arXiv:1507.04737 · Physical Review A

Optimal measurements for symmetric quantum states with applications to optical communication

Hari Krovi, Saikat Guha, Zachary Dutton, Marcus Palmer Da Silva

Published Dec 21, 2015• 26 citations

Abstract

The minimum probability of error (MPE) measurement discriminates between a set of candidate quantum states with the minimum average error probability allowed by quantum mechanics. Conditions for a measurement to be MPE were derived by Yuen, Kennedy, and Lax [H. P. Yuen et al., IEEE Trans. Info. Theory IT-21, 125134 (1975)]. MPE measurements have been found for states that form a single orbit under a group action, i.e., there is a transitive group action on the states in the set. For such state sets, termed geometrically uniform (GU) previously, it was shown that the ``pretty good measurement'' attains the MPE. Even so, evaluating the actual probability of error (and other performance metrics) attained by the pretty good measurement on a GU set involves inverting large matrices and is not easy in general. Our first contribution is a formula for the MPE and conditional probabilities of GU sets, using group representation theory. Next, we consider sets of pure states that have multiple orbits under the group action. Such states are termed compound geometrically uniform (CGU). MPE measurements for general CGU sets are not known. In this paper, we show how our representation-theoretic description of optimal measurements for GU sets naturally generalizes to the CGU case. We show how to compute the MPE measurement for CGU sets by reducing the problem to solving a few simultaneous equations. The number of equations depends on the sizes of the multiplicity space of irreducible representations. For many common group representations (such as those of several practical good linear codes), this is much more tractable than solving large semidefinite programs---which is what is needed to solve the Yuen-Kennedy-Lax conditions numerically for arbitrary state sets. We show how to evaluate MPE measurements for CGU states in some examples relevant to quantum-limited classical optical communication.

DOI: 10.1103/physreva.92.062333

Related papers

Optimal measurements for symmetric quantum states with applications to optical quantum communication

Hari Krovi, Saikat Guha, Zachary Dutton +1 more

Minimum probability of error (MPE) measurements are quantum mechanical measurements that discriminate between a set of candidate states and achieve the minimum error allowed by quantum mechanics. Conditions for a measurement to be an MPE measurement have been derived by Yuen, Kennedy and Lax. But finding explicit measurements that satisfy these conditions is a hard problem in general and even in cases where an explicit measurement is known, calculating the MPE of the measurement is not easy. In some cases, MPE measurements have been found such as when the states form a single orbit under a group action i.e., there is a transitive group action on the states. For such state sets, termed Geometrically Uniform (GU) in [1], it was shown that the `pretty good measurement' (PGM) is optimal. However, calculating the MPE and other performance metrics for the PGM involves inverting large matrices, and it is therefore not easy in general to evaluate. Our first contribution is a formula for the MPE and conditional probabilities of GU sets using group representation theory. Next, we consider sets of pure states that have multiple orbits under the group action. Such states are termed compound geometrically uniform (CGU). CGU sets appear in many practical problems in quantum communication and imaging. For example, they include all linear codes formed using pure-state modulation constellations, which are known to achieve the ultimate (Holevo) capacity of optical communication. Optimal (MPE) measurement for general CGU sets are not known. In this paper, we show how our representation-theoretic description of optimal measurements for GU sets naturally generalizes to the CGU case. We show how to compute the optimal measurement for CGU sets by reducing the problem to solving a few simultaneous equations. The number of equations depends on the sizes of the multiplicity space of irreducible representations. For many group representations (such as those of several practical good linear codes), this is much more tractable than solving large semi-definite programs-which is what is needed to solve for MPE measurements for an arbitrary set of pure states using the Yuen-Kennedy-Lax conditions [2]. We show examples of the evaluation of optimal measurements for CGU states.

IEEE International Symposium on Information Theory (ISIT)Jun 1, 20141 citation

A Semidefinite Programming Approach to Optimal Unambiguous Discrimination of Quantum States

Yonina C. Eldar

Abstract—In this paper, we consider the problem of unambiguous discrimination between a set of linearly independent pure quantum states. We show that the design of the optimal measurement that minimizes the probability of an inconclusive result can be formulated as a semidefinite programming problem. Based on this formulation, we develop a set of necessary and sufficient conditions for an optimal quantum measurement. We show that the optimal measurement can be computed very efficiently in polynomial time by exploiting the many well-known algorithms for solving semidefinite programs, which are guaranteed to converge to the global optimum. Using the general conditions for optimality, we derive necessary and sufficient conditions so that the measurement that results in an equal probability of an inconclusive result for each one of the quantum states is optimal. We refer to this measurement as the equal-probability measurement (EPM). We then show that for any state set, the prior probabilities of the states can be chosen such that the EPM is optimal. Finally, we consider state sets with strong symmetry properties and equal prior probabilities for which the EPM is optimal. We first consider geometrically uniform (GU) state sets that are defined over a group of unitary matrices and are generated by a single generating vector. We then consider compound GU state sets which are generated by a group of unitary matrices using multiple generating vectors, where the generating vectors satisfy a certain (weighted) norm constraint. Index Terms—Compound geometrically uniform (CGU) quantum states, equal-probability measurement (EPM), geometrically uniform (GU) quantum states, quantum detection, semidefinite programming, unambiguous discrimination. I.

Jun 14, 200283 citations

On the distinguishability of geometrically uniform quantum states

Juntai Zhou, Stefano Chessa, Eric Chitambar +1 more

Abstract A geometrically uniform (GU) ensemble is a uniformly weighted quantum state ensemble generated from a fixed state by a unitary representation of a finite group G. In this work we analyze the problem of discriminating GU ensembles from various angles. Assuming that the representation of G is irreducible, we first show that a particular optimal measurement can be understood as the limit of weighted ‘pretty good measurements’ (PGMs). This naturally provides examples of state discrimination for which the unweighted PGM is provably sub-optimal. We extend this analysis to certain reducible representations, and use Schur–Weyl duality to discuss two particular examples of GU ensembles in terms of Werner-type and permutation-invariant generator states. For the case of pure-state GU ensembles we give a streamlined proof of optimality of the PGM first proved in Eldar et al (2004 IEEE Trans. Inf. Theory 50 1198–207). We use this result to give simplified proofs of the optimality of the PGM, along with expressions for the corresponding success probabilities, for two tasks: the hidden subgroup problem (HSP) over semidirect product groups (first proved in Bacon et al (2005 46th Annual IEEE Symp. Foundations of Computer Science (FOCS’05) pp 469–78), and port-based teleportation (first proved in Mozrzymas et al (2019 New J. Phys. 20 053006) and Leditzky (2022 Lett. Math. Phys. 112 98). Finally, we consider the n-copy setting and adapt a result of Montanaro (2007 Commun. Math. Phys. 273 619–36) to derive a compact and easily evaluated lower bound on the success probability of the PGM for this task. This result can be applied to the HSP to obtain a new proof for an upper bound on the sample complexity by Hayashi et al (2006 Quantum Inf. Comput. 8 345–58).

arXiv:2501.12376Journal of Physics A Mathematical and TheoreticalSep 23, 20250 citations

Optimal Detection of Symmetric Mixed Quantum States

Yonina C. Eldar, Alexandre Megretski, George C. Verghese

We develop a sufficient condition for the least-squares measurement (LSM), or the square-root measurement, to minimize the probability of a detection error when distinguishing between a collection of mixed quantum states. Using this condition we derive the optimal measurement for state sets with a broad class of symmetries. We first consider geometrically uniform (GU) state sets with a possibly non-Abelian generating group, and show that if the generator satisfies a weighted norm constraint, then the LSM is optimal. In particular, for pure-state GU ensembles, the LSM is shown to be optimal. For arbitrary GU state sets we show that the optimal measurement operators are GU with generator that can be computed very efficiently in polynomial time, within any desired accuracy. We then consider compound GU (CGU) state sets which consist of subsets that are GU. When the generators satisfy a certain constraint, the LSM is again optimal. For arbitrary CGU state sets, the optimal measurement operators are shown to be CGU with generators that can be computed efficiently in polynomial time.

arXiv:quant-ph/0211111IEEE Transactions on Information TheoryJun 1, 2004151 citations

A semidefinite programming approach to optimal unambiguous discrimination of quantum states

Yonina C. Eldar

We consider the problem of unambiguous discrimination between a set of linearly independent pure quantum states. We show that the design of the optimal measurement that minimizes the probability of an inconclusive result can be formulated as a semidefinite programming problem. Based on this formulation, we develop a set of necessary and sufficient conditions for an optimal quantum measurement. We show that the optimal measurement can be computed very efficiently in polynomial time by exploiting the many well-known algorithms for solving semidefinite programs, which are guaranteed to converge to the global optimum. Using the general conditions for optimality, we derive necessary and sufficient conditions so that the measurement that results in an equal probability of an inconclusive result for each one of the quantum states is optimal. We refer to this measurement as the equal-probability measurement (EPM). We then show that for any state set, the prior probabilities of the states can be chosen such that the EPM is optimal. Finally, we consider state sets with strong symmetry properties and equal prior probabilities for which the EPM is optimal. We first consider geometrically uniform (GU) state sets that are defined over a group of unitary matrices and are generated by a single generating vector. We then consider compound GU state sets which are generated by a group of unitary matrices using multiple generating vectors, where the generating vectors satisfy a certain (weighted) norm constraint.

arXiv:quant-ph/0206093IEEE Transactions on Information TheoryFeb 1, 2003120 citations

Mixed-quantum-state detection with inconclusive results

Yonina C. Eldar

We consider the problem of designing an optimal quantum detector with a fixed rate of inconclusive results that maximizes the probability of correct detection, when distinguishing between a collection of mixed quantum states. We show that the design of the optimal detector can be formulated as a semidefinite programming problem, and derive a set of necessary and sufficient conditions for an optimal measurement. We then develop a sufficient condition for the scaled inverse measurement to maximize the probability of correct detection for the case in which the rate of inconclusive results exceeds a certain threshold. Using this condition we derive the optimal measurement for linearly independent pure-state sets, and for mixed-state sets with a broad class of symmetries. Specifically, we consider geometrically uniform (GU) state sets and compound geometrically uniform (CGU) state sets with generators that satisfy a certain constraint. We then show that the optimal measurements corresponding to GU and CGU state sets with arbitrary generators are also GU and CGU, respectively, with generators that can be computed very efficiently in polynomial time within any desired accuracy by solving a reduced size semidefinite programming problem.

arXiv:quant-ph/0211121Physical Review AApr 15, 200376 citations