Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1504.07734 · Physical Review A

Symmetry criteria for quantum simulability of effective interactions

Zoltán Zimborás, Robert Zeier, Thomas Schulte‐Herbrüggen, Daniel Klaus Burgarth

Published Oct 8, 2015• 44 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

What can one do with a given tunable quantum device? We provide complete symmetry criteria deciding whether some effective target interaction(s) can be simulated by a set of given interactions. Symmetries lead to a better understanding of simulation and permit a reasoning beyond the limitations of the usual explicit Lie closure. Conserved quantities induced by symmetries pave the way to a resource theory for simulability. On a general level, one can now decide equality for any pair of compact Lie algebras just given by their generators without determining the algebras explicitly. Several physical examples are illustrated, including entanglement invariants, the relation to unitary gate membership problems, as well as the central-spin model.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.92.042309

Related papers

Quantifying The Asymmetry Properties Of Quantum Mechanical Systems Using Entanglement Monotones

Borzumehr Toloui-Semnani

Dynamical symmetries in closed systems lead to conservation laws and to selection rules that are based on those conservation laws. However, conservation laws are not applica- ble to open systems that undergo irreversible transformations. More general selection rules are needed to determine whether, given two states, the transition from one state to the other is possible. Characterizing the asymmetry properties of quantum states using quantum information theoretical tools and methods is particularly fruitful for this purpose. This thesis is concerned with the problem of finding new general selection rules that hold for both open and closed systems. The usual approach to this problem relies heavily on group theory and involves a detailed study of the structure of the symmetry group. In this thesis, we approach the problem in a completely new way. Our approach is to use entanglement to investigate the asymmetry properties of quantum states. In order to do that, we embed the system’s Hilbert space in a larger tensor product Hilbert space, whereby all symmetric states are mapped to separable states, asymmetric states are mapped to entangled states, and the symmetric transformations between two states are replaced by local operations on their bipartite images. Our method is not restricted to only a specific group but applies, in general, to all symmetries that are associated with semi-simple compact Lie groups and their associated Lie algebras. The mapping of the original states to bipartite states that act on the larger Hilbert space enables us to use the well studied theory of entanglement to investigate the consequences of dynamic symmetries. For example, the monotonicity condition on measures of entanglement provide us with new selection rules. Under reversible transfor- mations, the entanglement of the bipartite image states becomes a conserved quantity. These entanglement-based conserved quantities are new and different from the conserved quantities based on expectation values of the Hamiltonian symmetry generators.

•Jan 1, 2013•0 citations

Characterizing entangling quantum dynamics

Michael J. Bremner

When can one quantum system be used to simulate another? What aspects of a quantum system restrict its capacity to simulate other systems? Understanding the limitations and possibilities of such simulations is a key issue at the intersection of physics and computer science. In this thesis we determine what physical systems can be simulated by finite-dimensional quantum systems with entangling Hamiltonians and complete local unitary control. By an entangling Hamiltonian we mean each of the system's subsystems are coupled, either directly or indirectly. This very broad class of Hamiltonians is applicable to a wide range of important physical systems in Nature.Our key motivation for studying such simulation problems is quantum computing. It can be shown that a locally controllable Hamiltonian system must be entangling if it is to be used to make a quantum computer. By characterizing the simulation properties of entangling Hamiltonian systems, we identify necessary (and in some cases sufficient) properties for such systems to be used in the implementation of a quantum computer.We perform our categorization of entangling Hamiltonian systems by determining the Lie algebras they can generate with local unitary control. We find that the key to this categorization is given by simple properties of the structure of the system Hamiltonian. Our main result is a complete characterization of all entangling Hamiltonian systems based on the set of Hamiltonians that they can generate with local unitary control.

•Jan 1, 2005•0 citations

Resource-Theoretic Quantifiers of Weak and Strong Symmetry Breaking: Strong Entanglement Asymmetry and Beyond

Yuya Kusuki, Sridip Pal, Hiroyasu Tajima

Quantifying how much a quantum state breaks a symmetry is essential for characterizing phases, nonequilibrium dynamics, and open-system behavior. For mixed states, however, conventional diagnostics of weak symmetry breaking can miss a stronger form of symmetry breaking associated with the possibility of exchanging conserved charges with an environment. We develop a resource theory of strong symmetry breaking by identifying the appropriate free states and free operations, and, for channels on a fixed system, by showing that the latter are precisely the operations realizable without exchanging the conserved charge with the environment. We systematically construct measures of strong symmetry breaking, including strong entanglement asymmetry and covariance matrices of symmetry generators, for a broad class of symmetry groups. We further completely characterize i.i.d. convertibility between arbitrary states under any compact Lie group strong symmetry. This identifies the combinations of resource-theoretically valid measures that quantify strong symmetry breaking for arbitrary states, including all mixed states. In particular, for $U(1)$ symmetry, if the states have positive variances of the conserved quantity and equal strong-symmetry periods, the conversion rate is completely determined by the variance ratio whenever the input is pure or the output is weak symmetric. Thus, for these state conversions, the variance of the conserved quantity plays an operational role analogous to that of entanglement entropy in entanglement theory or quantum Fisher information in the resource theory of weak asymmetry. We further show how weak symmetry breaking is irreversibly converted into strong symmetry breaking in open-system dynamics. We illustrate the framework with examples from quantum field theory, strong-to-weak spontaneous symmetry breaking, and a strong-symmetry analogue of Mpemba-type dynamics.

hep-thCross-listedarXiv:2601.20924•Jan 30, 2026•11 citations

Controllability and Observability of Multi-Spin Systems: Constraints by Symmetry and by Relaxation

Uwe Sander, T. Schulte-Herbrueggen

We investigate the universality of multi-spin systems in architectures of various symmetries of coupling type and topology. Explicit reachability sets under symmetry constraints are provided. Thus for a given (possibly symmetric) experimental coupling architecture several decision problems can be solved in a unified way: (i) can a target Hamiltonian be simulated? (ii) can a target gate be synthesised? (iii) to which extent is the system observable by a given set of detection operators? and, as a special case of the latter, (iv) can an underlying system Hamiltonian be identified with a given set of detection operators? Finally, in turn, lack of symmetry provides a convenient necessary condition for full controllability. Though often easier to assess than the well-established Lie-algebra rank condition, this is not sufficient unless the candidate dynamic simple Lie algebra can be pre-identified uniquely, which is fortunately less complicated than expected.

arXiv:0904.4654•Apr 29, 2009•7 citations

A Dynamical Lie-Algebraic Framework for Hamiltonian Engineering and Quantum Control

Yanying Liang, Ruibin Xu, Mao-Sheng Li +2 more

Determining the unitary dynamics accessible from finite Hamiltonian resources is a central problem in Hamiltonian engineering and quantum control. Dynamical Lie algebras (DLAs) connect available control Hamiltonians with the reachable dynamics, but their use as a design tool for modifying Hamiltonian generator sets remains less developed. In this work, we develop a finite-dimensional DLA framework for three generator-set operations: composition, invariance, and reduction. For composition, we construct direct sums of component DLAs using spectral projectors on an auxiliary register. For invariance, we analyze when modifications of Pauli-string generating sets preserve the generated Lie algebra, and introduce algebraic diagnostics for added generators. For reduction, we consider compact reductive DLAs and show how projection onto selected simple ideals gives reduced generating sets whose Lie closures are the corresponding ideal sums. We illustrate these results with finite-dimensional examples and numerical checks, including direct-sum dimension addition, central-spin invariance diagnostics, and DLA-based ansatz reduction for block-local Hamiltonians. The results show how DLA structure can be used to diagnose controllability and guide Hamiltonian generator design under explicit algebraic assumptions.

quant-pharXiv:2603.04916•New Journal of Physics•Mar 6, 2026•2 citations

Symmetry principles in quantum system theory of multi-qubit systems made simple

Thomas Schulte‐Herbrüggen, Uwe Sander, Robert Zeier

Controllability and observability of multi-spin systems in architectures of various symmetries of coupling type and topology are investigated. We complement recent work of explicitly determining the respective dynamic system Lie algebras and thereby also precise reachability sets under symmetry constraints. Here the focus is on the converse: under which conditions can the absence of symmetry be taken as an indicator of universality of the hardware architecture? More precisely, the absence of symmetry implies irreducibility and provides a convenient necessary condition for full controllability. Though much easier to assess than the well-established Lie-algebra rank condition, this is not sufficient unless in an n-qubit system with connected coupling topology the candidate dynamic simple Lie algebra can be identified uniquely as the full unitary algebra su(2n). - Here we discuss simple tests confined to solving homogeneous linear equations in order to filter irreducible unitary representations of other candidate algebras of classical type (orthogonal ones and unitary symplectic ones). Finally, we give an outlook under which conditions algebras of exceptional type can also be ruled out.

International Symposium on Communications, Control and Signal Processing•Mar 1, 2010•2 citations
What can one do with a given tunable quantum device? We provide complete symmetry criteria deciding whether some effective target interaction(s) can be simulated by a set of given interactions. Symmetries lead to a better understanding of simulation and permit a reasoning beyond the limitations of the usual explicit Lie closure. Conserved quantities induced by symmetries pave the way to a resource theory for simulability. On a general level, one can now decide equality for any pair of compact Lie algebras just given by their generators without determining the algebras explicitly. Several physical examples are illustrated, including entanglement invariants, the relation to unitary gate membership problems, as well as the central-spin model.
Dynamical symmetries in closed systems lead to conservation laws and to selection rules that are based on those conservation laws. However, conservation laws are not applica- ble to open systems that undergo irreversible transformations. More general selection rules are needed to determine whether, given two states, the transition from one state to the other is possible. Characterizing the asymmetry properties of quantum states using quantum information theoretical tools and methods is particularly fruitful for this purpose. This thesis is concerned with the problem of finding new general selection rules that hold for both open and closed systems. The usual approach to this problem relies heavily on group theory and involves a detailed study of the structure of the symmetry group. In this thesis, we approach the problem in a completely new way. Our approach is to use entanglement to investigate the asymmetry properties of quantum states. In order to do that, we embed the system’s Hilbert space in a larger tensor product Hilbert space, whereby all symmetric states are mapped to separable states, asymmetric states are mapped to entangled states, and the symmetric transformations between two states are replaced by local operations on their bipartite images. Our method is not restricted to only a specific group but applies, in general, to all symmetries that are associated with semi-simple compact Lie groups and their associated Lie algebras. The mapping of the original states to bipartite states that act on the larger Hilbert space enables us to use the well studied theory of entanglement to investigate the consequences of dynamic symmetries. For example, the monotonicity condition on measures of entanglement provide us with new selection rules. Under reversible transfor- mations, the entanglement of the bipartite image states becomes a conserved quantity. These entanglement-based conserved quantities are new and different from the conserved quantities based on expectation values of the Hamiltonian symmetry generators.
When can one quantum system be used to simulate another? What aspects of a quantum system restrict its capacity to simulate other systems? Understanding the limitations and possibilities of such simulations is a key issue at the intersection of physics and computer science. In this thesis we determine what physical systems can be simulated by finite-dimensional quantum systems with entangling Hamiltonians and complete local unitary control. By an entangling Hamiltonian we mean each of the system's subsystems are coupled, either directly or indirectly. This very broad class of Hamiltonians is applicable to a wide range of important physical systems in Nature.Our key motivation for studying such simulation problems is quantum computing. It can be shown that a locally controllable Hamiltonian system must be entangling if it is to be used to make a quantum computer. By characterizing the simulation properties of entangling Hamiltonian systems, we identify necessary (and in some cases sufficient) properties for such systems to be used in the implementation of a quantum computer.We perform our categorization of entangling Hamiltonian systems by determining the Lie algebras they can generate with local unitary control. We find that the key to this categorization is given by simple properties of the structure of the system Hamiltonian. Our main result is a complete characterization of all entangling Hamiltonian systems based on the set of Hamiltonians that they can generate with local unitary control.
Quantifying how much a quantum state breaks a symmetry is essential for characterizing phases, nonequilibrium dynamics, and open-system behavior. For mixed states, however, conventional diagnostics of weak symmetry breaking can miss a stronger form of symmetry breaking associated with the possibility of exchanging conserved charges with an environment. We develop a resource theory of strong symmetry breaking by identifying the appropriate free states and free operations, and, for channels on a fixed system, by showing that the latter are precisely the operations realizable without exchanging the conserved charge with the environment. We systematically construct measures of strong symmetry breaking, including strong entanglement asymmetry and covariance matrices of symmetry generators, for a broad class of symmetry groups. We further completely characterize i.i.d. convertibility between arbitrary states under any compact Lie group strong symmetry. This identifies the combinations of resource-theoretically valid measures that quantify strong symmetry breaking for arbitrary states, including all mixed states. In particular, for U(1)U(1)U(1) symmetry, if the states have positive variances of the conserved quantity and equal strong-symmetry periods, the conversion rate is completely determined by the variance ratio whenever the input is pure or the output is weak symmetric. Thus, for these state conversions, the variance of the conserved quantity plays an operational role analogous to that of entanglement entropy in entanglement theory or quantum Fisher information in the resource theory of weak asymmetry. We further show how weak symmetry breaking is irreversibly converted into strong symmetry breaking in open-system dynamics. We illustrate the framework with examples from quantum field theory, strong-to-weak spontaneous symmetry breaking, and a strong-symmetry analogue of Mpemba-type dynamics.
We investigate the universality of multi-spin systems in architectures of various symmetries of coupling type and topology. Explicit reachability sets under symmetry constraints are provided. Thus for a given (possibly symmetric) experimental coupling architecture several decision problems can be solved in a unified way: (i) can a target Hamiltonian be simulated? (ii) can a target gate be synthesised? (iii) to which extent is the system observable by a given set of detection operators? and, as a special case of the latter, (iv) can an underlying system Hamiltonian be identified with a given set of detection operators? Finally, in turn, lack of symmetry provides a convenient necessary condition for full controllability. Though often easier to assess than the well-established Lie-algebra rank condition, this is not sufficient unless the candidate dynamic simple Lie algebra can be pre-identified uniquely, which is fortunately less complicated than expected.
Determining the unitary dynamics accessible from finite Hamiltonian resources is a central problem in Hamiltonian engineering and quantum control. Dynamical Lie algebras (DLAs) connect available control Hamiltonians with the reachable dynamics, but their use as a design tool for modifying Hamiltonian generator sets remains less developed. In this work, we develop a finite-dimensional DLA framework for three generator-set operations: composition, invariance, and reduction. For composition, we construct direct sums of component DLAs using spectral projectors on an auxiliary register. For invariance, we analyze when modifications of Pauli-string generating sets preserve the generated Lie algebra, and introduce algebraic diagnostics for added generators. For reduction, we consider compact reductive DLAs and show how projection onto selected simple ideals gives reduced generating sets whose Lie closures are the corresponding ideal sums. We illustrate these results with finite-dimensional examples and numerical checks, including direct-sum dimension addition, central-spin invariance diagnostics, and DLA-based ansatz reduction for block-local Hamiltonians. The results show how DLA structure can be used to diagnose controllability and guide Hamiltonian generator design under explicit algebraic assumptions.
Controllability and observability of multi-spin systems in architectures of various symmetries of coupling type and topology are investigated. We complement recent work of explicitly determining the respective dynamic system Lie algebras and thereby also precise reachability sets under symmetry constraints. Here the focus is on the converse: under which conditions can the absence of symmetry be taken as an indicator of universality of the hardware architecture? More precisely, the absence of symmetry implies irreducibility and provides a convenient necessary condition for full controllability. Though much easier to assess than the well-established Lie-algebra rank condition, this is not sufficient unless in an n-qubit system with connected coupling topology the candidate dynamic simple Lie algebra can be identified uniquely as the full unitary algebra su(2n). - Here we discuss simple tests confined to solving homogeneous linear equations in order to filter irreducible unitary representations of other candidate algebras of classical type (orthogonal ones and unitary symplectic ones). Finally, we give an outlook under which conditions algebras of exceptional type can also be ruled out.