We study the robustness of quantum key distribution protocols using discrete or continuous variables to the channel noise. We introduce the model of such noise based on coupling of the signal to a thermal reservoir, typical for continuous-variable quantum key distribution, to the discrete-variable case. Then we perform a comparison of the bounds on the tolerable channel noise between these two kinds of protocols using the same noise parametrization, in the case of implementation which is perfect otherwise. Obtained results show that continuous-variable protocols can exhibit similar robustness to the channel noise when the transmittance of the channel is relatively high. However, for strong loss discrete-variable protocols are superior and can overcome even the infinite-squeezing continuous-variable protocol while using limited nonclassical resources. The requirement on the probability of a single-photon production which would have to be fulfilled by a practical source of photons in order to demonstrate such superiority is feasible thanks to the recent rapid development in this field.
We study the robustness of quantum key distribution protocols using discrete or continuous variables to the channel noise. We introduce the model of such noise based on coupling of the signal to a thermal reservoir, typical for continuous-variable quantum key distribution, to the discrete-variable case. Then we perform a comparison of the bounds on the tolerable channel noise between these two kinds of protocols using the same noise parametrization, in the case of implementation which is perfect otherwise. Obtained results show that continuous-variable protocols can exhibit similar robustness to the channel noise when the transmittance of the channel is relatively high. However, for strong loss discrete-variable protocols are superior and can overcome even the infinite-squeezing continuous-variable protocol while using limited nonclassical resources. The requirement on the probability of a single-photon production which would have to be fulfilled by a practical source of photons in order to demonstrate such superiority is feasible thanks to the recent rapid development in this field.
Abstract Discrete-variable (DV) and continuous-variable (CV) schemes constitute the two major families of quantum key distribution (QKD) protocols. Unfortunately, since the setup elements required by these schemes are quite different, making a fair comparison of their potential performance in particular applications is often troublesome, limiting the experimenters’ capability to choose an optimal solution. In this work we perform a general comparison of the major entanglement-based DV and CV QKD protocols in terms of their resistance to the channel noise, with the otherwise perfect setup, showing the definite superiority of the DV family. We analytically derive fundamental bounds on the tolerable channel noise and attenuation for entanglement-based CV QKD protocols. We also investigate the influence of DV QKD setup imperfections on the obtained results in order to determine benchmarks for the parameters of realistic photon sources and detectors, allowing the realistic DV protocols to outperform even the ideal CV QKD analogs. Our results indicate the realistic advantage of DV entanglement-based schemes over their CV counterparts and suggests the practical efforts for maximizing this advantage.
We address the robustness of quantum key distribution protocols to imperfections of a quantum channel. Starting from the Gaussian continuous-variable protocols we recapitulate the role of quadrature squeezing in providing security of the key in the noisy channels taking into account the limited efficiency of data processing. We then develop a model of channel noise that allows an equivalent quantification as for the continuous-variable protocols and apply it to the discrete-variable protocols. This allows us to perform the comparison of robustness of the protocols to the channel noise when either continuous- or discrete-variable coding is used. We show that while continuous-variable protocols enforced by arbitrarily strong nonclassicality demonstrate some quantitative advantage in the channels with relatively low losses, the discrete-variable protocols can achieve better tolerance to the channel noise even when using the limited nonclassical resource. The result is promising for planning of integrated secure communication systems.
Discrete-variable (DV) quantum key distribution (QKD) based on single-photon detectors and sources have been successfully deployed for long-range secure key distribution. On the other hand, continuous-variable (CV) quantum key distribution (QKD) based on coherent detectors and sources is currently lagging behind in terms of loss and noise tolerance. An important discerning factor between DV-QKD and CV-QKD is the effect of phase noise, which is known to be more relevant in CV-QKD. In this article, we investigate the effect of phase noise on DV-QKD and CV-QKD protocols, including the six-state protocol and squeezed-state protocol, in a thermal-loss channel but with the assumed availability of perfect sources and detectors. We find that in the low phase noise regime but high thermal noise regime, CV-QKD can tolerate more loss compared to DV-QKD. We also compare the secret key rate as an additional metric for the performance of QKD. Requirements for this quantity to be high vastly extend the regions at which CV-QKD performs better than DV-QKD. Our analysis addresses the questions of how phase noise affects DV-QKD and CV-QKD and why the former has historically performed better in a thermal-loss channel.
Abstract We address the crucial role of noisy squeezing in security and performance of continuous-variable (CV) quantum key distribution (QKD) protocols. Squeezing has long been recognized for its numerous advantages in CV QKD, such as enhanced robustness against channel noise and loss, and improved secret key rates. However, the excess noise of the squeezed states, that unavoidably originates already from optical loss as well as other imperfections in the source, raises concerns about its potential exploitation by an eavesdropper. For the widely adopted trust assumption on the excess noise in the signal states, we confirm the stability of the protocol against the noisy squeezing in both purely attenuating as well as noisy channels in the asymptotic limit, which implies perfect parameter estimation. In the finite-size regime we show that this stability largely holds at up to 107 data points using optimal biased homodyne detection for key distribution and parameter estimation. Untrusted assumption on the noisy squeezing, on the other hand, introduces additional security bounds on the squeezing excess noise already in the asymptotic regime, which is further enforced by the finite-size effects. Additionally, we show the critical negative role of noisy squeezing in the case of atmospheric free-space channels, already in the trusted-noise and asymptotic assumptions, which emphasizes the importance of squeezing purity in the free-space quantum channels. Our results pave the way towards practical realization of squeezed-state CV QKD protocols in both fibre and free-space channels.
Abstract We address the crucial role of noisy squeezing in security and performance of continuous-variable (CV) quantum key distribution (QKD) protocols. Squeezing has long been recognized for its numerous advantages in CV QKD, such as enhanced robustness against channel noise and loss, and improved secret key rates. However, the excess noise of the squeezed states, that unavoidably originates already from optical loss as well as other imperfections in the source, raises concerns about its potential exploitation by an eavesdropper. For the widely adopted trust assumption on the excess noise in the signal states, we confirm the stability of the protocol against the noisy squeezing in both purely attenuating as well as noisy channels in the asymptotic limit, which implies perfect parameter estimation. In the finite-size regime we show that this stability largely holds at up to 107 data points using optimal biased homodyne detection for key distribution and parameter estimation. Untrusted assumption on the noisy squeezing, on the other hand, introduces additional security bounds on the squeezing excess noise already in the asymptotic regime, which is further enforced by the finite-size effects. Additionally, we show the critical negative role of noisy squeezing in the case of atmospheric free-space channels, already in the trusted-noise and asymptotic assumptions, which emphasizes the importance of squeezing purity in the free-space quantum channels. Our results pave the way towards practical realization of squeezed-state CV QKD protocols in both fibre and free-space channels.
We address the efficiency and robustness of quantum key distribution (QKD) based on entangled states in conditions of noisy quantum channels. We consider schemes based on either source or detection station located in the middle or the channel, the latter configuration allowing realization of measurement-device independent QKD. In our study we focus both on discrete-variable (DV) QKD protocols utilizing direct photodetection as well as continuous-variable (CV) ones, which are based on the homodyne detection. Equivalently parametrizing the channel excess noise for both DV and CV protocols, we use robustness of an ideal CV QKD protocol as a benchmark for the entanglement-based DV QKD. We show that DV protocols typically overcome the CV ones in both source- and detector-in-the-middle setup configurations. However, this advantage can be undermined by the practical aspects on the DV protocols. Considering quantum-dot type of the DV sources of entanglement, we show the levels of pair generation and collection efficiencies needed to overcome any CV protocols. The requirements are generally compatible with the existing technologies but may require experimental efforts to achieve. Our results are essential for the practical entanglement-based QKD protocols with modern efficient sources, aimed at potential scalability in the quantum networks.