© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

Terms Privacy Legal Notice

arXiv:1407.7816 · Journal of High Energy Physics

Rényi entropy, stationarity, and entanglement of the conformal scalar

Jeongseog Lee, Aitor Lewkowycz, Eric Perlmutter, Benjamin R. Safdi

Published Mar 1, 2015• 44 citations

Abstract

We extend previous work on the perturbative expansion of the Rényi entropy, S q , around q = 1 for a spherical entangling surface in a general CFT. Applied to conformal scalar fields in various spacetime dimensions, the results appear to conflict with the known conformal scalar Rényi entropies. On the other hand, the perturbative results agree with known Rényi entropies in a variety of other theories, including theories of free fermions and vector fields and theories with Einstein gravity duals. We propose a resolution stemming from a careful consideration of boundary conditions near the entangling surface. This is equivalent to a proper treatment of total-derivative terms in the definition of the modular Hamiltonian. As a corollary, we are able to resolve an outstanding puzzle in the literature regarding the Rényi entropy of $$ \mathcal{N}=4 $$ super-Yang-Mills near q = 1. A related puzzle regards the question of stationarity of the renormalized entanglement entropy (REE) across a circle for a (2+1)-dimensional massive scalar field. We point out that the boundary contributions to the modular Hamiltonian shed light on the previously-observed non-stationarity. Moreover, IR divergences appear in perturbation theory about the massless fixed point that inhibit our ability to reliably calculate the REE at small non-zero mass.

DOI: 10.1007/jhep03(2015)075

Related papers

Rényi entropy and geometry

Jeongseog Lee, Lauren McGough, Benjamin R. Safdi

Entanglement entropy in even-dimensional conformal field theories (CFTs) contains well-known universal terms arising from the conformal anomaly. R\'enyi entropies are natural generalizations of the entanglement entropy that are much less understood. Above two spacetime dimensions, the universal terms in the R\'enyi entropies are unknown for general entangling geometries. We conjecture a new structure in the dependence of the four-dimensional R\'enyi entropies on the intrinsic and extrinsic geometry of the entangling surface. We provide evidence for this conjecture by direct numerical computations in the free scalar and fermion field theories. The computation involves relating the four-dimensional free massless R\'enyi entropies across cylindrical entangling surfaces to corresponding three-dimensional massive R\'enyi entropies across circular entangling surfaces. Our numerical technique also allows us to directly probe other interesting aspects of three-dimensional R\'enyi entropy, including the massless renormalized R\'enyi entropy and calculable contributions to the perimeter law.

arXiv:1403.1580•Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•Jun 18, 2014•31 citations

Universality in the geometric dependence of Rényi entropy

Aitor Lewkowycz, Eric Perlmutter

We derive several new results for Rényi entropy, S n , across generic entangling surfaces. We establish a perturbative expansion of the Rényi entropy, valid in generic quantum field theories, in deformations of a given density matrix. When applied to even-dimensional conformal field theories, these results lead to new constraints on the n-dependence, independent of any perturbative expansion. In 4d CFTs, we show that the n-dependence of the universal part of the ground state Rényi entropy for entangling surfaces with vanishing extrinsic curvature contribution is in fact fully determined by the Rényi entropy across a sphere in flat space. Using holography, we thus provide the first computations of Rényi entropy across non-spherical entangling surfaces in strongly coupled 4d CFTs. Furthermore, we address the possibility that in a wide class of 4d CFTs, the flat space spherical Rényi entropy also fixes the n-dependence of the extrinsic curvature contribution, and hence that of arbitrary entangling surfaces. Our results have intriguing implications for the structure of generic modular Hamiltonians.

arXiv:1407.8171•Journal of High Energy Physics•Jan 1, 2015•77 citations

Universality in the geometric dependence of Renyi entropy

Aitor Lewkowycz, Eric Perlmutter

We derive several new results for Rényi entropy, S n , across generic entangling surfaces. We establish a perturbative expansion of the Rényi entropy, valid in generic quantum field theories, in deformations of a given density matrix. When applied to even-dimensional conformal field theories, these results lead to new constraints on the n-dependence, independent of any perturbative expansion. In 4d CFTs, we show that the n-dependence of the universal part of the ground state Rényi entropy for entangling surfaces with vanishing extrinsic curvature contribution is in fact fully determined by the Rényi entropy across a sphere in flat space. Using holography, we thus provide the first computations of Rényi entropy across non-spherical entangling surfaces in strongly coupled 4d CFTs. Furthermore, we address the possibility that in a wide class of 4d CFTs, the flat space spherical Rényi entropy also fixes the n-dependence of the extrinsic curvature contribution, and hence that of arbitrary entangling surfaces. Our results have intriguing implications for the structure of generic modular Hamiltonians.

•Aug 17, 2016•43 citations

Rényi entropy and conformal defects

Lorenzo Bianchi, Marco Meineri, Robert Cobb Myers +1 more

We propose a field theoretic framework for calculating the dependence of Rényi entropies on the shape of the entangling surface in a conformal field theory. Our approach rests on regarding the corresponding twist operator as a conformal defect and in particular, we define the displacement operator which implements small local deformations of the entangling surface. We identify a simple constraint between the coefficient defining the two-point function of the displacement operator and the conformal weight of the twist operator, which consolidates a number of distinct conjectures on the shape dependence of the Rényi entropy. As an example, using this approach, we examine a conjecture regarding the universal coefficient associated with a conical singularity in the entangling surface for CFTs in any number of spacetime dimensions. We also provide a general formula for the second order variation of the Rényi entropy arising from small deformations of a spherical entangling surface, extending Mezei’s results for the entanglement entropy.

arXiv:1511.06713•Journal of High Energy Physics•Jul 1, 2016•107 citations

A universal feature of CFT Rényi entropy

Eric Perlmutter

We show that for a d-dimensional CFT in flat space, the Rényi entropy S q across a spherical entangling surface has the following property: in an expansion around q = 1, the first correction to the entanglement entropy is proportional to C T , the coefficient of the stress tensor vacuum two-point function, with a fixed d-dependent coefficient. This is equivalent to a similar statement about the free energy of CFTs living on S 1 × $ \mathbb{H} $ d−1 with inverse temperature β = 2πq. In addition to furnishing a direct argument applicable to all CFTs, we exhibit this result using a handful of gravity and field theory computations. Knowledge of C T thus doubles as knowledge of Rényi entropies in the neighborhood of q = 1, which we use to establish new results in 3d vector models at large N.

arXiv:1308.1083•Journal of High Energy Physics•Mar 1, 2014•87 citations

Relevant perturbation of entanglement entropy and stationarity

Tatsuma Nishioka

A relevant perturbation of the entanglement entropy of a sphere is examined holographically near the UV fixed point. Varying the conformal dimension of the relevant operator, we obtain three different sectors: (1) the entanglement entropy is stationary and the perturbative expansion is well defined with respect to the relevant coupling, (2) the entropy is stationary, but the perturbation fails, (3) the entropy is neither stationary nor perturbative. We compare our holographic results with the numerical calculation for a free massive scalar field in three dimensions, and find a qualitative agreement between them. We speculate that these statements hold for any relevant perturbation in any quantum field theory invariant under the Poincar\'e symmetry.

arXiv:1405.3650•Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•Aug 4, 2014•34 citations

We extend previous work on the perturbative expansion of the Rényi entropy, S q , around q = 1 for a spherical entangling surface in a general CFT. Applied to conformal scalar fields in various spacetime dimensions, the results appear to conflict with the known conformal scalar Rényi entropies. On the other hand, the perturbative results agree with known Rényi entropies in a variety of other theories, including theories of free fermions and vector fields and theories with Einstein gravity duals. We propose a resolution stemming from a careful consideration of boundary conditions near the entangling surface. This is equivalent to a proper treatment of total-derivative terms in the definition of the modular Hamiltonian. As a corollary, we are able to resolve an outstanding puzzle in the literature regarding the Rényi entropy of

\mathcal{N}=4

super-Yang-Mills near q = 1. A related puzzle regards the question of stationarity of the renormalized entanglement entropy (REE) across a circle for a (2+1)-dimensional massive scalar field. We point out that the boundary contributions to the modular Hamiltonian shed light on the previously-observed non-stationarity. Moreover, IR divergences appear in perturbation theory about the massless fixed point that inhibit our ability to reliably calculate the REE at small non-zero mass.

Entanglement entropy in even-dimensional conformal field theories (CFTs) contains well-known universal terms arising from the conformal anomaly. R\'enyi entropies are natural generalizations of the entanglement entropy that are much less understood. Above two spacetime dimensions, the universal terms in the R\'enyi entropies are unknown for general entangling geometries. We conjecture a new structure in the dependence of the four-dimensional R\'enyi entropies on the intrinsic and extrinsic geometry of the entangling surface. We provide evidence for this conjecture by direct numerical computations in the free scalar and fermion field theories. The computation involves relating the four-dimensional free massless R\'enyi entropies across cylindrical entangling surfaces to corresponding three-dimensional massive R\'enyi entropies across circular entangling surfaces. Our numerical technique also allows us to directly probe other interesting aspects of three-dimensional R\'enyi entropy, including the massless renormalized R\'enyi entropy and calculable contributions to the perimeter law.

We derive several new results for Rényi entropy, S n , across generic entangling surfaces. We establish a perturbative expansion of the Rényi entropy, valid in generic quantum field theories, in deformations of a given density matrix. When applied to even-dimensional conformal field theories, these results lead to new constraints on the n-dependence, independent of any perturbative expansion. In 4d CFTs, we show that the n-dependence of the universal part of the ground state Rényi entropy for entangling surfaces with vanishing extrinsic curvature contribution is in fact fully determined by the Rényi entropy across a sphere in flat space. Using holography, we thus provide the first computations of Rényi entropy across non-spherical entangling surfaces in strongly coupled 4d CFTs. Furthermore, we address the possibility that in a wide class of 4d CFTs, the flat space spherical Rényi entropy also fixes the n-dependence of the extrinsic curvature contribution, and hence that of arbitrary entangling surfaces. Our results have intriguing implications for the structure of generic modular Hamiltonians.

We derive several new results for Rényi entropy, S n , across generic entangling surfaces. We establish a perturbative expansion of the Rényi entropy, valid in generic quantum field theories, in deformations of a given density matrix. When applied to even-dimensional conformal field theories, these results lead to new constraints on the n-dependence, independent of any perturbative expansion. In 4d CFTs, we show that the n-dependence of the universal part of the ground state Rényi entropy for entangling surfaces with vanishing extrinsic curvature contribution is in fact fully determined by the Rényi entropy across a sphere in flat space. Using holography, we thus provide the first computations of Rényi entropy across non-spherical entangling surfaces in strongly coupled 4d CFTs. Furthermore, we address the possibility that in a wide class of 4d CFTs, the flat space spherical Rényi entropy also fixes the n-dependence of the extrinsic curvature contribution, and hence that of arbitrary entangling surfaces. Our results have intriguing implications for the structure of generic modular Hamiltonians.

We propose a field theoretic framework for calculating the dependence of Rényi entropies on the shape of the entangling surface in a conformal field theory. Our approach rests on regarding the corresponding twist operator as a conformal defect and in particular, we define the displacement operator which implements small local deformations of the entangling surface. We identify a simple constraint between the coefficient defining the two-point function of the displacement operator and the conformal weight of the twist operator, which consolidates a number of distinct conjectures on the shape dependence of the Rényi entropy. As an example, using this approach, we examine a conjecture regarding the universal coefficient associated with a conical singularity in the entangling surface for CFTs in any number of spacetime dimensions. We also provide a general formula for the second order variation of the Rényi entropy arising from small deformations of a spherical entangling surface, extending Mezei’s results for the entanglement entropy.

We show that for a d-dimensional CFT in flat space, the Rényi entropy S q across a spherical entangling surface has the following property: in an expansion around q = 1, the first correction to the entanglement entropy is proportional to C T , the coefficient of the stress tensor vacuum two-point function, with a fixed d-dependent coefficient. This is equivalent to a similar statement about the free energy of CFTs living on S 1 × $ \mathbb{H} $ d−1 with inverse temperature β = 2πq. In addition to furnishing a direct argument applicable to all CFTs, we exhibit this result using a handful of gravity and field theory computations. Knowledge of C T thus doubles as knowledge of Rényi entropies in the neighborhood of q = 1, which we use to establish new results in 3d vector models at large N.

A relevant perturbation of the entanglement entropy of a sphere is examined holographically near the UV fixed point. Varying the conformal dimension of the relevant operator, we obtain three different sectors: (1) the entanglement entropy is stationary and the perturbative expansion is well defined with respect to the relevant coupling, (2) the entropy is stationary, but the perturbation fails, (3) the entropy is neither stationary nor perturbative. We compare our holographic results with the numerical calculation for a free massive scalar field in three dimensions, and find a qualitative agreement between them. We speculate that these statements hold for any relevant perturbation in any quantum field theory invariant under the Poincar\'e symmetry.