© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

Terms Privacy Legal Notice

arXiv:1502.00207

Quantum game players can have advantage without discord

Zhaohui Wei, Shengyu Zhang

Published Feb 1, 2015• 0 citations

Abstract

The last two decades have witnessed a rapid development of quantum information processing, a new paradigm which studies the power and limit of "quantum advantages" in various information processing tasks. Problems such as when quantum advantage exists, and if existing, how much it could be, are at a central position of these studies. In a broad class of scenarios, there are, implicitly or explicitly, at least two parties involved, who share a state, and the correlation in this shared state is the key factor to the efficiency under concern. In these scenarios, the shared \emph{entanglement} or \emph{discord} is usually what accounts for quantum advantage. In this paper, we examine a fundamental problem of this nature from the perspective of game theory, a branch of applied mathematics studying selfish behaviors of two or more players. We exhibit a natural zero-sum game, in which the chance for any player to win the game depends only on the ending correlation. We show that in a certain classical equilibrium, a situation in which no player can further increase her payoff by any local classical operation, whoever first uses a quantum computer has a big advantage over its classical opponent. The equilibrium is fair to both players and, as a shared correlation, it does not contain any discord, yet a quantum advantage still exists. This indicates that at least in game theory, the previous notion of discord as a measure of non-classical correlation needs to be reexamined, when there are two players with different objectives.

DOI: 10.48550/arxiv.1502.00207

Related papers

Quantum Locality in Game Strategy

Carlos A. Melo-Luna, Cristian E. Susa, Andrés F. Ducuara +2 more

Game theory is a well established branch of mathematics whose formalism has a vast range of applications from the social sciences, biology, to economics. Motivated by quantum information science, there has been a leap in the formulation of novel game strategies that lead to new (quantum Nash) equilibrium points whereby players in some classical games are always outperformed if sharing and processing joint information ruled by the laws of quantum physics is allowed. We show that, for a bipartite non zero-sum game, input local quantum correlations, and separable states in particular, suffice to achieve an advantage over any strategy that uses classical resources, thus dispensing with quantum nonlocality, entanglement, or even discord between the players' input states. This highlights the remarkable key role played by pure quantum coherence at powering some protocols. Finally, we propose an experiment that uses separable states and basic photon interferometry to demonstrate the locally-correlated quantum advantage.

arXiv:1609.06389•Scientific Reports•Mar 22, 2017•31 citations

Experimental demonstration of quantum gain in a zero-sum game

Chong Zu, Yuexuan Wang, Xiuying Chang +3 more

We propose and experimentally demonstrate a zero-sum game that is in a fair Nash equilibrium for classical players, but has the property that a quantum player can always win using an appropriate strategy. The gain of the quantum player is measured experimentally for different quantum strategies and input states. It is found that the quantum gain is maximized by a maximally entangled state, but does not decrease to zero when entanglement disappears. Instead, it links with another kind of quantum correlation described by discord for the qubit case and the connection is demonstrated both theoretically and experimentally.

APS•Jun 1, 2012•3 citations

Experimental demonstration of quantum gain in a zero-sum game

Chong Zu, Y.-X. Wang, X.-Y. Chang +3 more

We propose and experimentally demonstrate a zero-sum game that is in a fair Nash equilibrium for classical players, but has the property that a quantum player can always win using an appropriate strategy. The gain of the quantum player is measured experimentally for different quantum strategies and input states. It is found that the quantum gain is maximized by a maximally entangled state, but does not decrease to zero when entanglement disappears. Instead, it links with another kind of quantum correlation described by discord for the qubit case and the connection is demonstrated both theoretically and experimentally.

New Journal of Physics•Mar 1, 2012•18 citations

Quantum Advantage for Shared Randomness Generation

Tamal Guha, Mir Alimuddin, Sumit Rout +3 more

Sharing correlated random variables is a resource for a number of information theoretic tasks such as privacy amplification, simultaneous message passing, secret sharing and many more. In this article, we show that to establish such a resource called shared randomness, quantum systems provide an advantage over their classical counterpart. Precisely, we show that appropriate albeit fixed measurements on a shared two-qubit state can generate correlations which cannot be obtained from any possible state on two classical bits. In a resource theoretic set-up, this feature of quantum systems can be interpreted as an advantage in winning a two players co-operative game, which we call the `non-monopolize social subsidy' game. It turns out that the quantum states leading to the desired advantage must possess non-classicality in the form of quantum discord. On the other hand, while distributing such sources of shared randomness between two parties via noisy channels, quantum channels with zero capacity as well as with classical capacity strictly less than unity perform more efficiently than the perfect classical channel. Protocols presented here are noise-robust and hence should be realizable with state-of-the-art quantum devices.

arXiv:2001.01889•Quantum•Oct 27, 2021•13 citations

Quantum Advantage in Shared Randomness Processing

Tamal Guha, Mir Alimuddin, Sumit Rout +3 more

Randomness appears both in classical stochastic physics and in quantum mechanics. A number of communication models and other information protocols entail sharing randomness among distant parties. Here we report a computational scenario of shared randomness processing where quantum sources manifest clear-cut precedence over the corresponding classical counterparts. The advantage is established in a resource theoretic set-up which we formalize in this work. The classical mutual information turns out to be a faithful resource quantifier of shared randomness although it does not sufficiently characterize all possible transitions among the resources. Quantum theory exhibits advantage in shared randomness processing in the sense that the set of resourceful states obtained under free operation from a bipartite quantum system is strictly larger than the set obtained from an analogous classical system. Interestingly, the quantum advantage can be manifested in the optimal payoff of a two players co-operative game -- the `non-monopolize social subsidy' game. We also show that the quantum states resulting to the desired advantage necessitates nonclassicality in the form of quantum discord. We then address the task of distributing shared randomness between two parties. Quite interestingly, it turns out that noisy quantum channel can exhibit advantage even when it has zero quantum capacity and classical capacity much less than the corresponding classical channel. The imperfect channel examples facilitates and welcomes experiment to achieve the reported quantum advantage with presently available quantum devices.

•Jan 7, 2020•0 citations

Quantum advantage beyond entanglement in Bayesian game theory

Adam Lowe

Abstract Quantum discord has been utilised in order to find quantum advantage in an extension of the Clauser, Horne, Shimony, and Holt game. By writing the game explicitly as a Bayesian game, the resulting game is modified such the payoff’s are different. Crucially, restrictions are imposed on the measurements that Alice and Bob can perform. By imposing these restrictions, it is found that there exists quantum advantage beyond entanglement for a given quantum state. This is shown by decomposing the expected payoff into a classical and quantum term. By optimising over the expected payoff, the classical limit is surpassed for the given state in the restricted measurement space. This gives an operational framework in order to witness and determine the quantum discord for specific states, whilst demonstrating the importance of measurement in quantum advantage.

arXiv:2306.05090•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Jan 8, 2024•3 citations

The last two decades have witnessed a rapid development of quantum information processing, a new paradigm which studies the power and limit of "quantum advantages" in various information processing tasks. Problems such as when quantum advantage exists, and if existing, how much it could be, are at a central position of these studies. In a broad class of scenarios, there are, implicitly or explicitly, at least two parties involved, who share a state, and the correlation in this shared state is the key factor to the efficiency under concern. In these scenarios, the shared \emph{entanglement} or \emph{discord} is usually what accounts for quantum advantage. In this paper, we examine a fundamental problem of this nature from the perspective of game theory, a branch of applied mathematics studying selfish behaviors of two or more players. We exhibit a natural zero-sum game, in which the chance for any player to win the game depends only on the ending correlation. We show that in a certain classical equilibrium, a situation in which no player can further increase her payoff by any local classical operation, whoever first uses a quantum computer has a big advantage over its classical opponent. The equilibrium is fair to both players and, as a shared correlation, it does not contain any discord, yet a quantum advantage still exists. This indicates that at least in game theory, the previous notion of discord as a measure of non-classical correlation needs to be reexamined, when there are two players with different objectives.

Game theory is a well established branch of mathematics whose formalism has a vast range of applications from the social sciences, biology, to economics. Motivated by quantum information science, there has been a leap in the formulation of novel game strategies that lead to new (quantum Nash) equilibrium points whereby players in some classical games are always outperformed if sharing and processing joint information ruled by the laws of quantum physics is allowed. We show that, for a bipartite non zero-sum game, input local quantum correlations, and separable states in particular, suffice to achieve an advantage over any strategy that uses classical resources, thus dispensing with quantum nonlocality, entanglement, or even discord between the players' input states. This highlights the remarkable key role played by pure quantum coherence at powering some protocols. Finally, we propose an experiment that uses separable states and basic photon interferometry to demonstrate the locally-correlated quantum advantage.

We propose and experimentally demonstrate a zero-sum game that is in a fair Nash equilibrium for classical players, but has the property that a quantum player can always win using an appropriate strategy. The gain of the quantum player is measured experimentally for different quantum strategies and input states. It is found that the quantum gain is maximized by a maximally entangled state, but does not decrease to zero when entanglement disappears. Instead, it links with another kind of quantum correlation described by discord for the qubit case and the connection is demonstrated both theoretically and experimentally.

We propose and experimentally demonstrate a zero-sum game that is in a fair Nash equilibrium for classical players, but has the property that a quantum player can always win using an appropriate strategy. The gain of the quantum player is measured experimentally for different quantum strategies and input states. It is found that the quantum gain is maximized by a maximally entangled state, but does not decrease to zero when entanglement disappears. Instead, it links with another kind of quantum correlation described by discord for the qubit case and the connection is demonstrated both theoretically and experimentally.

Sharing correlated random variables is a resource for a number of information theoretic tasks such as privacy amplification, simultaneous message passing, secret sharing and many more. In this article, we show that to establish such a resource called shared randomness, quantum systems provide an advantage over their classical counterpart. Precisely, we show that appropriate albeit fixed measurements on a shared two-qubit state can generate correlations which cannot be obtained from any possible state on two classical bits. In a resource theoretic set-up, this feature of quantum systems can be interpreted as an advantage in winning a two players co-operative game, which we call the `non-monopolize social subsidy' game. It turns out that the quantum states leading to the desired advantage must possess non-classicality in the form of quantum discord. On the other hand, while distributing such sources of shared randomness between two parties via noisy channels, quantum channels with zero capacity as well as with classical capacity strictly less than unity perform more efficiently than the perfect classical channel. Protocols presented here are noise-robust and hence should be realizable with state-of-the-art quantum devices.

Randomness appears both in classical stochastic physics and in quantum mechanics. A number of communication models and other information protocols entail sharing randomness among distant parties. Here we report a computational scenario of shared randomness processing where quantum sources manifest clear-cut precedence over the corresponding classical counterparts. The advantage is established in a resource theoretic set-up which we formalize in this work. The classical mutual information turns out to be a faithful resource quantifier of shared randomness although it does not sufficiently characterize all possible transitions among the resources. Quantum theory exhibits advantage in shared randomness processing in the sense that the set of resourceful states obtained under free operation from a bipartite quantum system is strictly larger than the set obtained from an analogous classical system. Interestingly, the quantum advantage can be manifested in the optimal payoff of a two players co-operative game -- the `non-monopolize social subsidy' game. We also show that the quantum states resulting to the desired advantage necessitates nonclassicality in the form of quantum discord. We then address the task of distributing shared randomness between two parties. Quite interestingly, it turns out that noisy quantum channel can exhibit advantage even when it has zero quantum capacity and classical capacity much less than the corresponding classical channel. The imperfect channel examples facilitates and welcomes experiment to achieve the reported quantum advantage with presently available quantum devices.

Abstract Quantum discord has been utilised in order to find quantum advantage in an extension of the Clauser, Horne, Shimony, and Holt game. By writing the game explicitly as a Bayesian game, the resulting game is modified such the payoff’s are different. Crucially, restrictions are imposed on the measurements that Alice and Bob can perform. By imposing these restrictions, it is found that there exists quantum advantage beyond entanglement for a given quantum state. This is shown by decomposing the expected payoff into a classical and quantum term. By optimising over the expected payoff, the classical limit is surpassed for the given state in the restricted measurement space. This gives an operational framework in order to witness and determine the quantum discord for specific states, whilst demonstrating the importance of measurement in quantum advantage.