Quantum discord for two-qubit $X$-states: A comprehensive approach inspired by classical polarization optics

Abstract

Classical correlation and quantum discord are computed for two-qubit $X$-states. Our approach, which is inspired by the methods of classical polarization optics, is geometric in the sense that the entire analysis is tied to the correlation ellipsoid of all normalized conditional states of the A-qubit with measurement elements applied to the B-qubit. Aspects of the computation which depend on the location of the reduced state of A inside the ellipsoid get clearly separated from those which do not. Our treatment is comprehensive\,: all known results are reproduced, often more economically, and several new insights and results emerge. Detailed reexamination of the famous work of Ali, Rau, and Alber [Phys. Rev. A {\bf 81}, 042105 (2010)], in the light of ours and a counterexample we manufacture against their principal theorem points to an uncommon situation in respect of their principal result\,: their theorem turns out to be `numerically correct' in all but a very tiny region in the space of $X$-states, notwithstanding the fact that their proof of the theorem seems to make, in the disguise of an unusual group theoretic argument, an {\em a priori} assumption equivalent to the theorem itself.