Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1609.02335 · Physical Review A

Cancellation of the N -composite-boson correlation energy under a BCS-like potential: A dimensionality-dependent effect

Shiue-Yuan Shiau, Monique Combescot, Yia‐Chung Chang

Published Sep 28, 2016• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We use Richardson-Gaudin exact equations to derive the ground-state energy of $N$ composite bosons (cobosons) interacting via a potential which acts between fermion pairs having zero center-of-mass momentum, that is, a potential similar to the reduced BCS potential used in conventional superconductivity. Through a density expansion, we show that while for two-dimensional (2D) systems, the $N$-coboson correlation energy undergoes a surprising cancellation which leaves the interaction part with an $N(N\ensuremath{-}1)$ dependence only, such a cancellation does not exist in 1D, 3D, or 4D systems (which correspond to 2D parabolic traps) nor when the cobosons interact via a similar short-range potential but between pairs having an arbitrary center-of-mass momentum. This shows that the previously found cancellation which exists for the Cooper-pair correlation energy results not only from the very peculiar form of the reduced BCS potential, but also from a quite mysterious dimensionality effect, the density of states for Cooper pairs feeling the BCS potential being essentially constant, as for 2D systems.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.94.032710

Related papers

Energy of N Cooper Pairs by Analytically Solving the Richardson-Gaudin Equations for Conventional Superconductors

Michel Crouzeix, Monique Combescot

This Letter provides the solution to a yet unsolved basic problem of solid state physics: the ground state energy of an arbitrary number of Cooper pairs interacting via the Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer potential. We here break a 50 yr old math problem by analytically solving Richardson-Gaudin equations which give the exact energy of these N pairs via N parameters coupled through N nonlinear equations. Our result fully supports the standard BCS result obtained for a pair number equal to half the number of states feeling the potential. More importantly, it shows that the interaction part of the N-pair energy depends on N as N(N-1) only from N=1 to the dense regime, a result which evidences that Cooper pairs interact via Pauli blocking only.

Physical Review Letters•Dec 22, 2011•16 citations

Correlated-pair approach to composite-boson scattering lengths

Shiue-Yuan Shiau, Monique Combescot, Yia‐Chung Chang

We derive the scattering length of composite bosons (cobosons) within the framework of the composite-boson many-body formalism that uses correlated-pair states as a basis instead of free-fermion states. The integral equation constructed from this physically relevant basis makes transparent the role of fermion exchange in the coboson-coboson effective scattering. Three potentials used for Cooper pairs, fermionic-atom dimers, and semiconductor excitons are considered. While the $s$-wave scattering length for the BCS-like potential is just equal to its Born value, the other two are substantially smaller. For fermionic-atom dimers and semiconductor excitons, our results, calculated within a restricted correlated-pair basis, are in good agreement with those obtained from procedures numerically more demanding. We also propose model coboson-coboson scatterings that are separable and thus easily workable and that produce scattering lengths which match quantitatively well with the numerically obtained values for all fermion mass ratios. These separable model scatterings can facilitate future works on many-body effects in coboson gases.

arXiv:1610.03212•Physical Review A•Nov 28, 2016•10 citations

Richardson-Gaudin Exact Solution

Monique Combescot, Shiue-Yuan Shiau

Chapter 10 deals with the exact solution to the BCS problem, as obtained by analytically solving Richardson-Gaudin equations. The chapter first provides a simple derivation of these equations and shows how to solve them for arbitrary N. The explicit N dependence of the N–Cooper pair energy obtained from this resolution provides invaluable insights into the role of the Pauli exclusion principle in paired fermion systems because the reduced BCS potential does not directly act between Cooper pairs. Revelation of this subtle point makes it possible to understand (i) why Cooper pairs can strongly overlap without breaking, whereas, at large density, an exciton system dissociates into an electron-hole plasma, and (ii) why the gap energy is far larger than the average pair energy. This understanding is further supported by the Cooper pair many-body parameter, which has the same form as the ones for Wannier or Frenkel excitons do.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Dec 1, 2015•0 citations

Energy of N Cooper pair by analytically solving Richardson-Gaudin equations

Michel Crouzeix, Monique Combescot

This Letter provides the solution to a yet unsolved basic problem of Solid State Physics: the ground state energy of an arbitrary number of Cooper pairs interacting via the Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer potential. We here break a 50 year old math problem by analytically solving Richardson-Gaudin equations which give the exact energy of these $N$ pairs via $N$ parameters coupled through $N$ non-linear equations. Our result fully supports the standard BCS result obtained for a pair number equal to half the number of states feeling the potential. More importantly, it shows that the interaction part of the $N$-pair energy depends on $N$ as $N(N-1)$ only from N=1 to the dense regime, a result which evidences that Cooper pairs interact via Pauli blocking only.

arXiv:1111.5801•Nov 24, 2011•0 citations

BCS-Bose model of exotic superconductors: Generalized coherence length

M. Casas, J. M. Getino, MANUEL DE LLANO +4 more

Analytic expressions are derived for the root-mean-square (rms) radius of a pair of fermions in a BCS many-fermion state in one, two, and three dimensions, in terms of the BCS gap energy and the associated chemical potential. These expressions are valid for any coupling strength of any pair interaction model implying a momentum-independent gap energy. The latter holds, e.g., for an attractive \ensuremath{\delta} pair potential examined in the one-dimensional (1D) case (whose N-fermion ground state can be determined exactly) or for the BCS (electron-phonon) model interaction in any dimension. Weak-coupling and/or high-density limits for the rms radius are identical in 1D, 2D, and 3D, and reduce to the familiar well-known Pippard result to within a factor of order unity. In contrast, strong-coupling and/or low-density limits coincide in 1D and 3D, but differ by a factor of order unity in the 2D limit, and in each case are essentially the size of a single, isolated pair. The 1D \ensuremath{\delta} interaction McGuire-Yang-Gaudin many-fermion model is studied in detail. The interaction renormalization scheme of Miyake and of Randeria, Duan, and Shieh, and the BCS interaction model, both in 2D, are employed to analyze cuprate superconductor empirical results. Reasonable agreement between theoretical rms radii with experimental coherence lengths suggests that cuprates can be described moderately well as weakly coupled superconductors within the BCS-Bose formalism.

Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Dec 1, 1994•31 citations

Composite bosons in the two-dimensional BCS-BEC crossover from Gaussian fluctuations

Luca Salasnich, Flavio Toigo

We study Gaussian fluctuations of the zero-temperature attractive Fermi gas in the two-dimensional (2D) BCS-BEC crossover showing that they are crucial to get a reliable equation of state in the Bose-Einstein condensation (BEC) regime of composite bosons, bound states of fermionic pairs. A low-momentum expansion up to the fourth order of the quadratic action of the fluctuating pairing field gives an ultraviolent divergent contribution of the Gaussian fluctuations to the grand potential. Performing dimensional regularization we evaluate the effective coupling constant in the beyond-mean-field grand potential. Remarkably, in the BEC regime our grand potential gives exactly the Popov's equation of state of 2D interacting bosons, and allows us to identify the scattering length ${a}_{B}$ of the interaction between composite bosons as ${a}_{B}={a}_{F}/({2}^{1/2}{e}^{1/4})=0.551...{a}_{F}$, with ${a}_{F}$ is the scattering length of fermions. Remarkably, the value from our analytical relationship between the two scattering lengths is in full agreement with that obtained by recent Monte Carlo calculations.

arXiv:1410.3995•Physical Review A•Jan 26, 2015•28 citations
We use Richardson-Gaudin exact equations to derive the ground-state energy of NNN composite bosons (cobosons) interacting via a potential which acts between fermion pairs having zero center-of-mass momentum, that is, a potential similar to the reduced BCS potential used in conventional superconductivity. Through a density expansion, we show that while for two-dimensional (2D) systems, the NNN-coboson correlation energy undergoes a surprising cancellation which leaves the interaction part with an N(N\ensuremath−1)N(N\ensuremath{-}1)N(N\ensuremath−1) dependence only, such a cancellation does not exist in 1D, 3D, or 4D systems (which correspond to 2D parabolic traps) nor when the cobosons interact via a similar short-range potential but between pairs having an arbitrary center-of-mass momentum. This shows that the previously found cancellation which exists for the Cooper-pair correlation energy results not only from the very peculiar form of the reduced BCS potential, but also from a quite mysterious dimensionality effect, the density of states for Cooper pairs feeling the BCS potential being essentially constant, as for 2D systems.
This Letter provides the solution to a yet unsolved basic problem of solid state physics: the ground state energy of an arbitrary number of Cooper pairs interacting via the Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer potential. We here break a 50 yr old math problem by analytically solving Richardson-Gaudin equations which give the exact energy of these N pairs via N parameters coupled through N nonlinear equations. Our result fully supports the standard BCS result obtained for a pair number equal to half the number of states feeling the potential. More importantly, it shows that the interaction part of the N-pair energy depends on N as N(N-1) only from N=1 to the dense regime, a result which evidences that Cooper pairs interact via Pauli blocking only.
We derive the scattering length of composite bosons (cobosons) within the framework of the composite-boson many-body formalism that uses correlated-pair states as a basis instead of free-fermion states. The integral equation constructed from this physically relevant basis makes transparent the role of fermion exchange in the coboson-coboson effective scattering. Three potentials used for Cooper pairs, fermionic-atom dimers, and semiconductor excitons are considered. While the sss-wave scattering length for the BCS-like potential is just equal to its Born value, the other two are substantially smaller. For fermionic-atom dimers and semiconductor excitons, our results, calculated within a restricted correlated-pair basis, are in good agreement with those obtained from procedures numerically more demanding. We also propose model coboson-coboson scatterings that are separable and thus easily workable and that produce scattering lengths which match quantitatively well with the numerically obtained values for all fermion mass ratios. These separable model scatterings can facilitate future works on many-body effects in coboson gases.
Chapter 10 deals with the exact solution to the BCS problem, as obtained by analytically solving Richardson-Gaudin equations. The chapter first provides a simple derivation of these equations and shows how to solve them for arbitrary N. The explicit N dependence of the N–Cooper pair energy obtained from this resolution provides invaluable insights into the role of the Pauli exclusion principle in paired fermion systems because the reduced BCS potential does not directly act between Cooper pairs. Revelation of this subtle point makes it possible to understand (i) why Cooper pairs can strongly overlap without breaking, whereas, at large density, an exciton system dissociates into an electron-hole plasma, and (ii) why the gap energy is far larger than the average pair energy. This understanding is further supported by the Cooper pair many-body parameter, which has the same form as the ones for Wannier or Frenkel excitons do.
This Letter provides the solution to a yet unsolved basic problem of Solid State Physics: the ground state energy of an arbitrary number of Cooper pairs interacting via the Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer potential. We here break a 50 year old math problem by analytically solving Richardson-Gaudin equations which give the exact energy of these NNN pairs via NNN parameters coupled through NNN non-linear equations. Our result fully supports the standard BCS result obtained for a pair number equal to half the number of states feeling the potential. More importantly, it shows that the interaction part of the NNN-pair energy depends on NNN as N(N−1)N(N-1)N(N−1) only from N=1 to the dense regime, a result which evidences that Cooper pairs interact via Pauli blocking only.
Analytic expressions are derived for the root-mean-square (rms) radius of a pair of fermions in a BCS many-fermion state in one, two, and three dimensions, in terms of the BCS gap energy and the associated chemical potential. These expressions are valid for any coupling strength of any pair interaction model implying a momentum-independent gap energy. The latter holds, e.g., for an attractive \ensuremath{\delta} pair potential examined in the one-dimensional (1D) case (whose N-fermion ground state can be determined exactly) or for the BCS (electron-phonon) model interaction in any dimension. Weak-coupling and/or high-density limits for the rms radius are identical in 1D, 2D, and 3D, and reduce to the familiar well-known Pippard result to within a factor of order unity. In contrast, strong-coupling and/or low-density limits coincide in 1D and 3D, but differ by a factor of order unity in the 2D limit, and in each case are essentially the size of a single, isolated pair. The 1D \ensuremath{\delta} interaction McGuire-Yang-Gaudin many-fermion model is studied in detail. The interaction renormalization scheme of Miyake and of Randeria, Duan, and Shieh, and the BCS interaction model, both in 2D, are employed to analyze cuprate superconductor empirical results. Reasonable agreement between theoretical rms radii with experimental coherence lengths suggests that cuprates can be described moderately well as weakly coupled superconductors within the BCS-Bose formalism.
We study Gaussian fluctuations of the zero-temperature attractive Fermi gas in the two-dimensional (2D) BCS-BEC crossover showing that they are crucial to get a reliable equation of state in the Bose-Einstein condensation (BEC) regime of composite bosons, bound states of fermionic pairs. A low-momentum expansion up to the fourth order of the quadratic action of the fluctuating pairing field gives an ultraviolent divergent contribution of the Gaussian fluctuations to the grand potential. Performing dimensional regularization we evaluate the effective coupling constant in the beyond-mean-field grand potential. Remarkably, in the BEC regime our grand potential gives exactly the Popov's equation of state of 2D interacting bosons, and allows us to identify the scattering length aB{a}_{B}aB​ of the interaction between composite bosons as aB=aF/(21/2e1/4)=0.551...aF{a}_{B}={a}_{F}/({2}^{1/2}{e}^{1/4})=0.551...{a}_{F}aB​=aF​/(21/2e1/4)=0.551...aF​, with aF{a}_{F}aF​ is the scattering length of fermions. Remarkably, the value from our analytical relationship between the two scattering lengths is in full agreement with that obtained by recent Monte Carlo calculations.