operators with random potential. In this paper, we prove the area law for several classes of Schrödinger operators whose potentials are ergodic but not random. We begin with quasiperiodic and limit-periodic operators and then move to a highly non-trivial case of potentials generated by subshifts of finite type. These arose in the theory of dynamical systems when studying chaotic phenomena. The corresponding asymptotic study requires involved spectral analysis, which therefore constitutes the bulk of the paper. Specifically, we prove uniform localisation of the eigenfunctions for the Maryland model and exponential decay of the eigenfunction correlator for various models. We believe these properties are of significant independent interest.

arXiv:2510.11111•Entropy•May 1, 2026•0 citations

The Absence of the Selfaveraging Property of the Entanglement Entropy of Disordered Free Fermions in One Dimension

Leonid Andreevich Pastur, Victor V. Slavin

arXiv:1703.06054•Journal of Statistical Physics•Nov 27, 2017•13 citations

Entanglement Entropy of Free Fermions with a Random Matrix as a One-Body Hamiltonian

Leonid Andreevich Pastur, Victor V. Slavin

We consider a quantum system of large size N and its subsystem of size L, assuming that N is much larger than L, which can also be sufficiently large, i.e., 1≪L≲N. A widely accepted mathematical version of this inequality is the asymptotic regime of successive limits: first the macroscopic limit N→∞, then an asymptotic analysis of the entanglement entropy as L→∞. In this paper, we consider another version of the above inequality: the regime of asymptotically proportional L and N, i.e., the simultaneous limits L→∞,N→∞,L/N→λ>0. Specifically, we consider a system of free fermions that is in its ground state, and such that its one-body Hamiltonian is a large random matrix, which is often used to model long-range hopping. By using random matrix theory, we show that in this case, the entanglement entropy obeys the volume law known for systems with short-range hopping but described either by a mixed state or a pure strongly excited state of the Hamiltonian. We also give streamlined proof of Page’s formula for the entanglement entropy of black hole radiation for a wide class of typical ground states, thereby proving the universality and the typicality of the formula.

arXiv:2405.11342•Entropy•Jun 30, 2024•0 citations

Exploring entanglement characteristics in disordered free fermion systems through random bi-partitioning

Mohammad Pouranvari

This study investigates the entanglement properties of disordered free fermion systems undergoing an Anderson phase transition from a delocalized to a localized phase. The entanglement entropy is employed to quantify the degree of entanglement, with the system randomly divided into two subsystems. To explore this phenomenon, one-dimensional tight-binding fermion models and Anderson models in one, two, and three dimensions are utilized. Comprehensive numerical calculations reveal that the entanglement entropy, determined using random bi-partitioning, follows a volume-law scaling in both the delocalized and localized phases, expressed as [Formula: see text], where D represents the dimension of the system. Furthermore, the role of short and long-range correlations in the entanglement entropy and the impact of the distribution of subsystem sites are analyzed.

arXiv:2208.11409•Modern Physics Letters A•Feb 20, 2024•1 citation

Statistics Dependence of the Entanglement Entropy

M. Cramer, Jens Eisert, Martin Bodo Plenio

The entanglement entropy of a distinguished region of a quantum many-body system reflects the entanglement in its pure ground state. Here we establish scaling laws for this entanglement in critical quasifree fermionic and bosonic lattice systems, without resorting to numerical means. We consider the setting of D-dimensional half-spaces which allows us to exploit a connection to the one-dimensional case. Intriguingly, we find a difference in the scaling properties depending on whether the system is bosonic-where an area law is proven to hold-or fermionic where we determine a logarithmic correction to the area law, which depends on the topology of the Fermi surface. We find Lifshitz quantum phase transitions accompanied with a nonanalyticity in the prefactor of the leading order term.

arXiv:quant-ph/0611264•Physical Review Letters•May 31, 2007•87 citations
We consider the macroscopic system of free lattice fermions in one dimension assuming that the one-body Hamiltonian of the system is the one dimensional discrete Schrödinger operator with independent identically distributed random potential. We show analytically and numerically that the variance of the entanglement entropy of the segment [−M,M][-M,M][−M,M] of the system is bounded away from zero as M→∞M\rightarrow \infty M→∞. This manifests the absence of the selfaveraging property of the entanglement entropy in our model, meaning that in the one-dimensional case the complete description of the entanglement entropy is provided by its whole probability distribution. This also may be contrasted the case of dimension two or more, where the variance of the entanglement entropy per unit surface area vanishes as % M\rightarrow \infty \cite{El-Co:17}, thereby guaranteeing the representativity of its mean for large MMM in the multidimensional case.
We study theoretically and numerically the entanglement entropy of the ddd-dimensional free fermions whose one-body Hamiltonian is the Anderson model. Using the basic facts of the exponential Anderson localization, we show first that the disorder averaged entanglement entropy $⟨{S}_{\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Lambda}}}⟩$ of the ddd dimension cube $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Lambda}}$ of side length lll admits the area law scaling $⟨{S}_{\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Lambda}}}⟩\ensuremath{\sim}{l}^{(d\ensuremath{-}1)},l\ensuremath{\gg}1$, even in the gapless case, thereby manifesting the area law in the mean for our model. For d=1d=1d=1 and $l\ensuremath{\gg}1$ we obtain then asymptotic bounds for the entanglement entropy of typical realizations of disorder and use them to show that the entanglement entropy is not self-averaging, i.e., has nonvanishing random fluctuations even if $l\ensuremath{\gg}1$.
The paper deals with the asymptotic behavior of a widely used correlation characteristic in large quantum systems. The correlation is quantum entanglement, the characteristic is entanglement entropy, and the system is an ideal gas of lattice fermions. If the one-body Hamiltonian of fermions is an ergodic finite difference operator with an exponentially decaying spectral projection, then the large-block form of the entanglement entropy is the so-called area law. However, the only class of one-body Hamiltonians for which this spectral condition was verified consists of discrete Schrödinger operators with random potential. In this paper, we prove the area law for several classes of Schrödinger operators whose potentials are ergodic but not random. We begin with quasiperiodic and limit-periodic operators and then move to a highly non-trivial case of potentials generated by subshifts of finite type. These arose in the theory of dynamical systems when studying chaotic phenomena. The corresponding asymptotic study requires involved spectral analysis, which therefore constitutes the bulk of the paper. Specifically, we prove uniform localisation of the eigenfunctions for the Maryland model and exponential decay of the eigenfunction correlator for various models. We believe these properties are of significant independent interest.
We consider a quantum system of large size N and its subsystem of size L, assuming that N is much larger than L, which can also be sufficiently large, i.e., 1≪L≲N. A widely accepted mathematical version of this inequality is the asymptotic regime of successive limits: first the macroscopic limit N→∞, then an asymptotic analysis of the entanglement entropy as L→∞. In this paper, we consider another version of the above inequality: the regime of asymptotically proportional L and N, i.e., the simultaneous limits L→∞,N→∞,L/N→λ>0. Specifically, we consider a system of free fermions that is in its ground state, and such that its one-body Hamiltonian is a large random matrix, which is often used to model long-range hopping. By using random matrix theory, we show that in this case, the entanglement entropy obeys the volume law known for systems with short-range hopping but described either by a mixed state or a pure strongly excited state of the Hamiltonian. We also give streamlined proof of Page’s formula for the entanglement entropy of black hole radiation for a wide class of typical ground states, thereby proving the universality and the typicality of the formula.
This study investigates the entanglement properties of disordered free fermion systems undergoing an Anderson phase transition from a delocalized to a localized phase. The entanglement entropy is employed to quantify the degree of entanglement, with the system randomly divided into two subsystems. To explore this phenomenon, one-dimensional tight-binding fermion models and Anderson models in one, two, and three dimensions are utilized. Comprehensive numerical calculations reveal that the entanglement entropy, determined using random bi-partitioning, follows a volume-law scaling in both the delocalized and localized phases, expressed as [Formula: see text], where D represents the dimension of the system. Furthermore, the role of short and long-range correlations in the entanglement entropy and the impact of the distribution of subsystem sites are analyzed.
The entanglement entropy of a distinguished region of a quantum many-body system reflects the entanglement in its pure ground state. Here we establish scaling laws for this entanglement in critical quasifree fermionic and bosonic lattice systems, without resorting to numerical means. We consider the setting of D-dimensional half-spaces which allows us to exploit a connection to the one-dimensional case. Intriguingly, we find a difference in the scaling properties depending on whether the system is bosonic-where an area law is proven to hold-or fermionic where we determine a logarithmic correction to the area law, which depends on the topology of the Fermi surface. We find Lifshitz quantum phase transitions accompanied with a nonanalyticity in the prefactor of the leading order term.