Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1605.05254 · Journal of Mathematical Physics

There is no direct generalization of positive partial transpose criterion to the three-by-three case

Łukasz Skowronek

Published Nov 1, 2016• 13 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We show that there cannot exist a straightforward generalization of the famous positive partial transpose criterion to three-by-three systems. We call straightforward generalizations that use a finite set of positive maps and arbitrary local rotations of the tested two-partite state. In particular, we show that a family of extreme positive maps discussed in a paper by Ha and Kye [Open Syst. Inf. Dyn. 18, 323–337 (2011)], cannot be replaced by a finite set of witnesses in the task of entanglement detection in three-by-three systems. In a more mathematically elegant parlance, our result says that the convex cone of positive maps of the set of three-dimensional matrices into itself is not finitely generated as a mapping cone.

DOI
10.1063/1.4966984

Related papers

Entanglement Witnesses Arising from Exposed Positive Linear Maps

Kil-Chan Ha, Seung-Hyeok Kye

We consider entanglement witnesses arising from positive linear maps which generate exposed extremal rays. We show that every entangled state can be detected by one of these witnesses, and this witness detects a unique set of entangled states among those. Therefore, they provide a minimal set of witnesses to detect any kind of entanglement in a sense. Furthermore, if those maps are indecomposable then they detect large classes of entangled states with positive partial transposes which have nonempty relative interiors in the cone generated by all PPT states. We also provide a one-parameter family of indecomposable positive linear maps which generate exposed extremal rays. This gives the first examples of such maps in three-dimensional matrix algebra.

arXiv:1108.0130•Open Systems & Information Dynamics•Dec 1, 2011•43 citations

A class of entanglement witnesses and a realignment-like criterion

Vahid Jannesary, Vahid Karimipour, Dariusz Chruściński

We present a multi-parameter family of positive maps between spaces of arbitrary but finite dimensions. This framework facilitates the construction of Entanglement Witnesses (EWs) specifically designed for systems living in [Formula: see text] dimensions. A sufficient condition for positivity is presented. Interestingly, it is shown that all EWs constructed this way are equivalent to a single realignment-like criterion which for [Formula: see text] and [Formula: see text] are different is in general stronger than the original realignment criterion. We illustrate effectiveness of this criterion considering examples of Positive Partial Transpose entangled states in [Formula: see text] and [Formula: see text] dimensions.

arXiv:2308.07019•Scientific Reports•Feb 17, 2025•2 citations

Is absolute separability determined by the partial transpose?

Srinivasan Arunachalam, Nathaniel Johnston, Russo, Vincent

The absolute separability problem asks for a characterization of the quantum states $ρ\in M_m\otimes M_n$ with the property that $UρU^\dagger$ is separable for all unitary matrices $U$. We investigate whether or not it is the case that $ρ$ is absolutely separable if and only if $UρU^\dagger$ has positive partial transpose for all unitary matrices $U$. In particular, we develop an easy-to-use method for showing that an entanglement witness or positive map is unable to detect entanglement in any such state, and we apply our method to many well-known separability criteria, including the range criterion, the realignment criterion, the Choi map and its generalizations, and the Breuer-Hall map. We also show that these two properties coincide for the family of isotropic states, and several eigenvalue results for entanglement witnesses are proved along the way that are of independent interest.

arXiv:1405.5853•May 22, 2014•3 citations

Is absolute separability determined by the partial transpose?

Srinivasan Arunachalam, Nathaniel Johnston, Vincent Russo

The absolute separability problem asks for a characterization of the quantum states $\rho \in M_m\otimes M_n$ with the property that $U\rho U^\dagger$ is separable for all unitary matrices $U$. We investigate whether or not it is the case that $\rho$ is absolutely separable if and only if $U\rho U^\dagger$ has positive partial transpose for all unitary matrices $U$. In particular, we develop an easy-to-use method for showing that an entanglement witness or positive map is unable to detect entanglement in any such state, and we apply our method to many well-known separability criteria, including the range criterion, the realignment criterion, the Choi map and its generalizations, and the Breuer--Hall map. We also show that these two properties coincide for the family of isotropic states, and several eigenvalue results for entanglement witnesses are proved along the way that are of independent interest.

Quantum Information and Computation•May 1, 2015•21 citations

Covariance matrix entanglement criterion for an arbitrary set of operators

V.K. Tripathi, Chandrashekar Radhakrishnan, Tim Byrnes

Abstract A criterion for entanglement detection based on covariance matrices for an arbitrary set of observables is formulated. The method generalizes the covariance matrix entanglement criterion by Simon (2000 Phys. Rev. Lett. 84 2726) to a more general set of operators using the positive partial transpose test for the covariance matrix. The relation is found by starting from the generalized uncertainty relation for multiple operators, and taking the partial transpose on the bipartition. The method is highly efficient and versatile in the sense that the set of measurement operators can be freely chosen, and there is no constraint on the commutation relations. The main restriction on the chosen set of measurement operators is that the correlators and expectation values of the partially transposed observable operators can be evaluated. The method is particularly suited for systems with higher dimensionality since the computations do not scale with the dimension of the Hilbert space—rather they scale with the number of chosen observables. We illustrate the approach by examining the entanglement between two spin ensembles, and show that it detects entanglement in a basis independent way.

arXiv:1806.03832•New Journal of Physics•Jun 15, 2020•9 citations

Multi-partite separable states with unique decompositions and construction of three qubit entanglement with positive partial transpose

Kil-Chan Ha, Seung-Hyeok Kye

We investigate conditions on a finite set of multi-partite product vectors for which separable states with corresponding product states have unique decompositions, and show that this is true in most cases if the number of product vectors is sufficiently small. In the three-qubit case, generic five-dimensional spaces give rise to faces of the convex set consisting of all separable states, which are affinely isomorphic to the five-dimensional simplex with six vertices. We construct, as a byproduct, three-qubit entangled positive partial transpose edge states of rank 4 with explicit formulas. This covers those entanglements which cannot be constructed from an unextendible product basis.

arXiv:1402.5813•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Dec 24, 2014•10 citations
We show that there cannot exist a straightforward generalization of the famous positive partial transpose criterion to three-by-three systems. We call straightforward generalizations that use a finite set of positive maps and arbitrary local rotations of the tested two-partite state. In particular, we show that a family of extreme positive maps discussed in a paper by Ha and Kye [Open Syst. Inf. Dyn. 18, 323–337 (2011)], cannot be replaced by a finite set of witnesses in the task of entanglement detection in three-by-three systems. In a more mathematically elegant parlance, our result says that the convex cone of positive maps of the set of three-dimensional matrices into itself is not finitely generated as a mapping cone.
We consider entanglement witnesses arising from positive linear maps which generate exposed extremal rays. We show that every entangled state can be detected by one of these witnesses, and this witness detects a unique set of entangled states among those. Therefore, they provide a minimal set of witnesses to detect any kind of entanglement in a sense. Furthermore, if those maps are indecomposable then they detect large classes of entangled states with positive partial transposes which have nonempty relative interiors in the cone generated by all PPT states. We also provide a one-parameter family of indecomposable positive linear maps which generate exposed extremal rays. This gives the first examples of such maps in three-dimensional matrix algebra.
We present a multi-parameter family of positive maps between spaces of arbitrary but finite dimensions. This framework facilitates the construction of Entanglement Witnesses (EWs) specifically designed for systems living in [Formula: see text] dimensions. A sufficient condition for positivity is presented. Interestingly, it is shown that all EWs constructed this way are equivalent to a single realignment-like criterion which for [Formula: see text] and [Formula: see text] are different is in general stronger than the original realignment criterion. We illustrate effectiveness of this criterion considering examples of Positive Partial Transpose entangled states in [Formula: see text] and [Formula: see text] dimensions.
The absolute separability problem asks for a characterization of the quantum states ρ∈Mm⊗Mnρ\in M_m\otimes M_nρ∈Mm​⊗Mn​ with the property that UρU†UρU^\daggerUρU† is separable for all unitary matrices UUU. We investigate whether or not it is the case that ρρρ is absolutely separable if and only if UρU†UρU^\daggerUρU† has positive partial transpose for all unitary matrices UUU. In particular, we develop an easy-to-use method for showing that an entanglement witness or positive map is unable to detect entanglement in any such state, and we apply our method to many well-known separability criteria, including the range criterion, the realignment criterion, the Choi map and its generalizations, and the Breuer-Hall map. We also show that these two properties coincide for the family of isotropic states, and several eigenvalue results for entanglement witnesses are proved along the way that are of independent interest.
The absolute separability problem asks for a characterization of the quantum states ρ∈Mm⊗Mn\rho \in M_m\otimes M_nρ∈Mm​⊗Mn​ with the property that UρU†U\rho U^\daggerUρU† is separable for all unitary matrices UUU. We investigate whether or not it is the case that ρ\rhoρ is absolutely separable if and only if UρU†U\rho U^\daggerUρU† has positive partial transpose for all unitary matrices UUU. In particular, we develop an easy-to-use method for showing that an entanglement witness or positive map is unable to detect entanglement in any such state, and we apply our method to many well-known separability criteria, including the range criterion, the realignment criterion, the Choi map and its generalizations, and the Breuer--Hall map. We also show that these two properties coincide for the family of isotropic states, and several eigenvalue results for entanglement witnesses are proved along the way that are of independent interest.
Abstract A criterion for entanglement detection based on covariance matrices for an arbitrary set of observables is formulated. The method generalizes the covariance matrix entanglement criterion by Simon (2000 Phys. Rev. Lett. 84 2726) to a more general set of operators using the positive partial transpose test for the covariance matrix. The relation is found by starting from the generalized uncertainty relation for multiple operators, and taking the partial transpose on the bipartition. The method is highly efficient and versatile in the sense that the set of measurement operators can be freely chosen, and there is no constraint on the commutation relations. The main restriction on the chosen set of measurement operators is that the correlators and expectation values of the partially transposed observable operators can be evaluated. The method is particularly suited for systems with higher dimensionality since the computations do not scale with the dimension of the Hilbert space—rather they scale with the number of chosen observables. We illustrate the approach by examining the entanglement between two spin ensembles, and show that it detects entanglement in a basis independent way.
We investigate conditions on a finite set of multi-partite product vectors for which separable states with corresponding product states have unique decompositions, and show that this is true in most cases if the number of product vectors is sufficiently small. In the three-qubit case, generic five-dimensional spaces give rise to faces of the convex set consisting of all separable states, which are affinely isomorphic to the five-dimensional simplex with six vertices. We construct, as a byproduct, three-qubit entangled positive partial transpose edge states of rank 4 with explicit formulas. This covers those entanglements which cannot be constructed from an unextendible product basis.