Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1504.07767 · Scientific Reports

Analysis of Entanglement Measures and LOCC Maximized Quantum Fisher Information of General Two Qubit Systems

Volkan Erol, Fatih Özaydin, Azmi Ali Altıntaṣ

Published Jun 24, 2014• 56 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Entanglement has been studied extensively for unveiling the mysteries of non-classical correlations between quantum systems. In the bipartite case, there are well known measures for quantifying entanglement such as concurrence, relative entropy of entanglement (REE) and negativity, which cannot be increased via local operations. It was found that for sets of non-maximally entangled states of two qubits, comparing these entanglement measures may lead to different entanglement orderings of the states. On the other hand, although it is not an entanglement measure and not monotonic under local operations, due to its ability of detecting multipartite entanglement, quantum Fisher information (QFI) has recently received an intense attraction generally with entanglement in the focus. In this work, we revisit the state ordering problem of general two qubit states. Generating a thousand random quantum states and performing an optimization based on local general rotations of each qubit, we calculate the maximal QFI for each state. We analyze the maximized QFI in comparison with concurrence, REE and negativity and obtain new state orderings. We show that there are pairs of states having equal maximized QFI but different values for concurrence, REE and negativity and vice versa.

DOI
10.1038/srep05422

Related papers

Mathematical Analysis of Entanglement Measures and Maximized Quantum Fisher Information

Volkan Erol

Entanglement measures such as concurrence, negativity and REE are well-known tools for quantifying non-classical correlations in quantum systems. However, these measures can lead to different state orderings for non-maximally entangled states. On the other hand, Quantum Fisher Information (QFI), while not an entanglement measure, provides a framework for analyzing a state's metrological potential. In this study, we numerically analyze the relationship between these entanglement measures and QFI for a large ensemble of random two-qubit states. We specifically focus on the maximized QFI (MQFI) obtained through local unitary rotations. Our findings demonstrate a strong correlation between entanglement and a state's metrological capacity, confirming that entanglement is a valuable resource. We show that while a state's QFI with a fixed generator can vary widely for a given entanglement value, local optimization to find the MQFI leads to a tighter, more predictable relationship. Our results also reinforce the principle that the metrological performance of all mixed states is fundamentally bounded by the theoretical limit of pure states. The polynomial fit equations for the upper and lower bounds of our data provide a quantitative description of these complex relationships.

•Sep 5, 2025•0 citations

Detecting Violation of Bell Inequalities using LOCC Maximized Quantum Fisher Information and Entanglement Measures

Volkan Erol

The violation of Bell's theorem is a very simple way to see that there is no underlying classical interpretation of quantum mechanics. The measurements made on the photons shows that light signal (information) could travel between them, hence completely eliminating any chance that the result was due to anything other than entanglement. Entanglement has been studied extensively for understanding the mysteries of non-classical correlations between quantum systems. It was found that violation of Bell's inequalities could be trivially calculated and for sets of nonmaximally entangled states of two qubits, comparing these entanglement measures may lead to different entanglement orderings of the states. On the other hand, although it is not an entanglement measure and not monotonic under local operations, due to its ability of detecting multipartite entanglement, quantum Fisher information (QFI) has recently received an intense attraction generally with entanglement in the focus. In this work, we visit violation of Bell's inequalities problem with a different approach. Generating a thousand random quantum states and performing an optimization based on local general rotations of each qubit, we calculate the maximal QFI for each state. We analyze the maximized QFI in comparison with violation in Bell's inequalities and we make similar comparison of this violation with commonly studied entanglement measures, negativity and relative entropy of entanglement. We show that there are interesting orderings for system states.

•Mar 31, 2017•8 citations

Mathematical Analysis of Entanglement Measures and Maximized Quantum Fisher Information

Volkan Erol

Entanglement measures such as concurrence, negativity and REE are well-known tools for quantifying non-classical correlations in quantum systems. However, these measures can lead to different state orderings for non-maximally entangled states. On the other hand, Quantum Fisher Information (QFI), while not an entanglement measure, provides a framework for analyzing a state's metrological potential. In this study, we numerically analyze the relationship between these entanglement measures and QFI for a large ensemble of random two-qubit states. We specifically focus on the maximized QFI (MQFI) obtained through local unitary rotations. Our findings demonstrate a strong correlation between entanglement and a state's metrological capacity, confirming that entanglement is a valuable resource. We show that while a state's QFI with a fixed generator can vary widely for a given entanglement value, local optimization to find the MQFI leads to a tighter, more predictable relationship. Our results also reinforce the principle that the metrological performance of all mixed states is fundamentally bounded by the theoretical limit of pure states. The polynomial fit equations for the upper and lower bounds of our data provide a quantitative description of these complex relationships.

•Sep 18, 2025•0 citations

An analysis of concurrence entanglement measure and quantum fisher information of quantum communication networks of two-qubits

Volkan Erol, Sinan Bugu, Fatih Özaydin +1 more

Quantum entanglement is one of key concepts in quantum communication engineering. Ordering the quantum systems according to their entanglement measures is a popular problem of the field. For two level (qubit) systems of two particles, state ordering has been studied with respect to well-known entanglement measures such as Concurrence, Negativity and Relative Entropy of Entanglement (REE) [1-5]. In this work, we study the state ordering of the two-qubit systems with respect to Quantum Fisher Information vs. Concurrence. In particular, constructing 1K random states and calculating their Concurrences and Negativities, we obtain the orderings of the states by comparing these results with Quantum Fisher Information values and present our results which are interesting when compared to that of two-level systems.

Signal Processing and Communications Applications Conference (SIU)•Apr 1, 2014•13 citations

A Proposal for Quantum Fisher Information Optimization and its Relation with Entanglement Measures

Volkan Erol

Studies about Quantum Information Theory continue actively in many research institutions. Very recently, pratical setups of large scale quantum computers are widely studied e.g. quantum repeaters, memories and processors. Entanglement provides us a computational advantage in realization of quantum algorithms. Some ways to quantifiying entanglement were defined. The best formal way to quantify it, is the methods that we call Entanglement Measures or Entanglement Monotones. In this research area, State Ordering Problem is defined and still an open problem especially for multiparticle entangled states. Fisher Information provides a good background for the solution of some actual Information Theory problems. Quantum Fisher Information (QFI) is a value that could be used in situations where phase sensitivity is important and this concept is expected to be the quantum version of the mentioned inftrastructure for Quantum Systems. QFI cannot be defined as an Entaglement Measure or Monotone. In the scope of this thesis, a new optimization technique is proposed for optimizing QFI and thanks to this optimization method, the ordering relation between QFI and entanglement measures is studied. Based on the studies made in the area of quantum state ordering, new and interesting analysis results are found and reported. The main important and interesting result achieved is that for two qubit quantum states, QFI maximized under Local Operation and Classical Communication has an interesting ordering relation with entanglement measures especially with Relative Entropy of Entanglement. Our study is extended for the qubit-qutrit systems and ordering relations and classification results are presented. For some quantum systems, the changes in QFI under decoherence channels are also considered.

arXiv:1705.04682•May 12, 2017•8 citations

LOCC-Maximized Quantum Fisher Information as a Necessary Condition for CHSH Violation

Volkan Erol

We investigate the relationship between CHSH inequality violation and quantum Fisher information (QFI) maximized over local operations and classical communication (LOCC) for two-qubit systems. Through systematic analysis of 1000 random states, we discover that no state with Bell parameter M(ρ) exceeding maximized QFI violates the CHSH inequality, suggesting QFImax serves as a necessary condition. States partition into three classes: (1) M(ρ) > QFImax with CHSH violation (23%), (2) M(ρ) > QFImax without violation (41%), and (3) M(ρ) < QFImax without violation (36%). We identify relative entropy of entanglement thresholds (0.14 and 0.26) separating regions of guaranteed violation, ambiguous behavior, and no violation. Furthermore, 98% of states exhibit QFI values that cross the separability bound under local rotations. These results provide efficient pre-screening criteria for device-independent quantum protocols and reveal deep connections between quantum metrology and Bell nonlocality.

•Oct 14, 2025•0 citations
Entanglement has been studied extensively for unveiling the mysteries of non-classical correlations between quantum systems. In the bipartite case, there are well known measures for quantifying entanglement such as concurrence, relative entropy of entanglement (REE) and negativity, which cannot be increased via local operations. It was found that for sets of non-maximally entangled states of two qubits, comparing these entanglement measures may lead to different entanglement orderings of the states. On the other hand, although it is not an entanglement measure and not monotonic under local operations, due to its ability of detecting multipartite entanglement, quantum Fisher information (QFI) has recently received an intense attraction generally with entanglement in the focus. In this work, we revisit the state ordering problem of general two qubit states. Generating a thousand random quantum states and performing an optimization based on local general rotations of each qubit, we calculate the maximal QFI for each state. We analyze the maximized QFI in comparison with concurrence, REE and negativity and obtain new state orderings. We show that there are pairs of states having equal maximized QFI but different values for concurrence, REE and negativity and vice versa.
Entanglement measures such as concurrence, negativity and REE are well-known tools for quantifying non-classical correlations in quantum systems. However, these measures can lead to different state orderings for non-maximally entangled states. On the other hand, Quantum Fisher Information (QFI), while not an entanglement measure, provides a framework for analyzing a state's metrological potential. In this study, we numerically analyze the relationship between these entanglement measures and QFI for a large ensemble of random two-qubit states. We specifically focus on the maximized QFI (MQFI) obtained through local unitary rotations. Our findings demonstrate a strong correlation between entanglement and a state's metrological capacity, confirming that entanglement is a valuable resource. We show that while a state's QFI with a fixed generator can vary widely for a given entanglement value, local optimization to find the MQFI leads to a tighter, more predictable relationship. Our results also reinforce the principle that the metrological performance of all mixed states is fundamentally bounded by the theoretical limit of pure states. The polynomial fit equations for the upper and lower bounds of our data provide a quantitative description of these complex relationships.
The violation of Bell's theorem is a very simple way to see that there is no underlying classical interpretation of quantum mechanics. The measurements made on the photons shows that light signal (information) could travel between them, hence completely eliminating any chance that the result was due to anything other than entanglement. Entanglement has been studied extensively for understanding the mysteries of non-classical correlations between quantum systems. It was found that violation of Bell's inequalities could be trivially calculated and for sets of nonmaximally entangled states of two qubits, comparing these entanglement measures may lead to different entanglement orderings of the states. On the other hand, although it is not an entanglement measure and not monotonic under local operations, due to its ability of detecting multipartite entanglement, quantum Fisher information (QFI) has recently received an intense attraction generally with entanglement in the focus. In this work, we visit violation of Bell's inequalities problem with a different approach. Generating a thousand random quantum states and performing an optimization based on local general rotations of each qubit, we calculate the maximal QFI for each state. We analyze the maximized QFI in comparison with violation in Bell's inequalities and we make similar comparison of this violation with commonly studied entanglement measures, negativity and relative entropy of entanglement. We show that there are interesting orderings for system states.
Entanglement measures such as concurrence, negativity and REE are well-known tools for quantifying non-classical correlations in quantum systems. However, these measures can lead to different state orderings for non-maximally entangled states. On the other hand, Quantum Fisher Information (QFI), while not an entanglement measure, provides a framework for analyzing a state's metrological potential. In this study, we numerically analyze the relationship between these entanglement measures and QFI for a large ensemble of random two-qubit states. We specifically focus on the maximized QFI (MQFI) obtained through local unitary rotations. Our findings demonstrate a strong correlation between entanglement and a state's metrological capacity, confirming that entanglement is a valuable resource. We show that while a state's QFI with a fixed generator can vary widely for a given entanglement value, local optimization to find the MQFI leads to a tighter, more predictable relationship. Our results also reinforce the principle that the metrological performance of all mixed states is fundamentally bounded by the theoretical limit of pure states. The polynomial fit equations for the upper and lower bounds of our data provide a quantitative description of these complex relationships.
Quantum entanglement is one of key concepts in quantum communication engineering. Ordering the quantum systems according to their entanglement measures is a popular problem of the field. For two level (qubit) systems of two particles, state ordering has been studied with respect to well-known entanglement measures such as Concurrence, Negativity and Relative Entropy of Entanglement (REE) [1-5]. In this work, we study the state ordering of the two-qubit systems with respect to Quantum Fisher Information vs. Concurrence. In particular, constructing 1K random states and calculating their Concurrences and Negativities, we obtain the orderings of the states by comparing these results with Quantum Fisher Information values and present our results which are interesting when compared to that of two-level systems.
Studies about Quantum Information Theory continue actively in many research institutions. Very recently, pratical setups of large scale quantum computers are widely studied e.g. quantum repeaters, memories and processors. Entanglement provides us a computational advantage in realization of quantum algorithms. Some ways to quantifiying entanglement were defined. The best formal way to quantify it, is the methods that we call Entanglement Measures or Entanglement Monotones. In this research area, State Ordering Problem is defined and still an open problem especially for multiparticle entangled states. Fisher Information provides a good background for the solution of some actual Information Theory problems. Quantum Fisher Information (QFI) is a value that could be used in situations where phase sensitivity is important and this concept is expected to be the quantum version of the mentioned inftrastructure for Quantum Systems. QFI cannot be defined as an Entaglement Measure or Monotone. In the scope of this thesis, a new optimization technique is proposed for optimizing QFI and thanks to this optimization method, the ordering relation between QFI and entanglement measures is studied. Based on the studies made in the area of quantum state ordering, new and interesting analysis results are found and reported. The main important and interesting result achieved is that for two qubit quantum states, QFI maximized under Local Operation and Classical Communication has an interesting ordering relation with entanglement measures especially with Relative Entropy of Entanglement. Our study is extended for the qubit-qutrit systems and ordering relations and classification results are presented. For some quantum systems, the changes in QFI under decoherence channels are also considered.
We investigate the relationship between CHSH inequality violation and quantum Fisher information (QFI) maximized over local operations and classical communication (LOCC) for two-qubit systems. Through systematic analysis of 1000 random states, we discover that no state with Bell parameter M(ρ) exceeding maximized QFI violates the CHSH inequality, suggesting QFImax serves as a necessary condition. States partition into three classes: (1) M(ρ) > QFImax with CHSH violation (23%), (2) M(ρ) > QFImax without violation (41%), and (3) M(ρ) < QFImax without violation (36%). We identify relative entropy of entanglement thresholds (0.14 and 0.26) separating regions of guaranteed violation, ambiguous behavior, and no violation. Furthermore, 98% of states exhibit QFI values that cross the separability bound under local rotations. These results provide efficient pre-screening criteria for device-independent quantum protocols and reveal deep connections between quantum metrology and Bell nonlocality.