arXiv:1701.03437 · Physical review. D/Physical review. D.

Towards searching for entangled photons in the CMB sky

Jiunn-Wei Chen, Shou-Huang Dai, Debaprasad Maity, Sichun Sun, Yun‐Long Zhang

Published Jan 4, 2019• 13 citations

Abstract

We explore the possibility of detecting entangled photon pairs from cosmic microwave background or other cosmological sources coming from two patches of the sky. The measurements use two detectors with different photon polarizer directions. When two photon sources are separated by a large angle relative to the earth, such that each detector has only one photon source in its field of view, a null test of unentangled photons can be performed. The deviation from this unentangled background is, in principle, the signature of photon entanglement. To confirm whether the deviation is consistent with entangled photons, we derive a photon polarization correlation to compare with, similar to that in a Bell inequality measurement. However, since photon coincidence measurement cannot be used to discriminate unentangled cosmic photons, it is unlikely that the correlation expectation value alone can violate Bell inequality to provide the signature for entanglement.

DOI: 10.1103/physrevd.99.023507

Related papers

Testing Bell’s Inequality with Cosmic Photons: Closing the Setting-Independence Loophole

Jason R. Gallicchio, Andrew S. Friedman, David I. Kaiser

We propose a practical scheme to use photons from causally disconnected cosmic sources to set the detectors in an experimental test of Bell's inequality. In current experiments, with settings determined by quantum random number generators, only a small amount of correlation between detector settings and local hidden variables, established less than a millisecond before each experiment, would suffice to mimic the predictions of quantum mechanics. By setting the detectors using pairs of quasars or patches of the cosmic microwave background, observed violations of Bell's inequality would require any such coordination to have existed for billions of years-an improvement of 20 orders of magnitude.

arXiv:1310.3288Physical Review LettersMar 18, 201499 citations

Experiment on Bell's Inequalities Violation Would Give Same Result with Un-entangled Classical Photons

Fabien Sabinet

Experiments testing Bell's inequalities generally uses sources of entangled photons emitted in opposite direction, sent through polarizer of specific different orientation and finally correlated. But the correlation result would be the same if photons was emitted by only one source of 360° rotating polarization, separated in two flux by a semi-transparent mirror, and finally correlated as in the standard experiment. Therefore, it would demonstrate that the result is not due to any entangled state of the photons.

Nov 1, 20200 citations

Quasar Correlation and Bell's Inequality

Eric Steinbring

Viewing two astronomical sources at large enough distance and angular separation can assure, by light-travel-time arguments, the acausality of their emitted photons. Using such photons to set apparatus parameters in a laboratory-based quantum-mechanical experiment could ensure those switch settings are independent and fair, allowing a loophole-free test of Bell's inequality. Quasars are a natural choice for this task, yet at ultimate extent it involves their simultaneous photometry towards opposite directions on the sky, which is untried. Cosmic isotropy can be invoked to set limits there, leaving fairness intact for causal pairs, but with a testable consequence of asymmetric bias: mean brightness correlations found less flat in sky angle than random, more acutely so inside a horizon of 90 degrees. Analysis of one dataset from the Gemini twin telescopes is presented, using over 14 years of archival broadband-optical images, serendipitously sampling thousands of quasars up to 180 degrees apart. These data reject a null result of no correlation with 97.7% confidence, instead consistent with a 3-sigma residual signal of 0.21 mag peaked at 65+/-3 degrees separation. Possible confirmatory observations are pointed to along with the improved experimental protocol of an Earth-wide test.

Nov 1, 20180 citations

Obstructions to Bell CMB experiments

Jérôme Martin, Vincent Vennin

We present a general and systematic study of how a Bell experiment on the cosmic microwave background could be carried out. We introduce different classes of pseudo-spin operators and show that, if the system is placed in a two-mode squeezed state as inflation predicts, they all lead to a violation of the Bell inequality. However, we also discuss the obstacles that one faces in order to realize this program in practice and show that they are probably insurmountable. We suggest alternative methods that could reveal the quantum origin of cosmological structures without relying on Bell experiments.

arXiv:1706.05001Physical review. D/Physical review. D.Sep 6, 201781 citations

A Comparative Analysis of Realistic and Theoretical Bell State Sources

Ákos Uzonyi

We present an experimental study of polarization-entangled photon pairs, investigating the dependence of the measurement outcomes on different polarization rotation angles and the slow temporal fluctuations of the generated quantum state. Entangled photon pairs are produced and analyzed using single-photon detectors while systematically varying polarization settings on both sides. Bell tests yield an S parameter of approximately 2.52, confirming strong entanglement. The measured coincidence counts between identical measurement outcomes exhibit the expected sinusoidal dependence on the combined rotation angles, but systematic deviations appear as pronounced peaks and variations in certain configurations. Long-term monitoring over twenty minutes shows correlated fluctuations on both sides in individual detection outcomes of up to 25%, while the total photon flux remains constant, indicating that these deviations originate from slow intrinsic changes in the generated quantum state. These temporal fluctuations can reduce the effective time window over which optimal polarization and phase alignment is maintained, highlighting the importance of implementing real-time compensation or feedback mechanisms in experiments requiring high-fidelity entanglement over extended durations. Our results provide insight into the stability limits of entangled photon sources and underscore the importance of accounting for temporal fluctuations in precision entanglement experiments.

Jan 1, 20260 citations

Pairwise-Correlated Quasars Across the Sky, and in an Earth-Wide Bell Test

Eric Steinbring

Viewing two astronomical sources at large enough distance and angular separation can assure, by light-travel-time arguments, the acausality of their emitted photons. Using these photons to set apparatus parameters in a laboratory-based quantum-mechanical experiment could ensure those settings are independent too, allowing a decisive, loophole-free test of Bell's inequality. Quasars are a natural choice for the task, yet at ultimate extent it involves their simultaneous flux measurement towards opposite directions on the sky, which is untried. Observational limits are formulated leaving independence intact in this case, provided the isotropy of causal quasar-pair flux-differences is preserved overall, but a consequence could be correlation among repeat samples at lesser separations. Analysis of one useful dataset from the Gemini twin telescopes is presented, using over 14 years of archival images, serendipitously sampling thousands of quasars up to 180 apart. These reject a null result of no correlation with 97.7% confidence, and are instead consistent with the expected bias: a mean residual 3-sigma signal of 0.21 magnitudes peaked at 65+/-3 degrees separation. Possible confirmatory observations are pointed to along with improved experimental protocol: an Earth-wide test.

arXiv:1811.00674Nov 1, 20180 citations