Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1504.00794

Comments on "Which is the Quantum Decay Law of Relativistic Particles?"

K. Urbanowski

Published Apr 3, 2015• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Results presented in a recent paper "Which is the Quantum Decay Law of Relativistic particles?", arXiv: 1412.3346v2 [quant--ph]], are analyzed. We show that approximations used therein to derive the main final formula for the survival probability of finding a moving unstable particle to be undecayed at time $t$ force this particle to almost stop moving, that is that, in fact, the derived formula is approximately valid only for $γ\cong 1$, where $γ= 1/\sqrt{1-β^{2}}$ and $β= v/c$, or in other words, for the velocity $v \simeq 0$.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.1504.00794

Related papers

Decay law of relativistic particles: Quantum theory meets special relativity

K. Urbanowski

Late time properties of moving relativistic particles are studied. Within the proper relativistic treatment of the problem we find decay curves of such particles and we show that late time deviations of the survival probability of these particles from the exponential form of the decay law, that is the transition times region between exponential and non-exponential form of the survival amplitude, occur much earlier than it follows from the classical standard approach boiled down to replace time t by t/γL (where γL is the relativistic Lorentz factor) in the formula for the survival probability. The consequence is that fluctuations of the corresponding decay curves can appear much earlier and much more unstable particles have a chance to survive up to these times or later. It is also shown that fluctuations of the instantaneous energy of the moving unstable particles have a similar form as the fluctuations in the particle rest frame but they are seen by the observer in his rest system much earlier than one could expect replacing t by t/γL in the corresponding expressions for this energy and that the amplitude of these fluctuations can be even larger than it follows from the standard approach. All these effects seem to be important when interpreting some accelerator experiments with high energy unstable particles and the like (possible connections of these effects with GSI anomaly are analyzed) and some results of astrophysical observations.

arXiv:1408.6564•Physics Letters B•Sep 5, 2014•32 citations

Time Dilation in Relativistic Quantum Decay Laws of Moving Unstable Particles

Filippo Giraldi

The relativistic quantum decay laws of moving unstable particles are analyzed for a general class of mass distribution densities which behave as power laws near the (nonvanishing) lower bound μ0 of the mass spectrum. The survival probability Pp(t) , the instantaneous mass Mp(t) , and the instantaneous decay rate Γp(t) of the moving unstable particle are evaluated over short and long times for an arbitrary value p of the (constant) linear momentum. The ultrarelativistic and nonrelativistic limits are studied. Over long times, the survival probability Pp(t) is approximately related to the survival probability at rest P0(t) by a scaling law. The scaling law can be interpreted as the effect of the relativistic time dilation if the asymptotic value Mp∞ of the instantaneous mass is considered as the effective mass of the unstable particle over long times. The effective mass has magnitude μ0 at rest and moves with linear momentum p or, equivalently, with constant velocity 1/1+μ02/p2 . The instantaneous decay rate Γp(t) is approximately independent of the linear momentum p , over long times, and, consequently, is approximately invariant by changing reference frame.

arXiv:1803.07709•Advances in High Energy Physics•May 29, 2018•4 citations

Properties of decaying relativistic particles: "GSI anomaly" like effects

K. Urbanowski

We study the survival probability of moving relativistic unstable particles and we found the integral representation of the survival amplitude for such particles moving with constant momentum ~ 6 0. Using this representation of the amplitude we found decay curves of such particles for the quantum mechanical models considered. These model studies show that late time deviations of the survival probability of these particles from the exponential form of the decay law, that is the transition times region between exponential and non-exponential form of the survival probability, occur much earlier than it follows from the classical standard approach resolving itself into replacing time t by t/γ (where γ is the relativistic Lorentz factor) in the formula for the survival probability and that the survival probabilities tend to zero as t → ∞ much slower than one would expect using classical time dilation relation. Here we show also that for some physically admissible models of unstable states the properly computed decay curves of the moving particles have analogous fluctuating form as the decay curves obtained in the GSI experiment.

•Jan 1, 2015•1 citation

Decay Law and Time Dilatation

Francesco Giacosa

We study the decay law for a moving unstable particle. The usual time-dilatation formula states that the decay width for an unstable state moving with a momentum $p$ and mass $M$ is $\tildeΓ_{p}=ΓM/\sqrt{p^{2}+M^{2}}$ with $Γ$ being the decay width in the rest frame. In agreement with previous studies, we show that in the context of QM as well as QFT this equation is \textit{not} correct provided that the quantum measurement is performed in a reference frame in which the unstable particle has momentum $p$ (note, a momentum eigenstate is \textit{not} a velocity eigenstate in QM). We then give, to our knowledge for the first time, an analytic expression of an improved formula and we show that the deviation from $\tildeΓ_{p}$ has a maximum for $p/M=\sqrt{2/3},$ but is typically \textit{very} small. Then, the result can be easily generalized to a momentum wave packet and also to an arbitrary initial state. Here, we give a very general expression of the non-decay probability. As a next step, we show that care is needed when one makes a boost of an unstable state with zero momentum/velocity: namely, the resulting state has zero overlap with the elements of the basis of unstable states (it is already decayed!). However, when considering a spread in velocity, one finds again that $\tilde{Γ}_{p}$ is typically a very good approximation. The study of a velocity wave-packet represents an interesting subject which constitutes one of the main outcomes of the present manuscript.\textbf{ }In the end, it should be stressed that there is no whatsoever breaking of special relativity, but as usual in QM, one should specify which kind of measurement on which kind of state is performed.

arXiv:1512.00232•Acta Physica Polonica B•Jan 1, 2016•17 citations

Non-classical Behavior of Moving Relativistic Unstable Particles

K. Urbanowski

We study the survival probability of moving relativistic unstable particles with definite momentum $\vec{p} \neq 0$. The amplitude of the survival probability of these particles is calculated using its integral representation. We found decay curves of such particles for the quantum mechanical models considered. These model studies show that late time deviations of the survival probability of these particles from the exponential form of the decay law, that is the transition times region between exponential and non-expo\-nen\-tial form of the survival probability, should occur much earlier than it follows from the classical standard approach resolving itself into replacing time $t$ by $t/γ$ (where $γ$ is the relativistic Lorentz factor) in the formula for the survival probability and that the survival probabilities should tend to zero as $t\rightarrow \infty$ much slower than one would expect using classical time dilation relation. Here we show also that for some physically admissible models of unstable states the computed decay curves of the moving particles have fluctuating form at relatively short times including times of order of the lifetime.

arXiv:1506.05076•Acta Physica Polonica B•Jan 1, 2017•6 citations

Nonclassical face of quantum decay processes

K. Urbanowski

A detailed analysis of the quantum decay processes shows the survival probability ( t ) can not take that exponential form at any time interval including times smaller than the lifetime τ . We show that for times t ∼ τ and for the times later than τ the form of ( t ) looks as a composition of an oscillating and exponential functions. The amplitude of these oscillations is very small for t ≪ τ and grows with increasing time and depends on the model considered. We also study the survival probability of moving relativistic unstable particles with definite momentum : It turns out that late time deviations of the survival probability of these particles from the exponential-like form of the decay law should occur much earlier than it follows from the classical standard approach resolving itself into replacing time t by t / γ (where γ is the relativistic Lorentz factor) in the formula for the survival probability ( t ).

Journal of Physics Conference Series•Aug 1, 2017•0 citations
Results presented in a recent paper "Which is the Quantum Decay Law of Relativistic particles?", arXiv: 1412.3346v2 [quant--ph]], are analyzed. We show that approximations used therein to derive the main final formula for the survival probability of finding a moving unstable particle to be undecayed at time ttt force this particle to almost stop moving, that is that, in fact, the derived formula is approximately valid only for γ≅1γ\cong 1γ≅1, where γ=1/1−β2γ= 1/\sqrt{1-β^{2}}γ=1/1−β2​ and β=v/cβ= v/cβ=v/c, or in other words, for the velocity v≃0v \simeq 0v≃0.
Late time properties of moving relativistic particles are studied. Within the proper relativistic treatment of the problem we find decay curves of such particles and we show that late time deviations of the survival probability of these particles from the exponential form of the decay law, that is the transition times region between exponential and non-exponential form of the survival amplitude, occur much earlier than it follows from the classical standard approach boiled down to replace time t by t/γL (where γL is the relativistic Lorentz factor) in the formula for the survival probability. The consequence is that fluctuations of the corresponding decay curves can appear much earlier and much more unstable particles have a chance to survive up to these times or later. It is also shown that fluctuations of the instantaneous energy of the moving unstable particles have a similar form as the fluctuations in the particle rest frame but they are seen by the observer in his rest system much earlier than one could expect replacing t by t/γL in the corresponding expressions for this energy and that the amplitude of these fluctuations can be even larger than it follows from the standard approach. All these effects seem to be important when interpreting some accelerator experiments with high energy unstable particles and the like (possible connections of these effects with GSI anomaly are analyzed) and some results of astrophysical observations.
The relativistic quantum decay laws of moving unstable particles are analyzed for a general class of mass distribution densities which behave as power laws near the (nonvanishing) lower bound μ0 of the mass spectrum. The survival probability Pp(t) , the instantaneous mass Mp(t) , and the instantaneous decay rate Γp(t) of the moving unstable particle are evaluated over short and long times for an arbitrary value p of the (constant) linear momentum. The ultrarelativistic and nonrelativistic limits are studied. Over long times, the survival probability Pp(t) is approximately related to the survival probability at rest P0(t) by a scaling law. The scaling law can be interpreted as the effect of the relativistic time dilation if the asymptotic value Mp∞ of the instantaneous mass is considered as the effective mass of the unstable particle over long times. The effective mass has magnitude μ0 at rest and moves with linear momentum p or, equivalently, with constant velocity 1/1+μ02/p2 . The instantaneous decay rate Γp(t) is approximately independent of the linear momentum p , over long times, and, consequently, is approximately invariant by changing reference frame.
We study the survival probability of moving relativistic unstable particles and we found the integral representation of the survival amplitude for such particles moving with constant momentum ~ 6 0. Using this representation of the amplitude we found decay curves of such particles for the quantum mechanical models considered. These model studies show that late time deviations of the survival probability of these particles from the exponential form of the decay law, that is the transition times region between exponential and non-exponential form of the survival probability, occur much earlier than it follows from the classical standard approach resolving itself into replacing time t by t/γ (where γ is the relativistic Lorentz factor) in the formula for the survival probability and that the survival probabilities tend to zero as t → ∞ much slower than one would expect using classical time dilation relation. Here we show also that for some physically admissible models of unstable states the properly computed decay curves of the moving particles have analogous fluctuating form as the decay curves obtained in the GSI experiment.
We study the decay law for a moving unstable particle. The usual time-dilatation formula states that the decay width for an unstable state moving with a momentum ppp and mass MMM is Γ~p=ΓM/p2+M2\tildeΓ_{p}=ΓM/\sqrt{p^{2}+M^{2}}Γ~p​=ΓM/p2+M2​ with ΓΓΓ being the decay width in the rest frame. In agreement with previous studies, we show that in the context of QM as well as QFT this equation is \textit{not} correct provided that the quantum measurement is performed in a reference frame in which the unstable particle has momentum ppp (note, a momentum eigenstate is \textit{not} a velocity eigenstate in QM). We then give, to our knowledge for the first time, an analytic expression of an improved formula and we show that the deviation from Γ~p\tildeΓ_{p}Γ~p​ has a maximum for p/M=2/3,p/M=\sqrt{2/3},p/M=2/3​, but is typically \textit{very} small. Then, the result can be easily generalized to a momentum wave packet and also to an arbitrary initial state. Here, we give a very general expression of the non-decay probability. As a next step, we show that care is needed when one makes a boost of an unstable state with zero momentum/velocity: namely, the resulting state has zero overlap with the elements of the basis of unstable states (it is already decayed!). However, when considering a spread in velocity, one finds again that Γ~p\tilde{Γ}_{p}Γ~p​ is typically a very good approximation. The study of a velocity wave-packet represents an interesting subject which constitutes one of the main outcomes of the present manuscript.\textbf{ }In the end, it should be stressed that there is no whatsoever breaking of special relativity, but as usual in QM, one should specify which kind of measurement on which kind of state is performed.
We study the survival probability of moving relativistic unstable particles with definite momentum p⃗≠0\vec{p} \neq 0p​=0. The amplitude of the survival probability of these particles is calculated using its integral representation. We found decay curves of such particles for the quantum mechanical models considered. These model studies show that late time deviations of the survival probability of these particles from the exponential form of the decay law, that is the transition times region between exponential and non-expo\-nen\-tial form of the survival probability, should occur much earlier than it follows from the classical standard approach resolving itself into replacing time ttt by t/γt/γt/γ (where γγγ is the relativistic Lorentz factor) in the formula for the survival probability and that the survival probabilities should tend to zero as t→∞t\rightarrow \inftyt→∞ much slower than one would expect using classical time dilation relation. Here we show also that for some physically admissible models of unstable states the computed decay curves of the moving particles have fluctuating form at relatively short times including times of order of the lifetime.
A detailed analysis of the quantum decay processes shows the survival probability ( t ) can not take that exponential form at any time interval including times smaller than the lifetime τ . We show that for times t ∼ τ and for the times later than τ the form of ( t ) looks as a composition of an oscillating and exponential functions. The amplitude of these oscillations is very small for t ≪ τ and grows with increasing time and depends on the model considered. We also study the survival probability of moving relativistic unstable particles with definite momentum : It turns out that late time deviations of the survival probability of these particles from the exponential-like form of the decay law should occur much earlier than it follows from the classical standard approach resolving itself into replacing time t by t / γ (where γ is the relativistic Lorentz factor) in the formula for the survival probability ( t ).