arXiv:1506.05430 · Physical Review A

Continuous-variable quantum cryptography with an untrusted relay: Detailed security analysis of the symmetric configuration

Carlo Ottaviani, Gaetana Spedalieri, Samuel L. Braunstein, Stefano Pirandola

Published Feb 18, 2015• 66 citations

Abstract

We consider the continuous-variable protocol of Pirandola et al. [arXiv:1312.4104] where the secret key is established by the measurement of an untrusted relay. In this network protocol, two authorized parties are connected to an untrusted relay by insecure quantum links. Secret correlations are generated by a continuous-variable Bell detection performed on incoming coherent states. In the present work we provide a detailed study of the symmetric configuration, where the relay is midway between the parties. We analyze symmetric eavesdropping strategies against the quantum links explicitly showing that, at fixed transmissivity and thermal noise, two-mode coherent attacks are optimal, manifestly outperforming one-mode collective attacks based on independent entangling cloners. Such an advantage is shown both in terms of security threshold and secret-key rate.

DOI: 10.1103/physreva.91.022320

Related papers

Continuous-variable quantum cryptography with untrusted relays

Stefano Pirandola, Carlo Ottaviani, Gaetana Spedalieri +2 more

We extend the field of continuous-variable quantum cryptography to a network formulation where two honest parties connect to an untrusted relay by insecure quantum links. To generate secret correlations, they transmit coherent states to the relay where a continuous-variable Bell detection is performed and the outcome broadcast. Even though the detection could be fully corrupted and the links subject to optimal coherent attacks, the honest parties can still extract a secret key, achieving high rates when the relay is proximal to one party, as typical in public networks with access points or proxy servers. Our theory is confirmed by an experiment generating key-rates which are orders of magnitude higher than those achievable with discrete-variable protocols. Thus, using the cheapest possible quantum resources, we experimentally show the possibility of high-rate quantum key distribution in network topologies where direct links are missing between end-users and intermediate relays cannot be trusted.

Dec 15, 20131 citation

Quantum cryptography with an ideal local relay

Gaetana Spedalieri, Carlo Ottaviani, Samuel L. Braunstein +4 more

We consider two remote parties connected to a relay by two quantum channels. To generate a secret key, they transmit coherent states to the relay, where the states are subject to a continuous-variable (CV) Bell detection. We study the ideal case where Alice's channel is lossless, i.e., the relay is locally in her lab and the Bell detection is perfomed with unit efficiency. This configuration allows us to explore the optimal performances achievable by CV measurement-device-independent quantum key distribution. This corresponds to the limit of a trusted local relay, where the detection loss can be re-scaled. Our theoretical analysis is confirmed by an experimental simulation where 10-4 secret bits per use can potentially be distributed at 170km assuming ideal reconciliation.

arXiv:1509.01113Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIEOct 13, 20156 citations

Quantum cryptography with an ideal local relay

Gaetana Spedalieri, Carlo Ottaviani, Samuel L. Braunstein +4 more

Jan 1, 20155 citations

Unconditional Security of Continuous-Variable Quantum Cryptography

Carlo Ottaviani

This thesis deals with a detailed study of the unconditional security of Continuous-Variable (CV) Quantum Key Distribution (QKD). We consider general communication architectures based on both point-to-point and end-to-end principle. For the first case we develop an extensive analysis of the unconditional security of both one-way and two-way protocol under several eavesdropping conditions. We describe an effective post-processing strategy, to apply to one-way communications, that allows to neutralise general coherent attacks. This result motivates us to formulate the conjecture that the "de Finettization" of the classical data, typically adopted in the asymptotic limit of many signals exchanged in order to reduce the attacks from a general coherent to a collective one, may not be necessary for Gaussian one-way communication. For what it concerns two-way protocols we show that after the reduction of the general attack using the de Finetti symmetrization, two-mode coherent attacks are the optimal eavesdropping. Our cryptanalysis shows that the parties can exploit a strategy, in combination with the results obtained on the security of one-way protocols against two-mode coherent attacks. In fact we prove explicitly that two-way communication with Gaussian continuous variables is immune to general coherent attacks. This is possible exploiting the random opening and closing of the circuit by Alice (ON/OFF switching), in the limit of many uses of the channel. We then conclude that collective attacks represent, strictly, the best strategy available to Eve. We have then studied the general security of one-way protocol considering not just lossy channel, but extending the cryptanalysis to all physically allowed canonical forms attacks. Finally we extended the study of thermal CV-QKD to two-way communication at different frequencies, in the framework of optimal collective attacks. In the last part of this thesis we focused on CV-QKD considering a modern end-to-end configuration. We then extend CV quantum cryptography to a network configuration. We develop a detailed cryptoanalysis of a communication scheme based on an untrusted relay, assisting the parties during the preparation of the secret key. We find the optimal eavesdropping and prove, both theoretically and experimentally, the feasibility of high-rate CV-QKD over metropolitan distances with of-the-shelves devices.

Jul 15, 20150 citations

Gaussian two-mode attacks in one-way quantum cryptography

Carlo Ottaviani, Stefano Mancini, Stefano Pirandola

We investigate the asymptotic security of one-way continuous variable quantum key distribution against Gaussian two-mode coherent attacks. The one-way protocol is implemented by arranging the channel uses in two-mode blocks. By applying symmetric random permutations over these blocks, the security analysis is in fact reduced to study two-mode coherent attacks and, in particular, Gaussian ones, due to the extremality of Gaussian states. We explicitly show that the use of two-mode Gaussian correlations by an eavesdropper leads to asymptotic secret key rates which are strictly larger than the rate obtained under standard single-mode Gaussian attacks.

arXiv:1703.07683Physical Review AMay 3, 201715 citations

Quantum-cryptography network via continuous-variable graph states

Yujing Qian, Zhean Shen, Guangqiang He +1 more

We propose a quantum-cryptography network based on a continuous-variable graph state along with its corresponding quantum key distribution (QKD) protocol. It allows two arbitrary parties in the graph state to share a secret Gaussian key (any-to-any QKD). A mathematical model is established to determine an arbitrary graph state'!`\ifmmode\bar\else\textasciimacron\fi{}s properties, including the possibility of QKD and the relevant criteria. The general entangling cloner attack strategy is analyzed in detail employing Shannon information theory. Results show that the proposed network is secure against such attack if the graph state meets certain criteria.

Physical Review ANov 29, 201219 citations