Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1403.6059

Comment to "Critical Exponents of the Superfluid-Bose Glass Transition in Three-Dimensions" by Z. Yao et al., arXiv:1402.5417v1

Rong Yu, Vivien S. Zapf, Tommaso Roscilde

Published Mar 24, 2014• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In this comment we address the preprint Z. Yao et al. (arXiv:1402.5417v1) concerning the conditions upon which the correct critical temperature exponent $ϕ$ can be observed (experimentally or numerically) close to the superfluid-Bose glass quantum phase transition in three dimensions. Yao et al. announce to have resolved the contradiction between the predictions of Fisher et al. [Phys. Rev. B 40, 546 (1989)] that $ϕ= νz \geq 2$ (where $ν$ and $z$ are critical exponents at the quantum phase transition) and recent experiments and simulations, showing an exponent $ϕ\sim 1.1$. Yao et al's resolution hinges on claiming that the $ϕ\sim 1.1$ observations, which were conducted by varying the chemical potential, were not made to sufficiently close to the critical point to observe universal behavior. Here we critically examine their criteria for observing universal behavior. We show that past simulations were in fact conducted closer to the quantum critical point than the new results of Yao et al.; and that Yao et al.'s own results for varying chemical potential are consistent with previous results showing $ϕ\sim 1.1$, and do not show a clear crossover to a different $ϕ$ value.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.1403.6059

Related papers

Critical Exponents of the Superfluid–Bose-Glass Transition in Three Dimensions

Zhiyuan Yao, Karine Piacentini Coelho da Costa, Mikhail N. Kiselev +1 more

Recent experimental and numerical studies of the critical-temperature exponent ϕ for the superfluid-Bose-glass universality in three-dimensional systems report strong violations of the key quantum critical relation, ϕ=νz, where z and ν are the dynamic and correlation-length exponents, respectively; these studies question the conventional scaling laws for this quantum critical point. Using Monte Carlo simulations of the disordered Bose-Hubbard model, we demonstrate that previous work on the superfluid-to-normal-fluid transition-temperature dependence on the chemical potential (or the magnetic field, in spin systems), T_{c}∝(μ-μ_{c})^{ϕ}, was misinterpreting transient behavior on approach to the fluctuation region with the genuine critical law. When the model parameters are modified to have a broad quantum critical region, simulations of both quantum and classical models reveal that the ϕ=νz law [with ϕ=2.7(2), z=3, and ν=0.88(5)] holds true, resolving the ϕ-exponent "crisis."

arXiv:1402.5417•Physical Review Letters•Jun 3, 2014•44 citations

Quantum-critical scaling at the Bose-glass transition of the 3d diluted Heisenberg antiferromagnet in a field

Yuchen Fan, Rong Yu, Tommaso Roscilde

The nature of the superfluid-to-Bose-glass (SF-BG) quantum phase transition, occurring in systems of interacting bosons immersed in a disordered environment, remains elusive. One fundamental open question is whether or not the transition obeys conventional scaling at quantum critical points (QCPs): this scaling would lock the value of the crossover exponent $\ensuremath{\phi}$---dictating the vanishing of the superfluid critical temperature upon approaching the QCP---to the value of quantum critical exponents for the ground-state transition. Yet such a relation between exponents has been called into question by several numerical as well as experimental results on the SF-BG transition. Here we revisit this issue in the case of the $S=1/2$ Heisenberg antiferromagnet on a site-diluted cubic lattice, which lends itself to efficient quantum Monte Carlo simulations. Our results show that the model exhibits a percolation transition in zero applied field, with the correlation length exponent $\ensuremath{\nu}=0.87(8)$ and $\ensuremath{\phi}=1.1(1)$ consistent with $3d$ percolation. When applying a sufficiently strong magnetic field, the dilution-induced transition decouples from geometric percolation, and it becomes a SF-BG transition; nonetheless, the $\ensuremath{\nu}$ and $\ensuremath{\phi}$ exponents maintain values consistent with those of the percolation transition. These results contradict the conventional scaling, which predicts $\ensuremath{\phi}\ensuremath{\geqslant}2$; and they suggest a possible relationship between the SF-BG transition and percolation of phase coherence.

arXiv:2211.04645•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Jan 19, 2024•0 citations

Magnetically ordered phase near transition to Bose-glass phase

A. V. Syromyatnikov, A. V. Sizanov

We discuss a magnetically ordered (``superfluid'') phase near quantum transition to the Bose-glass phase in a simple modeling system, a Heisenberg antiferromagnet with spatial dimension $d>2$ in an external magnetic field with disorder in exchange coupling constants. Our analytical consideration is based on hydrodynamic description of long-wavelength excitations. Results obtained are valid in the entire critical region near the quantum critical point (QCP), allowing us to describe a possible crossover from one critical behavior to another. We demonstrate that the system behaves in full agreement with predictions by M. P. Fisher et al. [Phys. Rev. B 40, 546 (1989)] in close vicinity to the QCP. We find as an extension to that analysis that the anomalous dimension $\ensuremath{\eta}=2\ensuremath{-}d$ and $\ensuremath{\beta}=\ensuremath{\nu}d/2$, where $\ensuremath{\beta}$ and $\ensuremath{\nu}$ are critical exponents of the order parameter and the correlation length, respectively. The density of states per spin of low-energy localized excitations is found to be independent of $d$ (``superuniversal''). We show that many recent experimental and numerical results obtained in various three-dimensional (3D) systems can be described by our formulas using percolation critical exponents. Then, it is a possibility that a percolation critical regime arises in the ordered phase in some 3D systems not very close to the QCP.

arXiv:1604.08728•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Jan 25, 2017•8 citations

Dual Superfluid-Bose-Glass Critical Point in Two Dimensions and the Universal Conductivity

Igor F. Herbut

The continuum version of the dual theory for a system of two-dimensional quantum disordered bosons with statistical particle-hole symmetry and at $T\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}=\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}0$ admits a new disordered critical point within the renormalization group calculation at fixed dimension. We obtain the universal conductivity and the critical exponents at the superfluid-Bose glass transition in the system: ${\ensuremath{\sigma}}_{c}\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}=\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}0.25(2e{)}^{2}/h$, $\ensuremath{\nu}\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}=\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}1.38$, and $z\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}=\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}1.93$, to the lowest order in fixed-point values of the dual coupling constants.

arXiv:cond-mat/9704134•Physical Review Letters•Nov 3, 1997•40 citations

Bose-glass to superfluid transition in the three-dimensional Bose-Hubbard model

Peter B. Hitchcock, Erik Schwartz Sørensen

We present a Monte Carlo study of the Bose glass to superfluid transition in the three-dimensional Bose-Hubbard model. Simulations are performed on the classical $(3+1)$ dimensional link-current representation using the geometrical worm algorithm. Finite-size scaling analysis (on lattices as large as $16\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}16\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}16\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}512$ sites) of the superfluid stiffness and the compressibility is consistent with a value of the dynamical critical exponent $z=3$, in agreement with existing scaling and renormalization group arguments that $z=d$. We find also a value of $\ensuremath{\nu}=0.70(12)$ for the correlation length exponent, satisfying the relation $\ensuremath{\nu}\ensuremath{\ge}2∕d$. However, a detailed study of the correlation functions, $C(r,\ensuremath{\tau})$, at the quantum critical point are not consistent with this value of $z$. We speculate that this discrepancy could be due to the fact that the correlation functions have not reached their true asymptotic behavior because of the relatively small spatial extent of the lattices used in the present study.

arXiv:cond-mat/0601182•Physical Review B•May 24, 2006•36 citations

QUANTUM PHASE TRANSITIONS IN DISORDERED BOSON SYSTEMS

Zhiyuan Yao

In this dissertation, we study the superfluid-insulator quantum phase transition in disordered boson systems. Recently, there has been considerable controversy over the validity of the scaling relations of the superfluid--Bose-glass quantum phase transition in three dimensions. Results from experimental and numerical studies on disordered quantum magnets contradict the scaling relations and the associated conventional scaling hypothesis for the singular part of the free energy. We determine various critical exponents of the superfluid--Bose-glass quantum phase transition in three-dimensional disordered Bose-Hubbard model through extensive Monte Carlo simulations. Our numerical study shows the previous studies on disordered quantum magnets were performed outside the quantum critical region, and our results for the critical exponents are in perfect agreement with previous theoretical predictions. We next move to study theoretically and numerically the superfluid-insulator quantum phase transition in one-dimensional disordered boson systems. While the superfluid-insulator transition in the weak disorder limit is well understood through the perturbative renormalization group study by Giamarchi and Schulz, transitions in the strong disorder regime are beyond the reach of this method. This problem was recently attacked by Altman et al. with the real space renormalization group method. They reached the conclusion that the superfluid-insulator transition in the strong disorder regime can be explained by the Coulomb blockade physics of weak links. However, their method is actually uncontrolled. Taking account of the crucial role of the hydrodynamic renormalization of weak links, finally, Pollet et al. put forward an asymptotically exact renormalization group theory of the superfluid-insulator transition. Based on this theory, we are able to provide an accurate description of the interplay between the well-known Giamarchi-Schulz criticality and the new weak-link criticality. A significant part of the ground-state phase diagram of one-dimensional disordered Bose-Hubbard model at unit filling is also determined numerically. In particular, we established the position of the multicritical point beyond which the new weak-link criticality takes over of the Giamarchi–Schulz criticality.

•Apr 12, 2021•0 citations
In this comment we address the preprint Z. Yao et al. (arXiv:1402.5417v1) concerning the conditions upon which the correct critical temperature exponent ϕϕϕ can be observed (experimentally or numerically) close to the superfluid-Bose glass quantum phase transition in three dimensions. Yao et al. announce to have resolved the contradiction between the predictions of Fisher et al. [Phys. Rev. B 40, 546 (1989)] that ϕ=νz≥2ϕ= νz \geq 2ϕ=νz≥2 (where ννν and zzz are critical exponents at the quantum phase transition) and recent experiments and simulations, showing an exponent ϕ∼1.1ϕ\sim 1.1ϕ∼1.1. Yao et al's resolution hinges on claiming that the ϕ∼1.1ϕ\sim 1.1ϕ∼1.1 observations, which were conducted by varying the chemical potential, were not made to sufficiently close to the critical point to observe universal behavior. Here we critically examine their criteria for observing universal behavior. We show that past simulations were in fact conducted closer to the quantum critical point than the new results of Yao et al.; and that Yao et al.'s own results for varying chemical potential are consistent with previous results showing ϕ∼1.1ϕ\sim 1.1ϕ∼1.1, and do not show a clear crossover to a different ϕϕϕ value.
Recent experimental and numerical studies of the critical-temperature exponent ϕ for the superfluid-Bose-glass universality in three-dimensional systems report strong violations of the key quantum critical relation, ϕ=νz, where z and ν are the dynamic and correlation-length exponents, respectively; these studies question the conventional scaling laws for this quantum critical point. Using Monte Carlo simulations of the disordered Bose-Hubbard model, we demonstrate that previous work on the superfluid-to-normal-fluid transition-temperature dependence on the chemical potential (or the magnetic field, in spin systems), T_{c}∝(μ-μ_{c})^{ϕ}, was misinterpreting transient behavior on approach to the fluctuation region with the genuine critical law. When the model parameters are modified to have a broad quantum critical region, simulations of both quantum and classical models reveal that the ϕ=νz law [with ϕ=2.7(2), z=3, and ν=0.88(5)] holds true, resolving the ϕ-exponent "crisis."
The nature of the superfluid-to-Bose-glass (SF-BG) quantum phase transition, occurring in systems of interacting bosons immersed in a disordered environment, remains elusive. One fundamental open question is whether or not the transition obeys conventional scaling at quantum critical points (QCPs): this scaling would lock the value of the crossover exponent $\ensuremath{\phi}$---dictating the vanishing of the superfluid critical temperature upon approaching the QCP---to the value of quantum critical exponents for the ground-state transition. Yet such a relation between exponents has been called into question by several numerical as well as experimental results on the SF-BG transition. Here we revisit this issue in the case of the S=1/2S=1/2S=1/2 Heisenberg antiferromagnet on a site-diluted cubic lattice, which lends itself to efficient quantum Monte Carlo simulations. Our results show that the model exhibits a percolation transition in zero applied field, with the correlation length exponent $\ensuremath{\nu}=0.87(8)$ and $\ensuremath{\phi}=1.1(1)$ consistent with 3d3d3d percolation. When applying a sufficiently strong magnetic field, the dilution-induced transition decouples from geometric percolation, and it becomes a SF-BG transition; nonetheless, the $\ensuremath{\nu}$ and $\ensuremath{\phi}$ exponents maintain values consistent with those of the percolation transition. These results contradict the conventional scaling, which predicts $\ensuremath{\phi}\ensuremath{\geqslant}2$; and they suggest a possible relationship between the SF-BG transition and percolation of phase coherence.
We discuss a magnetically ordered (``superfluid'') phase near quantum transition to the Bose-glass phase in a simple modeling system, a Heisenberg antiferromagnet with spatial dimension d>2d>2d>2 in an external magnetic field with disorder in exchange coupling constants. Our analytical consideration is based on hydrodynamic description of long-wavelength excitations. Results obtained are valid in the entire critical region near the quantum critical point (QCP), allowing us to describe a possible crossover from one critical behavior to another. We demonstrate that the system behaves in full agreement with predictions by M. P. Fisher et al. [Phys. Rev. B 40, 546 (1989)] in close vicinity to the QCP. We find as an extension to that analysis that the anomalous dimension $\ensuremath{\eta}=2\ensuremath{-}d$ and $\ensuremath{\beta}=\ensuremath{\nu}d/2$, where $\ensuremath{\beta}$ and $\ensuremath{\nu}$ are critical exponents of the order parameter and the correlation length, respectively. The density of states per spin of low-energy localized excitations is found to be independent of ddd (``superuniversal''). We show that many recent experimental and numerical results obtained in various three-dimensional (3D) systems can be described by our formulas using percolation critical exponents. Then, it is a possibility that a percolation critical regime arises in the ordered phase in some 3D systems not very close to the QCP.
The continuum version of the dual theory for a system of two-dimensional quantum disordered bosons with statistical particle-hole symmetry and at T=0T\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}=\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}0T=0 admits a new disordered critical point within the renormalization group calculation at fixed dimension. We obtain the universal conductivity and the critical exponents at the superfluid-Bose glass transition in the system: ${\ensuremath{\sigma}}_{c}\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}=\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}0.25(2e{)}^{2}/h$, $\ensuremath{\nu}\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}=\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}1.38$, and z=1.93z\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}=\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}1.93z=1.93, to the lowest order in fixed-point values of the dual coupling constants.
We present a Monte Carlo study of the Bose glass to superfluid transition in the three-dimensional Bose-Hubbard model. Simulations are performed on the classical (3+1)(3+1)(3+1) dimensional link-current representation using the geometrical worm algorithm. Finite-size scaling analysis (on lattices as large as $16\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}16\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}16\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}512$ sites) of the superfluid stiffness and the compressibility is consistent with a value of the dynamical critical exponent z=3z=3z=3, in agreement with existing scaling and renormalization group arguments that z=dz=dz=d. We find also a value of $\ensuremath{\nu}=0.70(12)$ for the correlation length exponent, satisfying the relation $\ensuremath{\nu}\ensuremath{\ge}2∕d$. However, a detailed study of the correlation functions, $C(r,\ensuremath{\tau})$, at the quantum critical point are not consistent with this value of zzz. We speculate that this discrepancy could be due to the fact that the correlation functions have not reached their true asymptotic behavior because of the relatively small spatial extent of the lattices used in the present study.
In this dissertation, we study the superfluid-insulator quantum phase transition in disordered boson systems. Recently, there has been considerable controversy over the validity of the scaling relations of the superfluid--Bose-glass quantum phase transition in three dimensions. Results from experimental and numerical studies on disordered quantum magnets contradict the scaling relations and the associated conventional scaling hypothesis for the singular part of the free energy. We determine various critical exponents of the superfluid--Bose-glass quantum phase transition in three-dimensional disordered Bose-Hubbard model through extensive Monte Carlo simulations. Our numerical study shows the previous studies on disordered quantum magnets were performed outside the quantum critical region, and our results for the critical exponents are in perfect agreement with previous theoretical predictions. We next move to study theoretically and numerically the superfluid-insulator quantum phase transition in one-dimensional disordered boson systems. While the superfluid-insulator transition in the weak disorder limit is well understood through the perturbative renormalization group study by Giamarchi and Schulz, transitions in the strong disorder regime are beyond the reach of this method. This problem was recently attacked by Altman et al. with the real space renormalization group method. They reached the conclusion that the superfluid-insulator transition in the strong disorder regime can be explained by the Coulomb blockade physics of weak links. However, their method is actually uncontrolled. Taking account of the crucial role of the hydrodynamic renormalization of weak links, finally, Pollet et al. put forward an asymptotically exact renormalization group theory of the superfluid-insulator transition. Based on this theory, we are able to provide an accurate description of the interplay between the well-known Giamarchi-Schulz criticality and the new weak-link criticality. A significant part of the ground-state phase diagram of one-dimensional disordered Bose-Hubbard model at unit filling is also determined numerically. In particular, we established the position of the multicritical point beyond which the new weak-link criticality takes over of the Giamarchi–Schulz criticality.