Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1410.5418

The Dirac equation without zitterbewegung

Michael B. Heaney

Published Oct 19, 2014• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

This paper presents a relativistic symmetrical interpretation of the Dirac equation in 1+1 dimensions which predicts no zitterbewegung for a free spin-1/2 particle. This could resolve the longstanding puzzle of zitterbewegung in relativistic quantum mechanics, and help clarify the physical meaning of the zitterbewegung currently under investigation in many-particle systems. Together with an earlier paper describing a relativistic symmetrical interpretation of the Klein-Gordon equation \cite{Heaney1}, this new interpretation resolves some inconsistencies in the conventional interpretations of both equations. This new interpretation also makes several experimental predictions that differ from the conventional interpretation of the Dirac equation.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.1410.5418

Related papers

A Relativistic Symmetrical Interpretation of the Dirac Equation in (1+1) Dimensions

Michael B. Heaney

This paper presents a new Relativistic Symmetrical Interpretation (RSI) of the Dirac equation in (1+1)D which postulates: quantum mechanics is intrinsically time-symmetric, with no arrow of time; the fundamental objects of quantum mechanics are transitions; a transition is fully described by a complex transition amplitude density with specified initial and final boundary conditions; and transition amplitude densities never collapse. This RSI is compared to the Copenhagen Interpretation (CI) for the analysis of Einstein's bubble experiment with a spin-$\frac{1}{2}$ particle. This RSI can predict the future and retrodict the past, has no zitterbewegung, resolves some inconsistencies of the CI, and eliminates some of the conceptual problems of the CI.

arXiv:1510.07972•Oct 25, 2015•0 citations

Relativistic wave equation for particles

Jyotirmoy Guha

We underscore the need of relativistic quantum mechanics in dealing with particles. Various notations used in relativity are defined and explained. We derive the Klein–Gordon equation for free particle as well as for particle in electromagnetic field. We obtain a solution and interpret it. We derive the Dirac equation for free particle as well as for particle in electromagnetic field. Plane wave solution to the Dirac equation is obtained. We show how spin of electron, idea of antiparticle , phenomena of pair production and pair annihilation follow from the Dirac equation.

Institute of Physics eBooks•Nov 1, 2024•0 citations

The Dirac equation: historical context, comparisons with the Schrödinger and Klein–Gordon equations, and elementary consequences

Thiago Takaji Tsutsui, Edilberto Oliveira Silva, Antonio S. M. de Castro +1 more

Abstract This paper offers educational insight into the Dirac equation, examining its historical context and contrasting it with the earlier Schrödinger and Klein–Gordon equations. The comparison highlights their Lorentz transformation symmetry and potential probabilistic interpretations. We explicitly solve the free particle dynamics in Dirac’s model, revealing the emergence of solutions with negative energy. In this discussion, we examine the Dirac Sea Hypothesis and explore the inherent helicity of the solutions. Additionally, we demonstrate how the Dirac equation accounts for spin and derive the Pauli equation in the non-relativistic limit. Through the Foldy–Wouthuysen transformation, we reveal how the equation incorporates spin–orbit interaction and other relativistic effects, ultimately leading to the hydrogen fine structure. A section on relativistic covariant notation is included to emphasize the invariance of the Dirac equation, along with more refined formulations of both the Klein–Gordon and Dirac equations. Designed for undergraduate students with an interest in the Dirac equation, this resource provides a historical perspective without being purely theoretical. Our approach underscores the significance of a pedagogical method that combines historical and comparative elements to profoundly understand the role of the Dirac equation in modern physics.

arXiv:2504.17797•European Journal of Physics•Aug 8, 2025•0 citations

Spin Operators for Massive Particles

Taeseung Choi, Sam Young Cho

Since the discovery a century ago, spin describing the intrinsic angular momentum of massive elementary particles has exposed its nature and significant roles in wide ranges of (relativistic) quantum phenomena and practical applications for future quantum technology. Emerging inconsistencies have also disclosed its telltale incomplete description. Finding relativistic spins (operators) of massive particles is a long-standing fundamental problem from the beginning of relativistic quantum mechanics. Here we present the rigorous derivation and the representation of spin operators from the spacetime symmetry. The covariant parity operation, defined by the spin operators, naturally leads to a fundamental equation equivalent to the covariant Dirac equation, which manifests existent relativistic spins. Proper understanding position operator in the Dirac theory on account of the spin operator through total angular momentum predicts no Zitterbewegung as well as conserving orbital and spin currents. The spin operators can be applicable for unraveling the inconsistencies and for exploring unveiled physics of massive particles.

arXiv:1410.0468•Oct 2, 2014•0 citations

Relativistic Equations. An Introduction

Ana Marı́a Cetto, Luis de la Peña

Chapter 19 introduces relativistic quantum mechanics, with the aim of providing the student with a basic knowledge of the subject and a link to more advanced courses in relativistic quantum theory. It begins by showing that when the Schrödinger equation is modified to make it consistent with special relativity, the result is the Klein–Gordon equation, which gives better qualitative agreement with experiment. Introducing the electron spin into the Schrödinger equation leads to the Pauli equation, which gives rise to important spin effects. By considering both special relativity and spin, one obtains the Dirac and the van der Waerden equations. The main properties and implications of Dirac’s equation are discussed, including the electron’s zitterbewegung. The solution of Dirac’s equation for the free particle is presented in detail, the hydrogen-like atom is shown to be exactly solvable, and the particle in an external electromagnetic field is included as a complementary material.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Dec 18, 2025•0 citations

Free Particles/Antiparticles

P. Strange

As in non-relativistic quantum theory, the simplest problem to solve in relativistic quantum theory is that of describing a free particle. Much can be learned from this case which will be of use in interpreting the topics covered in later chapters. Furthermore, some of the most profound features of relativistic quantum theory are well illustrated by the free particle, so it is a very instructive problem to consider in detail. Another advantage of the free-particle problem is that the mathematics involved in solving it is not nearly as involved as that necessary for solving problems involving particles under the influence of potentials. Firstly we shall look briefly at the formulae for the current and probability density, then we shall go on to examine the solutions of the Dirac equation and investigate their behaviour. This leads us to a discussion of spin, the Pauli limit, and the relativistic spin operator. Next we consider the negative energy solutions and show how relativistic quantum theory predicts the existence of antiparticles. Some of the dilemmas this concept introduces and their resolution are discussed. At the end of the chapter we go back to the Klein paradox, and examine it for an incident spin-1/2 particle. We find that the Klein paradox exists for Dirac particles in exactly the same way as it existed for Klein—Gordon particles and has the same resolution and interpretation.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Sep 17, 1998•0 citations
This paper presents a relativistic symmetrical interpretation of the Dirac equation in 1+1 dimensions which predicts no zitterbewegung for a free spin-1/2 particle. This could resolve the longstanding puzzle of zitterbewegung in relativistic quantum mechanics, and help clarify the physical meaning of the zitterbewegung currently under investigation in many-particle systems. Together with an earlier paper describing a relativistic symmetrical interpretation of the Klein-Gordon equation \cite{Heaney1}, this new interpretation resolves some inconsistencies in the conventional interpretations of both equations. This new interpretation also makes several experimental predictions that differ from the conventional interpretation of the Dirac equation.
This paper presents a new Relativistic Symmetrical Interpretation (RSI) of the Dirac equation in (1+1)D which postulates: quantum mechanics is intrinsically time-symmetric, with no arrow of time; the fundamental objects of quantum mechanics are transitions; a transition is fully described by a complex transition amplitude density with specified initial and final boundary conditions; and transition amplitude densities never collapse. This RSI is compared to the Copenhagen Interpretation (CI) for the analysis of Einstein's bubble experiment with a spin-12\frac{1}{2}21​ particle. This RSI can predict the future and retrodict the past, has no zitterbewegung, resolves some inconsistencies of the CI, and eliminates some of the conceptual problems of the CI.
We underscore the need of relativistic quantum mechanics in dealing with particles. Various notations used in relativity are defined and explained. We derive the Klein–Gordon equation for free particle as well as for particle in electromagnetic field. We obtain a solution and interpret it. We derive the Dirac equation for free particle as well as for particle in electromagnetic field. Plane wave solution to the Dirac equation is obtained. We show how spin of electron, idea of antiparticle , phenomena of pair production and pair annihilation follow from the Dirac equation.
Abstract This paper offers educational insight into the Dirac equation, examining its historical context and contrasting it with the earlier Schrödinger and Klein–Gordon equations. The comparison highlights their Lorentz transformation symmetry and potential probabilistic interpretations. We explicitly solve the free particle dynamics in Dirac’s model, revealing the emergence of solutions with negative energy. In this discussion, we examine the Dirac Sea Hypothesis and explore the inherent helicity of the solutions. Additionally, we demonstrate how the Dirac equation accounts for spin and derive the Pauli equation in the non-relativistic limit. Through the Foldy–Wouthuysen transformation, we reveal how the equation incorporates spin–orbit interaction and other relativistic effects, ultimately leading to the hydrogen fine structure. A section on relativistic covariant notation is included to emphasize the invariance of the Dirac equation, along with more refined formulations of both the Klein–Gordon and Dirac equations. Designed for undergraduate students with an interest in the Dirac equation, this resource provides a historical perspective without being purely theoretical. Our approach underscores the significance of a pedagogical method that combines historical and comparative elements to profoundly understand the role of the Dirac equation in modern physics.
Since the discovery a century ago, spin describing the intrinsic angular momentum of massive elementary particles has exposed its nature and significant roles in wide ranges of (relativistic) quantum phenomena and practical applications for future quantum technology. Emerging inconsistencies have also disclosed its telltale incomplete description. Finding relativistic spins (operators) of massive particles is a long-standing fundamental problem from the beginning of relativistic quantum mechanics. Here we present the rigorous derivation and the representation of spin operators from the spacetime symmetry. The covariant parity operation, defined by the spin operators, naturally leads to a fundamental equation equivalent to the covariant Dirac equation, which manifests existent relativistic spins. Proper understanding position operator in the Dirac theory on account of the spin operator through total angular momentum predicts no Zitterbewegung as well as conserving orbital and spin currents. The spin operators can be applicable for unraveling the inconsistencies and for exploring unveiled physics of massive particles.
Chapter 19 introduces relativistic quantum mechanics, with the aim of providing the student with a basic knowledge of the subject and a link to more advanced courses in relativistic quantum theory. It begins by showing that when the Schrödinger equation is modified to make it consistent with special relativity, the result is the Klein–Gordon equation, which gives better qualitative agreement with experiment. Introducing the electron spin into the Schrödinger equation leads to the Pauli equation, which gives rise to important spin effects. By considering both special relativity and spin, one obtains the Dirac and the van der Waerden equations. The main properties and implications of Dirac’s equation are discussed, including the electron’s zitterbewegung. The solution of Dirac’s equation for the free particle is presented in detail, the hydrogen-like atom is shown to be exactly solvable, and the particle in an external electromagnetic field is included as a complementary material.
As in non-relativistic quantum theory, the simplest problem to solve in relativistic quantum theory is that of describing a free particle. Much can be learned from this case which will be of use in interpreting the topics covered in later chapters. Furthermore, some of the most profound features of relativistic quantum theory are well illustrated by the free particle, so it is a very instructive problem to consider in detail. Another advantage of the free-particle problem is that the mathematics involved in solving it is not nearly as involved as that necessary for solving problems involving particles under the influence of potentials. Firstly we shall look briefly at the formulae for the current and probability density, then we shall go on to examine the solutions of the Dirac equation and investigate their behaviour. This leads us to a discussion of spin, the Pauli limit, and the relativistic spin operator. Next we consider the negative energy solutions and show how relativistic quantum theory predicts the existence of antiparticles. Some of the dilemmas this concept introduces and their resolution are discussed. At the end of the chapter we go back to the Klein paradox, and examine it for an incident spin-1/2 particle. We find that the Klein paradox exists for Dirac particles in exactly the same way as it existed for Klein—Gordon particles and has the same resolution and interpretation.