Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1502.06282

Comment on arXiv:1301.3829 and Reply to 'Comment on "Can disorder really enhance superconductivity?"' arXiv:1501.05148 by I.M. Suslov

James Mayoh, Antonio M. García-García

Published Feb 22, 2015• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In arXiv:1301.3829 and arXiv:1501.05148 I. M. Suslov proposes a theoretical description for the interplay between disorder and superconductivity that, among other things, claims to predict situations where superconductivity is enhanced by disorder. In this comment we show that Suslov's results do not make any sound predictions relating to this problem. Suslov also suggests that the percolation approach recently employed by the authors to compute the global critical temperature of inhomogeneous superconductors induced by weak multifractality is not satisfactory. We refute Suslov's opinion using simple ideas from the Bardeen-Cooper-Schiaffer (BCS) theory of superconductivity. More importantly we stress that our theory makes quantitative analytical predictions for observables such as the global critical temperature and the spatial distribution of the order parameter. Our work can therefore be easily confirmed or disproved through either numerical or experimental study.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.1502.06282

Related papers

Reply to Suslov

Keith Slevin, Tomi Ohtsuki

In a recent submission to this archive arXiv:cond-mat/0105325, Suslov has claimed that our recent numerical estimate of the critical exponent of the Anderson transition $\nu=1.57\pm.02$ is in error and that the available numerical data are consistent with a value of $\nu=1$. We contest this claim and demonstrate using Suslov's own scaling procedure that $\nu\ne 1$

•Jun 1, 2001•0 citations

Enhanced phase-coherent multifractal two-dimensional superconductivity

Bo Fan, Antonio M. García-García

We study the interplay of superconductivity and disorder by solving numerically the Bogoliubov--de Gennes equations in a two-dimensional lattice of size $80\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}80$, which makes investigating the weak-coupling limit possible. In contrast with results in the strong-coupling region, we observe enhancement of superconductivity and intriguing multifractal-like features such as a broad log-normal spatial distribution of the order parameter, a parabolic singularity spectrum, and level statistics consistent with those of a disordered metal at the Anderson transition. The calculation of the superfluid density, including small phase fluctuations, reveals that, despite this intricate spatial structure, phase coherence still holds for sufficiently weak disorder. It breaks down only for stronger disorder but before the insulating transition takes place.

arXiv:1911.09405•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Mar 18, 2020•31 citations

Distribution of the order parameter in strongly disordered superconductors: An analytic theory

Anton V. Khvalyuk, M. V. Feigel’man

We developed an analytic theory of inhomogeneous superconducting pairing in strongly disordered materials, which are moderately close to superconducting-insulator transition. Single-electron eigenstates are assumed to be Anderson localized, with a large localization volume. Superconductivity develops due to coherent delocalization of originally localized preformed Cooper pairs. The key assumption of the theory is that each such pair is coupled to a large number $Z\ensuremath{\gg}1$ of similar neighboring pairs. We derived integral equations for the probability distribution $P(\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}})$ of local superconducting order parameter $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}(\mathbit{r})$ and analyzed their solutions in the limit of small dimensionless Cooper coupling constant $\ensuremath{\lambda}\ensuremath{\ll}1$. The shape of the order-parameter distribution is found to depend crucially upon the effective number of nearest neighbors ${Z}_{\text{eff}}=2{\ensuremath{\nu}}_{0}{\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}}_{0}Z$, with ${\ensuremath{\nu}}_{0}$ being the single-particle density of states at the Fermi level. The solution we provide is valid both at large and small ${Z}_{\text{eff}}$; the latter case is nontrivial as the function $P(\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}})$ is heavily non-Gaussian. One of our key findings is the discovery of a broad range of parameters where the distribution function $P(\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}})$ is non-Gaussian but also noncritical (in the sense of superconductor-insulator transition criticality). The analytic results are supplemented by numerical data and good agreement between them is observed.

arXiv:2106.11848•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Dec 15, 2021•6 citations

Wonderful life at weak Coulomb interaction: increasing of superconducting/superfluid transition temperature by disorder

V. E. Kravtsov

We have shown that in systems where the Coulomb interaction is strongly suppressed, the superconducting transition temperature may be enhanced by disorder close to the Anderson localization transition. This phenomenon is based on the enhancement by disorder of the matrix element of attraction in the Cooper channel. For enhancement to take place one needs (i) strong disorder which makes the single-particle wave functions strongly inhomogeneous in space and (ii) strong correlation of the patterns of inhomogeneity for different wavefunctions. One case where such correlation is well known is the system close to the Anderson transition. We review the notion of multifractality of wavefunctions in this region and show how the enhancement of T c arises out of the multifractal correlations.

arXiv:1109.2515•Journal of Physics Conference Series•Jul 30, 2012•14 citations

Comment on "Nonequilibrium dynamics of superconductivity in the attractive Hubbard model"

Maxim Dzero, Emil A. Yuzbashyan, B. L. Altshuler

In a recent preprint [arXiv:1803.04118v2] Chern and Barros report numerical simulations of the mean-field interaction quench dynamics, $U_i\to U_f$, of the attractive Hubbard model that confirm our earlier prediction [Europhys. Lett. 85, 20004 (2008), arXiv:0805.2798] of spontaneous eruption of spatial inhomogeneities in the post-quench state with periodically oscillating superconducting order. Chern and Barros attribute this instability with respect to spatial fluctuations to the large magnitude of the final Hubbard coupling $U_f$. We point out that this interpretation is inaccurate and discuss further work necessary to numerically verify the mechanism of the instability and the nature of the steady state.

arXiv:1806.03474•Jun 9, 2018•2 citations

Quantum Theory of Disordered Superconductors - A Replica Approach

Yat Fan Lau

Motivated by the experimental observations of the anomalous metal states in many superconducting thin films systems, this thesis studies the interplay of disorder and interactions in superconductivity. We first demonstrate that the Fermi glass ground state is unstable in first-order perturbation theory under weak, short-ranged interaction, provided all states are localized. This finding elucidates why methods like the Hartree-Fock approximation are adequate to explain local moment formation in repulsive interactions. We then revisit the problem of dirty superconductors using a replica-symmetric BCS (RS-BCS) theory. We apply RS-BCS theory to disordered superconducting grains within the localization length, assuming the macroscopic system consists of weakly coupled grains. Besides disordered potential, We also consider regions with opposite signs of interaction exist in the grains, with net attractive interaction between electrons. Using RS-BCS mean field theory, we compute the phase diagram, tunneling density of states, and superfluid density across disorder strengths. Our results qualitatively agree with prior numerical studies for purely attractive interactions, and suggest a possible Cooper-pair-glass state when interactions of opposite signs nearly cancel.

•Jan 1, 2025•0 citations
In arXiv:1301.3829 and arXiv:1501.05148 I. M. Suslov proposes a theoretical description for the interplay between disorder and superconductivity that, among other things, claims to predict situations where superconductivity is enhanced by disorder. In this comment we show that Suslov's results do not make any sound predictions relating to this problem. Suslov also suggests that the percolation approach recently employed by the authors to compute the global critical temperature of inhomogeneous superconductors induced by weak multifractality is not satisfactory. We refute Suslov's opinion using simple ideas from the Bardeen-Cooper-Schiaffer (BCS) theory of superconductivity. More importantly we stress that our theory makes quantitative analytical predictions for observables such as the global critical temperature and the spatial distribution of the order parameter. Our work can therefore be easily confirmed or disproved through either numerical or experimental study.
In a recent submission to this archive arXiv:cond-mat/0105325, Suslov has claimed that our recent numerical estimate of the critical exponent of the Anderson transition ν=1.57±.02\nu=1.57\pm.02ν=1.57±.02 is in error and that the available numerical data are consistent with a value of ν=1\nu=1ν=1. We contest this claim and demonstrate using Suslov's own scaling procedure that ν≠1\nu\ne 1ν=1
We study the interplay of superconductivity and disorder by solving numerically the Bogoliubov--de Gennes equations in a two-dimensional lattice of size $80\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}80$, which makes investigating the weak-coupling limit possible. In contrast with results in the strong-coupling region, we observe enhancement of superconductivity and intriguing multifractal-like features such as a broad log-normal spatial distribution of the order parameter, a parabolic singularity spectrum, and level statistics consistent with those of a disordered metal at the Anderson transition. The calculation of the superfluid density, including small phase fluctuations, reveals that, despite this intricate spatial structure, phase coherence still holds for sufficiently weak disorder. It breaks down only for stronger disorder but before the insulating transition takes place.
We developed an analytic theory of inhomogeneous superconducting pairing in strongly disordered materials, which are moderately close to superconducting-insulator transition. Single-electron eigenstates are assumed to be Anderson localized, with a large localization volume. Superconductivity develops due to coherent delocalization of originally localized preformed Cooper pairs. The key assumption of the theory is that each such pair is coupled to a large number $Z\ensuremath{\gg}1$ of similar neighboring pairs. We derived integral equations for the probability distribution $P(\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}})$ of local superconducting order parameter $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}(\mathbit{r})$ and analyzed their solutions in the limit of small dimensionless Cooper coupling constant $\ensuremath{\lambda}\ensuremath{\ll}1$. The shape of the order-parameter distribution is found to depend crucially upon the effective number of nearest neighbors ${Z}_{\text{eff}}=2{\ensuremath{\nu}}_{0}{\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}}_{0}Z$, with ${\ensuremath{\nu}}_{0}$ being the single-particle density of states at the Fermi level. The solution we provide is valid both at large and small Zeff{Z}_{\text{eff}}Zeff​; the latter case is nontrivial as the function $P(\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}})$ is heavily non-Gaussian. One of our key findings is the discovery of a broad range of parameters where the distribution function $P(\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}})$ is non-Gaussian but also noncritical (in the sense of superconductor-insulator transition criticality). The analytic results are supplemented by numerical data and good agreement between them is observed.
We have shown that in systems where the Coulomb interaction is strongly suppressed, the superconducting transition temperature may be enhanced by disorder close to the Anderson localization transition. This phenomenon is based on the enhancement by disorder of the matrix element of attraction in the Cooper channel. For enhancement to take place one needs (i) strong disorder which makes the single-particle wave functions strongly inhomogeneous in space and (ii) strong correlation of the patterns of inhomogeneity for different wavefunctions. One case where such correlation is well known is the system close to the Anderson transition. We review the notion of multifractality of wavefunctions in this region and show how the enhancement of T c arises out of the multifractal correlations.
In a recent preprint [arXiv:1803.04118v2] Chern and Barros report numerical simulations of the mean-field interaction quench dynamics, Ui→UfU_i\to U_fUi​→Uf​, of the attractive Hubbard model that confirm our earlier prediction [Europhys. Lett. 85, 20004 (2008), arXiv:0805.2798] of spontaneous eruption of spatial inhomogeneities in the post-quench state with periodically oscillating superconducting order. Chern and Barros attribute this instability with respect to spatial fluctuations to the large magnitude of the final Hubbard coupling UfU_fUf​. We point out that this interpretation is inaccurate and discuss further work necessary to numerically verify the mechanism of the instability and the nature of the steady state.
Motivated by the experimental observations of the anomalous metal states in many superconducting thin films systems, this thesis studies the interplay of disorder and interactions in superconductivity. We first demonstrate that the Fermi glass ground state is unstable in first-order perturbation theory under weak, short-ranged interaction, provided all states are localized. This finding elucidates why methods like the Hartree-Fock approximation are adequate to explain local moment formation in repulsive interactions. We then revisit the problem of dirty superconductors using a replica-symmetric BCS (RS-BCS) theory. We apply RS-BCS theory to disordered superconducting grains within the localization length, assuming the macroscopic system consists of weakly coupled grains. Besides disordered potential, We also consider regions with opposite signs of interaction exist in the grains, with net attractive interaction between electrons. Using RS-BCS mean field theory, we compute the phase diagram, tunneling density of states, and superfluid density across disorder strengths. Our results qualitatively agree with prior numerical studies for purely attractive interactions, and suggest a possible Cooper-pair-glass state when interactions of opposite signs nearly cancel.