Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1611.05021 · Foundations of Physics

The Contextuality Loophole is Fatal for the Derivation of Bell Inequalities: Reply to a Comment by I. Schmelzer

Theo M. Nieuwenhuizen, Marian Kupczyński

Published Jan 18, 2017• 32 citations
arXivHTMLPDF
DOI
10.1007/s10701-017-0062-y

Related papers

About a “Contextuality Loophole” in Bell’s Theorem Claimed to Exist by Nieuwenhuizen

I. Schmelzer

arXiv:1610.09642•Foundations of Physics•Oct 27, 2016•4 citations

Is the Contextuality Loophole Fatal for the Derivation of Bell Inequalities?

Theo M. Nieuwenhuizen

It is explained on a physical basis how absence of contextuality allows Bell inequalities to be violated, without bringing an implication on locality or realism. Hereto we connect first to the local realistic theory Stochastic Electrodynamics, and then put the argument more broadly. Thus even if Bell Inequality Violation is demonstrated beyond reasonable doubt, it will have no say on local realism, because absence of contextuality prevents the Bell inequalities to be derived from local realistic models.

Foundations of Physics•May 10, 2010•117 citations

Bell’s Theorem, Bell Inequalities, and the “Probability Normalization Loophole”

John F. Clauser

The frontiers collection•Nov 15, 2016•7 citations

Bell tests for collider decay processes

Danilo M. Fucci, Alexandre C. Orthey, Alan J. Barr +1 more

We propose Bell tests for collider decays using independently sampled analysis axes as settings and detector regions to assign binary or null outcomes. We show that a Bell violation requires postselection, opening a loophole. However, under measurement independence and operational equivalence of acceptance events across settings, any local model exploiting the loophole must be nonclassical in the sense of measurement contextuality. We derive a Bell inequality violated by singlet correlations when the effective spin-analyzing powers are sufficiently high. Its violation then witnesses Bell nonlocality or measurement contextuality.

quant-pharXiv:2609.09294•Sep 10, 2026•0 citations

Reply to a comment of I. Schmelzer

Schulz, Benjamin

This is a reply to the comment of Schmelzer on my earlier paper. In contrast to Schmelzer's claims, it is shown that passive locality does not correspond to the completeness condition of EPR. Nevertheless, it is argued that Schmelzer has found several errors in my article which, fortunately, can be corrected. In spite of Schmelzer's arguments, the Fritsche-Haugk theory can be used to define a local hidden variable theory for the singlet state.

arXiv:0910.5660•Oct 29, 2009•1 citation

Bell's inequality from the contextual probabilistic viewpoint

Andrei Yu. Khrennikov

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Jun 10, 2010•1 citation
It is explained on a physical basis how absence of contextuality allows Bell inequalities to be violated, without bringing an implication on locality or realism. Hereto we connect first to the local realistic theory Stochastic Electrodynamics, and then put the argument more broadly. Thus even if Bell Inequality Violation is demonstrated beyond reasonable doubt, it will have no say on local realism, because absence of contextuality prevents the Bell inequalities to be derived from local realistic models.
We propose Bell tests for collider decays using independently sampled analysis axes as settings and detector regions to assign binary or null outcomes. We show that a Bell violation requires postselection, opening a loophole. However, under measurement independence and operational equivalence of acceptance events across settings, any local model exploiting the loophole must be nonclassical in the sense of measurement contextuality. We derive a Bell inequality violated by singlet correlations when the effective spin-analyzing powers are sufficiently high. Its violation then witnesses Bell nonlocality or measurement contextuality.