Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1507.02755 · The Journal of Chemical Physics

Extending the applicability of Redfield theories into highly non-Markovian regimes

Andrés Montoya−Castillo, Timothy C. Berkelbach, David R. Reichman

Published Nov 20, 2015• 64 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We present a new, computationally inexpensive method for the calculation of reduced density matrix dynamics for systems with a potentially large number of subsystem degrees of freedom coupled to a generic bath. The approach consists of propagation of weak-coupling Redfield-like equations for the high-frequency bath degrees of freedom only, while the low-frequency bath modes are dynamically arrested but statistically sampled. We examine the improvements afforded by this approximation by comparing with exact results for the spin-boson model over a wide range of parameter space. We further generalize the method to multi-site models and compare with exact results for a model of the Fenna-Matthews-Olson complex. The results from the method are found to dramatically improve Redfield dynamics in highly non-Markovian regimes, at a similar computational cost. Relaxation of the mode-freezing approximation via classical (Ehrenfest) evolution of the low-frequency modes results in a dynamical hybrid method. We find that this Redfield-based dynamical hybrid approach, which is computationally more expensive than bare Redfield dynamics, yields only a marginal improvement over the simpler approximation of complete mode arrest.

DOI
10.1063/1.4935443

Related papers

Reduced density matrix hybrid approach: An efficient and accurate method for adiabatic and non-adiabatic quantum dynamics

Timothy C. Berkelbach, David R. Reichman, Thomas E. Markland

We present a new approach to calculate real-time quantum dynamics in complex systems. The formalism is based on the partitioning of a system's environment into "core" and "reservoir" modes with the former to be treated quantum mechanically and the latter classically. The presented method only requires the calculation of the system's reduced density matrix averaged over the quantum core degrees of freedom which is then coupled to a classically evolved reservoir to treat the remaining modes. We demonstrate our approach by applying it to the spin-boson problem using the noninteracting blip approximation to treat the system and core, and Ehrenfest dynamics to treat the reservoir. The resulting hybrid methodology is accurate for both fast and slow baths, since it naturally reduces to its composite methods in their respective regimes of validity. In addition, our combined method is shown to yield good results in intermediate regimes where neither approximation alone is accurate and to perform equally well for both strong and weak system-bath coupling. Our approach therefore provides an accurate and efficient methodology for calculating quantum dynamics in complex systems.

arXiv:1110.0490•The Journal of Chemical Physics•Jan 19, 2012•68 citations

Generalized quantum master equations: Getting more for less

Andrés Montoya−Castillo

This thesis describes the development of practical and efficient computational approaches to the quantum dynamics of complex systems. Most of the work presented here relies on the generalized quantum master equation (GQME) formalism, which provides a simple equation of motion of reduced dimensionality for a set of dynamical quantities, e.g., nonequilibrium averages and equilibrium time correlation functions. The reduced dimensionality of the GQME comes at a cost: the introduction of the memory kernel, which accounts for the influence of all ``excluded'' degrees of freedom. Focusing first on the second-order perturbative treatment of the memory kernel known as Redfield theory, I present a collaborative effort to extend its applicability into highly non-Markovian regions via a mode freezing approach. In this method, a portion of bath modes characterized by low frequencies are treated as sources of static disorder and used to calculate modified Redfield dynamics. Application of the method to the spin-boson and FMO complex models indicates that the Redfield+frozen modes scheme consistently produces dynamics that are as good or better than bare Redfield dynamics. Next, we explore GQME approach coupled to the self-consistent solution of the memory kernel, which requires the calculation of auxiliary kernels. Previous implementations of the method had shown impressive boosts in efficiency and, when approximate methods were used to calculate the auxiliary kernels, accuracy over direct calculation of nonequilibrium averages. We show that this method, when formulated from the Mori perspective, is equally applicable to nonequilibrium averages and equilibrium correlation functions. In addition, we examine the dependence of the improvements afforded by the GQME framework on the choice projection operator and kernel closure. In particular, we demonstrate that improvements in efficiency, which rely on short memory lifetimes, are sensitively dependent on the choice of projection operator, and that the choice of kernel closure directly dictates the improvements in accuracy. In addition, we present evidence that indicates that the success of the GQME formalism when the auxiliary kernels are calculated via semi- and quasi-classical methods is largely due to the exact sampling of bath operators at t=0 required by the calculation of specific kernel closures. Next, we provide analytical arguments that delineate when the GQME framework coupled to the self-consistent solution of the memory kernel is likely to provide improvements in efficiency and accuracy. Finally, we present a path integral framework that can efficiently render the partially Wigner-transformed canonical density operator for systems coupled linearly to harmonic baths. This approach permits the direct calculation of any thermodynamic quantity and can be integrated into dynamical schemes like the Ehrenfest, surface hopping, or linearized semi-classical initial value representation methods to calculate equilibrium correlation functions.

•Jan 1, 2016•0 citations

Solution of the Redfield equation for the dissipative quantum dynamics of multilevel systems

W. Thomas Pollard, Richard A. Friesner

We present a new method for solving the Redfield equation, which describes the evolution of the reduced density matrix of a multilevel quantum-mechanical system interacting with a thermal bath. The method is based on a new decomposition of the Redfield relaxation tensor that makes possible its direct application to the density matrix without explicit construction of the full tensor. In the resulting expressions, only ordinary matrices are involved and so any quantum system whose Hamiltonian can be diagonalized can be treated with the full Redfield theory. To efficiently solve the equation of motion for the density matrix, we introduce a generalization of the short-iterative-Lanczos propagator. Together, these contributions allow the complete Redfield theory to be applied to significantly larger systems than was previously possible. Several model calculations are presented to illustrate the methodology, including one example with 172 quantum states.

The Journal of Chemical Physics•Apr 1, 1994•274 citations

Open quantum-classical systems: A hybrid MASH master equation

Kasra Asnaashari, Jeremy O. Richardson

We propose a method which combines the quantum-classical mapping approach to surface hopping (MASH) with the dissipative quantum dynamics of the Lindblad master equation. Like conventional surface-hopping methods, our approach is based on classical trajectories coupled to the dynamics of a quantum subsystem. However, instead of evolving the subsystem wavefunction according to the time-dependent Schrödinger equation, we use stochastic quantum trajectories derived from secular Redfield theory. This enables the simulation of open quantum systems coupled simultaneously to Markovian quantum baths and anharmonic non-Markovian classical degrees of freedom. Applications to the spin--boson model and to the cavity-enhanced fluorescence of an electronically nonadiabatic molecule show excellent agreement with fully quantum-mechanical benchmarks.

quant-pharXiv:2511.05282•The Journal of Chemical Physics•Nov 10, 2025•2 citations

Effective-mode representation of non-Markovian dynamics: A hierarchical approximation of the spectral density. I. Application to single surface dynamics

Keith H. Hughes, Clara D. Christ, Irène Burghardt

An approach to non-Markovian system-environment dynamics is described which is based on the construction of a hierarchy of coupled effective environmental modes that is terminated by coupling the final member of the hierarchy to a Markovian bath. For an arbitrary environment, which is linearly coupled to the subsystem, the discretized spectral density is replaced by a series of approximate spectral densities involving an increasing number of effective modes. This series of approximants, which are constructed analytically in this paper, guarantees the accurate representation of the overall system-plus-bath dynamics up to increasing times. The hierarchical structure is manifested in the approximate spectral densities in the form of the imaginary part of a continued fraction similar to Mori theory. The results are described for cases where the hierarchy is truncated at the first-, second-, and third-order level. It is demonstrated that the results generated from a reduced density matrix equation of motion and large dimensional system-plus-bath wavepacket calculations are in excellent agreement. For the reduced density matrix calculations, the system and hierarchy of effective modes are treated explicitly and the effects of the bath on the final member of the hierarchy are described by the Caldeira-Leggett equation and its generalization to zero temperature.

The Journal of Chemical Physics•Jul 9, 2009•136 citations

Dissipative quantum mechanics beyond the Bloch-Redfield approximation: A consistent weak-coupling expansion of the Ohmic spin boson model at arbitrary bias

Carsten J. Lindner, Herbert Schoeller

We study the time evolution of the reduced density matrix for the Ohmic spin boson model out of an uncorrelated but otherwise arbitrary initial state. We consider arbitrary bias $\ensuremath{\epsilon}$ and tunneling $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}$ at zero temperature for a weak coupling $\ensuremath{\alpha}$ to the bosonic bath. Using the real-time renormalization group method, we present a consistent weak-coupling expansion one order beyond the Bloch-Redfield approximation within a renormalized perturbation theory with analytical results covering the whole crossover regime from small times $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Omega}}t\ensuremath{\ll}1$ to large times $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Omega}}t\ensuremath{\gg}1$, where $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Omega}}=\sqrt{{\ensuremath{\epsilon}}^{2}+{\stackrel{\ifmmode \tilde{}\else \~{}\fi{}}{\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}}}^{2}}$ denotes the Rabi frequency in terms of the renormalized tunneling $\stackrel{\ifmmode \tilde{}\else \~{}\fi{}}{\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}}$. In addition, for exponentially small or large times, we perform a nonperturbative resummation of all logarithmic terms. We show that standard Born approximation schemes calculating the effective Liouvillian of the kinetic equation up to first order in $\ensuremath{\alpha}$ are not sufficient to account for various important corrections one order beyond the Bloch-Redfield solution. (1) The resummation of all secular terms $\ensuremath{\sim}{(\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Gamma}}t)}^{n}$ is necessary to obtain the correct exponential decay of all terms of the time evolution with decay rate $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Gamma}}$ or $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Gamma}}/2$, together with the correct pre-exponential functions. (2) The resummation of all logarithmic terms at high and low energies leads to a renormalized tunneling $\stackrel{\ifmmode \tilde{}\else \~{}\fi{}}{\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}}$ and to pre-exponential functions of logarithmic and power-law form. (3) The fact that two eigenvalues of $L(E)$ are close to each other by $O(\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Gamma}})$ requires degenerate perturbation theory for times $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Gamma}}t\ensuremath{\sim}O(1)$, where certain terms of the Liouvillian in $O({\ensuremath{\alpha}}^{2})$ are needed to calculate the stationary state and the time evolution of the nonoscillating purely decaying modes up to $O(\ensuremath{\alpha})$. In contrast to the zero-bias case, we find two further interesting results for the time dynamics of the oscillating modes. (4) The terms of the pre-exponential functions with a strong time dependence show a leading long-time tail $\ensuremath{\sim}\ensuremath{\alpha}/(\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Omega}}t)$, besides other subleading terms $\ensuremath{\sim}\ensuremath{\alpha}/{(\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Omega}}t)}^{2}$ well-known from the zero-bias case. (5) The terms of the pre-exponential functions with a weak (logarithmic) time dependence vary according to a power law ${(\frac{1}{\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Omega}}t})}^{2\ensuremath{\alpha}\frac{{\ensuremath{\epsilon}}^{2}}{{\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Omega}}}^{2}}}$ for exponentially large times. The power-law exponent depends on the bias and has to be contrasted to the one at exponentially small times where it crosses over to the bias-independent result $2\ensuremath{\alpha}$. We discuss that the complexity to calculate one order beyond Bloch-Redfield approximation is rather generic and applies also to other models of dissipative quantum mechanics.

arXiv:1802.09846•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Sep 17, 2018•17 citations
We present a new, computationally inexpensive method for the calculation of reduced density matrix dynamics for systems with a potentially large number of subsystem degrees of freedom coupled to a generic bath. The approach consists of propagation of weak-coupling Redfield-like equations for the high-frequency bath degrees of freedom only, while the low-frequency bath modes are dynamically arrested but statistically sampled. We examine the improvements afforded by this approximation by comparing with exact results for the spin-boson model over a wide range of parameter space. We further generalize the method to multi-site models and compare with exact results for a model of the Fenna-Matthews-Olson complex. The results from the method are found to dramatically improve Redfield dynamics in highly non-Markovian regimes, at a similar computational cost. Relaxation of the mode-freezing approximation via classical (Ehrenfest) evolution of the low-frequency modes results in a dynamical hybrid method. We find that this Redfield-based dynamical hybrid approach, which is computationally more expensive than bare Redfield dynamics, yields only a marginal improvement over the simpler approximation of complete mode arrest.
We present a new approach to calculate real-time quantum dynamics in complex systems. The formalism is based on the partitioning of a system's environment into "core" and "reservoir" modes with the former to be treated quantum mechanically and the latter classically. The presented method only requires the calculation of the system's reduced density matrix averaged over the quantum core degrees of freedom which is then coupled to a classically evolved reservoir to treat the remaining modes. We demonstrate our approach by applying it to the spin-boson problem using the noninteracting blip approximation to treat the system and core, and Ehrenfest dynamics to treat the reservoir. The resulting hybrid methodology is accurate for both fast and slow baths, since it naturally reduces to its composite methods in their respective regimes of validity. In addition, our combined method is shown to yield good results in intermediate regimes where neither approximation alone is accurate and to perform equally well for both strong and weak system-bath coupling. Our approach therefore provides an accurate and efficient methodology for calculating quantum dynamics in complex systems.
This thesis describes the development of practical and efficient computational approaches to the quantum dynamics of complex systems. Most of the work presented here relies on the generalized quantum master equation (GQME) formalism, which provides a simple equation of motion of reduced dimensionality for a set of dynamical quantities, e.g., nonequilibrium averages and equilibrium time correlation functions. The reduced dimensionality of the GQME comes at a cost: the introduction of the memory kernel, which accounts for the influence of all ``excluded'' degrees of freedom. Focusing first on the second-order perturbative treatment of the memory kernel known as Redfield theory, I present a collaborative effort to extend its applicability into highly non-Markovian regions via a mode freezing approach. In this method, a portion of bath modes characterized by low frequencies are treated as sources of static disorder and used to calculate modified Redfield dynamics. Application of the method to the spin-boson and FMO complex models indicates that the Redfield+frozen modes scheme consistently produces dynamics that are as good or better than bare Redfield dynamics. Next, we explore GQME approach coupled to the self-consistent solution of the memory kernel, which requires the calculation of auxiliary kernels. Previous implementations of the method had shown impressive boosts in efficiency and, when approximate methods were used to calculate the auxiliary kernels, accuracy over direct calculation of nonequilibrium averages. We show that this method, when formulated from the Mori perspective, is equally applicable to nonequilibrium averages and equilibrium correlation functions. In addition, we examine the dependence of the improvements afforded by the GQME framework on the choice projection operator and kernel closure. In particular, we demonstrate that improvements in efficiency, which rely on short memory lifetimes, are sensitively dependent on the choice of projection operator, and that the choice of kernel closure directly dictates the improvements in accuracy. In addition, we present evidence that indicates that the success of the GQME formalism when the auxiliary kernels are calculated via semi- and quasi-classical methods is largely due to the exact sampling of bath operators at t=0 required by the calculation of specific kernel closures. Next, we provide analytical arguments that delineate when the GQME framework coupled to the self-consistent solution of the memory kernel is likely to provide improvements in efficiency and accuracy. Finally, we present a path integral framework that can efficiently render the partially Wigner-transformed canonical density operator for systems coupled linearly to harmonic baths. This approach permits the direct calculation of any thermodynamic quantity and can be integrated into dynamical schemes like the Ehrenfest, surface hopping, or linearized semi-classical initial value representation methods to calculate equilibrium correlation functions.
We present a new method for solving the Redfield equation, which describes the evolution of the reduced density matrix of a multilevel quantum-mechanical system interacting with a thermal bath. The method is based on a new decomposition of the Redfield relaxation tensor that makes possible its direct application to the density matrix without explicit construction of the full tensor. In the resulting expressions, only ordinary matrices are involved and so any quantum system whose Hamiltonian can be diagonalized can be treated with the full Redfield theory. To efficiently solve the equation of motion for the density matrix, we introduce a generalization of the short-iterative-Lanczos propagator. Together, these contributions allow the complete Redfield theory to be applied to significantly larger systems than was previously possible. Several model calculations are presented to illustrate the methodology, including one example with 172 quantum states.
We propose a method which combines the quantum-classical mapping approach to surface hopping (MASH) with the dissipative quantum dynamics of the Lindblad master equation. Like conventional surface-hopping methods, our approach is based on classical trajectories coupled to the dynamics of a quantum subsystem. However, instead of evolving the subsystem wavefunction according to the time-dependent Schrödinger equation, we use stochastic quantum trajectories derived from secular Redfield theory. This enables the simulation of open quantum systems coupled simultaneously to Markovian quantum baths and anharmonic non-Markovian classical degrees of freedom. Applications to the spin--boson model and to the cavity-enhanced fluorescence of an electronically nonadiabatic molecule show excellent agreement with fully quantum-mechanical benchmarks.
An approach to non-Markovian system-environment dynamics is described which is based on the construction of a hierarchy of coupled effective environmental modes that is terminated by coupling the final member of the hierarchy to a Markovian bath. For an arbitrary environment, which is linearly coupled to the subsystem, the discretized spectral density is replaced by a series of approximate spectral densities involving an increasing number of effective modes. This series of approximants, which are constructed analytically in this paper, guarantees the accurate representation of the overall system-plus-bath dynamics up to increasing times. The hierarchical structure is manifested in the approximate spectral densities in the form of the imaginary part of a continued fraction similar to Mori theory. The results are described for cases where the hierarchy is truncated at the first-, second-, and third-order level. It is demonstrated that the results generated from a reduced density matrix equation of motion and large dimensional system-plus-bath wavepacket calculations are in excellent agreement. For the reduced density matrix calculations, the system and hierarchy of effective modes are treated explicitly and the effects of the bath on the final member of the hierarchy are described by the Caldeira-Leggett equation and its generalization to zero temperature.
We study the time evolution of the reduced density matrix for the Ohmic spin boson model out of an uncorrelated but otherwise arbitrary initial state. We consider arbitrary bias $\ensuremath{\epsilon}$ and tunneling $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}$ at zero temperature for a weak coupling $\ensuremath{\alpha}$ to the bosonic bath. Using the real-time renormalization group method, we present a consistent weak-coupling expansion one order beyond the Bloch-Redfield approximation within a renormalized perturbation theory with analytical results covering the whole crossover regime from small times $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Omega}}t\ensuremath{\ll}1$ to large times $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Omega}}t\ensuremath{\gg}1$, where $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Omega}}=\sqrt{{\ensuremath{\epsilon}}^{2}+{\stackrel{\ifmmode \tilde{}\else \~{}\fi{}}{\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}}}^{2}}$ denotes the Rabi frequency in terms of the renormalized tunneling $\stackrel{\ifmmode \tilde{}\else \~{}\fi{}}{\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}}$. In addition, for exponentially small or large times, we perform a nonperturbative resummation of all logarithmic terms. We show that standard Born approximation schemes calculating the effective Liouvillian of the kinetic equation up to first order in $\ensuremath{\alpha}$ are not sufficient to account for various important corrections one order beyond the Bloch-Redfield solution. (1) The resummation of all secular terms $\ensuremath{\sim}{(\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Gamma}}t)}^{n}$ is necessary to obtain the correct exponential decay of all terms of the time evolution with decay rate $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Gamma}}$ or $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Gamma}}/2$, together with the correct pre-exponential functions. (2) The resummation of all logarithmic terms at high and low energies leads to a renormalized tunneling $\stackrel{\ifmmode \tilde{}\else \~{}\fi{}}{\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}}$ and to pre-exponential functions of logarithmic and power-law form. (3) The fact that two eigenvalues of L(E)L(E)L(E) are close to each other by $O(\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Gamma}})$ requires degenerate perturbation theory for times $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Gamma}}t\ensuremath{\sim}O(1)$, where certain terms of the Liouvillian in $O({\ensuremath{\alpha}}^{2})$ are needed to calculate the stationary state and the time evolution of the nonoscillating purely decaying modes up to $O(\ensuremath{\alpha})$. In contrast to the zero-bias case, we find two further interesting results for the time dynamics of the oscillating modes. (4) The terms of the pre-exponential functions with a strong time dependence show a leading long-time tail $\ensuremath{\sim}\ensuremath{\alpha}/(\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Omega}}t)$, besides other subleading terms $\ensuremath{\sim}\ensuremath{\alpha}/{(\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Omega}}t)}^{2}$ well-known from the zero-bias case. (5) The terms of the pre-exponential functions with a weak (logarithmic) time dependence vary according to a power law ${(\frac{1}{\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Omega}}t})}^{2\ensuremath{\alpha}\frac{{\ensuremath{\epsilon}}^{2}}{{\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Omega}}}^{2}}}$ for exponentially large times. The power-law exponent depends on the bias and has to be contrasted to the one at exponentially small times where it crosses over to the bias-independent result $2\ensuremath{\alpha}$. We discuss that the complexity to calculate one order beyond Bloch-Redfield approximation is rather generic and applies also to other models of dissipative quantum mechanics.