Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1611.06273 · The Journal of Chemical Physics

Merging symmetry projection methods with coupled cluster theory: Lessons from the Lipkin model Hamiltonian

Jacob M. Wahlen-Strothman, Thomas M. Henderson, Matthew R. Hermes, Matthias Degroote, Yiheng Qiu, Jinmo Zhao, J. Dukelsky, Gustavo E. Scuseria

Published Feb 7, 2017• 36 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Coupled cluster and symmetry projected Hartree-Fock are two central paradigms in electronic structure theory. However, they are very different. Single reference coupled cluster is highly successful for treating weakly correlated systems but fails under strong correlation unless one sacrifices good quantum numbers and works with broken-symmetry wave functions, which is unphysical for finite systems. Symmetry projection is effective for the treatment of strong correlation at the mean-field level through multireference non-orthogonal configuration interaction wavefunctions, but unlike coupled cluster, it is neither size extensive nor ideal for treating dynamic correlation. We here examine different scenarios for merging these two dissimilar theories. We carry out this exercise over the integrable Lipkin model Hamiltonian, which despite its simplicity, encompasses non-trivial physics for degenerate systems and can be solved via diagonalization for a very large number of particles. We show how symmetry projection and coupled cluster doubles individually fail in different correlation limits, whereas models that merge these two theories are highly successful over the entire phase diagram. Despite the simplicity of the Lipkin Hamiltonian, the lessons learned in this work will be useful for building an ab initio symmetry projected coupled cluster theory that we expect to be accurate in the weakly and strongly correlated limits, as well as the recoupling regime.

DOI
10.1063/1.4974989

Related papers

Combining symmetry collective states with coupled-cluster theory: Lessons from the Agassi model Hamiltonian

Matthew R. Hermes, J. Dukelsky, Gustavo E. Scuseria

The failures of single-reference coupled-cluster theory for strongly correlated many-body systems is flagged at the mean-field level by the spontaneous breaking of one or more physical symmetries of the Hamiltonian. Restoring the symmetry of the mean-field determinant by projection reveals that coupled-cluster theory fails because it factorizes high-order excitation amplitudes incorrectly. However, symmetry-projected mean-field wave functions do not account sufficiently for dynamic (or weak) correlation. Here we pursue a merger of symmetry projection and coupled-cluster theory, following previous work along these lines that utilized the simple Lipkin model system as a test bed [J. Chem. Phys. 146, 054110 (2017)]. We generalize the concept of a symmetry-projected mean-field wave function to the concept of a symmetry projected state, in which the factorization of high-order excitation amplitudes in terms of low-order ones is guided by symmetry projection and is not exponential, and combine them with coupled-cluster theory in order to model the ground state of the Agassi Hamiltonian. This model has two separate channels of correlation and two separate physical symmetries which are broken under strong correlation. We show how the combination of symmetry collective states and coupled-cluster theory is effective in obtaining correlation energies and order parameters of the Agassi model throughout its phase diagram.

arXiv:1703.02123•Physical Review C•Jun 9, 2017•14 citations

Merging symmetry projection with coupled cluster theory

Yiheng Qiu

The goal of electronic structure theory is to solve the time-independent Schrodinger equation with a method that scales polynomially with the system size. The problem has been solved in the weakly-correlated regime, where coupled cluster theory (CC) with singles, doubles and perturbative triples (CCSD(T)) can achieve chemical accuracy. However, in the strongly-correlated regime, where the two-body interaction dominates, there are still no methods that can achieve a comparable accomplishment. Strong correlation always comes hand in hand with spontaneous symmetry breaking in mean-field theory. For example, coupled cluster theory faces a symmetry dilemma in the strongly correlated regime, where it either completely fails to describe the system if symmetry adapted, or has to artificially break certain symmetries in order to produce reasonable energies. It is plausible that the problem of strong correlation can be solved by curing the symptoms, i.e., fixing the symmetries. Symmetry projection has been carried out at the mean-field level, but it was unclear until this work how to incorporate correlation on top of it because of the language barrier between symmetry projection and coupled cluster theory. This thesis is devoted to combining CC and symmetry projection, focusing on spin and number symmetry. Different flavours of theories are obtained depending on whether a restricted or unrestricted reference is used. On the restricted side, the spin projected unrestricted Hartree Fock (SUHF) state can be rewritten as a polynomial of particle-hole excitations, acting on the restricted reference. Thus, this formalism opens up many ways to combine SUHF with CC. One the unrestricted side, the concept of disentangled cluster is introduced to describe the CC wavefunction transformed by symmetry rotation. A scheme basing on differential equations is devised to approximate these disentangled clusters, which scales polynomially and is systematically improvable. By combining symmetry projection and coupled cluster theory, the symmetry dilemma can be solved to a good extent.

•Aug 31, 2018•0 citations

Projected coupled cluster theory

Yiheng Qiu, Thomas M. Henderson, Jinmo Zhao +1 more

Coupled cluster theory is the method of choice for weakly correlated systems. But in the strongly correlated regime, it faces a symmetry dilemma, where it either completely fails to describe the system or has to artificially break certain symmetries. On the other hand, projected Hartree-Fock theory captures the essential physics of many kinds of strong correlations via symmetry breaking and restoration. In this work, we combine and try to retain the merits of these two methods by applying symmetry projection to broken symmetry coupled cluster wave functions. The non-orthogonal nature of states resulting from the application of symmetry projection operators furnishes particle-hole excitations to all orders, thus creating an obstacle for the exact evaluation of overlaps. Here we provide a solution via a disentanglement framework theory that can be approximated rigorously and systematically. Results of projected coupled cluster theory are presented for molecules and the Hubbard model, showing that spin projection significantly improves unrestricted coupled cluster theory while restoring good quantum numbers. The energy of projected coupled cluster theory reduces to the unprojected one in the thermodynamic limit, albeit at a much slower rate than projected Hartree-Fock.

arXiv:1706.06650•The Journal of Chemical Physics•Aug 11, 2017•77 citations

Symmetry projection methods in strongly correlated systems

Ruiheng Song

Quantum chemistry aims to understand and predict molecular structure and properties by solving the time-independent Schr\"odinger equation within fixed nuclei (Born-Oppenheimer) approximation. The Hamiltonian may have continuous symmetries (e.g., spin) or discrete symmetries (for example, point group). Mean-field wave functions may break some or all of these symmetries. By taking the symmetry-adapted pieces of these broken symmetry states, one can restore the physical character of the wave function while also treating relevant strong correlations. On the other hand, mean-field methods lack dynamic correlation arising from short-range interactions. Still, single-reference methods such as configuration interaction or coupled cluster theory can handle these correlations efficiently. Ideally, we would like to combine these approaches: performing configuration interaction or coupled cluster theory on a broken symmetry reference while restoring the desired symmetries. This work introduces a new approach to integrating symmetry projection and coupled cluster theory. By borrowing techniques from previous research, the new method can restore continuous symmetries like $U$(1) and $SU$(2) and discrete symmetries like point group and time reversal. This method achieves accurate results in challenging systems and has the same computational scaling as traditional coupled cluster theory. Jordan-Wigner transformation is a potent tool in spin models, but its application is challenging due to the inherent strings. The same techniques we use to combine symmetry projection and coupled cluster theory can be used to combine Jordan-Wigner transformation and coupled cluster. The strings are the ' symmetry projection ' operator when constructing the Hartree-Fock and coupled cluster wave functions for a Jordan-Wigner transformed Hamiltonian. Leveraging the method of symmetry projection, we obtain excellent results for both 1-D and 2-D spin models.

•Sep 30, 2024•0 citations

A power series approximation in symmetry projected coupled cluster theory

Ruiheng Song, Thomas M. Henderson, Gustavo E. Scuseria

Projected Hartree-Fock theory provides an accurate description of many kinds of strong correlations but does not properly describe weakly correlated systems. On the other hand, single-reference methods, such as configuration interaction or coupled cluster theory, can handle weakly correlated problems but cannot properly account for strong correlations. Ideally, we would like to combine these techniques in a symmetry-projected coupled cluster approach, but this is far from straightforward. In this work, we provide an alternative formulation to identify the so-called disentangled cluster operators, which arise when we combine these two methodological strands. Our formulation shows promising results for model systems and small molecules.

arXiv:2202.05931•The Journal of Chemical Physics•Feb 21, 2022•7 citations

Spin-projected generalized Hartree-Fock method as a polynomial of particle-hole excitations

Thomas M. Henderson, Gustavo E. Scuseria

The past several years have seen renewed interest in the use of symmetry-projected Hartree-Fock for the description of strong correlations. Unfortunately, these symmetry-projected mean-field methods do not adequately account for dynamic correlation. Presumably, this shortcoming could be addressed if one could combine symmetry-projected Hartree-Fock with a many-body method such as coupled-cluster theory, but this is by no means straightforward because the two techniques are formulated in very different ways. However, we have recently shown that the singlet ${S}^{2}$-projected unrestricted Hartree-Fock wave function can in fact be written in a coupled-cluster-like wave function. That is, the spin-projected unrestricted Hartree-Fock wave function can be written as a polynomial of a double-excitation operator acting on some closed-shell reference determinant. Here, we extend this result and show that the spin-projected generalized Hartree-Fock wave function (which has both ${S}^{2}$ and ${S}_{z}$ projection) is likewise a polynomial of low-order excitation operators acting on a closed-shell determinant and provide a closed-form expression for the resulting polynomial coefficients. The spin projection of the generalized Hartree-Fock wave function introduces connected triple and quadruple excitations which are absent when spin-projecting an unrestricted Hartree-Fock determinant. We include a few preliminary applications of the combination of this spin-projected Hartree-Fock and coupled-cluster theory to the Hubbard Hamiltonian and comment on generalizations of the methodology. Results here are not for production level, but a similarity-transformed theory that combines the two offers the promise of being accurate for both weak and strong correlation, and may offer significant improvements in the intermediate correlation regime where neither projected Hartree-Fock nor coupled cluster is particularly accurate.

arXiv:1706.01548•Physical Review A•Aug 4, 2017•14 citations
Coupled cluster and symmetry projected Hartree-Fock are two central paradigms in electronic structure theory. However, they are very different. Single reference coupled cluster is highly successful for treating weakly correlated systems but fails under strong correlation unless one sacrifices good quantum numbers and works with broken-symmetry wave functions, which is unphysical for finite systems. Symmetry projection is effective for the treatment of strong correlation at the mean-field level through multireference non-orthogonal configuration interaction wavefunctions, but unlike coupled cluster, it is neither size extensive nor ideal for treating dynamic correlation. We here examine different scenarios for merging these two dissimilar theories. We carry out this exercise over the integrable Lipkin model Hamiltonian, which despite its simplicity, encompasses non-trivial physics for degenerate systems and can be solved via diagonalization for a very large number of particles. We show how symmetry projection and coupled cluster doubles individually fail in different correlation limits, whereas models that merge these two theories are highly successful over the entire phase diagram. Despite the simplicity of the Lipkin Hamiltonian, the lessons learned in this work will be useful for building an ab initio symmetry projected coupled cluster theory that we expect to be accurate in the weakly and strongly correlated limits, as well as the recoupling regime.
The failures of single-reference coupled-cluster theory for strongly correlated many-body systems is flagged at the mean-field level by the spontaneous breaking of one or more physical symmetries of the Hamiltonian. Restoring the symmetry of the mean-field determinant by projection reveals that coupled-cluster theory fails because it factorizes high-order excitation amplitudes incorrectly. However, symmetry-projected mean-field wave functions do not account sufficiently for dynamic (or weak) correlation. Here we pursue a merger of symmetry projection and coupled-cluster theory, following previous work along these lines that utilized the simple Lipkin model system as a test bed [J. Chem. Phys. 146, 054110 (2017)]. We generalize the concept of a symmetry-projected mean-field wave function to the concept of a symmetry projected state, in which the factorization of high-order excitation amplitudes in terms of low-order ones is guided by symmetry projection and is not exponential, and combine them with coupled-cluster theory in order to model the ground state of the Agassi Hamiltonian. This model has two separate channels of correlation and two separate physical symmetries which are broken under strong correlation. We show how the combination of symmetry collective states and coupled-cluster theory is effective in obtaining correlation energies and order parameters of the Agassi model throughout its phase diagram.
The goal of electronic structure theory is to solve the time-independent Schrodinger equation with a method that scales polynomially with the system size. The problem has been solved in the weakly-correlated regime, where coupled cluster theory (CC) with singles, doubles and perturbative triples (CCSD(T)) can achieve chemical accuracy. However, in the strongly-correlated regime, where the two-body interaction dominates, there are still no methods that can achieve a comparable accomplishment. Strong correlation always comes hand in hand with spontaneous symmetry breaking in mean-field theory. For example, coupled cluster theory faces a symmetry dilemma in the strongly correlated regime, where it either completely fails to describe the system if symmetry adapted, or has to artificially break certain symmetries in order to produce reasonable energies. It is plausible that the problem of strong correlation can be solved by curing the symptoms, i.e., fixing the symmetries. Symmetry projection has been carried out at the mean-field level, but it was unclear until this work how to incorporate correlation on top of it because of the language barrier between symmetry projection and coupled cluster theory. This thesis is devoted to combining CC and symmetry projection, focusing on spin and number symmetry. Different flavours of theories are obtained depending on whether a restricted or unrestricted reference is used. On the restricted side, the spin projected unrestricted Hartree Fock (SUHF) state can be rewritten as a polynomial of particle-hole excitations, acting on the restricted reference. Thus, this formalism opens up many ways to combine SUHF with CC. One the unrestricted side, the concept of disentangled cluster is introduced to describe the CC wavefunction transformed by symmetry rotation. A scheme basing on differential equations is devised to approximate these disentangled clusters, which scales polynomially and is systematically improvable. By combining symmetry projection and coupled cluster theory, the symmetry dilemma can be solved to a good extent.
Coupled cluster theory is the method of choice for weakly correlated systems. But in the strongly correlated regime, it faces a symmetry dilemma, where it either completely fails to describe the system or has to artificially break certain symmetries. On the other hand, projected Hartree-Fock theory captures the essential physics of many kinds of strong correlations via symmetry breaking and restoration. In this work, we combine and try to retain the merits of these two methods by applying symmetry projection to broken symmetry coupled cluster wave functions. The non-orthogonal nature of states resulting from the application of symmetry projection operators furnishes particle-hole excitations to all orders, thus creating an obstacle for the exact evaluation of overlaps. Here we provide a solution via a disentanglement framework theory that can be approximated rigorously and systematically. Results of projected coupled cluster theory are presented for molecules and the Hubbard model, showing that spin projection significantly improves unrestricted coupled cluster theory while restoring good quantum numbers. The energy of projected coupled cluster theory reduces to the unprojected one in the thermodynamic limit, albeit at a much slower rate than projected Hartree-Fock.
Quantum chemistry aims to understand and predict molecular structure and properties by solving the time-independent Schr\"odinger equation within fixed nuclei (Born-Oppenheimer) approximation. The Hamiltonian may have continuous symmetries (e.g., spin) or discrete symmetries (for example, point group). Mean-field wave functions may break some or all of these symmetries. By taking the symmetry-adapted pieces of these broken symmetry states, one can restore the physical character of the wave function while also treating relevant strong correlations. On the other hand, mean-field methods lack dynamic correlation arising from short-range interactions. Still, single-reference methods such as configuration interaction or coupled cluster theory can handle these correlations efficiently. Ideally, we would like to combine these approaches: performing configuration interaction or coupled cluster theory on a broken symmetry reference while restoring the desired symmetries. This work introduces a new approach to integrating symmetry projection and coupled cluster theory. By borrowing techniques from previous research, the new method can restore continuous symmetries like UUU(1) and SUSUSU(2) and discrete symmetries like point group and time reversal. This method achieves accurate results in challenging systems and has the same computational scaling as traditional coupled cluster theory. Jordan-Wigner transformation is a potent tool in spin models, but its application is challenging due to the inherent strings. The same techniques we use to combine symmetry projection and coupled cluster theory can be used to combine Jordan-Wigner transformation and coupled cluster. The strings are the ' symmetry projection ' operator when constructing the Hartree-Fock and coupled cluster wave functions for a Jordan-Wigner transformed Hamiltonian. Leveraging the method of symmetry projection, we obtain excellent results for both 1-D and 2-D spin models.
Projected Hartree-Fock theory provides an accurate description of many kinds of strong correlations but does not properly describe weakly correlated systems. On the other hand, single-reference methods, such as configuration interaction or coupled cluster theory, can handle weakly correlated problems but cannot properly account for strong correlations. Ideally, we would like to combine these techniques in a symmetry-projected coupled cluster approach, but this is far from straightforward. In this work, we provide an alternative formulation to identify the so-called disentangled cluster operators, which arise when we combine these two methodological strands. Our formulation shows promising results for model systems and small molecules.
The past several years have seen renewed interest in the use of symmetry-projected Hartree-Fock for the description of strong correlations. Unfortunately, these symmetry-projected mean-field methods do not adequately account for dynamic correlation. Presumably, this shortcoming could be addressed if one could combine symmetry-projected Hartree-Fock with a many-body method such as coupled-cluster theory, but this is by no means straightforward because the two techniques are formulated in very different ways. However, we have recently shown that the singlet S2{S}^{2}S2-projected unrestricted Hartree-Fock wave function can in fact be written in a coupled-cluster-like wave function. That is, the spin-projected unrestricted Hartree-Fock wave function can be written as a polynomial of a double-excitation operator acting on some closed-shell reference determinant. Here, we extend this result and show that the spin-projected generalized Hartree-Fock wave function (which has both S2{S}^{2}S2 and Sz{S}_{z}Sz​ projection) is likewise a polynomial of low-order excitation operators acting on a closed-shell determinant and provide a closed-form expression for the resulting polynomial coefficients. The spin projection of the generalized Hartree-Fock wave function introduces connected triple and quadruple excitations which are absent when spin-projecting an unrestricted Hartree-Fock determinant. We include a few preliminary applications of the combination of this spin-projected Hartree-Fock and coupled-cluster theory to the Hubbard Hamiltonian and comment on generalizations of the methodology. Results here are not for production level, but a similarity-transformed theory that combines the two offers the promise of being accurate for both weak and strong correlation, and may offer significant improvements in the intermediate correlation regime where neither projected Hartree-Fock nor coupled cluster is particularly accurate.