arXiv:1312.3931 · Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical

Reversible dynamics in strongly non-local Boxworld systems

Sabri W Al-Safi, Anthony J. Short

Published Jul 29, 2014• 18 citations

Abstract

In order to better understand the structure of quantum theory, or speculate about theories that may supersede it, it can be helpful to consider alternative physical theories. 'Boxworld' describes one such theory, in which all non-signaling correlations are achievable. In a limited class of multipartite Boxworld systems—wherein all subsystems are identical and all measurements have the same number of outcomes—it has been demonstrated that the set of reversible dynamics is 'trivial', generated solely by local relabellings of measurement choices and outcomes, and permutations of subsystems. We develop the convex formalism of Boxworld to give an alternative proof of this result, then extend this proof to all multipartite Boxworld systems, and discuss the potential relevance to other theories. These results lend further support to the idea that the rich reversible dynamics in quantum theory may be the key to understanding its structure and its informational capabilities.

DOI: 10.1088/1751-8113/47/32/325303

Related papers

Quantum theory from the perspective of general probabilistic theories

Sabri W. Al-Safi

This thesis explores various perspectives on quantum phenomena, and how our understanding of these phenomena is informed by the study of general probabilistic theories. Particular attention is given to quantum nonlocality, and its interaction with areas of physical and mathematical interest such as entropy, reversible dynamics, information-based games and the idea of negative probability. We begin with a review of non-signaling distributions and convex operational theories, including “black box” descriptions of experiments and the mathematics of convex vector spaces. In Chapter 3 we derive various classical and quantum-like quasiprobabilistic representations of arbitrary non-signaling distributions. Previously, results in which the density operator is allowed to become non-positive [1] have proved useful in derivations of quantum theory from physical requirements [2]; we derive a dual result in which the measurement operators instead are allowed to become non-positive, and show that the generation of any non-signaling distribution is possible using a fixed separable state with negligible correlation. We also derive two distinct “quasi-local” models of non-signaling correlations. Chapter 4 investigates non-local games, in particular the game known as Information Causality. By analysing the probability of success in this game, we prove the conjectured tightness of a bound given in [3] concerning how well entanglement allows us to perform the task of random access coding, and introduce a quadratic bias bound which seems to capture a great deal of information about the set of quantum-achievable correlations. By reformulating Information Causality in terms of entropies, we find that a sensible measure of entropy precludes many general probabilistic theories whose non-locality is stronger than that of quantum theory. Chapter 5 explores the role that reversible transitivity (the principle that any two pure states are joined by a reversible transformation) plays as a characteristic feature of quantum theory. It has previously been shown that in Boxworld, the theory allowing for the full set of non-signaling correlations, any reversible transformation on a restricted class of composite systems is merely a composition of relabellings of measurement choices and outcomes, and permutations of subsystems [4]. We develop a tabular description of Boxworld states and effects first introduced in [5], and use this to extend this reversibility result to any composite Boxworld system in which none of the subsystems are classical.

Mar 3, 20151 citation

Indefinite causal order in boxworld theories

Jessica Bavaresco, Ämin Baumeler, Yelena Guryanova +1 more

An astonishing feature of higher-order quantum theory is that it can accommodate indefinite causal order. In the simplest bipartite setting, there exist signaling correlations for which it is fundamentally impossible to ascribe a definite causal order for the parties' actions. Moreover, the assumptions required to arrive at such a statement (local quantum transformations and well-behaved probabilities) result in a nontrivial set of correlations, whose boundary is, to date, uncharacterized. In this work, we investigate indefinite causal order in boxworld theories. We construct a higher-order theory whose descriptor is the generalized bit (gbit) - the natural successor of the classical bit and quantum qubit. By fixing the local transformations in boxworld and asking about the global causal structure, we find that we trivially recover the full set of two-way signaling correlations. In light of this, we motivate and propose two physical principles in order to limit the set of achievable correlations: nonsignaling preservation and no signaling without system exchange. We find that a higher-order boxworld theory that respects these physical principles leads to (i) a nontrivial set of achievable correlations and (ii) a violation of some causal inequalities that is higher than what can be achieved in higher-order quantum theory. These results lead us to conjecture that the set of correlations of our higher-order boxworld theory is an outer approximation to the set of correlations produced by higher-order quantum theory.

arXiv:2411.00951Nov 1, 20240 citations

Entanglement Generation Beyond Quantum Theory: From Product States to Popescu-Rohrlich Boxes

Shun Umekawa, Akihiro Hokkyo, Hayato Arai +1 more

Entanglement generation is a fundamental dynamical capability in quantum information science and underpins many quantum advantages. While quantum theory enables it through unitary dynamics, boxworld, a generalized probabilistic theory admitting Popescu--Rohrlich boxes with supraquantum correlations, has no reversible transformation capable of generating entanglement. We show that this no-go picture changes fundamentally once reversibility is relaxed to pure-state preservation. We construct a pure-state-preserving transformation that maps every uncorrelated pure state to a Popescu--Rohrlich box and completely classify all pure-state-preserving entangling transformations in the simplest bipartite boxworld. Our results provide the first explicit mechanism for generating beyond-quantum entanglement without introducing mixing and demonstrate a physical distinction between reversibility and pure-state preservation that is obscured by the structure of quantum theory.

quant-pharXiv:2608.02403Aug 4, 20260 citations

Reversibility and the structure of the local state space

Sabri W. Al-Safi, Jonathan G. Richens

The richness of quantum theory’s reversible dynamics is one of its unique operational characteristics, with recent results suggesting deep links between the theory’s reversible dynamics, its local state space and the degree of non-locality it permits. We explore the delicate interplay between these features, demonstrating that reversibility places strong constraints on both the local and global state space. Firstly, we show that all reversible dynamics are trivial (composed of local transformations and permutations of subsytems) in maximally non-local theories whose local state spaces satisfy a dichotomy criterion; this applies to a range of operational models that have previously been studied, such as d -dimensional ‘hyperballs’ and almost all regular polytope systems. By separately deriving a similar result for odd-sided polygons, we show that classical systems are the only regular polytope state spaces whose maximally non-local composites allow for non-trivial reversible dynamics. Secondly, we show that non-trivial reversible dynamics do exist in maximally non-local theories whose state spaces are reducible into two or more smaller spaces. We conjecture that this is a necessary condition for the existence of such dynamics, but that reversible entanglement generation remains impossible even in this scenario.

arXiv:1508.03491New Journal of PhysicsDec 4, 201515 citations

Deriving Quantum Theory from Its Local Structure and Reversibility

Gonzalo de la Torre, Lluís Masanes, Anthony J. Short +1 more

We investigate the class of physical theories with the same local structure as quantum theory but potentially different global structure. It has previously been shown that any bipartite correlations generated by such a theory can be simulated in quantum theory but that this does not hold for tripartite correlations. Here we explore whether imposing an additional constraint on this space of theories-that of dynamical reversibility-will allow us to recover the global quantum structure. In the particular case in which the local systems are identical qubits, we show that any theory admitting at least one continuous reversible interaction must be identical to quantum theory.

arXiv:1110.5482Physical Review LettersAug 30, 201254 citations

Quantum Entanglement as Shared Informational Identity A Postulational, Operator-Based, and Thermodynamic Framework for Nonlocal Correlations, Measurement, and Collapse

Ali Caner Yücel

Quantum entanglement produces correlations that violate classical locality constraints while remaining fully consistent with relativistic no-signaling. Although standard quantum mechanics predicts these correlations with extraordinary empirical success, the ontological meaning of entangled states and the physical status of wave-function collapse remain deeply debated. This paper develops a speculative but structured informational interpretation in which entangled subsystems are modeled as multiple local realizations of a single shared informational identity within an underlying finite-capacity substrate. The framework is articulated through explicit postulates, density-matrix analysis, entanglement entropy, a toy realization scheme, and an informational identity operator acting on composite states. Within this view, nonlocal correlations arise not from superluminal causal influence but from ontological non-separability at the informational level. Measurement is interpreted as informational resolution: a reduction of degeneracy in the local realization of a shared informational structure. The irreversible stabilization of outcomes is then linked to thermodynamic cost through Landauer-type reasoning. The proposal is not advanced as a replacement for quantum mechanics, nor as a fully worked-out hidden-variable theory, but as an ontological scaffold intended to unify entanglement, collapse, and thermodynamic irreversibility within an informational perspective. Compatibility with Bell inequalities, decoherence, basis selection, and no-signaling is discussed in detail, together with limitations and possible routes toward future formalization and empirical relevance.

Mar 6, 20260 citations