Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1507.05828 · Journal of Physics Conference Series

Centre of mass decoherence due to time dilation: paradoxical frame-dependence

Lajos Diósi

Published Aug 1, 2017• 18 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The recently proposed centre-of-mass decoherence of composite objects due to gravitational time-dilation [Pikovski et al , Nat.Phys. 11, 668 (2015)] is confronted with the principle of equivalence between gravity and observer's acceleration. In the laboratory frame, a positional superposition | x 1 〉 + | x 2 〉 can quickly decohere whereas in the free-falling frame, as I argue, the superposition can survive for almost arbitrary long times. The paradoxical result is explained by the so far unappreciated feature of the proposed model: the centre-of-mass canonical subsystem is ambiguous, it is di˙erent in the laboratory and the free-falling frames, respectively. As long as the centre-of-mass motion of the composite object is non-relativistic, a simple Galilean-covariant Hamiltonian represents the Pikovski et al theory with exactly the same physical predictions. We emphasize the power of this Hamiltonian to understand essential features of the Pikovski et al theory and to moderate a few divergent statements in recent works.

DOI
10.1088/1742-6596/880/1/012020

Related papers

Quantum mechanics for non-inertial observers

Marko Toroš, André Großardt, Angelo Bassi

A recent analysis by Pikovski et al. [Nat. Phys. 11, 668 (2015)] has triggered interest in the question of how to include relativistic corrections in the quantum dynamics governing many-particle systems in a gravitational field. Here we show how the center-of-mass motion of a quantum system subject to gravity can be derived more rigorously, addressing the ambiguous definition of relativistic center-of-mass coordinates. We further demonstrate that, contrary to the prediction by Pikovski et al., external forces play a crucial role in the relativistic coupling of internal and external degrees of freedom, resulting in a complete cancellation of the alleged coupling in Earth-bound laboratories for systems supported against gravity by an external force. We conclude that the proposed decoherence effect is an effect of relative acceleration between quantum system and measurement device, rather than a universal effect in gravitational fields.

arXiv:1701.04298•Jan 16, 2017•5 citations

Material-Dependent Gravitational Decoherence: Thermodynamic Evaluation of the Pikovski Time-Dilation Mechanism

Nikolaj Weber

Pikovski et al. showed that gravitational time dilation couples the internal energy of a composite quantum system to its center-of-mass position, producing dephasing without modifying quantum mechanics. The resulting decoherence rate depends on the energy variance of internal degrees of freedom and yields a Gaussian temporal profile. Building on the thermodynamic identity Var(H)=k_B T^2 C_V, we evaluate this effect for macroscopic objects modeled as Debye solids in Earth's gravitational field. We demonstrate that the decoherence rate scales as a universal T^{5/2} power law at cryogenic temperatures, providing a unique phenomenological signature distinguishing it from spontaneous collapse models (e.g., CSL) which predict temperature-independent rates. Furthermore, we expand the Pikovski mechanism to structurally disordered materials (fractons) and analytically show that the scaling modifies to T^{(d_s/2)+1}, acting as highly sensitive gravitational noise receptors.

•Mar 9, 2026•0 citations

Universal Decoherence under Gravity: A Perspective through the Equivalence Principle

Belinda Pang, Yanbei Chen, Farid Ya Khalili

Pikovski et al. [Nat. Phys. 11, 668 (2015)] show that a composite particle prepared in a pure initial quantum state and propagated in a uniform gravitational field undergoes a decoherence process at a rate determined by the gravitational acceleration. By assuming Einstein's equivalence principle to be valid, we analyze a physical realization of the (1+1)D thought experiment of Pikovski et al. to demonstrate that the dephasing between the different internal states arises not from gravity but rather from differences in their rest mass, and the mass dependence of the de Broglie wave's dispersion relation. We provide an alternative view to the situation considered by Pikovski et al., where we propose that gravity plays a kinematic role by providing a relative velocity to the detector frame with respect to the particle; visibility can be easily recovered by giving the screen an appropriate uniform velocity. We then apply this insight to their thought experiment in (1+1)D to draw a direct correspondence, and obtain the same mathematical result for dephasing. We finally propose that dephasing due to gravity may in fact take place for certain modifications to the gravitational potential where the equivalence principle is violated.

arXiv:1603.01984•Physical Review Letters•Aug 24, 2016•37 citations

Material-Dependent Gravitational Decoherence: Thermodynamic Evaluation of the Pikovski Time-Dilation Mechanism

Nikolaj Weber

We evaluate the macroscopic entanglement-loss implications of gravitational time dilation, first identified by Pikovski et al. (2015). By moving beyond the idealized zero-temperature single-mode approximation to a continuous Debye model in the canonical ensemble, we derive the explicit phononic heat-capacity limits for spontaneous gravitational decoherence. We find that the decoherence rate driven by internal time-dilation variance strongly scales with $\sigma \propto T^{5/2}$ at ultra-low experimental temperatures ($T \ll \Theta_D$), vanishing strictly at absolute zero. Furthermore, we demonstrate mathematically that translational invariance renders proper-time differences between spatially distinct branches of an identical matter distribution identically zero. Thus, contrary to the Diósi-Penrose approach, an isolated mass in a pure superposition cannot undergo solely self-gravitational state-collapse. Decoherence requires either an external gravitational potential gradient or internal structural asymmetry. Lastly, we prove that the topological spectral dimension $d_s$ of the macroscopic test mass determines the decoherence rate scaling, creating a new class of ultra-sensitive 'fracton-gravity sensors'.

•Mar 9, 2026•0 citations

Gravitational time dilation induced decoherence in spontaneous emission

Dong Xie, Chunling Xu, An Min Wang

We investigate decoherence of quantum superpositions induced by gravitational time dilation and spontaneous emission between two atomic levels. It has been shown that gravitational time dilation can be a universal decoherence source by Pikovski et al. Here, we consider the decoherence induced by the gravitational time dilation only in the situation of spontaneous emission. We obtain the analytical results of the coherence of particle’s position state. Then, we obtain that the coherence of particle’s position state depends on reference frame because the time dilation changes the distinguishability of emitted photons from two positions of particle in different reference frames. For observing the decoherence effect induced by the gravitational time dilation, time-delayed feedback can be utilized to increase the decoherence of particle’s superposition state.

arXiv:1511.00001•Modern Physics Letters B•Jun 20, 2017•0 citations

Equivalence principle for quantum systems: dephasing and phase shift of free-falling particles

Charis Anastopoulos, B. L. Hu

Abstract We ask the question of how the (weak) equivalence principle established in classical gravitational physics should be reformulated and interpreted for massive quantum objects that may also have internal degrees of freedom (dof). This inquiry is necessary because even elementary concepts like a classical trajectory are not well defined in quantum physics—trajectories originating from quantum histories become viable entities only under stringent decoherence conditions. From this investigation we posit two logically and operationally distinct statements of the equivalence principle for quantum systems. Version A: the probability distribution of position for a free-falling particle is the same as the probability distribution of a free particle, modulo a mass-independent shift of its mean. Version B: any two particles with the same velocity wave-function behave identically in free fall, irrespective of their masses. Both statements apply to all quantum states, including those without a classical correspondence, and also for composite particles with quantum internal dof. We also investigate the consequences of the interaction between internal and external dof induced by free fall. For a class of initial states, we find dephasing occurs for the translational dof, namely, the suppression of the off-diagonal terms of the density matrix, in the position basis. We also find a gravitational phase shift in the reduced density matrix of the internal dof that does not depend on the particle’s mass. For classical states, the phase shift has a natural classical interpretation in terms of gravitational red-shift and special relativistic time-dilation.

arXiv:1707.04526•Classical and Quantum Gravity•Jan 8, 2018•52 citations
The recently proposed centre-of-mass decoherence of composite objects due to gravitational time-dilation [Pikovski et al , Nat.Phys. 11, 668 (2015)] is confronted with the principle of equivalence between gravity and observer's acceleration. In the laboratory frame, a positional superposition | x 1 〉 + | x 2 〉 can quickly decohere whereas in the free-falling frame, as I argue, the superposition can survive for almost arbitrary long times. The paradoxical result is explained by the so far unappreciated feature of the proposed model: the centre-of-mass canonical subsystem is ambiguous, it is di˙erent in the laboratory and the free-falling frames, respectively. As long as the centre-of-mass motion of the composite object is non-relativistic, a simple Galilean-covariant Hamiltonian represents the Pikovski et al theory with exactly the same physical predictions. We emphasize the power of this Hamiltonian to understand essential features of the Pikovski et al theory and to moderate a few divergent statements in recent works.
A recent analysis by Pikovski et al. [Nat. Phys. 11, 668 (2015)] has triggered interest in the question of how to include relativistic corrections in the quantum dynamics governing many-particle systems in a gravitational field. Here we show how the center-of-mass motion of a quantum system subject to gravity can be derived more rigorously, addressing the ambiguous definition of relativistic center-of-mass coordinates. We further demonstrate that, contrary to the prediction by Pikovski et al., external forces play a crucial role in the relativistic coupling of internal and external degrees of freedom, resulting in a complete cancellation of the alleged coupling in Earth-bound laboratories for systems supported against gravity by an external force. We conclude that the proposed decoherence effect is an effect of relative acceleration between quantum system and measurement device, rather than a universal effect in gravitational fields.
Pikovski et al. showed that gravitational time dilation couples the internal energy of a composite quantum system to its center-of-mass position, producing dephasing without modifying quantum mechanics. The resulting decoherence rate depends on the energy variance of internal degrees of freedom and yields a Gaussian temporal profile. Building on the thermodynamic identity Var(H)=k_B T^2 C_V, we evaluate this effect for macroscopic objects modeled as Debye solids in Earth's gravitational field. We demonstrate that the decoherence rate scales as a universal T^{5/2} power law at cryogenic temperatures, providing a unique phenomenological signature distinguishing it from spontaneous collapse models (e.g., CSL) which predict temperature-independent rates. Furthermore, we expand the Pikovski mechanism to structurally disordered materials (fractons) and analytically show that the scaling modifies to T^{(d_s/2)+1}, acting as highly sensitive gravitational noise receptors.
Pikovski et al. [Nat. Phys. 11, 668 (2015)] show that a composite particle prepared in a pure initial quantum state and propagated in a uniform gravitational field undergoes a decoherence process at a rate determined by the gravitational acceleration. By assuming Einstein's equivalence principle to be valid, we analyze a physical realization of the (1+1)D thought experiment of Pikovski et al. to demonstrate that the dephasing between the different internal states arises not from gravity but rather from differences in their rest mass, and the mass dependence of the de Broglie wave's dispersion relation. We provide an alternative view to the situation considered by Pikovski et al., where we propose that gravity plays a kinematic role by providing a relative velocity to the detector frame with respect to the particle; visibility can be easily recovered by giving the screen an appropriate uniform velocity. We then apply this insight to their thought experiment in (1+1)D to draw a direct correspondence, and obtain the same mathematical result for dephasing. We finally propose that dephasing due to gravity may in fact take place for certain modifications to the gravitational potential where the equivalence principle is violated.
We evaluate the macroscopic entanglement-loss implications of gravitational time dilation, first identified by Pikovski et al. (2015). By moving beyond the idealized zero-temperature single-mode approximation to a continuous Debye model in the canonical ensemble, we derive the explicit phononic heat-capacity limits for spontaneous gravitational decoherence. We find that the decoherence rate driven by internal time-dilation variance strongly scales with σ∝T5/2\sigma \propto T^{5/2}σ∝T5/2 at ultra-low experimental temperatures (T≪ΘDT \ll \Theta_DT≪ΘD​), vanishing strictly at absolute zero. Furthermore, we demonstrate mathematically that translational invariance renders proper-time differences between spatially distinct branches of an identical matter distribution identically zero. Thus, contrary to the Diósi-Penrose approach, an isolated mass in a pure superposition cannot undergo solely self-gravitational state-collapse. Decoherence requires either an external gravitational potential gradient or internal structural asymmetry. Lastly, we prove that the topological spectral dimension dsd_sds​ of the macroscopic test mass determines the decoherence rate scaling, creating a new class of ultra-sensitive 'fracton-gravity sensors'.
We investigate decoherence of quantum superpositions induced by gravitational time dilation and spontaneous emission between two atomic levels. It has been shown that gravitational time dilation can be a universal decoherence source by Pikovski et al. Here, we consider the decoherence induced by the gravitational time dilation only in the situation of spontaneous emission. We obtain the analytical results of the coherence of particle’s position state. Then, we obtain that the coherence of particle’s position state depends on reference frame because the time dilation changes the distinguishability of emitted photons from two positions of particle in different reference frames. For observing the decoherence effect induced by the gravitational time dilation, time-delayed feedback can be utilized to increase the decoherence of particle’s superposition state.
Abstract We ask the question of how the (weak) equivalence principle established in classical gravitational physics should be reformulated and interpreted for massive quantum objects that may also have internal degrees of freedom (dof). This inquiry is necessary because even elementary concepts like a classical trajectory are not well defined in quantum physics—trajectories originating from quantum histories become viable entities only under stringent decoherence conditions. From this investigation we posit two logically and operationally distinct statements of the equivalence principle for quantum systems. Version A: the probability distribution of position for a free-falling particle is the same as the probability distribution of a free particle, modulo a mass-independent shift of its mean. Version B: any two particles with the same velocity wave-function behave identically in free fall, irrespective of their masses. Both statements apply to all quantum states, including those without a classical correspondence, and also for composite particles with quantum internal dof. We also investigate the consequences of the interaction between internal and external dof induced by free fall. For a class of initial states, we find dephasing occurs for the translational dof, namely, the suppression of the off-diagonal terms of the density matrix, in the position basis. We also find a gravitational phase shift in the reduced density matrix of the internal dof that does not depend on the particle’s mass. For classical states, the phase shift has a natural classical interpretation in terms of gravitational red-shift and special relativistic time-dilation.