Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1507.06789

A mechanical model of a PR-Box

Thomas Filk A

Published Jul 24, 2015• 5 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Several mechanical realizations of PR-Boxes are discussed. Apart from superluminal correlations, which are known not to be realizable by classical devices, the requirements (1) PR-condition on input-output relations, (2) non-signaling, and (3) allowing for independent measurements are discussed separately. The examples show that internal signaling (inside the box) does not invariably imply the possibility of external signaling and may externally be attributed to contextuality. The proposed model requires two classical bits to be exchanged internally in order to realize the defined requirements. However, with EPR correlations this can be reduced to one classical bit.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.1507.06789

Related papers

CTC assisted PR box type correlation can lead to signaling

Indranil Chakrabarty, Tanumoy Pramanik, Arun Kumar Pati +1 more

It is known that there exist non-local correlations that respect no-signaling criterion, but violate Bell-type inequalities more than quantum-mechanical correlations. Such super quantum correlations were introduced as the Popescu-Rohrlich (PR) box. We consider such non-local boxes with two/three inputs and two/three outputs. We show that these super quantum correlations can lead to signaling when at least one of the input bit has access to a word line along a closed time-like curve.

arXiv:1107.2908•Quantum Information and Computation•Oct 1, 2014•5 citations

Classical-to-quantum non-signalling boxes

Carolina Moreira Ferrera, Robin Simmons, James Purcell +2 more

Here we introduce the concept of classical input – quantum output (C-Q) non-signalling boxes, a generalisation of the classical input – classical output (C-C) non-signalling boxes. We argue that studying such objects leads to a better understanding of the relation between quantum nonlocality and non-locality beyond quantum mechanics. The main issue discussed in the paper is whether there exist 'genuine' C-Q boxes or all C-Q boxes can be built from objects already known, namely C-C boxes acting on pre-shared entangled quantum particles. We show that large classes of C-Q boxes are non-genuine. In particular, we show that all bi-partite C-Q boxes with outputs that are pure states are non-genuine. We also present various strategies for addressing the general problem, i.e. for multi-partite C-Q boxes which output mixed states, whose answer is still open. Finally, we show that even some very simple non-genuine C-Q boxes require large amounts of C-C nonlocal correlations in order to simulate them.

arXiv:2303.17268•Quantum•Aug 22, 2024•0 citations

A realistic device that simulates the non-local PR box without communication

Sven Aerts

A black box with two input bits and two output bits is called a non-local PR box, if the XOR of the output bits equals the AND of the input bits. In a recent article, Cerf et al. show that Alice and Bob, using such a PR box, can effectively simulate entanglement without the need of communication. We show that an adaptation of a model due to Dirk Aerts, yields a realistic simulation of the non-local PR box without communication. Because the model is entirely realistic, it cannot violate relativistic constraints. Like a non-local box, it can be used to simulate the singlet state coincidence probabilities, but the time to complete the observation of the outcome will exceed the time it takes a photon to travel one arm in an EPRB setup. The model explicitly shows how to produce an outcome that is locally perfectly random, but nevertheless determines what happens in the other wing of the experiment, without communication taking place between the two wings. In this sense, it can serve as an accurate metaphor for the mechanism of entanglement. The model considerably strengthens the claim that no communication is necessary to simulate entanglement.

arXiv:quant-ph/0504171•Apr 22, 2005•13 citations

Non-Classical Correlations in n-Cycle Setting

Kishor Bharti, Maharshi Ray, L. C. Kwek

Quantum communication and quantum computation form the two crucial facets of quantum information theory. While entanglement and its manifestation as Bell non-locality have been proved to be vital for communication tasks, contextuality (a generalisation of Bell non-locality) has shown to be the crucial resource behind various models of quantum computation. The practical and fundamental aspects of these non-classical resources are still poorly understood despite decades of research. We explore non-classical correlations exhibited by some of these quantum as well as super-quantum resources in the n-cycle setting. In particular, we focus on correlations manifested by Kochen–Specker–Klyachko box (KS box), scenarios involving n-cycle non-contextuality inequalities and Popescu–Rohlrich boxes (PR box). We provide the criteria for optimal classical simulation of a KS box of arbitrary n dimension. The non-contextuality inequalities are analysed for n-cycle setting, and the condition for the quantum violation for odd as well as even n-cycle is discussed. We offer a simple extension of even cycle non-contextuality inequalities to the phase space case. Furthermore, we simulate a generalised PR box using KS box and provide some interesting insights. Towards the end, we discuss a few possible interesting open problems for future research. Our work connects generalised PR boxes, arbitrary dimensional KS boxes, and n-cycle non-contextuality inequalities and thus provides the pathway for the study of these contextual and nonlocal resources at their junction.

arXiv:1812.04882•Entropy•Feb 1, 2019•4 citations

No Quantum Realization of Extremal No-Signaling Boxes

Ravishankar Ramanathan, Jan Tuziemski, Michał Horodecki +1 more

The study of quantum correlations is important for fundamental reasons as well as for quantum communication and information processing tasks. On the one hand, it is of tremendous interest to derive the correlations produced by measurements on separated composite quantum systems from within the set of all correlations obeying the no-signaling principle of relativity, by means of information-theoretic principles. On the other hand, an important ongoing research program concerns the formulation of device-independent cryptographic protocols based on quantum nonlocal correlations for the generation of secure keys, and the amplification and expansion of random bits against general no-signaling adversaries. In both these research programs, a fundamental question arises: Can any measurements on quantum states realize the correlations present in pure extremal no-signaling boxes? Here, we answer this question in full generality showing that no nontrivial (not local realistic) extremal boxes of general no-signaling theories can be realized in quantum theory. We then explore some important consequences of this fact.

arXiv:1410.0947•Physical Review Letters•Jul 25, 2016•25 citations

Information processing in non-signalling theories

Jonathan Barrett

We introduce a framework in which a variety of theories can be defined that share two features with quantum mechanics: the no-signalling principle for states, and the fact that the global state of a multi-partite system can be completely specified by correlations between local measurements on the individual subsystems. The aim is to investigate the relationships between the physical properties of these theories and the information processing possibilities that each one offers. One of these theories, which we call Generalised Non-Signalling Mechanics, includes states that can give rise to arbitrary non-signalling correlations, including the super-quantum correlations that have become known in the literature as non-local machines or PR boxes. By investigating these correlations in the context of a theory with well-defined dynamics, we hope to make further progress with a question raised by Popescu and Rohrlich: why does quantum mechanics not allow these strongly non-local correlations? We show that the existence of strongly non-local correlations forces much of the dynamics in this theory to be, in a certain sense, trivial, with consequences for teleportation, cryptography and computation. We also investigate another theory, which we call Generalised Local Mechanics, since all states in this theory are local. This has its own consequences for cryptography and computation. Finally, we raise the question of what further axiom(s) could be added to our framework in order uniquely to identify quantum mechanics.

•Aug 28, 2005•3 citations
Several mechanical realizations of PR-Boxes are discussed. Apart from superluminal correlations, which are known not to be realizable by classical devices, the requirements (1) PR-condition on input-output relations, (2) non-signaling, and (3) allowing for independent measurements are discussed separately. The examples show that internal signaling (inside the box) does not invariably imply the possibility of external signaling and may externally be attributed to contextuality. The proposed model requires two classical bits to be exchanged internally in order to realize the defined requirements. However, with EPR correlations this can be reduced to one classical bit.
Here we introduce the concept of classical input – quantum output (C-Q) non-signalling boxes, a generalisation of the classical input – classical output (C-C) non-signalling boxes. We argue that studying such objects leads to a better understanding of the relation between quantum nonlocality and non-locality beyond quantum mechanics. The main issue discussed in the paper is whether there exist 'genuine' C-Q boxes or all C-Q boxes can be built from objects already known, namely C-C boxes acting on pre-shared entangled quantum particles. We show that large classes of C-Q boxes are non-genuine. In particular, we show that all bi-partite C-Q boxes with outputs that are pure states are non-genuine. We also present various strategies for addressing the general problem, i.e. for multi-partite C-Q boxes which output mixed states, whose answer is still open. Finally, we show that even some very simple non-genuine C-Q boxes require large amounts of C-C nonlocal correlations in order to simulate them.
A black box with two input bits and two output bits is called a non-local PR box, if the XOR of the output bits equals the AND of the input bits. In a recent article, Cerf et al. show that Alice and Bob, using such a PR box, can effectively simulate entanglement without the need of communication. We show that an adaptation of a model due to Dirk Aerts, yields a realistic simulation of the non-local PR box without communication. Because the model is entirely realistic, it cannot violate relativistic constraints. Like a non-local box, it can be used to simulate the singlet state coincidence probabilities, but the time to complete the observation of the outcome will exceed the time it takes a photon to travel one arm in an EPRB setup. The model explicitly shows how to produce an outcome that is locally perfectly random, but nevertheless determines what happens in the other wing of the experiment, without communication taking place between the two wings. In this sense, it can serve as an accurate metaphor for the mechanism of entanglement. The model considerably strengthens the claim that no communication is necessary to simulate entanglement.
Quantum communication and quantum computation form the two crucial facets of quantum information theory. While entanglement and its manifestation as Bell non-locality have been proved to be vital for communication tasks, contextuality (a generalisation of Bell non-locality) has shown to be the crucial resource behind various models of quantum computation. The practical and fundamental aspects of these non-classical resources are still poorly understood despite decades of research. We explore non-classical correlations exhibited by some of these quantum as well as super-quantum resources in the n-cycle setting. In particular, we focus on correlations manifested by Kochen–Specker–Klyachko box (KS box), scenarios involving n-cycle non-contextuality inequalities and Popescu–Rohlrich boxes (PR box). We provide the criteria for optimal classical simulation of a KS box of arbitrary n dimension. The non-contextuality inequalities are analysed for n-cycle setting, and the condition for the quantum violation for odd as well as even n-cycle is discussed. We offer a simple extension of even cycle non-contextuality inequalities to the phase space case. Furthermore, we simulate a generalised PR box using KS box and provide some interesting insights. Towards the end, we discuss a few possible interesting open problems for future research. Our work connects generalised PR boxes, arbitrary dimensional KS boxes, and n-cycle non-contextuality inequalities and thus provides the pathway for the study of these contextual and nonlocal resources at their junction.
The study of quantum correlations is important for fundamental reasons as well as for quantum communication and information processing tasks. On the one hand, it is of tremendous interest to derive the correlations produced by measurements on separated composite quantum systems from within the set of all correlations obeying the no-signaling principle of relativity, by means of information-theoretic principles. On the other hand, an important ongoing research program concerns the formulation of device-independent cryptographic protocols based on quantum nonlocal correlations for the generation of secure keys, and the amplification and expansion of random bits against general no-signaling adversaries. In both these research programs, a fundamental question arises: Can any measurements on quantum states realize the correlations present in pure extremal no-signaling boxes? Here, we answer this question in full generality showing that no nontrivial (not local realistic) extremal boxes of general no-signaling theories can be realized in quantum theory. We then explore some important consequences of this fact.
We introduce a framework in which a variety of theories can be defined that share two features with quantum mechanics: the no-signalling principle for states, and the fact that the global state of a multi-partite system can be completely specified by correlations between local measurements on the individual subsystems. The aim is to investigate the relationships between the physical properties of these theories and the information processing possibilities that each one offers. One of these theories, which we call Generalised Non-Signalling Mechanics, includes states that can give rise to arbitrary non-signalling correlations, including the super-quantum correlations that have become known in the literature as non-local machines or PR boxes. By investigating these correlations in the context of a theory with well-defined dynamics, we hope to make further progress with a question raised by Popescu and Rohrlich: why does quantum mechanics not allow these strongly non-local correlations? We show that the existence of strongly non-local correlations forces much of the dynamics in this theory to be, in a certain sense, trivial, with consequences for teleportation, cryptography and computation. We also investigate another theory, which we call Generalised Local Mechanics, since all states in this theory are local. This has its own consequences for cryptography and computation. Finally, we raise the question of what further axiom(s) could be added to our framework in order uniquely to identify quantum mechanics.