Speculation on Photon Entropy during Refraction
Francesco R. Ruggeri
Entropy is usually associated with probabilities (e.g. Shannon’s entropy= S = - Sum over i Probability(i) ln{Probability(i)} which suggests there is some uncertainty in the problem, captured by S. Entropy, however, also seems to be associated with the evolution of a system in time. Historically, entropy was introduced through the first law of thermodynamics: dE = TdS - PdV, before there was any formula involving probabilities. Furthermore, a constant entropy, which applies to an adiabatic process, means the process is reversible in time. In this note, we consider the case of a photon which is represented by a quantum wavefunction exp(-iEt+ip dot r), but is also reversible in the case of reflection/refraction, even from a moving interface. The wavefunction, we argue, is associated with probability in space-time and so there should be associated entropies (as we have argued in (1)), but at the same entropy should be constant as the motion is reversible. In (1), we considered Shannon’s entropy for t and x and used A1 |cos(Et)| and A2 |cos(px)| over half a cycle as probabilities. We introduce a third entropy associated with time, but not E in this note. Here, we focus on the case of refraction. For a stationary interface, E is conserved, but p changes. Thus there is a change in the uncertainty in x, but not in t and the process is reversible, with time S being constant.( The first law suggests that S=constant, which is keeping with time entropy, but not with spatial (x) entropy.) We suggest that there may be multiple types of entropy associated with different observables. We next consider the case of reflection/refraction from a moving mirror/interface. In such a case, neither E nor p is conserved for the photon. Both time and spatial (x) entropy change, but the process is reversible and entropy should be constant. We suggest there exists an entropy which is constant, but is based on: -Et+ p dot r = t |p| (-E/|p| + unit vector dot r/t) where r/t vector is minus the velocity of the moving interface and the unit vector points in the direction of momentum p. We consider an associated entropy and the first law of thermodynamics.
•Sep 29, 2023•0 citations