arXiv:1610.04859 · Quantum

Classification of all alternatives to the Born rule in terms of informational properties

Thomas D. Galley, Lluís Masanes

Published Jul 14, 2017• 18 citations

Abstract

The standard postulates of quantum theory can be divided into two groups: the first one characterizes the structure and dynamics of pure states, while the second one specifies the structure of measurements and the corresponding probabilities. In this work we keep the first group of postulates and characterize all alternatives to the second group that give rise to finite-dimensional sets of mixed states. We prove a correspondence between all these alternatives and a class of representations of the unitary group. Some features of these probabilistic theories are identical to quantum theory, but there are important differences in others. For example, some theories have three perfectly distinguishable states in a two-dimensional Hilbert space. Others have exotic properties such as lack of bit symmetry, the violation of no simultaneous encoding (a property similar to information causality) and the existence of maximal measurements without phase groups. We also analyze which of these properties single out the Born rule.

DOI: 10.22331/q-2017-07-14-15

Related papers

Classification of all alternatives to the Born rule in terms of informational properties

Galley, TD, Lluís Masanes

The standard postulates of quantum theory can be divided into two groups: the first one characterizes the structure and dynamics of pure states, while the second one specifies the structure of measurements and the corresponding probabilities. In this work we keep the first group of postulates and characterize all alternatives to the second group that give rise to finite-dimensional sets of mixed states. We prove a correspondence between all these alternatives and a class of representations of the unitary group. Some features of these probabilistic theories are identical to quantum theory, but there are important differences in others. For example, some theories have three perfectly distinguishable states in a two-dimensional Hilbert space. Others have exotic properties such as lack of "bit symmetry", the violation of "no simultaneous encoding" (a property similar to information causality) and the existence of maximal measurements without phase groups. We also analyze which of these properties single out the Born rule.

Jul 14, 201716 citations

The Born Rule Without a Measurement Postulate

D. Ring

The Born rule governs the probability of outcomes of measurements of quantum systems. Many attempts have been made to derive the Born rule from other postulates. We perform such an analysis in an Everett interpretation without any measurement postulates at all. We explain that probability is an ill defined concept and that an agent who nevertheless wishes to make approximate predictions will have no alternative measure to weigh the alternatives without subjecting herself to a dutch book. Our demonstration is complete for projective measurements of pure states in a finite dimensional Hilbert space and we discuss how it might be applied to generalized measurements. A similar demonstration is impossible for mixed states. Nevertheless, following the standard convention, probability for mixed states has the same validity and issues as it does in classical physics.

Jan 23, 20260 citations

Modifying the measurement postulates of quantum theory

Thomas D. Galley

Quantum theory can be formulated using a small number of mathematical postulates. These postulates describe how quantum systems interact and evolve as well as describing measurements and probabilities of measurement outcomes. The measurement postulates are logically independent from the other postulates, which are dynamical and compositional in nature. In this thesis we study all theories which have the same dynamical and compositional postulates as quantum theory but different measurement postulates. In the first part we introduce the necessary tools for this task: the operational approach to physical theories (general probabilistic theories) and the representation theory of the unitary group. Following this we introduce a framework which is used to describe theories with modified measurement postulates and we classify all possible alternative measurement postulates using representation theory. We then study informational properties of single systems described by these theories and compare them to quantum systems. Finally we study properties of bi-partite systems in these theories. We show that all bi-partite systems in these theories violate two properties which are met by quantum systems: purification and local tomography.

Jan 1, 20180 citations

Any modification of the Born rule leads to a violation of the purification and local tomography principles

Thomas D. Galley, Lluís Masanes

Using the existing classification of all alternatives to the measurement postulates of quantum theory we study the properties of bi-partite systems in these alternative theories. We prove that in all these theories the purification principle is violated, meaning that some mixed states are not the reduction of a pure state in a larger system. This allows us to derive the measurement postulates of quantum theory from the structure of pure states and reversible dynamics, and the requirement that the purification principle holds. The violation of the purification principle implies that there is some irreducible classicality in these theories, which appears like an important clue for the problem of deriving the Born rule within the many-worlds interpretation. We also prove that in all such modifications the task of state tomography with local measurements is impossible, and present a simple toy theory displaying all these exotic non-quantum phenomena. This toy model shows that, contrarily to previous claims, it is possible to modify the Born rule without violating the no-signalling principle. Finally, we argue that the quantum measurement postulates are the most non-classical amongst all alternatives.

arXiv:1801.06414QuantumNov 6, 201816 citations

Impossibility of mixed-state purification in any alternative to the Born Rule

Thomas D. Galley, Lluís Masanes

Using the existing classification of all alternatives to the Measurement Postulates of Quantum Mechanics we study the properties of multi-partite systems in these alternative theories. We prove that in all these theories the Purification Principle is violated, meaning that some mixed states are not the reduction of a pure state in a larger system. This implies that simple operational processes, like mixing two states, cannot be described in an agent-free universe. This appears like a crucial clue for the problem of deriving the Born Rule within unitary quantum mechanics or the many-worlds interpretation. We also prove that in all such modifications the task of state tomography with local measurements is impossible, and present a simple toy theory displaying all these exotic non-quantum phenomena. This toy model shows that, contrarily to previous claims, it is possible to modify the Born rule without violating the No-Signalling Principle. Finally, we argue that the quantum measurement postulates are the most non-classical amongst all alternatives.

Jan 19, 20182 citations

Pure States

K. Kong Wan

This chapter presents a systematic treatment of quantum theory in terms of six groups of postulates on the fundamental properties of quantum systems: postulate on the description of pure states, postulate on the description of observables and their values, postulate on the transition from classical to quantum systems, postulates on the probabilistic relationship between states and observables, postulates on the time evolution of the system and postulate on states after measurement. It extends the basic theory to discuss mixed states, superselection rules and many-particle systems. The chapter presents a brief discussion of conceptual problems in quantum mechanics. A maximum amount of information about the system corresponds to a set of simultaneously measured values of a complete set of discrete observables of the system. Such an amount of information characterises a state of the system. States characterised by such a maximum amount of information about the system are called pure states.

Jul 9, 20190 citations