Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1408.5685 · Journal of Physics Conference Series

Weak measurement and its experimental realisation

R. L. Flack, Basil J. Hiley

Published Apr 14, 2014• 19 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The relationship between the real part of the weak value of the momentum operator at a post selected position is discussed and the meaning of the experimentally determined stream-lines in the Toronto experiment of Kocsis et al is re-examined. We argue against interpreting the energy flow lines as photon trajectories. The possibility of performing an analogous experiment using atoms is proposed in order that a direct comparison can be made with the trajectories calculated by Philippidis, Dewdney and Hiley using the Bohm approach.

DOI
10.1088/1742-6596/504/1/012016

Related papers

Weak Values of Momentum of the Electromagnetic Field: Average Momentum Flow Lines, Not Photon Trajectories

R. Flack, Basil J. Hiley

In a recent paper Mahler {\em et al.} have argued that the experiments of Kocsis {\em et al.} provide experimental evidence for Bohmian mechanics. Unfortunately these experiments used relativistic, zero rest mass photons whereas Bohmian mechanics is based on non-relativistic Schrödinger particles having non-zero rest mass. The experimental results can be accounted for in terms of a different approach based on the electromagnetic field that was already outlined by Bohm in an appendix of the second of his 1952 papers. A subsequent development of this approach by Bohm, Hiley, Holland, Kaloyerou, Lam and Dewdney, shows in detail how this theory accounts for experimental quantum phenomena in general. Using this theory, we are led to the conclusion that the experiments have constructed mean momentum flow lines by measuring the real part of what we term the weak Poynting vector. These results support and clarify the analysis of Bliokh {\em et al}. The experimental flow lines can be constructed independently of the number of photons in the beam leading to the conclusion that flow lines cannot be interpreted as `photon trajectories'. We discuss exactly how the notion of a photon arises in the field approach in the light of weak values.

arXiv:1611.06510•Nov 20, 2016•5 citations

Weak measurement, the energy–momentum tensor and the Bohm approach

R. Flack, Basil J. Hiley

In this chapter we show how the weak values, are related to the T 0 µ ( x, t ) component of the energy–momentum tensor. This enables the local energy and momentum to be measured using weak measurement techniques. We also show how the Bohm energy and momentum are related to T 0 µ ( x, t ) and therefore it follows that these quantities can also be measured using the same methods. Thus the Bohm “trajectories” can be empirically determined, as was shown by Kocsis et al . (2011a) in the case of photons. Because of the difficulties with the notion of a photon trajectory, we argue the case for determining experimentally similar trajectories for atoms where a trajectory does not cause these particular difficulties. Introduction The notion of weak measurement introduced by Aharonov, Albert and Vaidman (1988) and Aharonov and Vaidman (1990) has opened up a radically new way of exploring quantum phenomena. In contrast to the strong measurement (von Neumann, 1955), which involves the collapse of the wave function, a weak measurement induces a more subtle phase change which does not involve any collapse. This phase change can then be amplified and revealed in a subsequent strong measurement of a complementary operator that does not commute with the operator being measured. This amplification explains why it is possible for the result of a weak spin measurement of a spin-1/2 atom to be magnified by a factor of 100 (Aharonov et al ., 1988; Duck, Stevenson and Sudarshan, 1989). A weak measurement, then, provides a means of amplifying small signals as well as allowing us to gain new, more subtle information about quantum systems. One of the new features that we will concentrate on in this chapter is the possible measurement of the T 0 µ ( x, t ) components of the energy–momentum tensor.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Nov 30, 2014•6 citations

Quantum Trajectories: Real or Surreal?

Basil J. Hiley, Peter Van Reeth

The claim of Kocsis et al. to have experimentally determined "photon trajectories" calls for a re-examination of the meaning of "quantum trajectories". We will review the arguments that have been assumed to have established that a trajectory has no meaning in the context of quantum mechanics. We show that the conclusion that the Bohm trajectories should be called "surreal" because they are at "variance with the actual observed track" of a particle is wrong as it is based on a false argument. We also present the results of a numerical investigation of a double Stern-Gerlach experiment which shows clearly the role of the spin within the Bohm formalism and discuss situations where the appearance of the quantum potential is open to direct experimental exploration.

Entropy•May 8, 2018•18 citations

Weak value as an indicator of back-action

Riuji Mochizuki

In this study we critically examine some important papers on weak measurement and weak values. We find some insufficiency and mistakes in these papers, and we demonstrate that the real parts of weak values provide the back-action to the post-selection, which is caused by weak measurement. Two examples, a counterfactual statement of Hardy's paradox and experiments that determine the average trajectory of photons passing through double slits, are investigated from our point of view.

arXiv:1312.3036•Progress of Theoretical and Experimental Physics•Apr 1, 2014•2 citations

Photon trajectories, anomalous velocities and weak measurements: a classical interpretation

Konstantin Yu Bliokh, A. Ya. Bekshaev, Abraham G. Kofman +1 more

Recently, Kocsis et al (2011 Science 332 1170) reported the observation of 'average trajectories of single photons' in a two-slit interference experiment. This was possible by using the quantum weak-measurement method, which implies averaging over many events, i.e. in fact, a multi-photon limit of classical linear optics. We give a classical-optics interpretation of this experiment and other related problems. It appears that weak measurements of the local momentum of photons made by Kocsis et al represent measurements of the Poynting vector in an optical field. We consider both the real and imaginary parts of the local momentum and show that their measurements have been realized in classical optics using small-probe particles. We also examine the appearance of 'anomalous' values of the local momentum: either negative (backflow) or exceeding the wavenumber (superluminal propagation). These features appear to be closely related to vortices and evanescent waves. Finally, we revisit a number of older works and find examples of photon trajectories and anomalous-momentum measurements in various optical experiments.

arXiv:1304.1276•New Journal of Physics•Jul 9, 2013•128 citations

Feynman Paths and Weak Values

R. Flack, Basil J. Hiley

There has been a recent revival of interest in the notion of a 'trajectory' of a quantum particle. In this paper, we detail the relationship between Dirac's ideas, Feynman paths and the Bohm approach. The key to the relationship is the weak value of the momentum which Feynman calls a transition probability amplitude. With this identification we are able to conclude that a Bohm 'trajectory' is the average of an ensemble of actual individual stochastic Feynman paths. This implies that they can be interpreted as the mean momentum flow of a set of individual quantum processes and not the path of an individual particle. This enables us to give a clearer account of the experimental two-slit results of Kocsis et al.

Entropy•May 14, 2018•26 citations
The relationship between the real part of the weak value of the momentum operator at a post selected position is discussed and the meaning of the experimentally determined stream-lines in the Toronto experiment of Kocsis et al is re-examined. We argue against interpreting the energy flow lines as photon trajectories. The possibility of performing an analogous experiment using atoms is proposed in order that a direct comparison can be made with the trajectories calculated by Philippidis, Dewdney and Hiley using the Bohm approach.
In a recent paper Mahler {\em et al.} have argued that the experiments of Kocsis {\em et al.} provide experimental evidence for Bohmian mechanics. Unfortunately these experiments used relativistic, zero rest mass photons whereas Bohmian mechanics is based on non-relativistic Schrödinger particles having non-zero rest mass. The experimental results can be accounted for in terms of a different approach based on the electromagnetic field that was already outlined by Bohm in an appendix of the second of his 1952 papers. A subsequent development of this approach by Bohm, Hiley, Holland, Kaloyerou, Lam and Dewdney, shows in detail how this theory accounts for experimental quantum phenomena in general. Using this theory, we are led to the conclusion that the experiments have constructed mean momentum flow lines by measuring the real part of what we term the weak Poynting vector. These results support and clarify the analysis of Bliokh {\em et al}. The experimental flow lines can be constructed independently of the number of photons in the beam leading to the conclusion that flow lines cannot be interpreted as `photon trajectories'. We discuss exactly how the notion of a photon arises in the field approach in the light of weak values.
In this chapter we show how the weak values, are related to the T 0 µ ( x, t ) component of the energy–momentum tensor. This enables the local energy and momentum to be measured using weak measurement techniques. We also show how the Bohm energy and momentum are related to T 0 µ ( x, t ) and therefore it follows that these quantities can also be measured using the same methods. Thus the Bohm “trajectories” can be empirically determined, as was shown by Kocsis et al . (2011a) in the case of photons. Because of the difficulties with the notion of a photon trajectory, we argue the case for determining experimentally similar trajectories for atoms where a trajectory does not cause these particular difficulties. Introduction The notion of weak measurement introduced by Aharonov, Albert and Vaidman (1988) and Aharonov and Vaidman (1990) has opened up a radically new way of exploring quantum phenomena. In contrast to the strong measurement (von Neumann, 1955), which involves the collapse of the wave function, a weak measurement induces a more subtle phase change which does not involve any collapse. This phase change can then be amplified and revealed in a subsequent strong measurement of a complementary operator that does not commute with the operator being measured. This amplification explains why it is possible for the result of a weak spin measurement of a spin-1/2 atom to be magnified by a factor of 100 (Aharonov et al ., 1988; Duck, Stevenson and Sudarshan, 1989). A weak measurement, then, provides a means of amplifying small signals as well as allowing us to gain new, more subtle information about quantum systems. One of the new features that we will concentrate on in this chapter is the possible measurement of the T 0 µ ( x, t ) components of the energy–momentum tensor.
The claim of Kocsis et al. to have experimentally determined "photon trajectories" calls for a re-examination of the meaning of "quantum trajectories". We will review the arguments that have been assumed to have established that a trajectory has no meaning in the context of quantum mechanics. We show that the conclusion that the Bohm trajectories should be called "surreal" because they are at "variance with the actual observed track" of a particle is wrong as it is based on a false argument. We also present the results of a numerical investigation of a double Stern-Gerlach experiment which shows clearly the role of the spin within the Bohm formalism and discuss situations where the appearance of the quantum potential is open to direct experimental exploration.
Recently, Kocsis et al (2011 Science 332 1170) reported the observation of 'average trajectories of single photons' in a two-slit interference experiment. This was possible by using the quantum weak-measurement method, which implies averaging over many events, i.e. in fact, a multi-photon limit of classical linear optics. We give a classical-optics interpretation of this experiment and other related problems. It appears that weak measurements of the local momentum of photons made by Kocsis et al represent measurements of the Poynting vector in an optical field. We consider both the real and imaginary parts of the local momentum and show that their measurements have been realized in classical optics using small-probe particles. We also examine the appearance of 'anomalous' values of the local momentum: either negative (backflow) or exceeding the wavenumber (superluminal propagation). These features appear to be closely related to vortices and evanescent waves. Finally, we revisit a number of older works and find examples of photon trajectories and anomalous-momentum measurements in various optical experiments.
There has been a recent revival of interest in the notion of a 'trajectory' of a quantum particle. In this paper, we detail the relationship between Dirac's ideas, Feynman paths and the Bohm approach. The key to the relationship is the weak value of the momentum which Feynman calls a transition probability amplitude. With this identification we are able to conclude that a Bohm 'trajectory' is the average of an ensemble of actual individual stochastic Feynman paths. This implies that they can be interpreted as the mean momentum flow of a set of individual quantum processes and not the path of an individual particle. This enables us to give a clearer account of the experimental two-slit results of Kocsis et al.