Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1211.0661 · Physical Review Letters

Exact Solution for Vortex Dynamics in Temperature Quenches of Two-Dimensional Superfluids

Andrew Forrester, Han-Ching Chu, Gary A. Williams

Published Apr 19, 2013• 15 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

An exact analytic solution for the dynamics of vortex pairs is obtained for rapid temperature quenches of a superfluid film starting from the line of critical points below the critical temperature T(KT). An approximate solution for quenches at and above above T(KT) provides insights into the origin of logarithmic transients in the vortex decay, and is in general agreement with recent simulations of the quenched XY model. These results confirm that there is no "creation" of vortices whose density increases with the quench rate as predicted by the Kibble-Zurek theory but only monotonic decay of the thermal vortices already present at the initial temperature.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.110.165303

Related papers

Dynamics of the forward vortex cascade in two-dimensional quantum turbulence

Andrew Forrester, Gary A. Williams

The dynamics of the forward vortex cascade in 2D turbulence in a superfluid film is investigated using analytic techniques. The cascade is formed by injecting pairs with the same initial seperation (the stirring code) at a constant rate. They move to smaller scales with constant current under the action of frictional forces, finally reaching the core size separation, where they annihilate and the energy is removed by a thermal bath. On switching off the injection, the pair distribution first decays starting from the initial stirring scale, with the total vortex density decreasing linearly in time at a rate equal to the initial injection rate. As pairs at smaller scales decay, the vortex density then falls off as a power law, the same power law found in recent exact solutions of quenched 2D superfluids.

arXiv:1411.5080•Journal of Physics Conference Series•Dec 8, 2014•2 citations

Quench dynamics of the 2dXYmodel

Asja Jelić, Leticia F. Cugliandolo

We investigate the out of equilibrium dynamics of the two-dimensional XY model when cooled across the Berezinskii–Kosterlitz–Thouless (BKT) phase transition using different protocols. We focus on the evolution of the growing correlation length and the density of topological defects (vortices). By using Monte Carlo simulations we first determine the time and temperature dependence of the growing correlation length after an infinitely rapid quench from above the transition temperature to the quasi-long-range order region. The functional form is consistent with a logarithmic correction to the diffusive law and it serves to validate dynamic scaling in this problem. This analysis clarifies the different dynamic roles played by bound and free vortices. We then revisit the Kibble–Zurek mechanism in thermal phase transitions in which the disordered state is plagued with topological defects. We provide a theory of quenching rate dependence in systems with the BKT-type transition that goes beyond the equilibrium scaling arguments. Finally, we discuss the implications of our results for a host of physical systems with vortex excitations, including planar ferromagnets and liquid crystals.

arXiv:1012.0417•Journal of Statistical Mechanics Theory and Experiment•Feb 18, 2011•89 citations

Universal dynamics in the expansion of vortex clusters in a dissipative two-dimensional superfluid

Oliver R. Stockdale, Matthew T. Reeves, Xiaoquan Yu +5 more

A large ensemble of quantum vortices in a superfluid may itself be treated as a novel kind of fluid that exhibits anomalous hydrodynamics. Here we consider the dynamics of vortex clusters under thermal friction and present an analytic solution that uncovers a new universality class in the out-of-equilibrium dynamics of dissipative superfluids. We find that the long-time dynamics of the vorticity distribution is universal in the form of an expanding Rankine vortex (i.e., top-hat distribution) independent of initial conditions. This highlights a fundamentally different decay process to classical fluids, where the Rankine vortex is forbidden by viscous diffusion. Numerical simulations of large ensembles of point vortices confirm the universal expansion dynamics and further reveal the emergence of a frustrated lattice structure marked by strong correlations. We present experimental results of expanding vortex clusters in a quasi-two-dimensional Bose-Einstein condensate that are in excellent agreement with the vortex fluid theory predictions, demonstrating that the signatures of vortex fluid theory can be observed with as few as N∼11 vortices. Our theoretical, numerical, and experimental results establish the validity of the vortex fluid theory for superfluid systems.

Bulletin of the American Physical Society•Mar 18, 2021•0 citations

Dynamics of vortex cluster crystallisation and single-vortex pinning in two-dimensional superfluids

Oliver R. Stockdale

In this thesis, we analytically and numerically study two different scenarios of vortex dynamics in a two-dimensional superfluid. The first system we explore is an expanding cluster of like-sign vortices, which recently suggested it could explain observations in a superfluid optomechanics experiment. We employ a recent theoretical model that approximates large collections of vortices as a fluid and present an analytic solution for its dynamics. Analysis suggests that as a cluster expands due to thermal friction, it forms a Rankine vortex (i.e., a top-hat distribution) that expands self-similarly in time regardless of initial vorticity distribution. Numerical simulations of point vortices confirm this universal expanding regime and further demonstrates vortex lattice formation that goes beyond the vortex fluid theory. We analyse correlations that emerge in the resulting lattices and observe decaying disorder as the cluster expands. Furthermore, we analyse experimental data from a quasi-two-dimensional 87Rb Bose-Einstein condensate, which supports the vortex fluid theory’s predictions.The second scenario considers the dynamics of a scattering event where a single quantum vortex interacts with a uniform, circular pinning potential in a steady two-dimensional superfluid flow. We first develop an approximate hydrodynamical model to understand the interaction between the vortex and the pinning potential in the conservative regime and find it is in good agreement with the mean-field Gross-Pitaevskii equation in the low-velocity limit. We further solve the Gross-Pitaevskii equation for higher background velocities to study how the vortex moves around pinning sites, interacts with it, and ultimately becomes pinned. We uncover four different regimes of vortex pinning, each marked with a characteristic emission of sound energy. Finally, we study how vortices become unpinned from a pinning site, revealing large vortex dipoles form to stabilise the system.Our work in this thesis takes significant steps towards advancing knowledge of both the collective dynamics of vortices and their individual interaction with defects upon surface substrates. Our numerical and analytical results opens up new avenues of exploration be it further understanding dissipation mechanisms in two-dimensional superfluids, or elucidating the nature of vortex pinning in systems such as neutron stars.

•Mar 1, 2021•0 citations

Variations of the Kibble-Zurek scaling exponents of trapped Bose gases

Tenzin Rabga, Yangheon Lee, Dalmin Bae +2 more

We study the vortex nucleation dynamics in inhomogeneous atomic Bose gases quenched into a superfluid phase and investigate the dependence of the Kibble-Zurek (KZ) scaling exponent on the underlying trap configuration. For samples in a number of different inhomogeneous traps, we observe the characteristic power-law scaling of the vortex number with the thermal quench rate, as well as an enhanced vortex suppression in the outer regions with lower particle density, in agreement with the causality effect as encapsulated in the inhomogeneous Kibble-Zurek mechanism (IKZM). However, the measured KZ scaling exponents show significant differences from the theoretical estimates, and furthermore their trends as a function of the underlying trap configuration deviate from the IKZM prediction. We also investigate the early-time coarsening effect using a two-step quench protocol as proposed in a recent study and show that the interpretation of the measurement results without including the causality effect might be misleading. This paper provides a comprehensive study of vortex formation dynamics in quenched Bose gases confined in inhomogeneous trapping potentials and calls for a refined theoretical framework for quantitative understanding of the phase transition and defect formation processes in such inhomogeneous systems.

arXiv:2305.19483•Physical Review A•Aug 25, 2023•10 citations

Supercritical superfluid and vortex unbinding following a quantum quench

Ludwig Mathey, Anatoli Polkovnikov

We study the dynamics of the relative phase of a bilayer of two-dimensional superfluids after the two superfluids have been decoupled, using truncated Wigner approximation. On short time scales the relative phase shows ``light-cone''-like thermalization and creates a metastable superfluid state, which can be supercritical. On longer time scales this state relaxes to a disordered state due to dynamical vortex unbinding. This scenario of dynamically suppressed vortex proliferation constitutes a reverse-Kibble-Zurek effect. We observe dynamics of creation of vortex-antivortex pairs and their consequent motion. Our predictions can be directly measured in interference experiments [Z. Hadzibabic et al., Nature (London) 441, 1118 (2006)].

arXiv:0904.2881•Physical Review A•Oct 5, 2009•17 citations
An exact analytic solution for the dynamics of vortex pairs is obtained for rapid temperature quenches of a superfluid film starting from the line of critical points below the critical temperature T(KT). An approximate solution for quenches at and above above T(KT) provides insights into the origin of logarithmic transients in the vortex decay, and is in general agreement with recent simulations of the quenched XY model. These results confirm that there is no "creation" of vortices whose density increases with the quench rate as predicted by the Kibble-Zurek theory but only monotonic decay of the thermal vortices already present at the initial temperature.
The dynamics of the forward vortex cascade in 2D turbulence in a superfluid film is investigated using analytic techniques. The cascade is formed by injecting pairs with the same initial seperation (the stirring code) at a constant rate. They move to smaller scales with constant current under the action of frictional forces, finally reaching the core size separation, where they annihilate and the energy is removed by a thermal bath. On switching off the injection, the pair distribution first decays starting from the initial stirring scale, with the total vortex density decreasing linearly in time at a rate equal to the initial injection rate. As pairs at smaller scales decay, the vortex density then falls off as a power law, the same power law found in recent exact solutions of quenched 2D superfluids.
We investigate the out of equilibrium dynamics of the two-dimensional XY model when cooled across the Berezinskii–Kosterlitz–Thouless (BKT) phase transition using different protocols. We focus on the evolution of the growing correlation length and the density of topological defects (vortices). By using Monte Carlo simulations we first determine the time and temperature dependence of the growing correlation length after an infinitely rapid quench from above the transition temperature to the quasi-long-range order region. The functional form is consistent with a logarithmic correction to the diffusive law and it serves to validate dynamic scaling in this problem. This analysis clarifies the different dynamic roles played by bound and free vortices. We then revisit the Kibble–Zurek mechanism in thermal phase transitions in which the disordered state is plagued with topological defects. We provide a theory of quenching rate dependence in systems with the BKT-type transition that goes beyond the equilibrium scaling arguments. Finally, we discuss the implications of our results for a host of physical systems with vortex excitations, including planar ferromagnets and liquid crystals.
A large ensemble of quantum vortices in a superfluid may itself be treated as a novel kind of fluid that exhibits anomalous hydrodynamics. Here we consider the dynamics of vortex clusters under thermal friction and present an analytic solution that uncovers a new universality class in the out-of-equilibrium dynamics of dissipative superfluids. We find that the long-time dynamics of the vorticity distribution is universal in the form of an expanding Rankine vortex (i.e., top-hat distribution) independent of initial conditions. This highlights a fundamentally different decay process to classical fluids, where the Rankine vortex is forbidden by viscous diffusion. Numerical simulations of large ensembles of point vortices confirm the universal expansion dynamics and further reveal the emergence of a frustrated lattice structure marked by strong correlations. We present experimental results of expanding vortex clusters in a quasi-two-dimensional Bose-Einstein condensate that are in excellent agreement with the vortex fluid theory predictions, demonstrating that the signatures of vortex fluid theory can be observed with as few as N∼11 vortices. Our theoretical, numerical, and experimental results establish the validity of the vortex fluid theory for superfluid systems.
In this thesis, we analytically and numerically study two different scenarios of vortex dynamics in a two-dimensional superfluid. The first system we explore is an expanding cluster of like-sign vortices, which recently suggested it could explain observations in a superfluid optomechanics experiment. We employ a recent theoretical model that approximates large collections of vortices as a fluid and present an analytic solution for its dynamics. Analysis suggests that as a cluster expands due to thermal friction, it forms a Rankine vortex (i.e., a top-hat distribution) that expands self-similarly in time regardless of initial vorticity distribution. Numerical simulations of point vortices confirm this universal expanding regime and further demonstrates vortex lattice formation that goes beyond the vortex fluid theory. We analyse correlations that emerge in the resulting lattices and observe decaying disorder as the cluster expands. Furthermore, we analyse experimental data from a quasi-two-dimensional 87Rb Bose-Einstein condensate, which supports the vortex fluid theory’s predictions.The second scenario considers the dynamics of a scattering event where a single quantum vortex interacts with a uniform, circular pinning potential in a steady two-dimensional superfluid flow. We first develop an approximate hydrodynamical model to understand the interaction between the vortex and the pinning potential in the conservative regime and find it is in good agreement with the mean-field Gross-Pitaevskii equation in the low-velocity limit. We further solve the Gross-Pitaevskii equation for higher background velocities to study how the vortex moves around pinning sites, interacts with it, and ultimately becomes pinned. We uncover four different regimes of vortex pinning, each marked with a characteristic emission of sound energy. Finally, we study how vortices become unpinned from a pinning site, revealing large vortex dipoles form to stabilise the system.Our work in this thesis takes significant steps towards advancing knowledge of both the collective dynamics of vortices and their individual interaction with defects upon surface substrates. Our numerical and analytical results opens up new avenues of exploration be it further understanding dissipation mechanisms in two-dimensional superfluids, or elucidating the nature of vortex pinning in systems such as neutron stars.
We study the vortex nucleation dynamics in inhomogeneous atomic Bose gases quenched into a superfluid phase and investigate the dependence of the Kibble-Zurek (KZ) scaling exponent on the underlying trap configuration. For samples in a number of different inhomogeneous traps, we observe the characteristic power-law scaling of the vortex number with the thermal quench rate, as well as an enhanced vortex suppression in the outer regions with lower particle density, in agreement with the causality effect as encapsulated in the inhomogeneous Kibble-Zurek mechanism (IKZM). However, the measured KZ scaling exponents show significant differences from the theoretical estimates, and furthermore their trends as a function of the underlying trap configuration deviate from the IKZM prediction. We also investigate the early-time coarsening effect using a two-step quench protocol as proposed in a recent study and show that the interpretation of the measurement results without including the causality effect might be misleading. This paper provides a comprehensive study of vortex formation dynamics in quenched Bose gases confined in inhomogeneous trapping potentials and calls for a refined theoretical framework for quantitative understanding of the phase transition and defect formation processes in such inhomogeneous systems.
We study the dynamics of the relative phase of a bilayer of two-dimensional superfluids after the two superfluids have been decoupled, using truncated Wigner approximation. On short time scales the relative phase shows ``light-cone''-like thermalization and creates a metastable superfluid state, which can be supercritical. On longer time scales this state relaxes to a disordered state due to dynamical vortex unbinding. This scenario of dynamically suppressed vortex proliferation constitutes a reverse-Kibble-Zurek effect. We observe dynamics of creation of vortex-antivortex pairs and their consequent motion. Our predictions can be directly measured in interference experiments [Z. Hadzibabic et al., Nature (London) 441, 1118 (2006)].