Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1601.04058 · Physical review. B./Physical review. B

Long tail distributions near the many-body localization transition

David J. Luitz

Published Apr 1, 2016• 120 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The random field $S=\frac{1}{2}$ Heisenberg chain exhibits a dynamical many body localization transition at a critical disorder strength, which depends on the energy density. At weak disorder, the eigenstate thermalization hypothesis (ETH) is fulfilled on average, making local observables smooth functions of energy, whose eigenstate-to-eigenstate fluctuations decrease exponentially with system size. We demonstrate the validity of ETH in the thermal phase as well as its breakdown in the localized phase and show that rare states exist which do not strictly follow ETH, becoming more frequent closer to the transition. Similarly, the probability distribution of the entanglement entropy at intermediate disorder develops long tails all the way down to zero entanglement. We propose that these low entanglement tails stem from localized regions at the subsystem boundaries which were recently discussed as a possible mechanism for subdiffusive transport in the ergodic phase.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.93.134201

Related papers

Statistics of correlation functions in the random Heisenberg chain

Luis A. Colmenarez, Paul McClarty, Masud Haque +1 more

Ergodic quantum many-body systems satisfy the eigenstate thermalization hypothesis (ETH). However, strong disorder can destroy ergodicity through many-body localization (MBL) – at least in one dimensional systems – leading to a clear signal of the MBL transition in the probability distributions of energy eigenstate expectation values of local operators. For a paradigmatic model of MBL, namely the random-field Heisenberg spin chain, we consider the full probability distribution of eigenstate correlation functions across the entire phase diagram. We find gaussian distributions at weak disorder, as predicted by pure ETH. At intermediate disorder – in the thermal phase – we find further evidence for anomalous thermalization in the form of heavy tails of the distributions. In the MBL phase, we observe peculiar features of the correlator distributions: a strong asymmetry in S_i^z S_{i+r}^z S i z S i + r z correlators skewed towards negative values; and a multimodal distribution for spin-flip correlators. A quantitative quasi-degenerate perturbation theory calculation of these correlators yields a surprising agreement of the full distribution with the exact results, revealing, in particular, the origin of the multiple peaks in the spin-flip correlator distribution as arising from the resonant and off-resonant admixture of spin configurations. The distribution of the S_i^zS_{i+r}^z S i z S i + r z correlator exhibits striking differences between the MBL and Anderson insulator cases.

arXiv:1906.10701•SciPost Physics•Nov 21, 2019•34 citations

Statistics of correlation functions in the random Heisenberg chain

Colmenarez, Luis, Paul McClarty, Masudul Haque +1 more

Ergodic quantum many-body systems satisfy the eigenstate thermalization hypothesis (ETH). However, strong disorder can destroy ergodicity through many-body localization (MBL) - at least in one dimensional systems - leading to a clear signal of the MBL transition in the probability distributions of energy eigenstate expectation values of local operators. For a paradigmatic model of MBL, namely the random-field Heisenberg spin chain, we consider the full probability distribution of eigenstate correlation functions across the entire phase diagram. We find gaussian distributions at weak disorder, as predicted by pure ETH. At intermediate disorder - in the thermal phase - we find further evidence for anomalous thermalization in the form of heavy tails of the distributions. In the MBL phase, we observe peculiar features of the correlator distributions: a strong asymmetry in (SiSi+rz)-S-z correlators skewed towards negative values; and a multimodal distribution for spin-flip correlators. A quantitative quasi-degenerate perturbation theory calculation of these correlators yields a surprising agreement of the full distribution with the exact results, revealing, in particular, the origin of the multiple peaks in the spin-flip correlator distribution as arising from the resonant and off-resonant admixture of spin configurations. The distribution of the (SiSi+rz)-S-z correlator exhibits striking differences between the MBL and Anderson insulator cases.

•Jan 1, 2019•33 citations

A microscopically motivated renormalization scheme for the MBL/ETH transition

Thimothée Thiery, Markus Müller, Wojciech De Roeck

We introduce a multi-scale diagonalization scheme to study the transition between the many-body localized and the ergodic phase in disordered quantum chains. The scheme assumes a sharp dichotomy between subsystems that behave as localized and resonant spots that obey the Eigenstate Thermalization Hypothesis (ETH). We establish a set of microscopic principles defining the diagonalization scheme, and use them to numerically study the transition in very large systems. To a large extent the results are in agreement with an analytically tractable mean-field analysis of the scheme: We find that at the critical point the system is almost surely localized in the thermodynamic limit, hosting a set of thermal inclusions whose sizes are power-law distributed. On the localized side the {\em typical} localization length is bounded from above. The bound saturates upon approach to criticality, entailing that a finite ergodic inclusion thermalizes a region of diverging diameter. The dominant thermal inclusions have a fractal structure, implying that averaged correlators decay as stretched exponentials throughout the localized phase. Slightly on the ergodic side thermalization occurs through an avalanche instability of the nearly localized bulk, whereby rare, supercritically large ergodic spots eventually thermalize the entire sample. Their size diverges at the transition, while their density vanishes. The non-local, avalanche-like nature of this instability entails a breakdown of single parameter scaling and puts the delocalization transition outside the realm of standard critical phenomena.

arXiv:1711.09880•Nov 27, 2017•23 citations

Tracking the many-body localized to ergodic transition via extremal statistics of entanglement eigenvalues

Abhisek Samanta, Kedar Damle, Rajdeep Sensarma

Some interacting disordered many-body systems are unable to thermalize when the quenched disorder becomes larger than a threshold value. Although several properties of nonzero energy density eigenstates (in the middle of the many-body spectrum) exhibit a qualitative change across this many-body localization (MBL) transition, many of the commonly used diagnostics only do so over a broad transition regime. Here we provide evidence that the transition can be located precisely even at modest system sizes by sharply defined changes in the distribution of extremal eigenvalues of the reduced density matrix of subsystems. In particular, our results suggest that $p*={lim}_{{\ensuremath{\lambda}}_{2}\ensuremath{\rightarrow}ln{(2)}^{+}}{P}_{2}({\ensuremath{\lambda}}_{2})$, where ${P}_{2}({\ensuremath{\lambda}}_{2})$ is the probability distribution of the second lowest entanglement eigenvalue ${\ensuremath{\lambda}}_{2}$, behaves as an ``order parameter'' for the MBL phase: $p*>0$ in the MBL phase, while $p*=0$ in the ergodic phase with thermalization. Thus, in the MBL phase, there is a nonzero probability that a subsystem is entangled with the rest of the system only via the entanglement of one subsystem qubit with degrees of freedom outside the region. In contrast, this probability vanishes in the thermal phase.

arXiv:2001.10198•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Sep 2, 2020•11 citations

Bimodal entanglement entropy distribution in the many-body localization transition

Xiongjie Yu, David J. Luitz, Bryan K. Clark

We introduce the cut-averaged entanglement entropy in disordered periodic spin chains and prove it to be a concave function of subsystem size for individual eigenstates. This allows us to identify the entanglement scaling as a function of subsystem size for individual states in inhomogeneous systems. Using this quantity, we probe the critical region between the many-body localized (MBL) and ergodic phases in finite systems. In the middle of the spectrum, we show evidence for bimodality of the entanglement distribution in the MBL critical region, finding both volume law and area law eigenstates over disorder realizations as well as within single disorder realizations. The disorder-averaged entanglement entropy in this region then scales as a volume law with a coefficient below its thermal value. We discover in the critical region, as we approach the thermodynamic limit, that the cut-averaged entanglement entropy density falls on a one-parameter family of curves. Finally, we also show that without averaging over cuts the slope of the entanglement entropy vs subsystem size can be negative at intermediate and strong disorder, caused by rare localized regions in the system.

arXiv:1606.01260•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Nov 15, 2016•86 citations

Many-body Localization

Eirik Almklov Magnussen

We study a random-field Heisenberg model numerically and argue that as we vary the strength of the disorder W there is a phase transition between a thermal phase and a many-body localized phase at a critical disorder strength W C = 3.5 ± 1.0.We show some properties of the many-body localized phase and contrast them to the properties of the thermal phase.We have considered transport properties, scaling of entanglement entropy, level statistics, participation ratios and whether or not the system satisfies the ETH to distinguish between the phases.We also study the dynamics in the thermal phase near the transition and argue that the phase transition is governed by an infinite randomness fixed point.Furthermore we review much of what is known and conjectured about the physics of generic closed quantum systems.

•Jan 1, 2017•0 citations
The random field S=12S=\frac{1}{2}S=21​ Heisenberg chain exhibits a dynamical many body localization transition at a critical disorder strength, which depends on the energy density. At weak disorder, the eigenstate thermalization hypothesis (ETH) is fulfilled on average, making local observables smooth functions of energy, whose eigenstate-to-eigenstate fluctuations decrease exponentially with system size. We demonstrate the validity of ETH in the thermal phase as well as its breakdown in the localized phase and show that rare states exist which do not strictly follow ETH, becoming more frequent closer to the transition. Similarly, the probability distribution of the entanglement entropy at intermediate disorder develops long tails all the way down to zero entanglement. We propose that these low entanglement tails stem from localized regions at the subsystem boundaries which were recently discussed as a possible mechanism for subdiffusive transport in the ergodic phase.
Ergodic quantum many-body systems satisfy the eigenstate thermalization hypothesis (ETH). However, strong disorder can destroy ergodicity through many-body localization (MBL) – at least in one dimensional systems – leading to a clear signal of the MBL transition in the probability distributions of energy eigenstate expectation values of local operators. For a paradigmatic model of MBL, namely the random-field Heisenberg spin chain, we consider the full probability distribution of eigenstate correlation functions across the entire phase diagram. We find gaussian distributions at weak disorder, as predicted by pure ETH. At intermediate disorder – in the thermal phase – we find further evidence for anomalous thermalization in the form of heavy tails of the distributions. In the MBL phase, we observe peculiar features of the correlator distributions: a strong asymmetry in S_i^z S_{i+r}^z S i z S i + r z correlators skewed towards negative values; and a multimodal distribution for spin-flip correlators. A quantitative quasi-degenerate perturbation theory calculation of these correlators yields a surprising agreement of the full distribution with the exact results, revealing, in particular, the origin of the multiple peaks in the spin-flip correlator distribution as arising from the resonant and off-resonant admixture of spin configurations. The distribution of the S_i^zS_{i+r}^z S i z S i + r z correlator exhibits striking differences between the MBL and Anderson insulator cases.
Ergodic quantum many-body systems satisfy the eigenstate thermalization hypothesis (ETH). However, strong disorder can destroy ergodicity through many-body localization (MBL) - at least in one dimensional systems - leading to a clear signal of the MBL transition in the probability distributions of energy eigenstate expectation values of local operators. For a paradigmatic model of MBL, namely the random-field Heisenberg spin chain, we consider the full probability distribution of eigenstate correlation functions across the entire phase diagram. We find gaussian distributions at weak disorder, as predicted by pure ETH. At intermediate disorder - in the thermal phase - we find further evidence for anomalous thermalization in the form of heavy tails of the distributions. In the MBL phase, we observe peculiar features of the correlator distributions: a strong asymmetry in (SiSi+rz)-S-z correlators skewed towards negative values; and a multimodal distribution for spin-flip correlators. A quantitative quasi-degenerate perturbation theory calculation of these correlators yields a surprising agreement of the full distribution with the exact results, revealing, in particular, the origin of the multiple peaks in the spin-flip correlator distribution as arising from the resonant and off-resonant admixture of spin configurations. The distribution of the (SiSi+rz)-S-z correlator exhibits striking differences between the MBL and Anderson insulator cases.
We introduce a multi-scale diagonalization scheme to study the transition between the many-body localized and the ergodic phase in disordered quantum chains. The scheme assumes a sharp dichotomy between subsystems that behave as localized and resonant spots that obey the Eigenstate Thermalization Hypothesis (ETH). We establish a set of microscopic principles defining the diagonalization scheme, and use them to numerically study the transition in very large systems. To a large extent the results are in agreement with an analytically tractable mean-field analysis of the scheme: We find that at the critical point the system is almost surely localized in the thermodynamic limit, hosting a set of thermal inclusions whose sizes are power-law distributed. On the localized side the {\em typical} localization length is bounded from above. The bound saturates upon approach to criticality, entailing that a finite ergodic inclusion thermalizes a region of diverging diameter. The dominant thermal inclusions have a fractal structure, implying that averaged correlators decay as stretched exponentials throughout the localized phase. Slightly on the ergodic side thermalization occurs through an avalanche instability of the nearly localized bulk, whereby rare, supercritically large ergodic spots eventually thermalize the entire sample. Their size diverges at the transition, while their density vanishes. The non-local, avalanche-like nature of this instability entails a breakdown of single parameter scaling and puts the delocalization transition outside the realm of standard critical phenomena.
Some interacting disordered many-body systems are unable to thermalize when the quenched disorder becomes larger than a threshold value. Although several properties of nonzero energy density eigenstates (in the middle of the many-body spectrum) exhibit a qualitative change across this many-body localization (MBL) transition, many of the commonly used diagnostics only do so over a broad transition regime. Here we provide evidence that the transition can be located precisely even at modest system sizes by sharply defined changes in the distribution of extremal eigenvalues of the reduced density matrix of subsystems. In particular, our results suggest that $p*={lim}_{{\ensuremath{\lambda}}_{2}\ensuremath{\rightarrow}ln{(2)}^{+}}{P}_{2}({\ensuremath{\lambda}}_{2})$, where ${P}_{2}({\ensuremath{\lambda}}_{2})$ is the probability distribution of the second lowest entanglement eigenvalue ${\ensuremath{\lambda}}_{2}$, behaves as an ``order parameter'' for the MBL phase: p∗>0p*>0p∗>0 in the MBL phase, while p∗=0p*=0p∗=0 in the ergodic phase with thermalization. Thus, in the MBL phase, there is a nonzero probability that a subsystem is entangled with the rest of the system only via the entanglement of one subsystem qubit with degrees of freedom outside the region. In contrast, this probability vanishes in the thermal phase.
We introduce the cut-averaged entanglement entropy in disordered periodic spin chains and prove it to be a concave function of subsystem size for individual eigenstates. This allows us to identify the entanglement scaling as a function of subsystem size for individual states in inhomogeneous systems. Using this quantity, we probe the critical region between the many-body localized (MBL) and ergodic phases in finite systems. In the middle of the spectrum, we show evidence for bimodality of the entanglement distribution in the MBL critical region, finding both volume law and area law eigenstates over disorder realizations as well as within single disorder realizations. The disorder-averaged entanglement entropy in this region then scales as a volume law with a coefficient below its thermal value. We discover in the critical region, as we approach the thermodynamic limit, that the cut-averaged entanglement entropy density falls on a one-parameter family of curves. Finally, we also show that without averaging over cuts the slope of the entanglement entropy vs subsystem size can be negative at intermediate and strong disorder, caused by rare localized regions in the system.
We study a random-field Heisenberg model numerically and argue that as we vary the strength of the disorder W there is a phase transition between a thermal phase and a many-body localized phase at a critical disorder strength W C = 3.5 ± 1.0.We show some properties of the many-body localized phase and contrast them to the properties of the thermal phase.We have considered transport properties, scaling of entanglement entropy, level statistics, participation ratios and whether or not the system satisfies the ETH to distinguish between the phases.We also study the dynamics in the thermal phase near the transition and argue that the phase transition is governed by an infinite randomness fixed point.Furthermore we review much of what is known and conjectured about the physics of generic closed quantum systems.