Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1605.05956 · Physical Review A

Macroscopic quantum measurements of noncommuting observables

Tomer Jack Barnea, Marc-Olivier Renou, Florian Fröwis, Nicolas Gisin

Published Jul 12, 2017• 7 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Assuming a well-behaving quantum-to-classical transition, measuring large quantum systems should be highly informative with low measurement-induced disturbance, while the coupling between system and measurement apparatus is fairly simple and weak. Here, we show that this is indeed possible within the formalism of quantum mechanics. We discuss an example of estimating the collective magnetization of a spin ensemble by simultaneous measuring three orthogonal spin directions. For the task of estimating the direction of a spin-coherent state, we find that the average guessing fidelity and the system disturbance are nonmonotonic functions of the coupling strength. Strikingly, we discover an intermediate regime for the coupling strength where the guessing fidelity is quasioptimal, while the measured state is almost not disturbed.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.96.012111

Related papers

Robust Macroscopic Quantum Measurements in the Presence of Limited Control and Knowledge

Marc-Olivier Renou, Nicolas Gisin, Florian Fröwis

Quantum measurements have intrinsic properties that seem incompatible with our everyday-life macroscopic measurements. Macroscopic Quantum Measurement (MQM) is a concept that aims at bridging the gap between well-understood microscopic quantum measurements and macroscopic classical measurements. In this paper, we focus on the task of the polarization direction estimation of a system of N spins 1/2 particles and investigate the model some of us proposed in Barnea et al., 2017. This model is based on a von Neumann pointer measurement, where each spin component of the system is coupled to one of the three spatial component directions of a pointer. It shows traits of a classical measurement for an intermediate coupling strength. We investigate relaxations of the assumptions on the initial knowledge about the state and on the control over the MQM. We show that the model is robust with regard to these relaxations. It performs well for thermal states and a lack of knowledge about the size of the system. Furthermore, a lack of control on the MQM can be compensated by repeated “ultra-weak” measurements.

arXiv:1711.01105•Entropy•Jan 9, 2018•1 citation

Robust Macroscopic Quantum Measurements in the presence of limited control and knowledge

Marc-Olivier Renou, Nicolas Gisin, Froewis, Florian

Quantum measurements have intrinsic properties which seem incompatible with our everyday-life macroscopic measurements. Macroscopic Quantum Measurement (MQM) is a concept that aims at bridging the gap between well understood microscopic quantum measurements and macroscopic classical measurements. In this paper, we focus on the task of the polarization direction estimation of a system of $N$ spins $1/2$ particles and investigate the model some of us proposed in Barnea et al., 2017. This model is based on a von Neumann pointer measurement, where each spin component of the system is coupled to one of the three spatial components direction of a pointer. It shows traits of a classical measurement for an intermediate coupling strength. We investigate relaxations of the assumptions on the initial knowledge about the state and on the control over the MQM. We show that the model is robust with regard to these relaxations. It performs well for thermal states and a lack of knowledge about the size of the system. Furthermore, a lack of control on the MQM can be compensated by repeated "ultra-weak" measurements.

•Jan 1, 2018•1 citation

Macroscopic observables

David Poulin

We study macroscopic observables defined as the total value of a physical quantity over a collection of quantum systems. We show that previous results obtained for an infinite ensemble of identically prepared systems lead to incorrect conclusions for finite ensembles. In particular, exact measurement of a macroscopic observable significantly disturbs the state of any finite ensemble. However, we show how this disturbance can be made arbitrarily small when the measurements are of finite accuracy. We demonstrate a general trade-off between state disturbance and measurement coarseness as a function of the size of the ensemble. Using this trade-off, we show that the histories generated by any sequence of finite accuracy macroscopic measurements always generate a consistent family in the absence of large-scale entanglement for sufficiently large ensembles. Hence, macroscopic observables behave ``classically'' provided that their accuracy is coarser than the quantum correlation length scale of the system. The role of these observable is also discussed in the context of NMR quantum information processing and bulk ensemble quantum state tomography.

arXiv:quant-ph/0403212•Physical Review A•Feb 7, 2005•42 citations

Qubit State Monitoring by Measurement of Three Complementary Observables

Rusko Ruskov, Alexander N. Korotkov, Klaus Mølmer

We consider the evolution of a qubit (spin $1/2$) under the simultaneous continuous measurement of three noncommuting qubit operators ${\stackrel{^}{\ensuremath{\sigma}}}_{x}$, ${\stackrel{^}{\ensuremath{\sigma}}}_{y}$, and ${\stackrel{^}{\ensuremath{\sigma}}}_{z}$. For identical ideal detectors, the qubit state evolves by approaching a pure state with a random direction in the Bloch vector space and by undergoing locally isotropic diffusion in the perpendicular directions. The quantum state conditioned on the complete detector record is used to assess the fidelity of classically inspired estimates based on running time averages and discrete time bin detector outputs.

arXiv:1006.2013•Physical Review Letters•Sep 2, 2010•42 citations

Nonclassicality of a Macroscopic Qubit-Ensemble via Parity Measurement Induced Disturbance

Lorenzo Braccini, Debarshi Das, Ben Zindorf +3 more

We propose an experimental scheme to test the nonclassicality of a macroscopic ensemble of qubits, through the violation of the classical notion of macrorealism (MR) via the fundamental measurement-induced disturbance of quantum systems. An electromagnetic resonator is used to probe the parity of the qubit-ensemble. The action of sequential measurements allows the nonclassicality of whole ensemble to manifest itself, in the ideal case, irrespective of its size. This enables to probe the macroscopic limits of quantum mechanics as the qubit-ensemble is, effectively, a single large spin of many $\hbar$ units. Even as $\hbar \rightarrow 0$ in comparison to the total angular momentum of the ensemble, a constant amount of violation of MR is found in the noiseless case. However, environmental decoherence and inhomogeneity of qubit-electromagnetic field couplings precipitate the quantum-to-classical transition. This illustrates that Bohr's correspondence principle is not fundamental, but a consequence of practical limitations. We outline an implementation with a variety of qubits (superconducting qubits, spins in semiconductors, and Rydberg atoms) coupled to a coplanar waveguide resonator, and -- via the corresponding noise analysis -- find that violation of MR is detectable up to $100$ qubits via current technology.

quant-pharXiv:2511.15880•Physical Review Research•Nov 21, 2025•0 citations

PROBLEMS IN QUANTUM MEASUREMENT AND APPLICATIONS

Sun Chang

In connection with the recent experiments on quantum measurement, such as the “which-way”detection using the Bragg scattering of cold atoms and quantum interference using a small molecular C 60 quantum system, we introduce the quantum measurement problem and its relevant fundamental concepts and ideas, such as quantum coherence, quantum decoherence and quantum entanglement. In order to understand the loss of quantum coherence for a quantum system due to its interaction with another system behaving classically or macroscopically, we discuss some quantum dynamical models to describe the quantum decoherence and quantum dissipation induced by couplings to the external environment or inner motions. In the classical or macroscopic limit, it is shown that the wave function of the total system formed by the quantum system plus another system interacting with it is factorized as an entangled state with correlation between the measured quantum states and the configurations of the external large system or the inner degrees of freedom. In association with a novel viewpoint about quantum measurement, which has been directly verified by recent experiments (e.g.,S. Durr et al., Nature,1998,33:359), it is shown that quantum entanglement is indeed responsible for the quantum decoherence, and thus it can be regarded as a “clean” quantum measurement when the large system behaves as a classical object. These arguments give us a possible solution to the “Schrdinger cat paradox” and to whether the coherent superposition of macroscopic states exists. These discussions are also applied to the quantum decoherence problems in quantum information including quantum computing and quantum communication.

•Jan 1, 2000•0 citations
Assuming a well-behaving quantum-to-classical transition, measuring large quantum systems should be highly informative with low measurement-induced disturbance, while the coupling between system and measurement apparatus is fairly simple and weak. Here, we show that this is indeed possible within the formalism of quantum mechanics. We discuss an example of estimating the collective magnetization of a spin ensemble by simultaneous measuring three orthogonal spin directions. For the task of estimating the direction of a spin-coherent state, we find that the average guessing fidelity and the system disturbance are nonmonotonic functions of the coupling strength. Strikingly, we discover an intermediate regime for the coupling strength where the guessing fidelity is quasioptimal, while the measured state is almost not disturbed.
Quantum measurements have intrinsic properties that seem incompatible with our everyday-life macroscopic measurements. Macroscopic Quantum Measurement (MQM) is a concept that aims at bridging the gap between well-understood microscopic quantum measurements and macroscopic classical measurements. In this paper, we focus on the task of the polarization direction estimation of a system of N spins 1/2 particles and investigate the model some of us proposed in Barnea et al., 2017. This model is based on a von Neumann pointer measurement, where each spin component of the system is coupled to one of the three spatial component directions of a pointer. It shows traits of a classical measurement for an intermediate coupling strength. We investigate relaxations of the assumptions on the initial knowledge about the state and on the control over the MQM. We show that the model is robust with regard to these relaxations. It performs well for thermal states and a lack of knowledge about the size of the system. Furthermore, a lack of control on the MQM can be compensated by repeated “ultra-weak” measurements.
Quantum measurements have intrinsic properties which seem incompatible with our everyday-life macroscopic measurements. Macroscopic Quantum Measurement (MQM) is a concept that aims at bridging the gap between well understood microscopic quantum measurements and macroscopic classical measurements. In this paper, we focus on the task of the polarization direction estimation of a system of NNN spins 1/21/21/2 particles and investigate the model some of us proposed in Barnea et al., 2017. This model is based on a von Neumann pointer measurement, where each spin component of the system is coupled to one of the three spatial components direction of a pointer. It shows traits of a classical measurement for an intermediate coupling strength. We investigate relaxations of the assumptions on the initial knowledge about the state and on the control over the MQM. We show that the model is robust with regard to these relaxations. It performs well for thermal states and a lack of knowledge about the size of the system. Furthermore, a lack of control on the MQM can be compensated by repeated "ultra-weak" measurements.
We study macroscopic observables defined as the total value of a physical quantity over a collection of quantum systems. We show that previous results obtained for an infinite ensemble of identically prepared systems lead to incorrect conclusions for finite ensembles. In particular, exact measurement of a macroscopic observable significantly disturbs the state of any finite ensemble. However, we show how this disturbance can be made arbitrarily small when the measurements are of finite accuracy. We demonstrate a general trade-off between state disturbance and measurement coarseness as a function of the size of the ensemble. Using this trade-off, we show that the histories generated by any sequence of finite accuracy macroscopic measurements always generate a consistent family in the absence of large-scale entanglement for sufficiently large ensembles. Hence, macroscopic observables behave ``classically'' provided that their accuracy is coarser than the quantum correlation length scale of the system. The role of these observable is also discussed in the context of NMR quantum information processing and bulk ensemble quantum state tomography.
We consider the evolution of a qubit (spin 1/21/21/2) under the simultaneous continuous measurement of three noncommuting qubit operators ${\stackrel{^}{\ensuremath{\sigma}}}_{x}$, ${\stackrel{^}{\ensuremath{\sigma}}}_{y}$, and ${\stackrel{^}{\ensuremath{\sigma}}}_{z}$. For identical ideal detectors, the qubit state evolves by approaching a pure state with a random direction in the Bloch vector space and by undergoing locally isotropic diffusion in the perpendicular directions. The quantum state conditioned on the complete detector record is used to assess the fidelity of classically inspired estimates based on running time averages and discrete time bin detector outputs.
We propose an experimental scheme to test the nonclassicality of a macroscopic ensemble of qubits, through the violation of the classical notion of macrorealism (MR) via the fundamental measurement-induced disturbance of quantum systems. An electromagnetic resonator is used to probe the parity of the qubit-ensemble. The action of sequential measurements allows the nonclassicality of whole ensemble to manifest itself, in the ideal case, irrespective of its size. This enables to probe the macroscopic limits of quantum mechanics as the qubit-ensemble is, effectively, a single large spin of many ℏ\hbarℏ units. Even as ℏ→0\hbar \rightarrow 0ℏ→0 in comparison to the total angular momentum of the ensemble, a constant amount of violation of MR is found in the noiseless case. However, environmental decoherence and inhomogeneity of qubit-electromagnetic field couplings precipitate the quantum-to-classical transition. This illustrates that Bohr's correspondence principle is not fundamental, but a consequence of practical limitations. We outline an implementation with a variety of qubits (superconducting qubits, spins in semiconductors, and Rydberg atoms) coupled to a coplanar waveguide resonator, and -- via the corresponding noise analysis -- find that violation of MR is detectable up to 100100100 qubits via current technology.
In connection with the recent experiments on quantum measurement, such as the “which-way”detection using the Bragg scattering of cold atoms and quantum interference using a small molecular C 60 quantum system, we introduce the quantum measurement problem and its relevant fundamental concepts and ideas, such as quantum coherence, quantum decoherence and quantum entanglement. In order to understand the loss of quantum coherence for a quantum system due to its interaction with another system behaving classically or macroscopically, we discuss some quantum dynamical models to describe the quantum decoherence and quantum dissipation induced by couplings to the external environment or inner motions. In the classical or macroscopic limit, it is shown that the wave function of the total system formed by the quantum system plus another system interacting with it is factorized as an entangled state with correlation between the measured quantum states and the configurations of the external large system or the inner degrees of freedom. In association with a novel viewpoint about quantum measurement, which has been directly verified by recent experiments (e.g.,S. Durr et al., Nature,1998,33:359), it is shown that quantum entanglement is indeed responsible for the quantum decoherence, and thus it can be regarded as a “clean” quantum measurement when the large system behaves as a classical object. These arguments give us a possible solution to the “Schrdinger cat paradox” and to whether the coherent superposition of macroscopic states exists. These discussions are also applied to the quantum decoherence problems in quantum information including quantum computing and quantum communication.