Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1507.07828 · Journal of Computational Electronics

Comparing Wigner, Husimi and Bohmian distributions: which one is a true probability distribution in phase space?

Enrique Colomés, Zhen Zhan, Xavier Oriols

Published Aug 8, 2015• 30 citations
arXivHTMLPDF
DOI
10.1007/s10825-015-0737-6

Related papers

Bohmian trajectories and quantum phase space distributions

Nuno Costa Dias, João Nuno Prata

arXiv:quant-ph/0208156•Physics Letters A•Sep 1, 2002•26 citations

Weyl quantization and Wigner distributions on phase space

R. Wezeman

This thesis describes quantum mechanics in the phase space formulation. We introduce quantization and in particular the Weyl quantization. We study a general class of phase space distribution functions on phase space. The Wigner distribution function is one such distribution function. The Wigner distribution function in general attains negative values and thus can not be interpreted as a real probability density, as opposed to for example the Husimi distribution function. The Husimi distribution however does not yield the correct marginal distribution functions known from quantum mechanics. Properties of the Wigner and Husimi distribution function are studied to more extent. We calculate the Wigner and Husimi distribution function for the energy eigenstates of a particle trapped in a box. We then look at the semi classical limit for this example. The time evolution of Wigner functions are studied by making use of the Moyal bracket. The Moyal bracket and the Poisson bracket are compared in the classical limit. The phase space formulation of quantum mechanics has as advantage that classical concepts can be studied and compared to quantum mechanics. For certain quantum mechanical systems the time evolution of Wigner distribution functions becomes equivalent to the classical time evolution stated in the exact Egerov theorem. Another advantage of using Wigner functions is when one is interested in systems involving mixed states. A disadvantage of the phase space formulation is that for most problems it quickly loses its simplicity and becomes hard to calculate.

•Jan 1, 2014•2 citations

On the probability density interpretation of smoothed Wigner functions

Marcus A. M. de Aguiar, Alfredo M. Ozorio de Almeida

It has been conjectured that averages of the Wigner function over phase space volumes, larger than those of minimum uncertainty, are always positive. This is true for Gaussian averaging, so that the Husimi distribution is positive. However, the authors provide a specific counterexample for the averaging with a discontinuous hat function. The analysis of the specific system of a one-dimensional particle in a box also elucidates the respective advantages of the Wigner and the Husimi functions for the study of the semiclassical limit. The falsification of the averaging conjecture is shown not to depend on the discontinuities of the hat function, by considering the latter as the limit of a sequence of analytic functions.

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Oct 7, 1990•10 citations

Probability density distributions in phase space

F. J. Arranz, F. Borondo, R. M. Benito

Journal of Molecular Structure THEOCHEM•Mar 1, 1998•6 citations

Bohmian Total Potential View to Quantum Effects III. Tunnelling in Phase Space

María F. González, Josep María Bofill, Xavier Giménez

The tunnel effect in one-dimensional collision problems is analyzed in terms of numerical wavepacket time propagations, in position, momentum, and phase space representations of the problem. Bohm's total potential is used to provide a classical-like description of tunnelling quantum dynamics, under a time- and density-dependent potential. Wigner, Husimi, as well as Bohm phase space distributions are used in the present study, with their relative performances for the present problem having been analyzed.

The Journal of Physical Chemistry A•Oct 20, 2009•1 citation

Bohmian and quantum phase space distribution expansions and approximations

Leon W. Cohen, Patrick J. Loughlin

Physics Letters A•Feb 1, 2014•3 citations
This thesis describes quantum mechanics in the phase space formulation. We introduce quantization and in particular the Weyl quantization. We study a general class of phase space distribution functions on phase space. The Wigner distribution function is one such distribution function. The Wigner distribution function in general attains negative values and thus can not be interpreted as a real probability density, as opposed to for example the Husimi distribution function. The Husimi distribution however does not yield the correct marginal distribution functions known from quantum mechanics. Properties of the Wigner and Husimi distribution function are studied to more extent. We calculate the Wigner and Husimi distribution function for the energy eigenstates of a particle trapped in a box. We then look at the semi classical limit for this example. The time evolution of Wigner functions are studied by making use of the Moyal bracket. The Moyal bracket and the Poisson bracket are compared in the classical limit. The phase space formulation of quantum mechanics has as advantage that classical concepts can be studied and compared to quantum mechanics. For certain quantum mechanical systems the time evolution of Wigner distribution functions becomes equivalent to the classical time evolution stated in the exact Egerov theorem. Another advantage of using Wigner functions is when one is interested in systems involving mixed states. A disadvantage of the phase space formulation is that for most problems it quickly loses its simplicity and becomes hard to calculate.
It has been conjectured that averages of the Wigner function over phase space volumes, larger than those of minimum uncertainty, are always positive. This is true for Gaussian averaging, so that the Husimi distribution is positive. However, the authors provide a specific counterexample for the averaging with a discontinuous hat function. The analysis of the specific system of a one-dimensional particle in a box also elucidates the respective advantages of the Wigner and the Husimi functions for the study of the semiclassical limit. The falsification of the averaging conjecture is shown not to depend on the discontinuities of the hat function, by considering the latter as the limit of a sequence of analytic functions.
The tunnel effect in one-dimensional collision problems is analyzed in terms of numerical wavepacket time propagations, in position, momentum, and phase space representations of the problem. Bohm's total potential is used to provide a classical-like description of tunnelling quantum dynamics, under a time- and density-dependent potential. Wigner, Husimi, as well as Bohm phase space distributions are used in the present study, with their relative performances for the present problem having been analyzed.