Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1509.04363 · Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields

Can gravity account for the emergence of classicality?

Yuri Bonder, Elias Okon, Daniel Sudarsky

Published Dec 22, 2015• 22 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

A recent debate has ensued over the claim by Pikovski et al. [Nat. Phys. 11, 668 (2015)] that systems with internal degrees of freedom undergo a universal, gravity-induced, type of decoherence that explains their quantum-to-classical transition. This decoherence is supposed to arise from the different gravitational redshifts experienced by such systems when placed in a superposition of two wave packets at different heights in a gravitational field. Here we investigate some aspects of the discussion with the aid of simple examples. In particular, we first resolve an apparent conflict between the reported results and the equivalence principle by noting that the static and free-fall descriptions focus on states associated with different hypersurfaces. Next, we emphasize that predictions regarding the observability of interference become relevant only in the context of concrete experimental settings. As a result, we caution against hasty claims of universal validity. Finally, we dispute the claim that, at least in the scenarios discussed by Pikovski et al., gravitation is responsible for the reported results, and we question the alleged ability of decoherence to explain the quantum-to-classical transition. In consequence, we argue against the extraordinary assertion by Pikovski et al. that gravity can account for the emergence of classicality.

DOI
10.1103/physrevd.92.124050

Related papers

Universal Decoherence under Gravity: A Perspective through the Equivalence Principle

Belinda Pang, Yanbei Chen, Farid Ya Khalili

Pikovski et al. [Nat. Phys. 11, 668 (2015)] show that a composite particle prepared in a pure initial quantum state and propagated in a uniform gravitational field undergoes a decoherence process at a rate determined by the gravitational acceleration. By assuming Einstein's equivalence principle to be valid, we analyze a physical realization of the (1+1)D thought experiment of Pikovski et al. to demonstrate that the dephasing between the different internal states arises not from gravity but rather from differences in their rest mass, and the mass dependence of the de Broglie wave's dispersion relation. We provide an alternative view to the situation considered by Pikovski et al., where we propose that gravity plays a kinematic role by providing a relative velocity to the detector frame with respect to the particle; visibility can be easily recovered by giving the screen an appropriate uniform velocity. We then apply this insight to their thought experiment in (1+1)D to draw a direct correspondence, and obtain the same mathematical result for dephasing. We finally propose that dephasing due to gravity may in fact take place for certain modifications to the gravitational potential where the equivalence principle is violated.

arXiv:1603.01984•Physical Review Letters•Aug 24, 2016•37 citations

Gravitational decoherence of a composite particle: the interplay between gravitons and a classical Newtonian potential

Thiago H. Moreira, Lucas Chibebe Céleri

The fact that gravitational environments cannot be shielded (since gravity is universal) makes them of great theoretical interest to decoherence mechanisms and to the quantum-to-classical transition. While past results seemed to indicate that graviton-induced decoherence of spatial superpositions happens only for macroscopic systems, recently it was shown that this mechanism can be enhanced through the system's own dynamical internal structure. In this work, we extend this analysis by including the interaction with a classical Newtonian potential. We show that, although the graviton bath alone dominates the mechanism for short times compared to a timescale established by the size of the quantum spatial superposition, the interaction between the gravitons and the internal degrees of freedom of the system renders decoherence inevitable in the long-time limit, even for microscopic masses. We also show that this mechanism is slightly slowed down by the interplay with the classical Newtonian potential, which, for systems without dynamical internal degrees of freedom, can even lead to recoherence-like behaviour, at least in principle.

quant-pharXiv:2602.22517•Classical and Quantum Gravity•Feb 27, 2026•0 citations

Brief reply to "Can gravity account for the emergence of classicality?"

Igor Pikovski, Magdalena Zych, Fabio Costa +1 more

In a series of comments, Bonder et al. criticized our work on decoherence due to time dilation [Nature Physics 11, 668-672 (2015)]. First the authors erroneously claimed that our results contradict the equivalence principle, only to "resolve" the alleged conflict in a second note. The resolution - relativity of simultaneity - was already explained in our reply [arXiv:1508.03296], which Bonder et al. now essentially reiterate. The newly raised points were also already extensively clarified in our note. The physical prediction of our work remains valid: systems with internal dynamics decohere if the superposed paths have different proper times.

arXiv:1509.07767•Sep 24, 2015•1 citation

Quantum mechanics for non-inertial observers

Marko Toroš, André Großardt, Angelo Bassi

A recent analysis by Pikovski et al. [Nat. Phys. 11, 668 (2015)] has triggered interest in the question of how to include relativistic corrections in the quantum dynamics governing many-particle systems in a gravitational field. Here we show how the center-of-mass motion of a quantum system subject to gravity can be derived more rigorously, addressing the ambiguous definition of relativistic center-of-mass coordinates. We further demonstrate that, contrary to the prediction by Pikovski et al., external forces play a crucial role in the relativistic coupling of internal and external degrees of freedom, resulting in a complete cancellation of the alleged coupling in Earth-bound laboratories for systems supported against gravity by an external force. We conclude that the proposed decoherence effect is an effect of relative acceleration between quantum system and measurement device, rather than a universal effect in gravitational fields.

arXiv:1701.04298•Jan 16, 2017•5 citations

Gravitational waves and quantum systems: dynamics, decoherence, and the limits of electrodynamical analogy

Linda M. van Manen

This thesis investigates the role of gravitational waves in quantum systems, motivated by advances in our understanding of the quantum–gravity interface and efforts to identify experimental signatures of quantum gravity. It focuses on gravitational decoherence and the interplay between internal energy and centre-of-mass dynamics in composite quantum systems, complemented by a study of internal-energy effects in gravitationally mediated entanglement. First, we develop relativistic Hamiltonian formulations showing that changes in a composite system’s internal energy increase its gravitational mass rather than alter its momentum. This removes earlier ad hoc arguments for eliminating “anomalous friction forces”. We show that gravitational waves act as a dynamical background, inducing curvature-dependent forces that modify total momentum. Second, we revisit a thought experiment in which tensions between causality and complementarity arise. We identify a scenario in which these tensions follow from energy–mass equivalence, making the effect specific to gravitational interactions. In a gravitationally mediated entanglement experiment using Newtonian gravity as mediator, we investigate whether decohering gravitational radiation can resolve the apparent conflict. Finally, we build upon a model of gravitational decoherence consistent with general relativity. This requires deriving a higher-derivative quantum Langevin equation and master equation. The resulting dynamics show that gravitational interactions induce decoherence in the canonical momentum basis of the quadrupole and generate acceleration- and jerk-dependent corrections absent in electrodynamics. Together, these results show that weak-field gravitational interactions leave distinct relativistic imprints on quantum systems, including effects unique to gravitational waves, providing potential signatures that distinguish gravity from other interactions.

•Jan 1, 2026•0 citations

Quantum to classical transition induced by gravitational time dilation

Boris Sokolov, Iiro Vilja, Sabrina Maniscalco

We study the loss of quantumness caused by time dilation [I. Pikovski, M. Zych, F. Costa, and \ifmmode \check{C}\else \v{C}\fi{}. Brukner, Nat. Phys. 11, 668 (2015)] for a Schr\"odinger cat state. We give a holistic view of the quantum to classical transition by comparing the dynamics of several nonclassicality indicators, such as the Wigner function interference fringe, the negativity of the Wigner function, the nonclassical depth, the Vogel criterion, and the Klyshko criterion. Our results show that only two of these indicators depend critically on the size of the cat, namely, on how macroscopic the superposition is. Finally we compare the gravitation-induced decoherence times to the typical decoherence times due to classical noise originating from the unavoidable statistical fluctuations in the characteristic parameters of the system [J. Trapani, M. Bina, S. Maniscalco, and M. G. A. Paris, Phys. Rev. A 91, 022113 (2015)]. We show that the experimental observation of decoherence due to time dilation imposes severe limitations on the allowed levels of classical noise in the experiments.

arXiv:1702.02433•Physical Review A•Jul 26, 2017•9 citations
A recent debate has ensued over the claim by Pikovski et al. [Nat. Phys. 11, 668 (2015)] that systems with internal degrees of freedom undergo a universal, gravity-induced, type of decoherence that explains their quantum-to-classical transition. This decoherence is supposed to arise from the different gravitational redshifts experienced by such systems when placed in a superposition of two wave packets at different heights in a gravitational field. Here we investigate some aspects of the discussion with the aid of simple examples. In particular, we first resolve an apparent conflict between the reported results and the equivalence principle by noting that the static and free-fall descriptions focus on states associated with different hypersurfaces. Next, we emphasize that predictions regarding the observability of interference become relevant only in the context of concrete experimental settings. As a result, we caution against hasty claims of universal validity. Finally, we dispute the claim that, at least in the scenarios discussed by Pikovski et al., gravitation is responsible for the reported results, and we question the alleged ability of decoherence to explain the quantum-to-classical transition. In consequence, we argue against the extraordinary assertion by Pikovski et al. that gravity can account for the emergence of classicality.
Pikovski et al. [Nat. Phys. 11, 668 (2015)] show that a composite particle prepared in a pure initial quantum state and propagated in a uniform gravitational field undergoes a decoherence process at a rate determined by the gravitational acceleration. By assuming Einstein's equivalence principle to be valid, we analyze a physical realization of the (1+1)D thought experiment of Pikovski et al. to demonstrate that the dephasing between the different internal states arises not from gravity but rather from differences in their rest mass, and the mass dependence of the de Broglie wave's dispersion relation. We provide an alternative view to the situation considered by Pikovski et al., where we propose that gravity plays a kinematic role by providing a relative velocity to the detector frame with respect to the particle; visibility can be easily recovered by giving the screen an appropriate uniform velocity. We then apply this insight to their thought experiment in (1+1)D to draw a direct correspondence, and obtain the same mathematical result for dephasing. We finally propose that dephasing due to gravity may in fact take place for certain modifications to the gravitational potential where the equivalence principle is violated.
The fact that gravitational environments cannot be shielded (since gravity is universal) makes them of great theoretical interest to decoherence mechanisms and to the quantum-to-classical transition. While past results seemed to indicate that graviton-induced decoherence of spatial superpositions happens only for macroscopic systems, recently it was shown that this mechanism can be enhanced through the system's own dynamical internal structure. In this work, we extend this analysis by including the interaction with a classical Newtonian potential. We show that, although the graviton bath alone dominates the mechanism for short times compared to a timescale established by the size of the quantum spatial superposition, the interaction between the gravitons and the internal degrees of freedom of the system renders decoherence inevitable in the long-time limit, even for microscopic masses. We also show that this mechanism is slightly slowed down by the interplay with the classical Newtonian potential, which, for systems without dynamical internal degrees of freedom, can even lead to recoherence-like behaviour, at least in principle.
In a series of comments, Bonder et al. criticized our work on decoherence due to time dilation [Nature Physics 11, 668-672 (2015)]. First the authors erroneously claimed that our results contradict the equivalence principle, only to "resolve" the alleged conflict in a second note. The resolution - relativity of simultaneity - was already explained in our reply [arXiv:1508.03296], which Bonder et al. now essentially reiterate. The newly raised points were also already extensively clarified in our note. The physical prediction of our work remains valid: systems with internal dynamics decohere if the superposed paths have different proper times.
A recent analysis by Pikovski et al. [Nat. Phys. 11, 668 (2015)] has triggered interest in the question of how to include relativistic corrections in the quantum dynamics governing many-particle systems in a gravitational field. Here we show how the center-of-mass motion of a quantum system subject to gravity can be derived more rigorously, addressing the ambiguous definition of relativistic center-of-mass coordinates. We further demonstrate that, contrary to the prediction by Pikovski et al., external forces play a crucial role in the relativistic coupling of internal and external degrees of freedom, resulting in a complete cancellation of the alleged coupling in Earth-bound laboratories for systems supported against gravity by an external force. We conclude that the proposed decoherence effect is an effect of relative acceleration between quantum system and measurement device, rather than a universal effect in gravitational fields.
This thesis investigates the role of gravitational waves in quantum systems, motivated by advances in our understanding of the quantum–gravity interface and efforts to identify experimental signatures of quantum gravity. It focuses on gravitational decoherence and the interplay between internal energy and centre-of-mass dynamics in composite quantum systems, complemented by a study of internal-energy effects in gravitationally mediated entanglement. First, we develop relativistic Hamiltonian formulations showing that changes in a composite system’s internal energy increase its gravitational mass rather than alter its momentum. This removes earlier ad hoc arguments for eliminating “anomalous friction forces”. We show that gravitational waves act as a dynamical background, inducing curvature-dependent forces that modify total momentum. Second, we revisit a thought experiment in which tensions between causality and complementarity arise. We identify a scenario in which these tensions follow from energy–mass equivalence, making the effect specific to gravitational interactions. In a gravitationally mediated entanglement experiment using Newtonian gravity as mediator, we investigate whether decohering gravitational radiation can resolve the apparent conflict. Finally, we build upon a model of gravitational decoherence consistent with general relativity. This requires deriving a higher-derivative quantum Langevin equation and master equation. The resulting dynamics show that gravitational interactions induce decoherence in the canonical momentum basis of the quadrupole and generate acceleration- and jerk-dependent corrections absent in electrodynamics. Together, these results show that weak-field gravitational interactions leave distinct relativistic imprints on quantum systems, including effects unique to gravitational waves, providing potential signatures that distinguish gravity from other interactions.
We study the loss of quantumness caused by time dilation [I. Pikovski, M. Zych, F. Costa, and \ifmmode \check{C}\else \v{C}\fi{}. Brukner, Nat. Phys. 11, 668 (2015)] for a Schr\"odinger cat state. We give a holistic view of the quantum to classical transition by comparing the dynamics of several nonclassicality indicators, such as the Wigner function interference fringe, the negativity of the Wigner function, the nonclassical depth, the Vogel criterion, and the Klyshko criterion. Our results show that only two of these indicators depend critically on the size of the cat, namely, on how macroscopic the superposition is. Finally we compare the gravitation-induced decoherence times to the typical decoherence times due to classical noise originating from the unavoidable statistical fluctuations in the characteristic parameters of the system [J. Trapani, M. Bina, S. Maniscalco, and M. G. A. Paris, Phys. Rev. A 91, 022113 (2015)]. We show that the experimental observation of decoherence due to time dilation imposes severe limitations on the allowed levels of classical noise in the experiments.