Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1308.5210 · Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields

Consistent probabilities in perfect fluid quantum universes

Clécio R. Bom, Nelson Pinto-Neto, Grasiele Batista dos Santos

Published Jan 21, 2014• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Recently it has been claimed that the Wheeler--DeWitt quantization of gravity is unable to avoid cosmological singularities. However, in order to make this assertion, one must specify the underlying interpretation of quantum mechanics which has been adopted. For instance, several nonsingular models were obtained in Wheeler--DeWitt quantum cosmology in the framework of the de Broglie--Bohm quantum theory. Conversely, there are specific situations where the singularity cannot be avoided in the framework of the consistent histories approach to quantum mechanics. In these specific situations, the matter content is described by a scalar field, and the Wheeler--DeWitt equation looks like a Klein--Gordon equation. The aim of this work is to study a possible singular behavior of quantum cosmological models in which the matter content is described by a hydrodynamical perfect fluid, where the resulting wave equation is a genuine Schr\"odinger equation. In this case, it is shown that the conclusions of the consistent histories and the de Broglie--Bohm approaches coincide in the quantum cosmological models where the curvature of the spatial sections is not positive definite, namely, that the cosmological singularities are eliminated. In the case of positive spatial curvature, the family of histories is no longer consistent, and no conclusion can be given in this framework.

DOI
10.1103/physrevd.89.023514

Related papers

Wheeler-DeWitt quantization can solve the singularity problem

Nelson Pinto-Neto, F. T. Falciano, Roberto Pereira B +1 more

We study the Wheeler-DeWitt quantum cosmology of a spatially flat Friedmann cosmological model with a free massless scalar field. We compare the consistent histories approach with the de Broglie--Bohm theory when applied to this simple model under two different quantization schemes: the Schr\"odinger-like quantization, which essentially takes the square root of the resulting Klein-Gordon equation through the restriction to positive frequencies and their associated Newton-Wigner states, or the induced Klein-Gordon quantization, that allows both positive and negative frequencies together. We show that the consistent histories approach can give a precise answer to the question concerning the existence of a quantum bounce if and only if one takes the single frequency approach within a single family of histories; namely, a family containing histories concerning properties of the quantum system at only two specific moments of time: the infinity past and the infinity future. In that case, as shown by Craig and Singh [Phys. Rev. D 82, 123526 (2010)], there is no quantum bounce. In any other situation, the question concerning the existence of a quantum bounce has no meaning in the consistent histories approach. On the contrary, we show that if one considers the de Broglie--Bohm theory, there are always states where quantum bounces occur in both quantization schemes. Hence, the assertion that the Wheeler-DeWitt quantization does not solve the singularity problem in cosmology is not precise. To address this question, one must specify not only the quantum interpretation adopted but also the quantization scheme chosen.

arXiv:1206.4021•Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•Sep 5, 2012•43 citations

A Consistent Histories Formulation of Wheeler-DeWitt Quantum Cosmology

David Craig A, Parampreet Singh, Andrei Yu. Khrennikov

We summarize a fully worked-out consistent histories formulation of a quantum cosmological model, and illustrate with an example calculation of the probability that the quantum universe becomes singular. Specifically, we take a complete Wheeler-DeWitt canonical quantization of a flat Friedmann-Robertson- Walker cosmological model sourced with a free massless scalar field, and construct the decoherence functional which determines which quantum histories may be consistently assigned probabilities. As an example, we exhibit the probability that the quantum universe is singular in the sense that it assumes zero volume. The classical solutions of this model are all singular; we show that the quantum solutions are as well.We comment on the crucial role played by quantum decoherence in arriving at this conclusion. © 2010 American Institute of Physics.

AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2010•4 citations

Consistent probabilities in Wheeler-DeWitt quantum cosmology

David Craig, Parampreet Singh

We give an explicit, rigorous framework for calculating quantum probabilities in a model theory of quantum gravity. Specifically, we construct the decoherence functional for the Wheeler-DeWitt quantization of a flat Friedmann-Robertson-Walker cosmology with a free, massless, minimally coupled scalar field, thus providing a complete decoherent histories formulation for this quantum cosmological model. The decoherence functional is applied to study predictions concerning the model's Dirac (relational) observables; the behavior of semiclassical states and superpositions of such states; and to study the singular behavior of quantum Wheeler-DeWitt universes. Within this framework, rigorous formulas are given for calculating the corresponding probabilities from the wave function when those probabilities may be consistently defined, thus replacing earlier heuristics for interpreting the wave function of the universe with explicit constructions. It is shown according to a rigorously formulated standard, and in a quantum-mechanically consistent way, that in this quantization these models are generically singular. Independent of the choice of state we show that the probability for these Wheeler-DeWitt quantum universes to ever encounter a singularity is unity. In addition, the relation between histories formulations of quantum theory and relational Dirac observables is clarified.

arXiv:1006.3837•Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•Dec 22, 2010•46 citations

Quantum Potential and Cosmological Singularities

Sang Pyo Kim

We apply the de Broglie-Bohm interpretation to the Wheeler-DeWitt equation for the quantum FRW cosmological model with a minimal massless scalar field. We find that the quantum FRW cosmological model has quantum potential dominated solutions that avoid the initial and the final cosmological singularities. It is suggested that the quantum potential and the back-reaction of geometry and matter fields may change the property of the cosmological singularities of the Universe. 1 E-mail: sangkim@knusun1.kunsan.ac.kr 1 Introduction One of the most prominent classical-mechanical problems that quantum mechanics can solve is the classical singularity. For example, an electron of an atom suffers from the instability that due to the infinitely negative Coulomb potential and the electron in a zero-momentum state should fall into the infinite potential 2 . In quantum mechanics, however, the s-wavefunction (zero orbital angular momentum state) of the electron has zero probability at the singula...

•Jan 1, 1997•20 citations

Consistent probabilities in loop quantum cosmology

David A Craig, Parampreet Singh

A fundamental issue for any quantum cosmological theory is to specify how probabilities can be assigned to various quantum events or sequences of events such as the occurrence of singularities or bounces. In previous work, we have demonstrated how this issue can be successfully addressed within the consistent histories approach to quantum theory for Wheeler–DeWitt-quantized cosmological models. In this work, we generalize that analysis to the exactly solvable loop quantization of a spatially flat, homogeneous and isotropic cosmology sourced with a massless, minimally coupled scalar field known as sLQC. We provide an explicit, rigorous and complete decoherent-histories formulation for this model and compute the probabilities for the occurrence of a quantum bounce versus a singularity. Using the scalar field as an emergent internal time, we show for generic states that the probability for a singularity to occur in this model is zero, and that of a bounce is unity, complementing earlier studies of the expectation values of the volume and matter density in this theory. We also show from the consistent histories point of view that all states in this model, whether quantum or classical, achieve arbitrarily large volume in the limit of infinite 'past' or 'future' scalar 'time', in the sense that the wave function evaluated at any arbitrary fixed value of the volume vanishes in that limit. Finally, we briefly discuss certain misconceptions concerning the utility of the consistent histories approach in these models.

arXiv:1306.6142•Classical and Quantum Gravity•Sep 27, 2013•33 citations

Wheeler-DeWitt quantization and singularities

F. T. Falciano, Nelson Pinto-Neto, Ward Struyve

We consider a Bohmian approach to the Wheeler-DeWitt quantization of the Friedmann-Lema\^{\i}tre-Robertson-Walker model and investigate the question of whether or not there are singularities, in the sense that the Universe reaches zero volume. We find that for generic wave functions (i.e., nonclassical wave functions), there is a nonzero probability for a trajectory to be nonsingular. This should be contrasted to the consistent histories approach for which it was recently shown by Craig and Singh that there is always a singularity. This result illustrates that the question of singularities depends much on which version of quantum theory one adopts. This was already pointed out by Pinto-Neto et al., albeit with a different Bohmian approach. Our current Bohmian approach agrees with the consistent histories approach by Craig and Singh for single-time histories, unlike the one studied earlier by Pinto-Neto et al. Although the trajectories are usually different in the two Bohmian approaches, their qualitative behavior is the same for generic wave functions.

arXiv:1501.04181•Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•Feb 20, 2015•26 citations
Recently it has been claimed that the Wheeler--DeWitt quantization of gravity is unable to avoid cosmological singularities. However, in order to make this assertion, one must specify the underlying interpretation of quantum mechanics which has been adopted. For instance, several nonsingular models were obtained in Wheeler--DeWitt quantum cosmology in the framework of the de Broglie--Bohm quantum theory. Conversely, there are specific situations where the singularity cannot be avoided in the framework of the consistent histories approach to quantum mechanics. In these specific situations, the matter content is described by a scalar field, and the Wheeler--DeWitt equation looks like a Klein--Gordon equation. The aim of this work is to study a possible singular behavior of quantum cosmological models in which the matter content is described by a hydrodynamical perfect fluid, where the resulting wave equation is a genuine Schr"odinger equation. In this case, it is shown that the conclusions of the consistent histories and the de Broglie--Bohm approaches coincide in the quantum cosmological models where the curvature of the spatial sections is not positive definite, namely, that the cosmological singularities are eliminated. In the case of positive spatial curvature, the family of histories is no longer consistent, and no conclusion can be given in this framework.
We study the Wheeler-DeWitt quantum cosmology of a spatially flat Friedmann cosmological model with a free massless scalar field. We compare the consistent histories approach with the de Broglie--Bohm theory when applied to this simple model under two different quantization schemes: the Schr\"odinger-like quantization, which essentially takes the square root of the resulting Klein-Gordon equation through the restriction to positive frequencies and their associated Newton-Wigner states, or the induced Klein-Gordon quantization, that allows both positive and negative frequencies together. We show that the consistent histories approach can give a precise answer to the question concerning the existence of a quantum bounce if and only if one takes the single frequency approach within a single family of histories; namely, a family containing histories concerning properties of the quantum system at only two specific moments of time: the infinity past and the infinity future. In that case, as shown by Craig and Singh [Phys. Rev. D 82, 123526 (2010)], there is no quantum bounce. In any other situation, the question concerning the existence of a quantum bounce has no meaning in the consistent histories approach. On the contrary, we show that if one considers the de Broglie--Bohm theory, there are always states where quantum bounces occur in both quantization schemes. Hence, the assertion that the Wheeler-DeWitt quantization does not solve the singularity problem in cosmology is not precise. To address this question, one must specify not only the quantum interpretation adopted but also the quantization scheme chosen.
We summarize a fully worked-out consistent histories formulation of a quantum cosmological model, and illustrate with an example calculation of the probability that the quantum universe becomes singular. Specifically, we take a complete Wheeler-DeWitt canonical quantization of a flat Friedmann-Robertson- Walker cosmological model sourced with a free massless scalar field, and construct the decoherence functional which determines which quantum histories may be consistently assigned probabilities. As an example, we exhibit the probability that the quantum universe is singular in the sense that it assumes zero volume. The classical solutions of this model are all singular; we show that the quantum solutions are as well.We comment on the crucial role played by quantum decoherence in arriving at this conclusion. © 2010 American Institute of Physics.
We give an explicit, rigorous framework for calculating quantum probabilities in a model theory of quantum gravity. Specifically, we construct the decoherence functional for the Wheeler-DeWitt quantization of a flat Friedmann-Robertson-Walker cosmology with a free, massless, minimally coupled scalar field, thus providing a complete decoherent histories formulation for this quantum cosmological model. The decoherence functional is applied to study predictions concerning the model's Dirac (relational) observables; the behavior of semiclassical states and superpositions of such states; and to study the singular behavior of quantum Wheeler-DeWitt universes. Within this framework, rigorous formulas are given for calculating the corresponding probabilities from the wave function when those probabilities may be consistently defined, thus replacing earlier heuristics for interpreting the wave function of the universe with explicit constructions. It is shown according to a rigorously formulated standard, and in a quantum-mechanically consistent way, that in this quantization these models are generically singular. Independent of the choice of state we show that the probability for these Wheeler-DeWitt quantum universes to ever encounter a singularity is unity. In addition, the relation between histories formulations of quantum theory and relational Dirac observables is clarified.
We apply the de Broglie-Bohm interpretation to the Wheeler-DeWitt equation for the quantum FRW cosmological model with a minimal massless scalar field. We find that the quantum FRW cosmological model has quantum potential dominated solutions that avoid the initial and the final cosmological singularities. It is suggested that the quantum potential and the back-reaction of geometry and matter fields may change the property of the cosmological singularities of the Universe. 1 E-mail: sangkim@knusun1.kunsan.ac.kr 1 Introduction One of the most prominent classical-mechanical problems that quantum mechanics can solve is the classical singularity. For example, an electron of an atom suffers from the instability that due to the infinitely negative Coulomb potential and the electron in a zero-momentum state should fall into the infinite potential 2 . In quantum mechanics, however, the s-wavefunction (zero orbital angular momentum state) of the electron has zero probability at the singula...
A fundamental issue for any quantum cosmological theory is to specify how probabilities can be assigned to various quantum events or sequences of events such as the occurrence of singularities or bounces. In previous work, we have demonstrated how this issue can be successfully addressed within the consistent histories approach to quantum theory for Wheeler–DeWitt-quantized cosmological models. In this work, we generalize that analysis to the exactly solvable loop quantization of a spatially flat, homogeneous and isotropic cosmology sourced with a massless, minimally coupled scalar field known as sLQC. We provide an explicit, rigorous and complete decoherent-histories formulation for this model and compute the probabilities for the occurrence of a quantum bounce versus a singularity. Using the scalar field as an emergent internal time, we show for generic states that the probability for a singularity to occur in this model is zero, and that of a bounce is unity, complementing earlier studies of the expectation values of the volume and matter density in this theory. We also show from the consistent histories point of view that all states in this model, whether quantum or classical, achieve arbitrarily large volume in the limit of infinite 'past' or 'future' scalar 'time', in the sense that the wave function evaluated at any arbitrary fixed value of the volume vanishes in that limit. Finally, we briefly discuss certain misconceptions concerning the utility of the consistent histories approach in these models.
We consider a Bohmian approach to the Wheeler-DeWitt quantization of the Friedmann-Lema\^{\i}tre-Robertson-Walker model and investigate the question of whether or not there are singularities, in the sense that the Universe reaches zero volume. We find that for generic wave functions (i.e., nonclassical wave functions), there is a nonzero probability for a trajectory to be nonsingular. This should be contrasted to the consistent histories approach for which it was recently shown by Craig and Singh that there is always a singularity. This result illustrates that the question of singularities depends much on which version of quantum theory one adopts. This was already pointed out by Pinto-Neto et al., albeit with a different Bohmian approach. Our current Bohmian approach agrees with the consistent histories approach by Craig and Singh for single-time histories, unlike the one studied earlier by Pinto-Neto et al. Although the trajectories are usually different in the two Bohmian approaches, their qualitative behavior is the same for generic wave functions.