Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1407.5175 · Proceedings of the Steklov Institute of Mathematics

Coherent control of a qubit is trap-free

Alexander Nikolaevich Pechen, Nikolay Borisovich Ilin

Published Jul 24, 2014• 32 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

There is a strong interest in optimal manipulating of quantum systems by external controls. Traps are controls which are optimal only locally but not globally. If they exist, they can be serious obstacles to the search of globally optimal controls in numerical and laboratory experiments, and for this reason the analysis of traps attracts considerable attention. In this paper we prove that for a wide range of control problems for two-level quantum systems all locally optimal controls are also globally optimal. Hence we conclude that two-level systems in general are trap-free. In particular, manipulating qubits—two-level quantum systems forming a basic building block for quantum computation—is free of traps for fundamental problems such as the state preparation and gate generation.

DOI
10.1134/s0081543814040166

Related papers

Trap-free manipulation in the Landau-Zener system

Alexander Nikolaevich Pechen, Nikolay Borisovich Ilin

The analysis of traps, that is, locally but not globally optimal controls, for quantum control systems has attracted great interest in recent years. The central problem that has remained open is to demonstrate for a given system either the existence or the absence of traps. We prove the absence of traps and hence completely solve this problem for the important tasks of unconstrained manipulation of the transition probability and unitary gate generation in the Landau-Zener system, a system with a wide range of applications across physics, chemistry, and biochemistry. This finding provides an example of a controlled quantum system which is completely free of traps. We also discuss the impact of laboratory constraints due to decoherence, noise in the control pulse, and restrictions on the available controls, which, when being sufficiently severe, can produce traps.

arXiv:1304.1357•Physical Review A•Nov 21, 2012•42 citations

Control landscape for ultrafast manipulation by a qubit

Alexander Nikolaevich Pechen, Nikolay Borisovich Ilin

Abstract In this work we study extrema of objective functionals for ultrafast manipulation by a qubit. Traps are extrema of the objective functionals which are optimal for manipulation by quantum systems only locally, not globally. Prior work has devoted a large amount of effort to the analysis of traps for quantum systems controlled by laser pulses which are long enough, and, for example, manipulation by a qubit with long control pulses was shown to be trap-free. Ultrafast femtosecond and attosecond control has now become widely applicable, which makes the analysis of traps on the ultrafast time scale a necessity. We complete such analysis for a qubit and show that ultrafast state transfer in a qubit remains trap-free for a wide range of the initial and final states of the qubit. We prove that for this range the probability of transition between the initial and the final states has a saddle but no traps.

arXiv:1909.09216•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Jan 12, 2017•16 citations

Role of control constraints in quantum optimal control

Dmitry V. Zhdanov, Tamar Seideman

The problems of optimizing the value of an arbitrary observable of a two-level system at both a fixed time and the shortest possible time is theoretically explored. Complete identification and classification along with comprehensive analysis of globally optimal control policies and traps (i.e., policies which are locally but not globally optimal) are presented. The central question addressed is whether the control landscape remains trap-free if control constraints of the inequality type are imposed. The answer is astonishingly controversial: Although the traps are proven always to exist in this case, in practice they become trivially escapable once the control time is fixed and chosen long enough.

arXiv:1507.08785•Physical Review A•Nov 13, 2015•13 citations

Quantum Control Landscapes and Traps

Boris Olegovich Volkov, Alexander Nikolaevich Pechen

Abstract Quantum control is a necessary tool for a variety of modern quantum technologies as it allows to optimally manipulate quantum systems for various tasks. Traps are points of local but not global optimum of the objective functional for a given quantum control problem. In a more general sense, traps are critical points of the objective functional which are hard to escape by local search algorithms. Here a review of some results of the analysis of possibility of having traps in landscapes of coherently controlled closed quantum systems is given. In one-qubit case, there are no traps. For special multilevel quantum systems, higher-order traps may appear.

Russian Microelectronics•Dec 1, 2023•1 citation

On extrema of the objective functional for short-time generation of single-qubit quantum gates

Alexander Nikolaevich Pechen, N B Il'in

In the present work the extrema of the objective functional for the problem of generation of quantum gates (logical elements for quantum computations) for two--level systems are investigated for short duration of the control. The problem of existence of local but not global extrema, the so called traps, is considered. In prior works the absence of traps was proved for a sufficiently long control duration. In this paper we prove that for almost all target unitary operators and system Hamiltonians traps are absent for an arbitrarily small control duration. For the remainder target unitary operators and Hamiltonians we obtain a new estimate for the lower boundary of the control duration which guarantees the absence of traps.

arXiv:1909.12958•Izvestiya Mathematics•Aug 22, 2016•11 citations

Introduction to quantum control: From basic concepts to applications in quantum technologies

Christiane P. Koch

Quantum control refers to our ability to manipulate quantum systems. This tutorial-style chapter focuses on the use of classical electromagnetic fields to steer the system dynamics. In this approach, the quantum nature of the control stems solely from the underlying dynamics, through the exploitation of destructive and constructive interference to reach the control target. We first discuss two basic control principles -- coherent control which uses manipulation in frequency or time to design these interferences, and adiabatic following where access to the control target is enabled by tracking the time-dependent ground state. For complex control targets and system dynamics that exceed the scope of these basic principles, optimal control theory provides a powerful suite of tools to design the necessary protocols. A key consideration for the successful application of optimal control theory is a proper choice of the optimization functional. All concepts are illustrated using recent work from my research group, with a focus on controlling atoms and superconducting qubits. The chapter concludes with an outlook on integrating coherent control with engineered dissipation and a discussion of open questions in the field.

quant-pharXiv:2512.04990•Dec 5, 2025•0 citations
There is a strong interest in optimal manipulating of quantum systems by external controls. Traps are controls which are optimal only locally but not globally. If they exist, they can be serious obstacles to the search of globally optimal controls in numerical and laboratory experiments, and for this reason the analysis of traps attracts considerable attention. In this paper we prove that for a wide range of control problems for two-level quantum systems all locally optimal controls are also globally optimal. Hence we conclude that two-level systems in general are trap-free. In particular, manipulating qubits—two-level quantum systems forming a basic building block for quantum computation—is free of traps for fundamental problems such as the state preparation and gate generation.
The analysis of traps, that is, locally but not globally optimal controls, for quantum control systems has attracted great interest in recent years. The central problem that has remained open is to demonstrate for a given system either the existence or the absence of traps. We prove the absence of traps and hence completely solve this problem for the important tasks of unconstrained manipulation of the transition probability and unitary gate generation in the Landau-Zener system, a system with a wide range of applications across physics, chemistry, and biochemistry. This finding provides an example of a controlled quantum system which is completely free of traps. We also discuss the impact of laboratory constraints due to decoherence, noise in the control pulse, and restrictions on the available controls, which, when being sufficiently severe, can produce traps.
Abstract In this work we study extrema of objective functionals for ultrafast manipulation by a qubit. Traps are extrema of the objective functionals which are optimal for manipulation by quantum systems only locally, not globally. Prior work has devoted a large amount of effort to the analysis of traps for quantum systems controlled by laser pulses which are long enough, and, for example, manipulation by a qubit with long control pulses was shown to be trap-free. Ultrafast femtosecond and attosecond control has now become widely applicable, which makes the analysis of traps on the ultrafast time scale a necessity. We complete such analysis for a qubit and show that ultrafast state transfer in a qubit remains trap-free for a wide range of the initial and final states of the qubit. We prove that for this range the probability of transition between the initial and the final states has a saddle but no traps.
The problems of optimizing the value of an arbitrary observable of a two-level system at both a fixed time and the shortest possible time is theoretically explored. Complete identification and classification along with comprehensive analysis of globally optimal control policies and traps (i.e., policies which are locally but not globally optimal) are presented. The central question addressed is whether the control landscape remains trap-free if control constraints of the inequality type are imposed. The answer is astonishingly controversial: Although the traps are proven always to exist in this case, in practice they become trivially escapable once the control time is fixed and chosen long enough.
Abstract Quantum control is a necessary tool for a variety of modern quantum technologies as it allows to optimally manipulate quantum systems for various tasks. Traps are points of local but not global optimum of the objective functional for a given quantum control problem. In a more general sense, traps are critical points of the objective functional which are hard to escape by local search algorithms. Here a review of some results of the analysis of possibility of having traps in landscapes of coherently controlled closed quantum systems is given. In one-qubit case, there are no traps. For special multilevel quantum systems, higher-order traps may appear.
In the present work the extrema of the objective functional for the problem of generation of quantum gates (logical elements for quantum computations) for two--level systems are investigated for short duration of the control. The problem of existence of local but not global extrema, the so called traps, is considered. In prior works the absence of traps was proved for a sufficiently long control duration. In this paper we prove that for almost all target unitary operators and system Hamiltonians traps are absent for an arbitrarily small control duration. For the remainder target unitary operators and Hamiltonians we obtain a new estimate for the lower boundary of the control duration which guarantees the absence of traps.
Quantum control refers to our ability to manipulate quantum systems. This tutorial-style chapter focuses on the use of classical electromagnetic fields to steer the system dynamics. In this approach, the quantum nature of the control stems solely from the underlying dynamics, through the exploitation of destructive and constructive interference to reach the control target. We first discuss two basic control principles -- coherent control which uses manipulation in frequency or time to design these interferences, and adiabatic following where access to the control target is enabled by tracking the time-dependent ground state. For complex control targets and system dynamics that exceed the scope of these basic principles, optimal control theory provides a powerful suite of tools to design the necessary protocols. A key consideration for the successful application of optimal control theory is a proper choice of the optimization functional. All concepts are illustrated using recent work from my research group, with a focus on controlling atoms and superconducting qubits. The chapter concludes with an outlook on integrating coherent control with engineered dissipation and a discussion of open questions in the field.