Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1608.00994 · Physical Review A

Geometry of entanglement in the Bloch sphere

Michel Boyer, Rotem Liss, Tal Mor

Published Mar 7, 2017• 23 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Entanglement is an important concept in quantum information, quantum communication, and quantum computing. We provide a geometrical analysis of entanglement and separability for all the rank 2 quantum mixed states: complete analysis for the bipartite states and partial analysis for the multipartite states. For each rank 2 mixed state, we define its unique Bloch sphere, that is spanned by the eigenstates of its density matrix. We characterize those Bloch spheres into exactly five classes of entanglement and separability, give examples for each class, and prove that those are the only classes.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.95.032308

Related papers

Entanglement and Geometrical Distances in Quantum Information and Quantum Cryptography

Rotem Liss

The counter-intuitive features of Quantum Mechanics make it possible to solve problems and perform tasks that are beyond the abilities of classical computers and classical communication devices. The area of quantum information processing studies how representing information by quantum states can help achieving such improvements.In this research, we use basic notions of quantum information (mainly entanglement, Bloch sphere, and geometrical distances between quantum states) for analyzing relations of quantum states to each other and quantum cryptographic protocols.Entanglement is an important feature of quantum states. Intuitively (and, partly, inaccurately), entanglement represents quantum (non-classical) correlations between several different quantum systems. Entanglement is one of the most important quantum phenomena, and it has many uses in quantum information, quantum communication, and quantum computing.Some quantum states can be geometrically represented by the Bloch sphere: the unit sphere in the three-dimensional Euclidean space. The "standard" quantum states, to which the laws of Quantum Mechanics directly apply, are called pure states. Other states are the mixed states: probability distributions ("mixtures") of several pure states. The points on the Bloch sphere are the pure states, and those inside the Bloch sphere are the mixed states. This geometrical representation is useful and intuitive for many purposes.We provide a geometrical analysis of entanglement for all the quantum mixed states of rank 2 (all the mixtures of exactly two pure states): for any such state (in any dimension), we define a generalized Bloch sphere by using the two pure states, and we analyze this state and its neighbor states inside this Bloch sphere. We look at the set of non-entangled states ("separable states") in the Bloch sphere and characterize it into exactly five possible classes. We give examples for each class and prove that there are no other classes. In addition, we suggest possible definitions of "entanglement measures" by using the "trace distance" from the nearest separable state.Many types of distances between quantum states can be defined. One of the most useful distances is the trace distance, which bounds the "distinguishability" between the states. The trace distance is very useful in quantum information and quantum cryptography, and it also has a simple geometrical interpretation: it is half of the Euclidean distance between the states in the Bloch sphere.Quantum key distribution (QKD) protocols make it possible for two participators to achieve the classically-impossible task of generating a secret random shared key even if their adversary is computationally unlimited. Several important QKD protocols, including the first protocol of Bennett and Brassard (BB84), have their unconditional security proved against adversaries performing the most general attacks in a theoretical (idealized) setting. We discuss a slightly different protocol, named "BB84-INFO-z", and prove it secure against a broad class of attacks (the collective attacks). Moreover, we make use of the "trace distance" for making our security proof more "composable" than similar security proofs for BB84: namely, for making a step towards proving that the secret key remains secret even when the two participators actually use it for cryptographic purposes.

•Aug 31, 2022•1 citation

Geometrical analysis and entanglement measure of symmetric multiqubit states

Bilal Benzimoun, Mohammed Daoud A

We geometrically examine the entanglement in symmetric multiquibt states using the spin coherent states properties. We employ the Majorana representation to examine how coherent (polarized) and unpolarized states can be represented in the Bloch sphere and subsequently to quantify entanglement in multipartite systems. Entanglement can be viewed as a distance separate two points in Bloch sphere and how this notion can be extended for multipartite states in W class. This provides us with an entanglement measure for [Formula: see text]-states analogue to the notion of Concurrence.

International Journal of Geometric Methods in Modern Physics•Jul 1, 2020•2 citations

Entangled Bloch spheres: Bloch matrix and two-qubit state space

Omar Gamel

We represent a two-qubit density matrix in the basis of Pauli matrix tensor products, with the coefficients constituting a Bloch matrix, analogous to the single qubit Bloch vector. We find the quantum state positivity requirements on the Bloch matrix components, leading to three important inequalities, allowing us to parametrize and visualize the two-qubit state space. Applying the singular value decomposition naturally separates the degrees of freedom to local and nonlocal, and simplifies the positivity inequalities. It also allows us to geometrically represent a state as two entangled Bloch spheres with superimposed correlation axes. It is shown that unitary transformations, local or nonlocal, have simple interpretations as axis rotations or mixing of certain degrees of freedom. The nonlocal unitary invariants of the state are then derived in terms of local unitary invariants. The positive partial transpose criterion for entanglement is generalized, and interpreted as a reflection, or a change of a single sign. The formalism is used to characterize maximally entangled states, and generalize two qubit isotropic and Werner states.

arXiv:1602.01548•Physical Review A•Jun 20, 2016•107 citations

Topological order on the Bloch sphere

Rotem Liss, Tal Mor, Román Orús

Abstract A Bloch sphere is the geometrical representation of an arbitrary two-dimensional Hilbert space. Possible classes of entanglement and separability for the pure and mixed states on the Bloch sphere were suggested by [Boyer et al 2017 PRA 95 032 308]. Here we construct a Bloch sphere for the Hilbert space spanned by one of the ground states of Kitaev’s toric code model and one of its closest product states. We prove that this sphere contains only one separable state, thus belonging to the fourth class suggested by the said paper. We furthermore study the topological order of the pure states on its surface and conclude that, according to conventional definitions, only one state (the toric code ground state) seems to present non-trivial topological order. We conjecture that most of the states on this Bloch sphere are neither ‘trivial’ states (namely, they cannot be generated from a product state using a trivial circuit) nor topologically ordered. In addition, we show that the whole setting can be understood in terms of Grover rotations with gauge symmetry, akin to the quantum search algorithm.

arXiv:1812.00671•New Journal of Physics•Mar 1, 2020•0 citations

Geometry of entanglement and separability in Hilbert subspaces of dimension up to three

Rotem Liss, Tal Mor, Andreas Winter

Abstract We present a complete classification of the geometry of the mutually complementary sets of entangled and separable states in three-dimensional Hilbert subspaces of bipartite and multipartite quantum systems. Our analysis begins by finding the geometric structure of the pure product states in a given three-dimensional Hilbert subspace, which determines all the possible separable and entangled mixed states over the same subspace. In bipartite systems, we characterise the 14 possible qualitatively different geometric shapes for the set of separable states in any three-dimensional Hilbert subspace (5 classes which also appear in two-dimensional subspaces and were found and analysed by Boyer et al. (Phys Rev A 95:032308, 2017. https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevA.95.032308 ), and 9 novel classes which appear only in three-dimensional subspaces), describe their geometries, and provide figures illustrating them. We also generalise these results to characterise the sets of fully separable states (and hence the complementary sets of somewhat entangled states) in three-dimensional subspaces of multipartite systems. Our results show which geometrical forms quantum entanglement can and cannot take in low-dimensional subspaces.

arXiv:2309.05144•Letters in Mathematical Physics•Jun 21, 2024•3 citations

CLASSIFICATION OF ENTANGLEMENT IN SYMMETRIC STATES

Martin Aulbach

Quantum states that are symmetric with respect to permutations of their subsystems appear in a wide range of physical settings, and they have a variety of promising applications in quantum information science. In this thesis, the entanglement of symmetric multipartite states is categorized, with a particular focus on the pure multi-qubit case and the geometric measure of entanglement. An essential tool for this analysis is the Majorana representation, a generalization of the single-qubit Bloch sphere representation, which allows for a unique representation of symmetric n-qubit states by n points on the surface of a sphere. Here this representation is employed to search for the maximally entangled symmetric states of up to 12 qubits in terms of the geometric measure, and an intuitive visual understanding of the upper bound on the maximal symmetric entanglement is given. Furthermore, it will be seen that the Majorana representation facilitates the characterization of entanglement equivalence classes such as stochastic local operations and classical communication (SLOCC) and the degeneracy configuration (DC). It is found that SLOCC operations between symmetric states can be described by the Möbius transformations of complex analysis, which allows for a clear visualization of the SLOCC freedoms and facilitates the understanding of SLOCC invariants and equivalence classes. In particular, explicit forms of representative states for all symmetric SLOCC classes of up to five qubits are derived. Well-known entanglement classification schemes such as the four qubit entanglement families or polynomial invariants are reviewed in the light of the results gathered here, which leads to sometimes surprising connections. Some interesting links and applications of the Majorana representation to related fields of mathematics and physics are also discussed.

arXiv:1110.5200•International Journal of Quantum Information•Oct 1, 2012•37 citations
Entanglement is an important concept in quantum information, quantum communication, and quantum computing. We provide a geometrical analysis of entanglement and separability for all the rank 2 quantum mixed states: complete analysis for the bipartite states and partial analysis for the multipartite states. For each rank 2 mixed state, we define its unique Bloch sphere, that is spanned by the eigenstates of its density matrix. We characterize those Bloch spheres into exactly five classes of entanglement and separability, give examples for each class, and prove that those are the only classes.
The counter-intuitive features of Quantum Mechanics make it possible to solve problems and perform tasks that are beyond the abilities of classical computers and classical communication devices. The area of quantum information processing studies how representing information by quantum states can help achieving such improvements.In this research, we use basic notions of quantum information (mainly entanglement, Bloch sphere, and geometrical distances between quantum states) for analyzing relations of quantum states to each other and quantum cryptographic protocols.Entanglement is an important feature of quantum states. Intuitively (and, partly, inaccurately), entanglement represents quantum (non-classical) correlations between several different quantum systems. Entanglement is one of the most important quantum phenomena, and it has many uses in quantum information, quantum communication, and quantum computing.Some quantum states can be geometrically represented by the Bloch sphere: the unit sphere in the three-dimensional Euclidean space. The "standard" quantum states, to which the laws of Quantum Mechanics directly apply, are called pure states. Other states are the mixed states: probability distributions ("mixtures") of several pure states. The points on the Bloch sphere are the pure states, and those inside the Bloch sphere are the mixed states. This geometrical representation is useful and intuitive for many purposes.We provide a geometrical analysis of entanglement for all the quantum mixed states of rank 2 (all the mixtures of exactly two pure states): for any such state (in any dimension), we define a generalized Bloch sphere by using the two pure states, and we analyze this state and its neighbor states inside this Bloch sphere. We look at the set of non-entangled states ("separable states") in the Bloch sphere and characterize it into exactly five possible classes. We give examples for each class and prove that there are no other classes. In addition, we suggest possible definitions of "entanglement measures" by using the "trace distance" from the nearest separable state.Many types of distances between quantum states can be defined. One of the most useful distances is the trace distance, which bounds the "distinguishability" between the states. The trace distance is very useful in quantum information and quantum cryptography, and it also has a simple geometrical interpretation: it is half of the Euclidean distance between the states in the Bloch sphere.Quantum key distribution (QKD) protocols make it possible for two participators to achieve the classically-impossible task of generating a secret random shared key even if their adversary is computationally unlimited. Several important QKD protocols, including the first protocol of Bennett and Brassard (BB84), have their unconditional security proved against adversaries performing the most general attacks in a theoretical (idealized) setting. We discuss a slightly different protocol, named "BB84-INFO-z", and prove it secure against a broad class of attacks (the collective attacks). Moreover, we make use of the "trace distance" for making our security proof more "composable" than similar security proofs for BB84: namely, for making a step towards proving that the secret key remains secret even when the two participators actually use it for cryptographic purposes.
We geometrically examine the entanglement in symmetric multiquibt states using the spin coherent states properties. We employ the Majorana representation to examine how coherent (polarized) and unpolarized states can be represented in the Bloch sphere and subsequently to quantify entanglement in multipartite systems. Entanglement can be viewed as a distance separate two points in Bloch sphere and how this notion can be extended for multipartite states in W class. This provides us with an entanglement measure for [Formula: see text]-states analogue to the notion of Concurrence.
We represent a two-qubit density matrix in the basis of Pauli matrix tensor products, with the coefficients constituting a Bloch matrix, analogous to the single qubit Bloch vector. We find the quantum state positivity requirements on the Bloch matrix components, leading to three important inequalities, allowing us to parametrize and visualize the two-qubit state space. Applying the singular value decomposition naturally separates the degrees of freedom to local and nonlocal, and simplifies the positivity inequalities. It also allows us to geometrically represent a state as two entangled Bloch spheres with superimposed correlation axes. It is shown that unitary transformations, local or nonlocal, have simple interpretations as axis rotations or mixing of certain degrees of freedom. The nonlocal unitary invariants of the state are then derived in terms of local unitary invariants. The positive partial transpose criterion for entanglement is generalized, and interpreted as a reflection, or a change of a single sign. The formalism is used to characterize maximally entangled states, and generalize two qubit isotropic and Werner states.
Abstract A Bloch sphere is the geometrical representation of an arbitrary two-dimensional Hilbert space. Possible classes of entanglement and separability for the pure and mixed states on the Bloch sphere were suggested by [Boyer et al 2017 PRA 95 032 308]. Here we construct a Bloch sphere for the Hilbert space spanned by one of the ground states of Kitaev’s toric code model and one of its closest product states. We prove that this sphere contains only one separable state, thus belonging to the fourth class suggested by the said paper. We furthermore study the topological order of the pure states on its surface and conclude that, according to conventional definitions, only one state (the toric code ground state) seems to present non-trivial topological order. We conjecture that most of the states on this Bloch sphere are neither ‘trivial’ states (namely, they cannot be generated from a product state using a trivial circuit) nor topologically ordered. In addition, we show that the whole setting can be understood in terms of Grover rotations with gauge symmetry, akin to the quantum search algorithm.
Abstract We present a complete classification of the geometry of the mutually complementary sets of entangled and separable states in three-dimensional Hilbert subspaces of bipartite and multipartite quantum systems. Our analysis begins by finding the geometric structure of the pure product states in a given three-dimensional Hilbert subspace, which determines all the possible separable and entangled mixed states over the same subspace. In bipartite systems, we characterise the 14 possible qualitatively different geometric shapes for the set of separable states in any three-dimensional Hilbert subspace (5 classes which also appear in two-dimensional subspaces and were found and analysed by Boyer et al. (Phys Rev A 95:032308, 2017. https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevA.95.032308 ), and 9 novel classes which appear only in three-dimensional subspaces), describe their geometries, and provide figures illustrating them. We also generalise these results to characterise the sets of fully separable states (and hence the complementary sets of somewhat entangled states) in three-dimensional subspaces of multipartite systems. Our results show which geometrical forms quantum entanglement can and cannot take in low-dimensional subspaces.
Quantum states that are symmetric with respect to permutations of their subsystems appear in a wide range of physical settings, and they have a variety of promising applications in quantum information science. In this thesis, the entanglement of symmetric multipartite states is categorized, with a particular focus on the pure multi-qubit case and the geometric measure of entanglement. An essential tool for this analysis is the Majorana representation, a generalization of the single-qubit Bloch sphere representation, which allows for a unique representation of symmetric n-qubit states by n points on the surface of a sphere. Here this representation is employed to search for the maximally entangled symmetric states of up to 12 qubits in terms of the geometric measure, and an intuitive visual understanding of the upper bound on the maximal symmetric entanglement is given. Furthermore, it will be seen that the Majorana representation facilitates the characterization of entanglement equivalence classes such as stochastic local operations and classical communication (SLOCC) and the degeneracy configuration (DC). It is found that SLOCC operations between symmetric states can be described by the Möbius transformations of complex analysis, which allows for a clear visualization of the SLOCC freedoms and facilitates the understanding of SLOCC invariants and equivalence classes. In particular, explicit forms of representative states for all symmetric SLOCC classes of up to five qubits are derived. Well-known entanglement classification schemes such as the four qubit entanglement families or polynomial invariants are reviewed in the light of the results gathered here, which leads to sometimes surprising connections. Some interesting links and applications of the Majorana representation to related fields of mathematics and physics are also discussed.