Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1606.08368 · Physical Review Letters

No-Go Theorem for the Characterization of Work Fluctuations in Coherent Quantum Systems

Martí Perarnau-Llobet, Elisa Bäumer, Karen V. Hovhannisyan, Marcus Huber, Antonio Acín

Published Feb 14, 2017• 208 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

An open question of fundamental importance in thermodynamics is how to describe the fluctuations of work for quantum coherent processes. In the standard approach, based on a projective energy measurement both at the beginning and at the end of the process, the first measurement destroys any initial coherence in the energy basis. Here we seek extensions of this approach which can possibly account for initially coherent states. We consider all measurement schemes to estimate work and require that (i) the difference of average energy corresponds to average work for closed quantum systems and that (ii) the work statistics agree with the standard two-measurement scheme for states with no coherence in the energy basis. We first show that such a scheme cannot exist. Next, we consider the possibility of performing collective measurements on several copies of the state and prove that it is still impossible to simultaneously satisfy requirements (i) and (ii). Nevertheless, improvements do appear, and in particular, we develop a measurement scheme that acts simultaneously on two copies of the state and allows us to describe a whole class of coherent transformations.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.118.070601

Related papers

Quantum Fluctuations of Work and Generalised Quantum Measurements

Martí Perarnau-Llobet, Elisa Bäumer, Karen V. Hovhannisyan +2 more

An open question of fundamental importance in thermodynamics is how to describe the fluctuations of work for quantum coherent processes. In the standard approach, based on a projective energy measurement both at the beginning and at the end of the process, the first measurement destroys any initial coherence in the energy basis. Here we seek for extensions of this approach which can possibly account for initially coherent states. We therefore consider all measurement schemes to estimate work and require that (i) they agree with the standard two-measurement scheme for states with no coherence in the energy basis, and (ii) the expected value of the measurement outcomes is equal to the average energy difference of the unmeasured process for all states. We first show that such a scheme does not exist. Next, we consider the possibility of performing collective measurements on several copies of the state and prove that it still impossible to satisfy simultaneously requirements (i) and (ii). Nevertheless, improvements do appear, and in particular we develop a measurement scheme which acts simultaneously on two copies of the state and allows to describe a whole class of coherent transformations.

•Jun 27, 2016•2 citations

Class of quasiprobability distributions of work and initial quantum coherence

Gianluca Francica

The work is a concept of fundamental importance in thermodynamics. An open question is how to describe the work fluctuation for quantum coherent processes in the presence of initial quantum coherence in the energy basis. With the aim of giving a unified description, here we introduce and study a class of quasiprobability distributions of work, which give an average work equal to the average energy change of the system and reduce to the two-projective measurement scheme for an initial incoherent state. Moreover, we characterize the work with the help of fluctuation relations. In particular, by considering the joint distribution of work and initial quantum coherence, we find a fluctuation theorem involving quantum coherence, from which follows a second law of thermodynamics in the case of initial thermal populations. Furthermore, we propose a way to measure the characteristic function of work and we discuss the negativity of the quasiprobability. The effects of coherence are also investigated for a simple system of a qubit.

arXiv:2110.00977•Oct 3, 2021•0 citations

Class of quasiprobability distributions of work with initial quantum coherence

Gianluca Francica

The work is a concept of fundamental importance in thermodynamics. An open question is how to describe the work fluctuation for quantum coherent processes in the presence of initial quantum coherence in the energy basis. With the aim of giving a unified description, here we introduce and study a class of quasiprobability distributions of work, which give an average work equal to the average energy change of the system and reduce to the two-projective-measurement scheme for an initial incoherent state. Moreover, we characterize the work with the help of fluctuation relations. In particular, by considering the joint distribution of work and initial quantum coherence, we find a fluctuation theorem involving quantum coherence, from which follows a second law of thermodynamics in the case of initial thermal populations.

Physical review. E•Jan 3, 2022•31 citations

Minimally invasive measurement of work in coherent quantum systems

Cyril Elouard, Karen Hovhannisyan, Giulia Rubino

A central challenge in quantum thermodynamics is to access work fluctuations in coherent processes without distorting the energetics of the unmeasured evolution. In standard two-point schemes, the initial energy measurement dephases coherent inputs, causing the measured average work to differ from that of the unmeasured evolution. Here, we develop an operational scheme for accessing work statistics for closed quantum systems based on the abstract notion of variation in the Heisenberg picture Hamiltonian. This scheme preserves energetically relevant coherences, thereby faithfully reproducing unmeasured work, while still producing positive probabilities. We derive modified Jarzynski and Crooks relations, as well as a thermodynamic uncertainty relation, identifying coherence-induced correction terms. Furthermore, we show that this scheme can reliably quantify the performance of a coherent engine in situations where the two-point energy measurement would suppress work output. In addition, the scheme requires only a single measurement and can predict the work associated with a subsequent unitary transformation. We exploit this feature to construct a Maxwell-demon protocol that can outperform energy-based feedback engines for coherent work extraction. Our results establish this scheme as a framework for accessing coherent work fluctuations without erasing the coherence that drives quantum thermodynamic performance.

quant-pharXiv:2607.02652•Jul 6, 2026•0 citations

Energy conservation and fluctuation theorem are incompatible for quantum work

Karen V. Hovhannisyan, Alberto Imparato

Characterizing fluctuations of work in coherent quantum systems is notoriously problematic. Here we reveal the ultimate source of the problem by proving that ( A ) energy conservation and ( B ) the Jarzynski fluctuation theorem cannot be observed at the same time. Condition A stipulates that, for any initial state of the system, the measured average work must be equal to the difference of initial and final average energies, and that untouched systems must exchange deterministically zero work. Condition B is only for thermal initial states and encapsulates the second law of thermodynamics. We prove that A and B are incompatible for work measurement schemes that are differentiable functions of the state and satisfy two mild structural constraints. This covers all existing schemes and leaves the theoretical possibility of jointly observing A and B open only for a narrow class of exotic schemes. For the special but important case of state-independent schemes, the situation is much more rigid: we prove that, essentially, only the two-point measurement scheme is compatible with B .

arXiv:2104.09364•Quantum•May 6, 2024•12 citations

Joint measurability in nonequilibrium quantum thermodynamics

Konstantin Beyer, Roope Uola, Kimmo Luoma +1 more

In this Letter we investigate the concept of quantum work and its measurability from the viewpoint of quantum measurement theory. Very often, quantum work and fluctuation theorems are discussed in the framework of projective two-point measurement (TPM) schemes. According to a well-known no-go theorem, there is no work observable which satisfies both (i) an average work condition and (ii) the TPM statistics for diagonal input states. Such projective measurements represent a restrictive class among all possible measurements. It is desirable, both from a theoretical and experimental point of view, to extend the scheme to the general case including suitably designed unsharp measurements. This shifts the focus to the question of what information about work and its fluctuations one is able to extract from such generalized measurements. We show that the no-go theorem no longer holds if the observables in a TPM scheme are jointly measurable for any intermediate unitary evolution. We explicitly construct a model with unsharp energy measurements and derive bounds for the visibility that ensure joint measurability. In such an unsharp scenario a single work measurement apparatus can be constructed that allows us to determine the correct average work and to obtain free energy differences with the help of a Jarzynski equality.

arXiv:2111.02854•Physical review. E•Aug 1, 2022•14 citations
An open question of fundamental importance in thermodynamics is how to describe the fluctuations of work for quantum coherent processes. In the standard approach, based on a projective energy measurement both at the beginning and at the end of the process, the first measurement destroys any initial coherence in the energy basis. Here we seek extensions of this approach which can possibly account for initially coherent states. We consider all measurement schemes to estimate work and require that (i) the difference of average energy corresponds to average work for closed quantum systems and that (ii) the work statistics agree with the standard two-measurement scheme for states with no coherence in the energy basis. We first show that such a scheme cannot exist. Next, we consider the possibility of performing collective measurements on several copies of the state and prove that it is still impossible to simultaneously satisfy requirements (i) and (ii). Nevertheless, improvements do appear, and in particular, we develop a measurement scheme that acts simultaneously on two copies of the state and allows us to describe a whole class of coherent transformations.
An open question of fundamental importance in thermodynamics is how to describe the fluctuations of work for quantum coherent processes. In the standard approach, based on a projective energy measurement both at the beginning and at the end of the process, the first measurement destroys any initial coherence in the energy basis. Here we seek for extensions of this approach which can possibly account for initially coherent states. We therefore consider all measurement schemes to estimate work and require that (i) they agree with the standard two-measurement scheme for states with no coherence in the energy basis, and (ii) the expected value of the measurement outcomes is equal to the average energy difference of the unmeasured process for all states. We first show that such a scheme does not exist. Next, we consider the possibility of performing collective measurements on several copies of the state and prove that it still impossible to satisfy simultaneously requirements (i) and (ii). Nevertheless, improvements do appear, and in particular we develop a measurement scheme which acts simultaneously on two copies of the state and allows to describe a whole class of coherent transformations.
The work is a concept of fundamental importance in thermodynamics. An open question is how to describe the work fluctuation for quantum coherent processes in the presence of initial quantum coherence in the energy basis. With the aim of giving a unified description, here we introduce and study a class of quasiprobability distributions of work, which give an average work equal to the average energy change of the system and reduce to the two-projective measurement scheme for an initial incoherent state. Moreover, we characterize the work with the help of fluctuation relations. In particular, by considering the joint distribution of work and initial quantum coherence, we find a fluctuation theorem involving quantum coherence, from which follows a second law of thermodynamics in the case of initial thermal populations. Furthermore, we propose a way to measure the characteristic function of work and we discuss the negativity of the quasiprobability. The effects of coherence are also investigated for a simple system of a qubit.
The work is a concept of fundamental importance in thermodynamics. An open question is how to describe the work fluctuation for quantum coherent processes in the presence of initial quantum coherence in the energy basis. With the aim of giving a unified description, here we introduce and study a class of quasiprobability distributions of work, which give an average work equal to the average energy change of the system and reduce to the two-projective-measurement scheme for an initial incoherent state. Moreover, we characterize the work with the help of fluctuation relations. In particular, by considering the joint distribution of work and initial quantum coherence, we find a fluctuation theorem involving quantum coherence, from which follows a second law of thermodynamics in the case of initial thermal populations.
A central challenge in quantum thermodynamics is to access work fluctuations in coherent processes without distorting the energetics of the unmeasured evolution. In standard two-point schemes, the initial energy measurement dephases coherent inputs, causing the measured average work to differ from that of the unmeasured evolution. Here, we develop an operational scheme for accessing work statistics for closed quantum systems based on the abstract notion of variation in the Heisenberg picture Hamiltonian. This scheme preserves energetically relevant coherences, thereby faithfully reproducing unmeasured work, while still producing positive probabilities. We derive modified Jarzynski and Crooks relations, as well as a thermodynamic uncertainty relation, identifying coherence-induced correction terms. Furthermore, we show that this scheme can reliably quantify the performance of a coherent engine in situations where the two-point energy measurement would suppress work output. In addition, the scheme requires only a single measurement and can predict the work associated with a subsequent unitary transformation. We exploit this feature to construct a Maxwell-demon protocol that can outperform energy-based feedback engines for coherent work extraction. Our results establish this scheme as a framework for accessing coherent work fluctuations without erasing the coherence that drives quantum thermodynamic performance.
Characterizing fluctuations of work in coherent quantum systems is notoriously problematic. Here we reveal the ultimate source of the problem by proving that ( A ) energy conservation and ( B ) the Jarzynski fluctuation theorem cannot be observed at the same time. Condition A stipulates that, for any initial state of the system, the measured average work must be equal to the difference of initial and final average energies, and that untouched systems must exchange deterministically zero work. Condition B is only for thermal initial states and encapsulates the second law of thermodynamics. We prove that A and B are incompatible for work measurement schemes that are differentiable functions of the state and satisfy two mild structural constraints. This covers all existing schemes and leaves the theoretical possibility of jointly observing A and B open only for a narrow class of exotic schemes. For the special but important case of state-independent schemes, the situation is much more rigid: we prove that, essentially, only the two-point measurement scheme is compatible with B .
In this Letter we investigate the concept of quantum work and its measurability from the viewpoint of quantum measurement theory. Very often, quantum work and fluctuation theorems are discussed in the framework of projective two-point measurement (TPM) schemes. According to a well-known no-go theorem, there is no work observable which satisfies both (i) an average work condition and (ii) the TPM statistics for diagonal input states. Such projective measurements represent a restrictive class among all possible measurements. It is desirable, both from a theoretical and experimental point of view, to extend the scheme to the general case including suitably designed unsharp measurements. This shifts the focus to the question of what information about work and its fluctuations one is able to extract from such generalized measurements. We show that the no-go theorem no longer holds if the observables in a TPM scheme are jointly measurable for any intermediate unitary evolution. We explicitly construct a model with unsharp energy measurements and derive bounds for the visibility that ensure joint measurability. In such an unsharp scenario a single work measurement apparatus can be constructed that allows us to determine the correct average work and to obtain free energy differences with the help of a Jarzynski equality.