Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1605.08897 · Journal of Statistical Mechanics Theory and Experiment

Entanglement spectrum of fermionic bilayer honeycomb lattice: Hofstadter butterfly

Zahra Moradi, Jahanfar Abouie

Published Nov 1, 2016• 7 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Abstract We perform an analytical study of the energy and entanglement spectrum of non-interacting fermionic bilayer honeycomb lattices in the presence of trigonal warping in the energy spectrum, on-site energy difference and uniform magnetic field. Employing single particle correlation functions, we present an explicit form for a layer–layer entanglement Hamiltonian whose spectrum is the entanglement spectrum. We demonstrate that in the absence of trigonal warping, at zero on-site energy difference exact correspondence is established between the entanglement spectrum and energy spectrum of a monolayer which means that the entanglement spectrum perfectly reflects the edge state properties of the bilayer. We also show that trigonal warping breaks down such a perfect correspondence, however, in Γ -K direction in the hexagonal Brillouin zone, their behaviors are remarkably the same for particular relevances of hopping parameters. In the presence of an on-site energy difference the symmetry of the entanglement spectrum is broken with opening an indirect entanglement gap. We also study the effects of a perpendicular magnetic field on both energy and the entanglement spectrum of the bilayer in the presence of trigonal warping and on-site energy difference. We demonstrate that the entanglement spectrum versus magnetic flux has a self similar fractal structure, known as the Hofstadter butterfly. Our results also show that the on-site energy difference causes a transition from the Hofstadter butterfly to a tree-like picture.

DOI
10.1088/1742-5468/2016/11/113101

Related papers

Trigonal warping in bilayer graphene: Energy versus entanglement spectrum

Sonja Predin, Paul Wenk, John Schliemann

We present a mainly analytical study of the entanglement spectrum of Bernal-stacked graphene bilayers in the presence of trigonal warping in the energy spectrum. Upon tracing out one layer, the entanglement spectrum shows qualitative geometric differences to the energy spectrum of a graphene monolayer. However, topological quantities such as Berry-phase-type contributions to Chern numbers agree. The latter analysis involves not only the eigenvalues of the entanglement Hamiltonian but also its eigenvectors. We also discuss the entanglement spectra resulting from tracing out other sublattices. As a technical basis of our analysis, we provide closed analytical expressions for the full eigensystem of bilayer graphene in the entire Brillouin zone with a trigonally warped spectrum.

arXiv:1512.06556•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Mar 2, 2016•28 citations

Entanglement spectrum of graphene systems

Sonja Predin

In the present thesis, the properties of the entanglement spectra of the ground state of graphene bilayers Bernal-stacked is analytically investigated. In addition, the entanglement spectra of the ground state of the honeycomb lattice in the presence of superconductivity instabilities are analytically studied. We consider not only the eigenvalues of the reduced density matrix that form the entanglement spectrum, but also, its eigenstates. From these eigenstates, we construct topological quantities, such as the Berry phase and the Chern number, in order to investigate the topological properties of the entanglement spectrum. In the first part of this thesis, we present an analytical study of the graphene bilayers, mainly focusing on the effects of the trigonal warping. When the term causing the trigonal warping is neglected, the entanglement Hamiltonian obtained by tracing out one layer shows a proportionality with the energetic Hamiltonian of the remaining monolayer graphene, in the limit of strongly coupled layers. We demonstrate that this proportionality leads to an agreement of the topological quantities of these Hamiltonians. Moreover, we demonstrate that the entanglement spectrum of graphene bilayers with a trigonal warping spectrum clearly differs in the geometric shape from the energy spectrum of the remaining monolayer graphene. However, there is an agreement of the topological quantities such as Berry phase contributions to Chern numbers. In the second part of this thesis, we give a detailed study of graphene in the presence of superconductivity instabilities, mainly considering the s-wave and the chiral dx2−y2 +idxy state.We investigate the relationship between the entanglement and energy spectrum, making use of the concepts of the Chern number constructed from eigenstates of the entanglement Hamiltonian. We demonstrate that the entanglement and remaining subsystem Hamiltonians can have different topologies. These findings are illustrated by considering the entanglement Hamiltonian of the ground state of graphene with dx2−y2 + idxy superconductivity obtained by tracing out one spin direction. Our investigations are based on closed analytical expressions for the full eigensystem in the entire Brillouin zone of bilayer graphene with a trigonally warped spectrum and graphene with superconductivity instabilities.

•Jan 1, 2017•0 citations

Entanglement spectra and entanglement thermodynamics of Hofstadter bilayers

John Schliemann

We study Hofstadter bilayers, i.e. coupled hopping models on two-dimensional square lattices in a perpendicular magnetic field. Upon tracing out one of the layers, we find an explicit expression for the resulting entanglement spectrum in terms of the energy eigenvalues of the underlying monolayer system. For strongly coupled layers, the entanglement Hamiltonian is proportional to the energetic Hamiltonian of the monolayer system. The proportionality factor, however, cannot be interpreted as the inverse thermodynamic temperature, but represents a phenomenological temperature scale. We derive an explicit relationship between both temperature scales which is in close analogy to a standard result of classic thermodynamics. In the limit of vanishing temperature, thermodynamic quantities such as entropy and inner energy approach their ground-state values, but show a fractal structure as a function of magnetic flux.

arXiv:1302.5517•New Journal of Physics•May 9, 2013•17 citations

Edge States, Entanglement Spectra, and Wannier Functions in Haldane's Honeycomb Lattice Model and its Bilayer Generalization

Zhoushen Huang, Daniel P. Arovas

We study Haldane's honeycomb lattice model and a bilayer generalization thereof from the perspective of edge states, entanglement spectra, and Wannier function behavior. For the monolayer model, we obtain the zigzag edge states analytically, and identify the edge state crossing point $k_c$ with where the $f = 1/2$ entanglement occupancy and the half-odd-integer Wannier centers occur. A continuous interpolation between the entanglement states and the Wannier states is introduced. We then construct a bilayer model by Bernal stacking two monolayers coupled by interlayer hopping. We analyze a particular limit of this model where an extended symmetry, related to inversion, is present. The band topology then reveals a break-down of the correspondence between edge and entanglement spectrum, which is analyzed in detail, and compared with the inversion-symmetric Z2 topological insulators which show a similar phenomenon.

arXiv:1205.6266•May 29, 2012•7 citations

Dynamics of entanglement asymmetry for space-inversion symmetry of free fermions on honeycomb lattices

Ryogo Hara, Shimpei Endo, Shion Yamashika

We study the entanglement asymmetry for the space-inversion symmetry of free fermions on a two-dimensional honeycomb lattice with an on-site energy imbalance between the two sublattices. We show that the entanglement asymmetry of a local subsystem exhibits nonanalytic dependence on the energy imbalance, due to the presence of Dirac points in the Brillouin zone. We also study the quench dynamics from the ground state into the inversion-symmetric point at which the energy imbalance vanishes. Under certain conditions on the subsystem geometry, the entanglement asymmetry relaxes to a finite value after the quench, revealing that the inversion-symmetry breaking in the initial ground state can persist even under the symmetric dynamics. We attribute the absence of symmetry restoration to the presence of a flat energy dispersion (flat band) in a specific direction.

cond-mat.quant-gasCross-listedarXiv:2511.14114•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Nov 19, 2025•1 citation

Interacting fermions in two dimension in simultaneous presence of disorder and magnetic field

Saptarshi Mandal, Sanjay Gupta

We study the revival of Hofstadter butterfly due to the competition between disorder and electronic interaction using mean field approximation of unrestricted Hartree Fock method at zero temperature for two dimensional square and honeycomb lattices. Interplay of disorder and electronic correlation to nullify each other is corroborated by the fact that honeycomb lattice needs more strength of electronic correlation owing to its less co-ordination number which enhances the effect of disorder. The extent of revival of the butterfly is better in square lattice than honeycomb lattice due to higher coordination number. The effect of disorder and interaction is also investigated to study entanglement entropy and entanglement spectrum. We find that for honeycomb lattice area law of entanglement entropy is obeyed in all cases but for square lattice there is some departure from area law for larger subsystems. The entanglement spectrum have the reflection symmetry of the original butterfly of the Hofstadter spectrum. The interaction induces a gap in the entanglement spectrum as well conforming the correspondence between physical spectrum and entanglement spectrum. The effect of disorder closes the interaction induced gap in the entanglement spectrum establishing the nullification of interaction due to disorder and vice versa.

arXiv:1911.03466•Journal of Physics Condensed Matter•Mar 14, 2022•1 citation
Abstract We perform an analytical study of the energy and entanglement spectrum of non-interacting fermionic bilayer honeycomb lattices in the presence of trigonal warping in the energy spectrum, on-site energy difference and uniform magnetic field. Employing single particle correlation functions, we present an explicit form for a layer–layer entanglement Hamiltonian whose spectrum is the entanglement spectrum. We demonstrate that in the absence of trigonal warping, at zero on-site energy difference exact correspondence is established between the entanglement spectrum and energy spectrum of a monolayer which means that the entanglement spectrum perfectly reflects the edge state properties of the bilayer. We also show that trigonal warping breaks down such a perfect correspondence, however, in Γ -K direction in the hexagonal Brillouin zone, their behaviors are remarkably the same for particular relevances of hopping parameters. In the presence of an on-site energy difference the symmetry of the entanglement spectrum is broken with opening an indirect entanglement gap. We also study the effects of a perpendicular magnetic field on both energy and the entanglement spectrum of the bilayer in the presence of trigonal warping and on-site energy difference. We demonstrate that the entanglement spectrum versus magnetic flux has a self similar fractal structure, known as the Hofstadter butterfly. Our results also show that the on-site energy difference causes a transition from the Hofstadter butterfly to a tree-like picture.
We present a mainly analytical study of the entanglement spectrum of Bernal-stacked graphene bilayers in the presence of trigonal warping in the energy spectrum. Upon tracing out one layer, the entanglement spectrum shows qualitative geometric differences to the energy spectrum of a graphene monolayer. However, topological quantities such as Berry-phase-type contributions to Chern numbers agree. The latter analysis involves not only the eigenvalues of the entanglement Hamiltonian but also its eigenvectors. We also discuss the entanglement spectra resulting from tracing out other sublattices. As a technical basis of our analysis, we provide closed analytical expressions for the full eigensystem of bilayer graphene in the entire Brillouin zone with a trigonally warped spectrum.
In the present thesis, the properties of the entanglement spectra of the ground state of graphene bilayers Bernal-stacked is analytically investigated. In addition, the entanglement spectra of the ground state of the honeycomb lattice in the presence of superconductivity instabilities are analytically studied. We consider not only the eigenvalues of the reduced density matrix that form the entanglement spectrum, but also, its eigenstates. From these eigenstates, we construct topological quantities, such as the Berry phase and the Chern number, in order to investigate the topological properties of the entanglement spectrum. In the first part of this thesis, we present an analytical study of the graphene bilayers, mainly focusing on the effects of the trigonal warping. When the term causing the trigonal warping is neglected, the entanglement Hamiltonian obtained by tracing out one layer shows a proportionality with the energetic Hamiltonian of the remaining monolayer graphene, in the limit of strongly coupled layers. We demonstrate that this proportionality leads to an agreement of the topological quantities of these Hamiltonians. Moreover, we demonstrate that the entanglement spectrum of graphene bilayers with a trigonal warping spectrum clearly differs in the geometric shape from the energy spectrum of the remaining monolayer graphene. However, there is an agreement of the topological quantities such as Berry phase contributions to Chern numbers. In the second part of this thesis, we give a detailed study of graphene in the presence of superconductivity instabilities, mainly considering the s-wave and the chiral dx2−y2 +idxy state.We investigate the relationship between the entanglement and energy spectrum, making use of the concepts of the Chern number constructed from eigenstates of the entanglement Hamiltonian. We demonstrate that the entanglement and remaining subsystem Hamiltonians can have different topologies. These findings are illustrated by considering the entanglement Hamiltonian of the ground state of graphene with dx2−y2 + idxy superconductivity obtained by tracing out one spin direction. Our investigations are based on closed analytical expressions for the full eigensystem in the entire Brillouin zone of bilayer graphene with a trigonally warped spectrum and graphene with superconductivity instabilities.
We study Hofstadter bilayers, i.e. coupled hopping models on two-dimensional square lattices in a perpendicular magnetic field. Upon tracing out one of the layers, we find an explicit expression for the resulting entanglement spectrum in terms of the energy eigenvalues of the underlying monolayer system. For strongly coupled layers, the entanglement Hamiltonian is proportional to the energetic Hamiltonian of the monolayer system. The proportionality factor, however, cannot be interpreted as the inverse thermodynamic temperature, but represents a phenomenological temperature scale. We derive an explicit relationship between both temperature scales which is in close analogy to a standard result of classic thermodynamics. In the limit of vanishing temperature, thermodynamic quantities such as entropy and inner energy approach their ground-state values, but show a fractal structure as a function of magnetic flux.
We study Haldane's honeycomb lattice model and a bilayer generalization thereof from the perspective of edge states, entanglement spectra, and Wannier function behavior. For the monolayer model, we obtain the zigzag edge states analytically, and identify the edge state crossing point kck_ckc​ with where the f=1/2f = 1/2f=1/2 entanglement occupancy and the half-odd-integer Wannier centers occur. A continuous interpolation between the entanglement states and the Wannier states is introduced. We then construct a bilayer model by Bernal stacking two monolayers coupled by interlayer hopping. We analyze a particular limit of this model where an extended symmetry, related to inversion, is present. The band topology then reveals a break-down of the correspondence between edge and entanglement spectrum, which is analyzed in detail, and compared with the inversion-symmetric Z2 topological insulators which show a similar phenomenon.
We study the entanglement asymmetry for the space-inversion symmetry of free fermions on a two-dimensional honeycomb lattice with an on-site energy imbalance between the two sublattices. We show that the entanglement asymmetry of a local subsystem exhibits nonanalytic dependence on the energy imbalance, due to the presence of Dirac points in the Brillouin zone. We also study the quench dynamics from the ground state into the inversion-symmetric point at which the energy imbalance vanishes. Under certain conditions on the subsystem geometry, the entanglement asymmetry relaxes to a finite value after the quench, revealing that the inversion-symmetry breaking in the initial ground state can persist even under the symmetric dynamics. We attribute the absence of symmetry restoration to the presence of a flat energy dispersion (flat band) in a specific direction.
We study the revival of Hofstadter butterfly due to the competition between disorder and electronic interaction using mean field approximation of unrestricted Hartree Fock method at zero temperature for two dimensional square and honeycomb lattices. Interplay of disorder and electronic correlation to nullify each other is corroborated by the fact that honeycomb lattice needs more strength of electronic correlation owing to its less co-ordination number which enhances the effect of disorder. The extent of revival of the butterfly is better in square lattice than honeycomb lattice due to higher coordination number. The effect of disorder and interaction is also investigated to study entanglement entropy and entanglement spectrum. We find that for honeycomb lattice area law of entanglement entropy is obeyed in all cases but for square lattice there is some departure from area law for larger subsystems. The entanglement spectrum have the reflection symmetry of the original butterfly of the Hofstadter spectrum. The interaction induces a gap in the entanglement spectrum as well conforming the correspondence between physical spectrum and entanglement spectrum. The effect of disorder closes the interaction induced gap in the entanglement spectrum establishing the nullification of interaction due to disorder and vice versa.