Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1604.07141 · International Journal of Quantum Information

Quantum backflow effect and nonclassicality

Francesco Albarelli, Tommaso Guaita, Matteo G. A. Paris

Published Sep 14, 2016• 19 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The quantum backflow effect is a counterintuitive behavior of the probability current of a free particle, which may be negative even for states with vanishing negative momentum component. Here, we address the notion of nonclassicality arising from the backflow effect, i.e. from the negativity of the probability current, and analyze its relationships with the notion of nonclassicality based on the negativity of the Wigner function. Our results show that backflow is linked to a different, and in fact more restrictive, notion of nonclassicality, the negativity of the Wigner function being only a necessary prerequisite for its occurrence. This hierarchical structure may be confirmed by looking at the addition of thermal noise, which more easily destroys the negativity of the probability current than the negativity of the Wigner function itself.

DOI
10.1142/s0219749916500325

Related papers

Quantum backflow for many-particle systems

Maximilien Barbier

Quantum backflow is the classically forbidden effect pertaining to the fact that a particle with a positive momentum may exhibit a negative probability current at some space-time point. We investigate how this peculiar phenomenon extends to many-particle systems. We give a general formulation of quantum backflow for systems formed of $N$ free nonrelativistic structureless particles, either identical or distinguishable. Restricting our attention to bosonic systems where the $N$ identical bosons are in the same one-particle state allows us in particular to analytically show that the maximum achievable amount of quantum backflow in this case becomes arbitrarily small for large values of $N$.

arXiv:2005.14685•Physical Review A•Aug 31, 2020•15 citations

On the experiment-friendly formulation of quantum backflow

Maximilien Barbier, Arseni Goussev

In its standard formulation, quantum backflow is a classically impossible phenomenon in which a free quantum particle in a positive-momentum state exhibits a negative probability current. Recently, Miller et al. [Quantum 5, 379 (2021)] have put forward a new, "experiment-friendly" formulation of quantum backflow that aims at extending the notion of quantum backflow to situations in which the particle's state may have both positive and negative momenta. Here, we investigate how the experiment-friendly formulation of quantum backflow compares to the standard one when applied to a free particle in a positive-momentum state. We show that the two formulations are not always compatible. We further identify a parametric regime in which the two formulations appear to be in qualitative agreement with one another.

arXiv:2103.06728•Quantum•Sep 7, 2021•17 citations

Probability backflow and a new dimensionless quantum number

Anthony J. Bracken, G.F. Melloy

Pure states of a free particle in non-relativistic quantum mechanics are described, in which the probability of finding the particle to have a negative x-coordinate increases over an arbitrarily long, but finite, time interval, even though the x-component of the particle's velocity is certainly positive throughout that time interval. It is shown that, for any state of this type, the greatest amount of probability which can flow back from positive to negative x-values in this counter-intuitive way, over any given time interval, is equal to the largest eigenvalue of a certain Hermitian operator, and it is estimated numerically to have a value near 0.04. This value is not only independent of the length of the time interval and the mass of the particle, but is also independent of the value of Planck's constant. It reflects the structure of Schrodinger's equation, rather than the values of the parameters appearing there. Backflow of positive probability is related to the non-positivity of Wigner's density function, and can be regarded as arising from a flow of negative probability in the same direction as the velocity. Generalizations are indicated, to the relativistic free electron, and to non-relativistic cases in which probability backflow occurs even in opposition to an arbitrarily strong constant force.

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Mar 21, 1994•142 citations

Quantum backflow in a ring

Arseni Goussev

Free motion of a quantum particle with the wave function entirely comprised of plane waves with non-negative momenta may be accompanied by negative probability current, an effect called quantum backflow. The effect is weak and fragile and has not yet been observed experimentally. Here we show that quantum backflow becomes significantly more pronounced and more amenable to experimental observation if, instead of letting the particle move along a straight line, one forces it to move in a circular ring.

arXiv:2008.08022•Physical Review A•Feb 22, 2021•25 citations

Quantum backflow for a free-particle hermite wavepacket

P. Strange

Abstract Quantum backflow is the unexpected effect that wavepackets consisting of only positive momentum components can apparently move in the negative direction. This is usually described in terms of the backflow constant, which is a dimensionless quantity describing least upper bound on the amount of probability that can flow backwards during a given time interval. Backflow is usually calculated for wavepackets that can be written as a sum of positive momentum plane waves. Here we present a calculation of the backflow constant using the localised free particle hermite wavefunctions where equal weights of positive and negative momentum eigenfunctions occur. The resulting backflow constant is substantially smaller than the accepted value. The reasons for this are discussed and finally we draw conclusions about the calculation of backflow more generally.

Physica Scripta•Jan 4, 2024•6 citations

General quantum backflow in realistic wave packets

Tomasz Paterek, Arseni Goussev

Quantum backflow is a counterintuitive phenomenon in which the probability density of a quantum particle propagates opposite to its momentum. Experimental observation of backflow has remained elusive due to two main challenges: (i) the effect is intrinsically small, with less than 4% of the probability able to flow backward, and (ii) it requires wave packets with a well-defined momentum direction, which are difficult both to prepare and to verify under realistic, noisy conditions. Here, we overcome these challenges by introducing a general formulation of quantum backflow applicable to arbitrary momentum distributions. The framework recovers the standard backflow limit for unidirectional states and identifies general backflow as probability flow exceeding that predicted by the particle's momentum distribution alone. We show that this excess can reach nearly 13%, surpassing the standard backflow bound by more than a factor of three. Furthermore, we extend the framework to the closely related phenomenon of quantum reentry, provide explicit examples of quantum states exhibiting large general backflow and reentry, and discuss the foundational implications of these nonclassical effects. Our results open a pathway toward the experimental observation of quantum backflow in realistic settings.

quant-pharXiv:2511.10155•Physical Review Letters•Nov 14, 2025•3 citations
The quantum backflow effect is a counterintuitive behavior of the probability current of a free particle, which may be negative even for states with vanishing negative momentum component. Here, we address the notion of nonclassicality arising from the backflow effect, i.e. from the negativity of the probability current, and analyze its relationships with the notion of nonclassicality based on the negativity of the Wigner function. Our results show that backflow is linked to a different, and in fact more restrictive, notion of nonclassicality, the negativity of the Wigner function being only a necessary prerequisite for its occurrence. This hierarchical structure may be confirmed by looking at the addition of thermal noise, which more easily destroys the negativity of the probability current than the negativity of the Wigner function itself.
Quantum backflow is the classically forbidden effect pertaining to the fact that a particle with a positive momentum may exhibit a negative probability current at some space-time point. We investigate how this peculiar phenomenon extends to many-particle systems. We give a general formulation of quantum backflow for systems formed of NNN free nonrelativistic structureless particles, either identical or distinguishable. Restricting our attention to bosonic systems where the NNN identical bosons are in the same one-particle state allows us in particular to analytically show that the maximum achievable amount of quantum backflow in this case becomes arbitrarily small for large values of NNN.
In its standard formulation, quantum backflow is a classically impossible phenomenon in which a free quantum particle in a positive-momentum state exhibits a negative probability current. Recently, Miller et al. [Quantum 5, 379 (2021)] have put forward a new, "experiment-friendly" formulation of quantum backflow that aims at extending the notion of quantum backflow to situations in which the particle's state may have both positive and negative momenta. Here, we investigate how the experiment-friendly formulation of quantum backflow compares to the standard one when applied to a free particle in a positive-momentum state. We show that the two formulations are not always compatible. We further identify a parametric regime in which the two formulations appear to be in qualitative agreement with one another.
Pure states of a free particle in non-relativistic quantum mechanics are described, in which the probability of finding the particle to have a negative x-coordinate increases over an arbitrarily long, but finite, time interval, even though the x-component of the particle's velocity is certainly positive throughout that time interval. It is shown that, for any state of this type, the greatest amount of probability which can flow back from positive to negative x-values in this counter-intuitive way, over any given time interval, is equal to the largest eigenvalue of a certain Hermitian operator, and it is estimated numerically to have a value near 0.04. This value is not only independent of the length of the time interval and the mass of the particle, but is also independent of the value of Planck's constant. It reflects the structure of Schrodinger's equation, rather than the values of the parameters appearing there. Backflow of positive probability is related to the non-positivity of Wigner's density function, and can be regarded as arising from a flow of negative probability in the same direction as the velocity. Generalizations are indicated, to the relativistic free electron, and to non-relativistic cases in which probability backflow occurs even in opposition to an arbitrarily strong constant force.
Free motion of a quantum particle with the wave function entirely comprised of plane waves with non-negative momenta may be accompanied by negative probability current, an effect called quantum backflow. The effect is weak and fragile and has not yet been observed experimentally. Here we show that quantum backflow becomes significantly more pronounced and more amenable to experimental observation if, instead of letting the particle move along a straight line, one forces it to move in a circular ring.
Abstract Quantum backflow is the unexpected effect that wavepackets consisting of only positive momentum components can apparently move in the negative direction. This is usually described in terms of the backflow constant, which is a dimensionless quantity describing least upper bound on the amount of probability that can flow backwards during a given time interval. Backflow is usually calculated for wavepackets that can be written as a sum of positive momentum plane waves. Here we present a calculation of the backflow constant using the localised free particle hermite wavefunctions where equal weights of positive and negative momentum eigenfunctions occur. The resulting backflow constant is substantially smaller than the accepted value. The reasons for this are discussed and finally we draw conclusions about the calculation of backflow more generally.
Quantum backflow is a counterintuitive phenomenon in which the probability density of a quantum particle propagates opposite to its momentum. Experimental observation of backflow has remained elusive due to two main challenges: (i) the effect is intrinsically small, with less than 4% of the probability able to flow backward, and (ii) it requires wave packets with a well-defined momentum direction, which are difficult both to prepare and to verify under realistic, noisy conditions. Here, we overcome these challenges by introducing a general formulation of quantum backflow applicable to arbitrary momentum distributions. The framework recovers the standard backflow limit for unidirectional states and identifies general backflow as probability flow exceeding that predicted by the particle's momentum distribution alone. We show that this excess can reach nearly 13%, surpassing the standard backflow bound by more than a factor of three. Furthermore, we extend the framework to the closely related phenomenon of quantum reentry, provide explicit examples of quantum states exhibiting large general backflow and reentry, and discuss the foundational implications of these nonclassical effects. Our results open a pathway toward the experimental observation of quantum backflow in realistic settings.