Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1612.08410 · Nature Communications

Efficient entanglement distillation without quantum memory

Daniela Abdelkhalek, Mareike Syllwasschy, Nicolas J. Cerf, Jaromı́r Fiurášek, Roman Schnabel

Published May 31, 2016• 19 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Entanglement distribution between distant parties is an essential component to most quantum communication protocols. Unfortunately, decoherence effects such as phase noise in optical fibres are known to demolish entanglement. Iterative (multistep) entanglement distillation protocols have long been proposed to overcome decoherence, but their probabilistic nature makes them inefficient since the success probability decays exponentially with the number of steps. Quantum memories have been contemplated to make entanglement distillation practical, but suitable quantum memories are not realised to date. Here, we present the theory for an efficient iterative entanglement distillation protocol without quantum memories and provide a proof-of-principle experimental demonstration. The scheme is applied to phase-diffused two-mode-squeezed states and proven to distil entanglement for up to three iteration steps. The data are indistinguishable from those that an efficient scheme using quantum memories would produce. Since our protocol includes the final measurement it is particularly promising for enhancing continuous-variable quantum key distribution.

DOI
10.1038/ncomms11720

Related papers

Compact Continuous-Variable Entanglement Distillation

Animesh Datta, Lijian Zhang, Joshua Nunn +4 more

We introduce a new scheme for continuous-variable entanglement distillation that requires only linear temporal and constant physical or spatial resources. Distillation is the process by which high-quality entanglement may be distributed between distant nodes of a network in the unavoidable presence of decoherence. The known versions of this protocol scale exponentially in space and doubly exponentially in time. Our optimal scheme therefore provides exponential improvements over existing protocols. It uses a fixed-resource module-an entanglement distillery-comprising only four quantum memories of at most 50% storage efficiency and allowing a feasible experimental implementation. Tangible quantum advantages are obtainable by using existing off-resonant Raman quantum memories outside their conventional role of storage.

arXiv:1107.4122•Physical Review Letters•Feb 8, 2012•62 citations

Compact entanglement distillery using realistic quantum memories

Levon Chakhmakhchyan, S. Guérin, Joshua Nunn +1 more

We adopt the beam-splitter model for losses to analyze the performance of a recent compact continuous-variable entanglement distillation protocol [A. Datta et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 108, 060502 (2012)] implemented using realistic quantum memories. We show that the decoherence undergone by a two-mode squeezed state while stored in a quantum memory can strongly modify the results of the preparatory step of the protocol. We find that the well-known method for locally increasing entanglement, phonon subtraction, may not result in entanglement gain when losses are taken into account. Thus, we investigate the critical number ${m}_{c}$ of phonon subtraction attempts from the matter modes of the quantum memory. If the initial state is not de-Gaussified within ${m}_{c}$ attempts, the protocol should be restarted to obtain any entanglement increase. Moreover, the condition ${m}_{c}>1$ implies an additional constraint on the subtraction beam-splitter interaction transmissivity, viz., it should be about $50%$ for a wide range of protocol parameters. Additionally, we consider the average entanglement rate, which takes into account both the unavoidable probabilistic nature of the protocol and its possible failure as a result of a large number of unsuccessful subtraction attempts. We find that a higher value of the average entanglement can be achieved by increasing the subtraction beam-splitter interaction transmissivity. We conclude that the compact distillation protocol with the practical constraints coming from realistic quantum memories allows a feasible experimental realization within existing technologies.

arXiv:1308.0842•Physical Review A•Oct 11, 2013•5 citations

Enhancing distillability of secret keys with entanglement distillation and classical advantage distillation

Shin Sun, Kenneth Goodenough, Daniel Bhatti +2 more

Realizing secure communication between distant parties is one of the main goals of quantum technology. Although quantum key distribution (QKD) promises information-theoretic security for sharing a secret key, the key rate heavily depends on the level of noise in the quantum channel. To overcome the noise, both quantum and classical techniques exist, i.e., entanglement distillation and classical advantage distillation. So far, these techniques have only been used separately from each other. Herein, we present a two-stage distillation scheme concatenating entanglement distillation with classical advantage distillation. For the advantage distillation, we utilize a fixed protocol, specifically, the repetition code; in the case of entanglement distillation, we employ an enumeration algorithm to find an optimal protocol. We test our scheme for noisy entangled states and demonstrate its quantitative advantage: Our two-stage distillation scheme achieves finite key rates even in a high-noise regime where entanglement distillation or advantage distillation alone cannot afford key sharing. We also calculate the security bounds for relevant QKD protocols with our key-distillation scheme and show that they exceed the previous security bounds on the critical quantum bit error rates with only advantage distillation. Since the advantage distillation part does not introduce further requirements for quantum resources other than those required for entanglement distillation, the proposed scheme is well suited for quantum key distribution tasks with entanglement distribution networks.

arXiv:2410.19334•Physical Review A•Sep 11, 2025•3 citations

Overcoming the repeaterless bound in continuous-variable quantum communication without quantum memories

Matthew S. Winnel, Joshua J. Guanzon, Nedasadat Hosseinidehaj +1 more

One of the main problems in quantum communications is how to achieve high rates at long distances. Quantum repeaters, i.e., untrusted, intermediate relay stations, are necessary to overcome the repeaterless bound which sets the fundamental rate-distance limit of repeaterless communications. In this work, we introduce a continuous-variable protocol which overcomes the repeaterless bound and scales like the single-repeater bound using just one linear-optical device called a "quantum scissor", combining the entanglement distillation and entanglement swapping elements of previous repeater proposals into a single step, thus, removing the need for quantum memories. Implementing a standard continuous-variable quantum key distribution protocol using our repeater we predict key rates which surpass the repeaterless bound. Our protocol works well for non-ideal single-photon sources and non-ideal single-photon detectors, and can tolerate some level of excess noise, making our protocol implementable with existing technology. We show that our scheme can be extended to longer repeater chains using quantum memories, using less physical resources than previous schemes. Furthermore, for applications beyond key distribution, our scheme generalises to higher order and distils more entanglement at the cost of a reduced probability of success.

arXiv:2105.03586•May 8, 2021•6 citations

Continuous-variable entanglement distillation between remote quantum nodes

Yanhong Liu, Jieli Yan, Lixia Ma +2 more

The development of quantum network relies on high-quality entanglement between remote quantum nodes. In reality the unavoidable decoherence limits the quality of entangled quantum nodes, however, entanglement distillation can overcome this problem. Here we propose an experimentally feasible scheme of continuous-variable entanglement generation, storage, and distillation between distant quantum nodes, which only requires the atomic ensemble quantum memory and balanced homodyne detection (BHD). Initially one copy of a bipartite entangled state of light, suffering phase fluctuations during the distributions, is stored in two distant atomic ensembles so that the atomic ensembles are entangled. Within the storage lifetime, by distributing and storing another copy of entangled optical modes in these two atomic ensembles, the distillation on entangled atomic spin waves can be implemented based on the post-selection of the BHD result. Our scheme provides a highly entangled state between remote quantum nodes for downstream applications, and enables the extension to multipartite entanglement distillation in a large-scale quantum network.

Physical Review A•Nov 6, 2018•3 citations

Continuous-variable entanglement distillation and noncommutative central limit theorems

Earl T. Campbell, Marco G. Genoni, Jens Eisert

Entanglement distillation transforms weakly entangled noisy states into highly entangled states, a primitive to be used in quantum repeater schemes and other protocols designed for quantum communication and key distribution. In this work, we present a comprehensive framework for continuous-variable entanglement distillation schemes that convert noisy non-Gaussian states into Gaussian ones in many iterations of the protocol. Instances of these protocols include (a) the recursive-Gaussifier protocol, (b) the temporally reordered recursive-Gaussifier protocol, and (c) the pumping-Gaussifier protocol. The flexibility of these protocols gives rise to several beneficial trade-offs related to success probabilities or memory requirements, which can be adjusted to reflect experimental demands. Despite these protocols involving measurements, we relate the convergence in this protocol to new instances of noncommutative central limit theorems, in a formalism that we lay out in great detail. Implications of the findings for quantum repeater schemes are discussed.

arXiv:1211.5483•Physical Review A•Apr 24, 2013•28 citations
Entanglement distribution between distant parties is an essential component to most quantum communication protocols. Unfortunately, decoherence effects such as phase noise in optical fibres are known to demolish entanglement. Iterative (multistep) entanglement distillation protocols have long been proposed to overcome decoherence, but their probabilistic nature makes them inefficient since the success probability decays exponentially with the number of steps. Quantum memories have been contemplated to make entanglement distillation practical, but suitable quantum memories are not realised to date. Here, we present the theory for an efficient iterative entanglement distillation protocol without quantum memories and provide a proof-of-principle experimental demonstration. The scheme is applied to phase-diffused two-mode-squeezed states and proven to distil entanglement for up to three iteration steps. The data are indistinguishable from those that an efficient scheme using quantum memories would produce. Since our protocol includes the final measurement it is particularly promising for enhancing continuous-variable quantum key distribution.
We introduce a new scheme for continuous-variable entanglement distillation that requires only linear temporal and constant physical or spatial resources. Distillation is the process by which high-quality entanglement may be distributed between distant nodes of a network in the unavoidable presence of decoherence. The known versions of this protocol scale exponentially in space and doubly exponentially in time. Our optimal scheme therefore provides exponential improvements over existing protocols. It uses a fixed-resource module-an entanglement distillery-comprising only four quantum memories of at most 50% storage efficiency and allowing a feasible experimental implementation. Tangible quantum advantages are obtainable by using existing off-resonant Raman quantum memories outside their conventional role of storage.
We adopt the beam-splitter model for losses to analyze the performance of a recent compact continuous-variable entanglement distillation protocol [A. Datta et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 108, 060502 (2012)] implemented using realistic quantum memories. We show that the decoherence undergone by a two-mode squeezed state while stored in a quantum memory can strongly modify the results of the preparatory step of the protocol. We find that the well-known method for locally increasing entanglement, phonon subtraction, may not result in entanglement gain when losses are taken into account. Thus, we investigate the critical number mc{m}_{c}mc​ of phonon subtraction attempts from the matter modes of the quantum memory. If the initial state is not de-Gaussified within mc{m}_{c}mc​ attempts, the protocol should be restarted to obtain any entanglement increase. Moreover, the condition mc>1{m}_{c}>1mc​>1 implies an additional constraint on the subtraction beam-splitter interaction transmissivity, viz., it should be about 5050%50 for a wide range of protocol parameters. Additionally, we consider the average entanglement rate, which takes into account both the unavoidable probabilistic nature of the protocol and its possible failure as a result of a large number of unsuccessful subtraction attempts. We find that a higher value of the average entanglement can be achieved by increasing the subtraction beam-splitter interaction transmissivity. We conclude that the compact distillation protocol with the practical constraints coming from realistic quantum memories allows a feasible experimental realization within existing technologies.
Realizing secure communication between distant parties is one of the main goals of quantum technology. Although quantum key distribution (QKD) promises information-theoretic security for sharing a secret key, the key rate heavily depends on the level of noise in the quantum channel. To overcome the noise, both quantum and classical techniques exist, i.e., entanglement distillation and classical advantage distillation. So far, these techniques have only been used separately from each other. Herein, we present a two-stage distillation scheme concatenating entanglement distillation with classical advantage distillation. For the advantage distillation, we utilize a fixed protocol, specifically, the repetition code; in the case of entanglement distillation, we employ an enumeration algorithm to find an optimal protocol. We test our scheme for noisy entangled states and demonstrate its quantitative advantage: Our two-stage distillation scheme achieves finite key rates even in a high-noise regime where entanglement distillation or advantage distillation alone cannot afford key sharing. We also calculate the security bounds for relevant QKD protocols with our key-distillation scheme and show that they exceed the previous security bounds on the critical quantum bit error rates with only advantage distillation. Since the advantage distillation part does not introduce further requirements for quantum resources other than those required for entanglement distillation, the proposed scheme is well suited for quantum key distribution tasks with entanglement distribution networks.
One of the main problems in quantum communications is how to achieve high rates at long distances. Quantum repeaters, i.e., untrusted, intermediate relay stations, are necessary to overcome the repeaterless bound which sets the fundamental rate-distance limit of repeaterless communications. In this work, we introduce a continuous-variable protocol which overcomes the repeaterless bound and scales like the single-repeater bound using just one linear-optical device called a "quantum scissor", combining the entanglement distillation and entanglement swapping elements of previous repeater proposals into a single step, thus, removing the need for quantum memories. Implementing a standard continuous-variable quantum key distribution protocol using our repeater we predict key rates which surpass the repeaterless bound. Our protocol works well for non-ideal single-photon sources and non-ideal single-photon detectors, and can tolerate some level of excess noise, making our protocol implementable with existing technology. We show that our scheme can be extended to longer repeater chains using quantum memories, using less physical resources than previous schemes. Furthermore, for applications beyond key distribution, our scheme generalises to higher order and distils more entanglement at the cost of a reduced probability of success.
The development of quantum network relies on high-quality entanglement between remote quantum nodes. In reality the unavoidable decoherence limits the quality of entangled quantum nodes, however, entanglement distillation can overcome this problem. Here we propose an experimentally feasible scheme of continuous-variable entanglement generation, storage, and distillation between distant quantum nodes, which only requires the atomic ensemble quantum memory and balanced homodyne detection (BHD). Initially one copy of a bipartite entangled state of light, suffering phase fluctuations during the distributions, is stored in two distant atomic ensembles so that the atomic ensembles are entangled. Within the storage lifetime, by distributing and storing another copy of entangled optical modes in these two atomic ensembles, the distillation on entangled atomic spin waves can be implemented based on the post-selection of the BHD result. Our scheme provides a highly entangled state between remote quantum nodes for downstream applications, and enables the extension to multipartite entanglement distillation in a large-scale quantum network.
Entanglement distillation transforms weakly entangled noisy states into highly entangled states, a primitive to be used in quantum repeater schemes and other protocols designed for quantum communication and key distribution. In this work, we present a comprehensive framework for continuous-variable entanglement distillation schemes that convert noisy non-Gaussian states into Gaussian ones in many iterations of the protocol. Instances of these protocols include (a) the recursive-Gaussifier protocol, (b) the temporally reordered recursive-Gaussifier protocol, and (c) the pumping-Gaussifier protocol. The flexibility of these protocols gives rise to several beneficial trade-offs related to success probabilities or memory requirements, which can be adjusted to reflect experimental demands. Despite these protocols involving measurements, we relate the convergence in this protocol to new instances of noncommutative central limit theorems, in a formalism that we lay out in great detail. Implications of the findings for quantum repeater schemes are discussed.