Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1307.2630 · Physical Review A

Amplification limit of weak measurements: A variational approach

Shengshi Pang, Todd A. Brun, Shengjun Wu, Zeng‐Bing Chen

Published Jul 14, 2014• 13 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Postselected weak measurement has been widely used in experiments to observe weak effects in various physical systems. However, it is still unclear how large the amplification ability of a weak measurement can be and what determines the limit of this ability, which is fundamental to understanding and applying weak measurements. The limitation of the conventional weak-value formalism for this problem is the divergence of weak values when the pre- and postselections are nearly orthogonal. In this paper, we study this problem by a variational approach for a general Hamiltonian ${H}_{\mathrm{int}}=gA\ensuremath{\bigotimes}\ensuremath{\Omega}\ensuremath{\delta}(t\ensuremath{-}{t}_{0}),\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}g\ensuremath{\ll}1$. We derive a general asymptotic solution and show that the amplification limit is essentially independent of $g$ and is determined by only the initial state of the detector and the number of distinct eigenvalues of $A$ or $\ensuremath{\Omega}$. An example of spin-$\frac{1}{2}$ particles with a pair of Stern-Gerlach devices is given to illustrate the results. The limiting case of continuous-variable systems is also investigated to demonstrate the influence of system dimension on the amplification limit.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.90.012108

Related papers

Weak measurement with orthogonal preselection and postselection

Shengshi Pang, Shengjun Wu, Zeng‐Bing Chen

Weak measurement is a novel quantum measurement scheme, which is usually characterized by the weak value formalism. To guarantee the validity of the weak value formalism, the fidelity between the preselection and the postselection should not be too small generally. In this work, we study the weak measurement on a qubit system with exactly or asymptotically orthogonal pre- and postselections. We shall establish a general rigorous framework for the weak measurement beyond the weak value formalism, and obtain the average output of a weak measurement when the pre- and postselections are exactly orthogonal. We shall also study the asymptotic behavior of a weak measurement in the limiting process that the pre- and postselections tend to be orthogonal.

arXiv:1205.0619•Physical Review A•Aug 17, 2012•30 citations

Limits on amplification by Aharonov-Albert-Vaidman weak measurement

Tatsuhiko Koike, Saki Tanaka

We analyze the amplification by the Aharonov-Albert-Vaidman weak quantum measurement on a Sagnac interferometer [Dixon et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 102, 173601 (2009)] up to all orders of the coupling strength between the measured system and the measuring device. The amplifier transforms a small tilt of a mirror into a large transverse displacement of the laser beam. The conventional analysis has shown that the measured value is proportional to the weak value, so that the amplification can be made arbitrarily large in the cost of decreasing output laser intensity. It is shown that the measured displacement and the amplification factor are in fact not proportional to the weak value and rather vanish in the limit of infinitesimal output intensity. We derive the optimal overlap of the pre- and postselected states with which the amplification become maximum. We also show that the nonlinear effects begin to arise in the performed experiments so that any improvements in the experiment, typically with an amplification greater than 100, should require the nonlinear theory in translating the observed value to the original displacement.

arXiv:1108.2050•Physical Review A•Dec 5, 2011•59 citations

Weak-value amplification beyond the standard quantum limit in position measurements

A. Nishizawa

In a weak measurement with postselection, a measurement value, called the weak value, can be amplified beyond the eigenvalues of an observable. However, there are some controversies whether weak-value amplification is practically useful in increasing the sensitivity of the measurement, in which fundamental quantum noise dominates. In this paper, we investigate the sensitivity limit of an optical interferometer when weak-value amplification is implemented, properly accounting for quantum shot noise and radiation-pressure noise. To do so, we formulate weak-value amplification in the Heisenberg picture instead of in the Schr\"odinger picture, which is conventionally used. This formulation enables us to understand intuitively what happens when the measurement outcome is postselected and the weak value is amplified. As a result, we find that the sensitivity limit is given by the standard quantum limit that is the same as in a standard interferometry. We also discuss a way to circumvent the standard quantum limit.

arXiv:1504.04777•Physical Review A•Sep 21, 2015•9 citations

Weak measurements beyond the Aharonov-Albert-Vaidman formalism

Shengjun Wu, Yang Li

We extend the idea of weak measurements to the general case, provide a complete treatment, and obtain results for both the regime when the preselected and postselected states (PPS) are almost orthogonal and the regime when they are exactly orthogonal. We surprisingly find that for a fixed interaction strength, there may exist a maximum signal amplification and a corresponding optimum overlap of PPS to achieve it. For weak measurements in the orthogonal regime, we find interesting quantities that play the same role that weak values play in the nonorthogonal regime.

arXiv:1010.1155•Physical Review A•May 5, 2011•107 citations

Weak Value Amplification of Photons in Optical Nonlinear Medium, Opto-Mechanical, and Spin-Mechanical Systems

Sergio Carrasco, Miguel Orszag

A measurement of an observable A performed on a quantum system that is initially prepared in a state ρi, followed by a probabilistic procedure that leaves the system in a final state ρf, a process often referred as state postselection (or filtering process), can yield, on average, anomalous measurement results, i.e., values that may exceed the eigenvalue range of the observable being measured or be complex numbers. There is, therefore, an amplification effect of the average measurement result, i.e., the effect of the system on the measurement device is increased. When the coupling between the system and the measurement device satisfies some weakness conditions, the amplification effect occurs due to the weak value of the operator A. In this article, the amplification effect due to the postselection process is reviewed, and theoretical proposals and experiments published in the recent literature on the field are commented on. The emphasis is made on interactions occurring in optical nonlinear media and opto-mechanical and spin-mechanical systems, in which the amplification of number operators takes place.

Photonics•Mar 23, 2024•2 citations

Measuring the spin of a spin-1/2 and getting a result of 7

Joseph McGowan, Nicholas Mantella, Noah Baker +1 more

The weak value of an operator is the average result of measuring that operator on a quantum system given specified initial and final states. The overlap between these states appears in the denominator of the weak value, and thus if that overlap is small, the weak value can be arbitrarily large. In 1988, Albert, Aharonov, and Vaidman proposed a weak Stern-Gerlach experiment which would be able to measure a so-called anomalous weak value, a measurement result which lies out- side of the eigenvalue spectrum of the operator being measured. Though anomalous weak values have been measured in numerous optical systems, here we present the first such realization of this experiment as originally proposed. By placing a Bose-Einstein condensate of 87Rb in a magnetic gradient and performing an unlikely postselection, we measure an effective magnification of a weak magnetic momentum kick (~ 8 $μ$m/s) by a factor of 14. We also demonstrate that increasing the momentum kick decreases the "weakness" of the measurement and reduces the amplification.

quant-pharXiv:2609.37822•Sep 30, 2026•0 citations
Postselected weak measurement has been widely used in experiments to observe weak effects in various physical systems. However, it is still unclear how large the amplification ability of a weak measurement can be and what determines the limit of this ability, which is fundamental to understanding and applying weak measurements. The limitation of the conventional weak-value formalism for this problem is the divergence of weak values when the pre- and postselections are nearly orthogonal. In this paper, we study this problem by a variational approach for a general Hamiltonian Hint=gA\ensuremath⨂\ensuremathΩ\ensuremathδ(t\ensuremath−t0),g\ensuremath≪1{H}_{\mathrm{int}}=gA\ensuremath{\bigotimes}\ensuremath{\Omega}\ensuremath{\delta}(t\ensuremath{-}{t}_{0}),\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}g\ensuremath{\ll}1Hint​=gA\ensuremath⨂\ensuremathΩ\ensuremathδ(t\ensuremath−t0​),g\ensuremath≪1. We derive a general asymptotic solution and show that the amplification limit is essentially independent of ggg and is determined by only the initial state of the detector and the number of distinct eigenvalues of AAA or \ensuremathΩ\ensuremath{\Omega}\ensuremathΩ. An example of spin-12\frac{1}{2}21​ particles with a pair of Stern-Gerlach devices is given to illustrate the results. The limiting case of continuous-variable systems is also investigated to demonstrate the influence of system dimension on the amplification limit.
Weak measurement is a novel quantum measurement scheme, which is usually characterized by the weak value formalism. To guarantee the validity of the weak value formalism, the fidelity between the preselection and the postselection should not be too small generally. In this work, we study the weak measurement on a qubit system with exactly or asymptotically orthogonal pre- and postselections. We shall establish a general rigorous framework for the weak measurement beyond the weak value formalism, and obtain the average output of a weak measurement when the pre- and postselections are exactly orthogonal. We shall also study the asymptotic behavior of a weak measurement in the limiting process that the pre- and postselections tend to be orthogonal.
We analyze the amplification by the Aharonov-Albert-Vaidman weak quantum measurement on a Sagnac interferometer [Dixon et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 102, 173601 (2009)] up to all orders of the coupling strength between the measured system and the measuring device. The amplifier transforms a small tilt of a mirror into a large transverse displacement of the laser beam. The conventional analysis has shown that the measured value is proportional to the weak value, so that the amplification can be made arbitrarily large in the cost of decreasing output laser intensity. It is shown that the measured displacement and the amplification factor are in fact not proportional to the weak value and rather vanish in the limit of infinitesimal output intensity. We derive the optimal overlap of the pre- and postselected states with which the amplification become maximum. We also show that the nonlinear effects begin to arise in the performed experiments so that any improvements in the experiment, typically with an amplification greater than 100, should require the nonlinear theory in translating the observed value to the original displacement.
In a weak measurement with postselection, a measurement value, called the weak value, can be amplified beyond the eigenvalues of an observable. However, there are some controversies whether weak-value amplification is practically useful in increasing the sensitivity of the measurement, in which fundamental quantum noise dominates. In this paper, we investigate the sensitivity limit of an optical interferometer when weak-value amplification is implemented, properly accounting for quantum shot noise and radiation-pressure noise. To do so, we formulate weak-value amplification in the Heisenberg picture instead of in the Schr\"odinger picture, which is conventionally used. This formulation enables us to understand intuitively what happens when the measurement outcome is postselected and the weak value is amplified. As a result, we find that the sensitivity limit is given by the standard quantum limit that is the same as in a standard interferometry. We also discuss a way to circumvent the standard quantum limit.
We extend the idea of weak measurements to the general case, provide a complete treatment, and obtain results for both the regime when the preselected and postselected states (PPS) are almost orthogonal and the regime when they are exactly orthogonal. We surprisingly find that for a fixed interaction strength, there may exist a maximum signal amplification and a corresponding optimum overlap of PPS to achieve it. For weak measurements in the orthogonal regime, we find interesting quantities that play the same role that weak values play in the nonorthogonal regime.
A measurement of an observable A performed on a quantum system that is initially prepared in a state ρi, followed by a probabilistic procedure that leaves the system in a final state ρf, a process often referred as state postselection (or filtering process), can yield, on average, anomalous measurement results, i.e., values that may exceed the eigenvalue range of the observable being measured or be complex numbers. There is, therefore, an amplification effect of the average measurement result, i.e., the effect of the system on the measurement device is increased. When the coupling between the system and the measurement device satisfies some weakness conditions, the amplification effect occurs due to the weak value of the operator A. In this article, the amplification effect due to the postselection process is reviewed, and theoretical proposals and experiments published in the recent literature on the field are commented on. The emphasis is made on interactions occurring in optical nonlinear media and opto-mechanical and spin-mechanical systems, in which the amplification of number operators takes place.
The weak value of an operator is the average result of measuring that operator on a quantum system given specified initial and final states. The overlap between these states appears in the denominator of the weak value, and thus if that overlap is small, the weak value can be arbitrarily large. In 1988, Albert, Aharonov, and Vaidman proposed a weak Stern-Gerlach experiment which would be able to measure a so-called anomalous weak value, a measurement result which lies out- side of the eigenvalue spectrum of the operator being measured. Though anomalous weak values have been measured in numerous optical systems, here we present the first such realization of this experiment as originally proposed. By placing a Bose-Einstein condensate of 87Rb in a magnetic gradient and performing an unlikely postselection, we measure an effective magnification of a weak magnetic momentum kick (~ 8 μμμm/s) by a factor of 14. We also demonstrate that increasing the momentum kick decreases the "weakness" of the measurement and reduces the amplification.