Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1512.03756 · Science

Quantum spin dynamics and entanglement generation with hundreds of trapped ions

Justin Bohnet, Brian C. Sawyer, J. Britton, Michael L. Wall, Ana María Rey, Michael Foss‐Feig, J. J. Bollinger

Published Jun 9, 2016• 545 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Quantum simulation of spin models can provide insight into problems that are difficult or impossible to study with classical computers. Trapped ions are an established platform for quantum simulation, but only systems with fewer than 20 ions have demonstrated quantum correlations. We studied quantum spin dynamics arising from an engineered, homogeneous Ising interaction in a two-dimensional array of (9)Be(+) ions in a Penning trap. We verified entanglement in spin-squeezed states of up to 219 ions, directly observing 4.0 ± 0.9 decibels of spectroscopic enhancement, and observed states with non-Gaussian statistics consistent with oversqueezed states. The good agreement with ab initio theory that includes interactions and decoherence lays the groundwork for simulations of the transverse-field Ising model with variable-range interactions, which are generally intractable with classical methods.

DOI
10.1126/science.aad9958

Related papers

Quantum Simulation of Interacting Spin Models with Trapped Ions

Kazi Rajibul Islam

The quantum simulation of complex many body systems holds promise for understanding the origin of emergent properties of strongly correlated systems, such as high-Tc superconductors and spin liquids. Cold atomic systems provide an almost ideal platform for quantum simulation due to their excellent quantum coherence, initialization and readout properties, and their ability to support several forms of interactions. In this thesis, I present experiments on the quantum simulation of long range Ising models in the presence of transverse magnetic fields with a chain of up to sixteen ultracold 171-Yb+ ions trapped in a linear radio frequency Paul trap. Two hyperfine levels in each of the 171-Yb+ ions serve as the spin-1/2 systems. We detect the spin states of the individual ions by observing state-dependent fluorescence with single site resolution, and can directly measure any possible spin correlation function. The spin-spin interactions are engineered by applying dipole forces from precisely tuned lasers whose beatnotes induce stimulated Raman transitions that couple virtually to collective phonon modes of the ion motion. The Ising couplings are controlled, both in sign and strength with respect to the effective transverse field, and adiabatically manipulated to study various aspects of this spin model, such as the emergence of a quantum phase transition in the ground state and spin frustration due to competing antiferromagnetic interactions. Spin frustration often gives rise to a massive degeneracy in the ground state, which can lead to entanglement in the spin system. We detect and characterize this frustration induced entanglement in a system of three spins, demonstrating the first direct experimental connection between frustration and entanglement. With larger numbers of spins we also vary the range of the antiferromagnetic couplings through appropriate laser tunings and observe that longer range interactions reduce the excitation energy and thereby frustrate the ground state order. This system can potentially be scaled up to study a wide range of fully connected spin networks with a few dozens of spins, where the underlying theory becomes intractable on a classical computer.

•Jan 1, 2012•6 citations

Probing Quantum Magnetism in 2D with an Array of Hundreds of Trapped Ions

John Bollinger

Quantum simulations using AMO systems promise a new way to experimentally study emergent quantum phenomena, but few systems have demonstrated the capability to control ensembles in which quantum effects cannot be directly computed. The 2D array of 100s of 9Be+ ions in a Penning trap, crystallized in a triangular lattice when laser cooled, is a promising platform for intractable quantum simulations using the 9Be+ valence electron spin as a qubit [1]. Spin-dependent forces are employed to modify the strong Coulomb interaction of the ions, mimicking a quantum magnetic interaction. The range of the magnetic interaction can be tuned from infinite to a dipole-dipole like coupling. Combining the application of the spin-dependent force with a transverse magnetic field should lead to the development of quantum correlations between the spins, which can be measured through optical readout of the spin state, both globally and with site-resolved imaging. In this way, trapped atomic ions can be used to probe novel and intractable aspects of quantum magnetism, including the effects of long-range interactions and simulations of quantum non-equilibrium phenomena [2]. In addition to a general overview, I will discuss recent work from a new Penning trap set-up at NIST.

Bulletin of the American Physical Society•Mar 4, 2015•0 citations

Quantum simulation with Rydberg ions in a Penning trap

Wilson S. Martins, Markus Hennrich, Ferdinand Schmidt-Kaler +1 more

Quantum simulation of interacting many-body spin systems is routinely performed with cold trapped ions, and systems with hundreds of spins have been studied in one and two dimensions. In the most common realizations of these platforms, spin degrees of freedom are encoded in low-lying electronic levels, and interactions among the spins are mediated through crystal vibrations. Here we propose a new approach which enables the quantum simulation of two-dimensional spin systems with interaction strengths that are increased by orders of magnitude. This, together with the unprecedented longevity of trapped ions, opens an avenue for the exploration of phenomena that take place on long timescales, e.g., slow and collective relaxation in frustrated and kinetically constrained systems. Our platform makes use of the strong dipolar interactions among electronic Rydberg states and planar confinement provided by a Penning trap. We investigate how the strong electric and magnetic fields that form this trap affect the properties of the Rydberg states and show that spin-spin interaction strengths on the order of MHz are achievable under experimentally realistic conditions. As a brief illustration of the capabilities of this quantum simulator, we study the entanglement in a frustrated spin system realized by three ions.

quant-pharXiv:2601.01626•PRX Quantum•Jan 6, 2026•0 citations

Simulation of the Quantum Ising Model in an Ion Trap

Axel Friedenauer

In a proof-of-principle experiment, we simulate the dynamics of a quantum spin system in an ion trap. Following a theoretical proposal by D. Porras and I. Cirac, we use a system of ground state cooled trapped ions to simulate and study the dynamics of a quantum-mechanical system, or more precisely, the dynamics of a quantum spin Hamiltonian. We implement the smallest non-trivial quantum spin Hamiltonian, the quantum Ising model for two spins. Each spin is represented by two hyperfine ground levels of trapped 25Mg+ ions. The interaction with an external magnetic field is simulated by coherently coupling these hyperfine levels via laser and radiofrequency radiation. The spin-spin interaction is simulated via optical dipole forces, where the effective interaction is mediated by the phonons of the linear ion chain. We demonstrate the adiabatic evolution from a paramagnetically ordered system to ferromagnetic order. The final state of this adiabatic transition is a superposition state of the two degenerate spin configurations of ferromagnetic order Psi_final = 1/sqrt(2) (|up up> + |down down>) with a quantum magnetisation of 98%. We also show the transition from paramagnetic to antiferromagnetic order with the final state Psi_final = 1/sqrt(2) (|up down> + |down up>). Moreover, we prove that this transition which is to become a quantum phase transition in the thermodynamic limit of infinitely many spins, is driven by quantum fluctuations which dominate the dynamics of such systems at the absolute zero-point of temperature rather than thermal fluctuations which are absent at 0 K. This is verified by the fact that the final state of our adiabatic evolution is entangled, close to a Bell state at a fidelity exceeding 88%. The set of tools presented in this thesis might serve as a basis for larger scale quantum simulations which might help in gaining insight into many-particle effects that are intractable on classical computers such as spin frustration in triangular lattices or high-Tc superconductivity.

•Jan 1, 2010•3 citations

Quantum simulations of the Ising model with trapped ions: Devil's staircase and arbitrary lattice proposal

S. É. Korenblit

A collection of trapped atomic ions represents one of the most attractive platforms for the quantum simulation of interacting spin networks and quantum magnetism. Spin-dependent optical dipole forces applied to an ion crystal create long-range eective spin-spin interactions and allow the simulation of spin Hamiltonians that possess nontrivial phases and dynamics. We trap linear chains of 171Yb+ ions in a Paul trap, and constrain the occupation of energy levels to the ground hyperne clock-states, creating a qubit or pseudo-spin 1/2 system. We proceed to implement spin-spin couplings between two ions using the far detuned Mlmer-Srenson scheme and perform adiabatic quantum simulations of Ising Hamiltonians with long-range couplings. We then demonstrate our ability to control the sign and relative strength of the interaction between three ions. Using this control, we simulate a frustrated triangular lattice, and for the first time establish an experimental connection between frustration and quantum entanglement. We then scale up our simulation to show phase transitions from paramagnetism to ferromagnetism for nine ions, and to anti-ferromagnetism for sixteen ions. The experimental work culminates with our most complicated Hamiltonian - a long range anti-ferromagnetic Ising interaction between 10 ions with a biasing axial field. Theoretical work presented in this thesis shows how the approach to quantum simulation utilized in this thesis can be further extended and improved. It is shown how appropriate design of laser elds can provide for arbitrary multidimensional spin-spin interaction graphs even for the case of a linear spatial array of ions. This scheme uses currently existing trap technology and is scalable to levels where classical methods of simulation are intractable.

•Jan 1, 2013•0 citations

Quantum simulation and many-body physics with hundreds of trapped ions

J. J. Bollinger, J. Britton, Brian C. Sawyer

By employing forces that depend on the internal electronic state (or spin) of an atomic ion, the Coulomb potential energy of a trapped ion crystal can be modified in a spin-dependent way to mimic effective quantum spin Hamiltonians. We use simple models to explain how effective Ising interactions are engineered with trapped-ion crystals. We discuss the range of interactions that can be readily generated and an experimental implementation using single-plane ion crystals in a Penning trap.

•Jan 1, 2013•1 citation
Quantum simulation of spin models can provide insight into problems that are difficult or impossible to study with classical computers. Trapped ions are an established platform for quantum simulation, but only systems with fewer than 20 ions have demonstrated quantum correlations. We studied quantum spin dynamics arising from an engineered, homogeneous Ising interaction in a two-dimensional array of (9)Be(+) ions in a Penning trap. We verified entanglement in spin-squeezed states of up to 219 ions, directly observing 4.0 ± 0.9 decibels of spectroscopic enhancement, and observed states with non-Gaussian statistics consistent with oversqueezed states. The good agreement with ab initio theory that includes interactions and decoherence lays the groundwork for simulations of the transverse-field Ising model with variable-range interactions, which are generally intractable with classical methods.
The quantum simulation of complex many body systems holds promise for understanding the origin of emergent properties of strongly correlated systems, such as high-Tc superconductors and spin liquids. Cold atomic systems provide an almost ideal platform for quantum simulation due to their excellent quantum coherence, initialization and readout properties, and their ability to support several forms of interactions. In this thesis, I present experiments on the quantum simulation of long range Ising models in the presence of transverse magnetic fields with a chain of up to sixteen ultracold 171-Yb+ ions trapped in a linear radio frequency Paul trap. Two hyperfine levels in each of the 171-Yb+ ions serve as the spin-1/2 systems. We detect the spin states of the individual ions by observing state-dependent fluorescence with single site resolution, and can directly measure any possible spin correlation function. The spin-spin interactions are engineered by applying dipole forces from precisely tuned lasers whose beatnotes induce stimulated Raman transitions that couple virtually to collective phonon modes of the ion motion. The Ising couplings are controlled, both in sign and strength with respect to the effective transverse field, and adiabatically manipulated to study various aspects of this spin model, such as the emergence of a quantum phase transition in the ground state and spin frustration due to competing antiferromagnetic interactions. Spin frustration often gives rise to a massive degeneracy in the ground state, which can lead to entanglement in the spin system. We detect and characterize this frustration induced entanglement in a system of three spins, demonstrating the first direct experimental connection between frustration and entanglement. With larger numbers of spins we also vary the range of the antiferromagnetic couplings through appropriate laser tunings and observe that longer range interactions reduce the excitation energy and thereby frustrate the ground state order. This system can potentially be scaled up to study a wide range of fully connected spin networks with a few dozens of spins, where the underlying theory becomes intractable on a classical computer.
Quantum simulations using AMO systems promise a new way to experimentally study emergent quantum phenomena, but few systems have demonstrated the capability to control ensembles in which quantum effects cannot be directly computed. The 2D array of 100s of 9Be+ ions in a Penning trap, crystallized in a triangular lattice when laser cooled, is a promising platform for intractable quantum simulations using the 9Be+ valence electron spin as a qubit [1]. Spin-dependent forces are employed to modify the strong Coulomb interaction of the ions, mimicking a quantum magnetic interaction. The range of the magnetic interaction can be tuned from infinite to a dipole-dipole like coupling. Combining the application of the spin-dependent force with a transverse magnetic field should lead to the development of quantum correlations between the spins, which can be measured through optical readout of the spin state, both globally and with site-resolved imaging. In this way, trapped atomic ions can be used to probe novel and intractable aspects of quantum magnetism, including the effects of long-range interactions and simulations of quantum non-equilibrium phenomena [2]. In addition to a general overview, I will discuss recent work from a new Penning trap set-up at NIST.
Quantum simulation of interacting many-body spin systems is routinely performed with cold trapped ions, and systems with hundreds of spins have been studied in one and two dimensions. In the most common realizations of these platforms, spin degrees of freedom are encoded in low-lying electronic levels, and interactions among the spins are mediated through crystal vibrations. Here we propose a new approach which enables the quantum simulation of two-dimensional spin systems with interaction strengths that are increased by orders of magnitude. This, together with the unprecedented longevity of trapped ions, opens an avenue for the exploration of phenomena that take place on long timescales, e.g., slow and collective relaxation in frustrated and kinetically constrained systems. Our platform makes use of the strong dipolar interactions among electronic Rydberg states and planar confinement provided by a Penning trap. We investigate how the strong electric and magnetic fields that form this trap affect the properties of the Rydberg states and show that spin-spin interaction strengths on the order of MHz are achievable under experimentally realistic conditions. As a brief illustration of the capabilities of this quantum simulator, we study the entanglement in a frustrated spin system realized by three ions.
In a proof-of-principle experiment, we simulate the dynamics of a quantum spin system in an ion trap. Following a theoretical proposal by D. Porras and I. Cirac, we use a system of ground state cooled trapped ions to simulate and study the dynamics of a quantum-mechanical system, or more precisely, the dynamics of a quantum spin Hamiltonian. We implement the smallest non-trivial quantum spin Hamiltonian, the quantum Ising model for two spins. Each spin is represented by two hyperfine ground levels of trapped 25Mg+ ions. The interaction with an external magnetic field is simulated by coherently coupling these hyperfine levels via laser and radiofrequency radiation. The spin-spin interaction is simulated via optical dipole forces, where the effective interaction is mediated by the phonons of the linear ion chain. We demonstrate the adiabatic evolution from a paramagnetically ordered system to ferromagnetic order. The final state of this adiabatic transition is a superposition state of the two degenerate spin configurations of ferromagnetic order Psi_final = 1/sqrt(2) (|up up> + |down down>) with a quantum magnetisation of 98%. We also show the transition from paramagnetic to antiferromagnetic order with the final state Psi_final = 1/sqrt(2) (|up down> + |down up>). Moreover, we prove that this transition which is to become a quantum phase transition in the thermodynamic limit of infinitely many spins, is driven by quantum fluctuations which dominate the dynamics of such systems at the absolute zero-point of temperature rather than thermal fluctuations which are absent at 0 K. This is verified by the fact that the final state of our adiabatic evolution is entangled, close to a Bell state at a fidelity exceeding 88%. The set of tools presented in this thesis might serve as a basis for larger scale quantum simulations which might help in gaining insight into many-particle effects that are intractable on classical computers such as spin frustration in triangular lattices or high-Tc superconductivity.
A collection of trapped atomic ions represents one of the most attractive platforms for the quantum simulation of interacting spin networks and quantum magnetism. Spin-dependent optical dipole forces applied to an ion crystal create long-range eective spin-spin interactions and allow the simulation of spin Hamiltonians that possess nontrivial phases and dynamics. We trap linear chains of 171Yb+ ions in a Paul trap, and constrain the occupation of energy levels to the ground hyperne clock-states, creating a qubit or pseudo-spin 1/2 system. We proceed to implement spin-spin couplings between two ions using the far detuned Mlmer-Srenson scheme and perform adiabatic quantum simulations of Ising Hamiltonians with long-range couplings. We then demonstrate our ability to control the sign and relative strength of the interaction between three ions. Using this control, we simulate a frustrated triangular lattice, and for the first time establish an experimental connection between frustration and quantum entanglement. We then scale up our simulation to show phase transitions from paramagnetism to ferromagnetism for nine ions, and to anti-ferromagnetism for sixteen ions. The experimental work culminates with our most complicated Hamiltonian - a long range anti-ferromagnetic Ising interaction between 10 ions with a biasing axial field. Theoretical work presented in this thesis shows how the approach to quantum simulation utilized in this thesis can be further extended and improved. It is shown how appropriate design of laser elds can provide for arbitrary multidimensional spin-spin interaction graphs even for the case of a linear spatial array of ions. This scheme uses currently existing trap technology and is scalable to levels where classical methods of simulation are intractable.