Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1409.8322 · Physical Review E

Fixed-point structure and effective fractional dimensionality for O( N ) models with long-range interactions

Nicolò Defenu, Andrea Trombettoni, Alessandro Codello

Published Nov 11, 2015• 95 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We study, by renormalization group methods, $\mathrm{O}(N)$ models with interactions decaying as power law with exponent $d+\ensuremath{\sigma}$. When only the long-range momentum term ${p}^{\ensuremath{\sigma}}$ is considered in the propagator, the critical exponents can be computed from those of the corresponding short-range $\mathrm{O}(N)$ models at an effective fractional dimension ${D}_{\mathrm{eff}}$. Neglecting wave function renormalization effects the result for the effective dimension is ${D}_{\mathrm{eff}}=\frac{2d}{\ensuremath{\sigma}}$, which turns to be exact in the spherical model limit $(N\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\infty})$. Introducing a running wave function renormalization term the effective dimension becomes instead ${D}_{\mathrm{eff}}=\frac{(2\ensuremath{-}{\ensuremath{\eta}}_{\mathrm{SR}})d}{\ensuremath{\sigma}}$. The latter result coincides with the one found using standard scaling arguments. Explicit results in two and three dimensions are given for the exponent $\ensuremath{\nu}$. We propose an improved method to describe the full theory space of the models where both short- and long-range propagator terms are present and no a priori choice among the two in the renormalization group flow is done. The eigenvalue spectrum of the full theory for all possible fixed points is drawn and a full description of the fixed-point structure is given, including multicritical long-range universality classes. The effective dimension is shown to be only approximate, and the resulting error is estimated.

DOI
10.1103/physreve.92.052113

Related papers

Universality in long-range interacting systems: The effective dimension approach

Andrea Solfanelli, Nicolò Defenu

Dimensional correspondences have a long history in critical phenomena. Here, we review the effective dimension approach, which relates the scaling exponents of a critical system in d spatial dimensions with power-law decaying interactions r^{d+σ} to a local system, i.e., with finite-range interactions, in an effective fractal dimension d_{eff}. This method simplifies the study of long-range models by leveraging known results from their local counterparts. While the validity of this approximation beyond the mean-field level has been long debated, we demonstrate that the effective dimension approach, while approximate for non-Gaussian fixed points, accurately estimates the critical exponents of long-range models with an accuracy typically larger than 97%. To do so, we review perturbative renormalization-group (RG) results, extend the approximation's validity using functional RG techniques, and compare our findings with precise numerical data from conformal bootstrap for the two-dimensional Ising model with long-range interactions.

arXiv:2406.14651•Physical review. E•Oct 17, 2024•7 citations

Renormalization group for the φ4 theory with long-range interaction and the critical exponent η of the Ising model

Raphael Goll, Peter Kopietz

We calculate the critical exponent η of the D-dimensional Ising model from a simple truncation of the functional renormalization group flow equations for a scalar field theory with long-range interaction. Our approach relies on the smallness of the inverse range of the interaction and on the assumption that the Ginzburg momentum defining the width of the scaling regime in momentum space is larger than the scale where the renormalized interaction crosses over from long range to short range; the numerical value of η can then be estimated by stopping the renormalization group flow at this scale. In three dimensions our result η=0.03651 is in good agreement with recent conformal bootstrap and Monte Carlo calculations. We extend our calculations to fractional dimensions D and obtain the resulting critical exponent η(D) between two and four dimensions. For dimensions 2≤D≤3 our result for η is consistent with previous calculations.

arXiv:1804.04150•Physical review. E•Aug 28, 2018•6 citations

Perturbative Renormalization and Universality Diagram for Long-Range Quantum Criticality

Zhiyi Li, Zhijie Fan, Kun Chen +1 more

Experimental progress in quantum simulators highlights the role of long-range (LR) interactions in reshaping quantum criticality and stabilizing exotic phases beyond the short-range (SR) paradigm. We study ferromagnetic long-range quantum $O(n)$ models with interactions decaying as $1/r^{d+σ}$ and develop a perturbative renormalization-group expansion around the LR--SR boundary by setting $d=3-ε$ and $σ=2-δ$. In this parametrization, the full interacting LR window $2d/3<σ<2$ becomes $0<δ<2ε/3$, and is therefore perturbatively controlled. A two-loop calculation yields explicit expressions, in terms of $ε$, $δ$, and $n$, for the correlation-length exponent $ν$ and for the frequency and momentum anomalous dimensions $η_ω$ and $η_k$. The resulting exponents reduce to long-range Gaussian scaling at $σ=2d/3$ and to SR quantum Wilson-Fisher scaling in the $σ\to 2$ limit, thereby identifying $σ_*=2$ as the LR--SR boundary within the controlled $3-ε$ expansion. Combining the RG results with scaling boundaries and classical LR analogies, we propose a $(d,σ)$ universality diagram for ferromagnetic long-range quantum $O(n)$ criticality and use it as an organizing framework for the phase diagram of long-range quantum spin chains.

cond-mat.stat-mechCross-listedarXiv:2606.22407•Jun 23, 2026•0 citations

Theory of critical phenomena with long-range temporal interaction

Shaolong Zeng, Fan Zhong

Abstract We systematically develop theories of critical phenomena with a prior formed memory of a power-law decaying long-range temporal interaction parameterized by a constant θ > 0 for a space dimension d both below and above an upper critical dimension d c = 6 − 2/θ. We first provide more evidences to confirm the previous theory that a dimensional constant d t is demanded to rectify a hyperscaling law, to produce correct unique mean-field critical exponents via an effective spatial dimension originating from temporal dimension, and to transform the time and change the dynamic critical exponent. Next, for d < d c , we develop a renormalization-group theory by employing the momentum-shell technique to the leading nontrivial order explicitly and to higher orders formally in ϵ = d c − d but to zero order in ε = 1 − θ and find that more scaling laws besides the hyperscaling law are broken due to the breaking of the fluctuation-dissipation theorem. Moreover, because dynamics and statics are intimately interwoven, even the static critical exponents involve contributions from the dynamics and hence do not restore the short-range exponents even for θ = 1 and the crossover between the short-range and long-range fixed points is discontinuous contrary to the case of long-range spatial interaction. In addition, a new scaling law relating the dynamic critical exponent with the static ones emerges, indicating that the dynamic critical exponent is not independent. However, once d t is displaced by a series of ϵ and ε such that most values of the critical exponents are changed, all scaling laws are saved again, even though the fluctuation-dissipation theorem keeps violating. Then, for d ≥ d c , we develop an effective-dimension theory by carefully discriminating the corrections of both temporal and spatial dimensions and find three different regions. For d ≥ d c0 = 4, the upper critical dimension of the usual short-range theory, the usual Landau mean-field theory with fluctuations confined to the effective-dimension equal to d c0 correctly describe the critical phenomena with memory, while for d c < d ≤ 4, there exist new universality classes whose critical exponents depend only on the space dimension but not at all on θ. Yet another region consists of d = d c only and the previous theory is retrieved. All these results show that the dimensional constant d t is the fundamental ingredient of the theories for critical phenomena with memory. However, its value continuously varies with the space dimension and vanishes exactly at d = 4, reflecting the variation of the amount of the temporal dimension that is transferred to the spatial one with the strength of fluctuations. Moreover, special finite-size scaling appears ubiquitously except for d = d c0.

arXiv:2212.11076•Physica Scripta•Jun 8, 2023•3 citations

The 4-εεε Expansion for Long-range Interacting Systems

Zhiyi Li, Kun Chen, Youjin Deng

The establishment of the Wilson-Fisher fixed point (WFP) for $O(n)$ spin models in $d=4-ε$ dimensions stands as a cornerstone of the renormalization group (RG) theory for critical phenomena. However, when long-range (LR) interactions, algebraically decaying as $\propto 1/r^{d+σ}$, are introduced, the fate of the short-range WFP (SR-WFP) has remained a subject of intense debate since the 1970s. We employ two complementary techniques -- the standard field-theoretic RG and a perturbative bootstrap scheme, and perform the $ε$-expansion calculations up to the two-loop level. We show that, as long as $σ<2$, the SR-WFP becomes unstable and a stable LR-WFP emerges, and, in the non-classical regime with $d/2 < σ< 2$, the critical exponents, including the anomalous dimension, are functions of $ε$, $δ=2-σ$ and $n$, which reduce to the exact results in the limiting cases $ε\to 0$, $δ\to 0$ or $n \to \infty$. Our $(4-ε)$-expansion calculations support the scenario that the threshold between the LR- and SR-WFP occurs strictly at $σ_*=2$, well consistent with the recent high-precision numerical study while different from the widely accepted Sak's criterion.

arXiv:2602.07818•Feb 8, 2026•0 citations

Long-range random-field models: scaling theory and 1/n expansion

Alan J. Bray

Random-field models are considered with long-range exchange, J(r) approximately 1/r d+ sigma , and/or long-range correlated random fields, (h(r)h(r')) approximately 1/ mod r-r' mod d- rho . A general scaling analysis is presented, in which the existence of three independent critical exponents is emphasized. Four different universality classes are identified, according to whether the fixed point controlling the critical behaviour is of short-range or long-range character for the exchange and/or the random-field correlations. The lines in the rho - sigma plane at which the long-range couplings first become relevant are expressed in terms of the exponents eta and eta of the corresponding short-range problem: long-range exchange is relevant for sigma <2- eta , long-range field correlations for rho >2 eta - eta . The scaling results are confirmed and amplified by explicit calculations of three independent exponents of the n-component spin model, correct to order 1/n. The results reveal errors in published expansions around the upper critical dimension.

Journal of Physics C Solid State Physics•Nov 10, 1986•25 citations
We study, by renormalization group methods, O(N)\mathrm{O}(N)O(N) models with interactions decaying as power law with exponent d+\ensuremathσd+\ensuremath{\sigma}d+\ensuremathσ. When only the long-range momentum term p\ensuremathσ{p}^{\ensuremath{\sigma}}p\ensuremathσ is considered in the propagator, the critical exponents can be computed from those of the corresponding short-range O(N)\mathrm{O}(N)O(N) models at an effective fractional dimension Deff{D}_{\mathrm{eff}}Deff​. Neglecting wave function renormalization effects the result for the effective dimension is Deff=2d\ensuremathσ{D}_{\mathrm{eff}}=\frac{2d}{\ensuremath{\sigma}}Deff​=\ensuremathσ2d​, which turns to be exact in the spherical model limit (N\ensuremath→\ensuremath∞)(N\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\infty})(N\ensuremath→\ensuremath∞). Introducing a running wave function renormalization term the effective dimension becomes instead Deff=(2\ensuremath−\ensuremathηSR)d\ensuremathσ{D}_{\mathrm{eff}}=\frac{(2\ensuremath{-}{\ensuremath{\eta}}_{\mathrm{SR}})d}{\ensuremath{\sigma}}Deff​=\ensuremathσ(2\ensuremath−\ensuremathηSR​)d​. The latter result coincides with the one found using standard scaling arguments. Explicit results in two and three dimensions are given for the exponent \ensuremathν\ensuremath{\nu}\ensuremathν. We propose an improved method to describe the full theory space of the models where both short- and long-range propagator terms are present and no a priori choice among the two in the renormalization group flow is done. The eigenvalue spectrum of the full theory for all possible fixed points is drawn and a full description of the fixed-point structure is given, including multicritical long-range universality classes. The effective dimension is shown to be only approximate, and the resulting error is estimated.
Dimensional correspondences have a long history in critical phenomena. Here, we review the effective dimension approach, which relates the scaling exponents of a critical system in d spatial dimensions with power-law decaying interactions r^{d+σ} to a local system, i.e., with finite-range interactions, in an effective fractal dimension d_{eff}. This method simplifies the study of long-range models by leveraging known results from their local counterparts. While the validity of this approximation beyond the mean-field level has been long debated, we demonstrate that the effective dimension approach, while approximate for non-Gaussian fixed points, accurately estimates the critical exponents of long-range models with an accuracy typically larger than 97%. To do so, we review perturbative renormalization-group (RG) results, extend the approximation's validity using functional RG techniques, and compare our findings with precise numerical data from conformal bootstrap for the two-dimensional Ising model with long-range interactions.
We calculate the critical exponent η of the D-dimensional Ising model from a simple truncation of the functional renormalization group flow equations for a scalar field theory with long-range interaction. Our approach relies on the smallness of the inverse range of the interaction and on the assumption that the Ginzburg momentum defining the width of the scaling regime in momentum space is larger than the scale where the renormalized interaction crosses over from long range to short range; the numerical value of η can then be estimated by stopping the renormalization group flow at this scale. In three dimensions our result η=0.03651 is in good agreement with recent conformal bootstrap and Monte Carlo calculations. We extend our calculations to fractional dimensions D and obtain the resulting critical exponent η(D) between two and four dimensions. For dimensions 2≤D≤3 our result for η is consistent with previous calculations.
Experimental progress in quantum simulators highlights the role of long-range (LR) interactions in reshaping quantum criticality and stabilizing exotic phases beyond the short-range (SR) paradigm. We study ferromagnetic long-range quantum O(n)O(n)O(n) models with interactions decaying as 1/rd+σ1/r^{d+σ}1/rd+σ and develop a perturbative renormalization-group expansion around the LR--SR boundary by setting d=3−εd=3-εd=3−ε and σ=2−δσ=2-δσ=2−δ. In this parametrization, the full interacting LR window 2d/3<σ<22d/3<σ<22d/3<σ<2 becomes 0<δ<2ε/30<δ<2ε/30<δ<2ε/3, and is therefore perturbatively controlled. A two-loop calculation yields explicit expressions, in terms of εεε, δδδ, and nnn, for the correlation-length exponent ννν and for the frequency and momentum anomalous dimensions ηωη_ωηω​ and ηkη_kηk​. The resulting exponents reduce to long-range Gaussian scaling at σ=2d/3σ=2d/3σ=2d/3 and to SR quantum Wilson-Fisher scaling in the σ→2σ\to 2σ→2 limit, thereby identifying σ∗=2σ_*=2σ∗​=2 as the LR--SR boundary within the controlled 3−ε3-ε3−ε expansion. Combining the RG results with scaling boundaries and classical LR analogies, we propose a (d,σ)(d,σ)(d,σ) universality diagram for ferromagnetic long-range quantum O(n)O(n)O(n) criticality and use it as an organizing framework for the phase diagram of long-range quantum spin chains.
Abstract We systematically develop theories of critical phenomena with a prior formed memory of a power-law decaying long-range temporal interaction parameterized by a constant θ > 0 for a space dimension d both below and above an upper critical dimension d c = 6 − 2/θ. We first provide more evidences to confirm the previous theory that a dimensional constant d t is demanded to rectify a hyperscaling law, to produce correct unique mean-field critical exponents via an effective spatial dimension originating from temporal dimension, and to transform the time and change the dynamic critical exponent. Next, for d < d c , we develop a renormalization-group theory by employing the momentum-shell technique to the leading nontrivial order explicitly and to higher orders formally in ϵ = d c − d but to zero order in ε = 1 − θ and find that more scaling laws besides the hyperscaling law are broken due to the breaking of the fluctuation-dissipation theorem. Moreover, because dynamics and statics are intimately interwoven, even the static critical exponents involve contributions from the dynamics and hence do not restore the short-range exponents even for θ = 1 and the crossover between the short-range and long-range fixed points is discontinuous contrary to the case of long-range spatial interaction. In addition, a new scaling law relating the dynamic critical exponent with the static ones emerges, indicating that the dynamic critical exponent is not independent. However, once d t is displaced by a series of ϵ and ε such that most values of the critical exponents are changed, all scaling laws are saved again, even though the fluctuation-dissipation theorem keeps violating. Then, for d ≥ d c , we develop an effective-dimension theory by carefully discriminating the corrections of both temporal and spatial dimensions and find three different regions. For d ≥ d c0 = 4, the upper critical dimension of the usual short-range theory, the usual Landau mean-field theory with fluctuations confined to the effective-dimension equal to d c0 correctly describe the critical phenomena with memory, while for d c < d ≤ 4, there exist new universality classes whose critical exponents depend only on the space dimension but not at all on θ. Yet another region consists of d = d c only and the previous theory is retrieved. All these results show that the dimensional constant d t is the fundamental ingredient of the theories for critical phenomena with memory. However, its value continuously varies with the space dimension and vanishes exactly at d = 4, reflecting the variation of the amount of the temporal dimension that is transferred to the spatial one with the strength of fluctuations. Moreover, special finite-size scaling appears ubiquitously except for d = d c0.
The establishment of the Wilson-Fisher fixed point (WFP) for O(n)O(n)O(n) spin models in d=4−εd=4-εd=4−ε dimensions stands as a cornerstone of the renormalization group (RG) theory for critical phenomena. However, when long-range (LR) interactions, algebraically decaying as ∝1/rd+σ\propto 1/r^{d+σ}∝1/rd+σ, are introduced, the fate of the short-range WFP (SR-WFP) has remained a subject of intense debate since the 1970s. We employ two complementary techniques -- the standard field-theoretic RG and a perturbative bootstrap scheme, and perform the εεε-expansion calculations up to the two-loop level. We show that, as long as σ<2σ<2σ<2, the SR-WFP becomes unstable and a stable LR-WFP emerges, and, in the non-classical regime with d/2<σ<2d/2 < σ< 2d/2<σ<2, the critical exponents, including the anomalous dimension, are functions of εεε, δ=2−σδ=2-σδ=2−σ and nnn, which reduce to the exact results in the limiting cases ε→0ε\to 0ε→0, δ→0δ\to 0δ→0 or n→∞n \to \inftyn→∞. Our (4−ε)(4-ε)(4−ε)-expansion calculations support the scenario that the threshold between the LR- and SR-WFP occurs strictly at σ∗=2σ_*=2σ∗​=2, well consistent with the recent high-precision numerical study while different from the widely accepted Sak's criterion.
Random-field models are considered with long-range exchange, J(r) approximately 1/r d+ sigma , and/or long-range correlated random fields, (h(r)h(r')) approximately 1/ mod r-r' mod d- rho . A general scaling analysis is presented, in which the existence of three independent critical exponents is emphasized. Four different universality classes are identified, according to whether the fixed point controlling the critical behaviour is of short-range or long-range character for the exchange and/or the random-field correlations. The lines in the rho - sigma plane at which the long-range couplings first become relevant are expressed in terms of the exponents eta and eta of the corresponding short-range problem: long-range exchange is relevant for sigma <2- eta , long-range field correlations for rho >2 eta - eta . The scaling results are confirmed and amplified by explicit calculations of three independent exponents of the n-component spin model, correct to order 1/n. The results reveal errors in published expansions around the upper critical dimension.