Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1211.0433

The few-body universality is not exact for more than three particles

D. K. Gridnev

Published Nov 2, 2012• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In the literature it is conjectured that the ground state energies of three and four bosons are universally related for all pair-interactions given that two bosons have a zero energy resonance and no negative energy bound states. Here it is proved analytically that such relation cannot be exact.
DOI
10.48550/arxiv.1211.0433

Related papers

Scaling and universality in two dimensions: three-body bound states with short-ranged interactions

F F Bellotti, T. Frederico, M T Yamashita +3 more

The momentum space zero-range model is used to investigate universal properties of three interacting particles confined to two dimensions. The pertinent equations are first formulated for a system of two identical and one distinct particle and the two different two-body subsystems are characterized by two-body energies and masses. The three-body energy in units of one of the two-body energies is a universal function of the other two-body energy and the mass ratio. We derive convenient analytical formulae for calculations of the three-body energy as a function of these two independent parameters and exhibit the results as universal curves. In particular, we show that the three-body system can have any number of stable bound states. When the mass ratio of the distinct to identical particles is greater than 0.22, we find that at most two stable bound states exist, while for two heavy and one light mass an increasing number of bound states is possible. The specific number of stable bound states depends on the ratio of two-body bound state energies and on the mass ratio, and we map out an energy–mass phase diagram of the number of stable bound states. Realizable systems of both fermions and bosons are discussed in this framework.

arXiv:1107.3017•Journal of Physics B Atomic Molecular and Optical Physics•Sep 26, 2011•29 citations

Emergent four-body parameter in universal two-species bosonic systems

Lorenzo Contessi, Johannes Kirscher, Manuel Pavón Valderrama

The description of unitary few-boson systems is conceptually simple: only one parameter – the three-body binding energy – is required to predict the binding energies of clusters with an arbitrary number of bosons. Whether this correlation between the three- and many-boson systems still holds for two species of bosons for which only the inter-species interaction is resonant depends on how many particles of each species are in the system. For few-body clusters with species A and B and a resonant AB interaction, it is known that the emergent AAB and ABB three-body scales are correlated to the ground-state binding energies of the AAAB and ABBB systems, respectively. We find that this link between three and four bodies is broken for the AABB tetramer whose binding energy is neither constrained by the AAB nor by the ABB trimer. From this de-correlation, we predict the existence of a scale unique to the AABB tetramer. In our explanation of this phenomenon, we understand the AABB and AAAB/ABBB tetramers as representatives of two different universal classes of N-body systems with distinct renormalization-group and discrete-scaling properties.

arXiv:2103.14711•Physics Letters A•Jun 2, 2021•2 citations

Universality and scaling limit of weakly-bound tetramers

M. R. Hadizadeh, Marcelo Takeshi Yamashita, Lauro Tomio D +2 more

The occurrence of a new limit cycle in few-body physics, expressing a universal scaling function relating the binding energies of two successive tetramer states, is revealed by considering a renormalized zero-range two-body interaction in bound state of four identical bosons. The tetramer energy spectrum is obtained by adding a boson to an Efimov bound state with energy B3 in the unitary limit (for zero two-body binding energy or infinite two-body scattering length). Each excited Nth tetramer energy B(N)4 is shown to slide along a scaling function as a short-range four-body scale is changed, emerging from the 3+1 threshold for a universal ratio B4(N)/B3 = 4.6, which does not depend on N. The new scale can also be revealed by a resonance in the atom-trimer recombination process.

AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2012•6 citations

Exact renormalization relation and binding energies for three identical bosons

Langxuan Chen, Pengfei Zhang

In the low-energy limit, non-relativistic particles with short-range interactions exhibit universal behavior that is largely independent of microscopic details. This universality is typically described by effective field theory, in which the two-body interaction is renormalized to a single parameter-the scattering length. For systems of identical bosons, the three-body problem reveals the Efimov effect, a novel phenomenon proposed that necessitates the introduction of an additional three-body parameter. However, the exact relation between this three-body parameter, the coupling constants in the effective field theory, and the binding energies of Efimov states remains unresolved. In this Letter, we address this question through a comprehensive analysis of the Skorniakov-Ter-Martirosian equation with a finite cutoff. We establish an exact renormalization relation for the three-body parameter and determine its connection to the energies of Efimov bound states. These results are validated through high-precision numerical simulations. We expect our findings to be of fundamental interest across various fields, including atomic, nuclear, condensed matter, and particle physics, and to have broad applications in both few-body and many-body physics.

arXiv:2506.12531•Physical Review A•Aug 29, 2025•3 citations

Exact solution of the three-boson problem at vanishing energy

Christophe Mora, Alexander O. Gogolin, Reinhold Egger

A zero-range approach is used to model resonant two-body interactions between three identical bosons. A dimensionless phase parametrizes the three-body boundary condition while the scattering length enters the Bethe–Peierls boundary condition. The model is solved exactly at zero energy for any value of the scattering length, positive or negative. From this solution, an analytical expression for the rate of three-body recombination to the universal shallow dimer is extracted.

arXiv:1007.4818•Comptes Rendus Physique•Jan 1, 2011•9 citations

Proof of universality in one-dimensional few-body systems including anisotropic interactions

Lucas Happ, Maxim A. Efremov

Abstract We provide an analytical proof of universality for bound states in one-dimensional systems of two and three particles, valid for short-range interactions with negative or vanishing integral over space. The proof is performed in the limit of weak pair-interactions and covers both binding energies and wave functions. Moreover, in this limit the results are formally shown to converge to the respective ones found in the case of the zero-range contact interaction.

arXiv:2107.12233•Journal of Physics B Atomic Molecular and Optical Physics•Nov 3, 2021•4 citations
The momentum space zero-range model is used to investigate universal properties of three interacting particles confined to two dimensions. The pertinent equations are first formulated for a system of two identical and one distinct particle and the two different two-body subsystems are characterized by two-body energies and masses. The three-body energy in units of one of the two-body energies is a universal function of the other two-body energy and the mass ratio. We derive convenient analytical formulae for calculations of the three-body energy as a function of these two independent parameters and exhibit the results as universal curves. In particular, we show that the three-body system can have any number of stable bound states. When the mass ratio of the distinct to identical particles is greater than 0.22, we find that at most two stable bound states exist, while for two heavy and one light mass an increasing number of bound states is possible. The specific number of stable bound states depends on the ratio of two-body bound state energies and on the mass ratio, and we map out an energy–mass phase diagram of the number of stable bound states. Realizable systems of both fermions and bosons are discussed in this framework.
The description of unitary few-boson systems is conceptually simple: only one parameter – the three-body binding energy – is required to predict the binding energies of clusters with an arbitrary number of bosons. Whether this correlation between the three- and many-boson systems still holds for two species of bosons for which only the inter-species interaction is resonant depends on how many particles of each species are in the system. For few-body clusters with species A and B and a resonant AB interaction, it is known that the emergent AAB and ABB three-body scales are correlated to the ground-state binding energies of the AAAB and ABBB systems, respectively. We find that this link between three and four bodies is broken for the AABB tetramer whose binding energy is neither constrained by the AAB nor by the ABB trimer. From this de-correlation, we predict the existence of a scale unique to the AABB tetramer. In our explanation of this phenomenon, we understand the AABB and AAAB/ABBB tetramers as representatives of two different universal classes of N-body systems with distinct renormalization-group and discrete-scaling properties.
The occurrence of a new limit cycle in few-body physics, expressing a universal scaling function relating the binding energies of two successive tetramer states, is revealed by considering a renormalized zero-range two-body interaction in bound state of four identical bosons. The tetramer energy spectrum is obtained by adding a boson to an Efimov bound state with energy B3 in the unitary limit (for zero two-body binding energy or infinite two-body scattering length). Each excited Nth tetramer energy B(N)4 is shown to slide along a scaling function as a short-range four-body scale is changed, emerging from the 3+1 threshold for a universal ratio B4(N)/B3 = 4.6, which does not depend on N. The new scale can also be revealed by a resonance in the atom-trimer recombination process.
In the low-energy limit, non-relativistic particles with short-range interactions exhibit universal behavior that is largely independent of microscopic details. This universality is typically described by effective field theory, in which the two-body interaction is renormalized to a single parameter-the scattering length. For systems of identical bosons, the three-body problem reveals the Efimov effect, a novel phenomenon proposed that necessitates the introduction of an additional three-body parameter. However, the exact relation between this three-body parameter, the coupling constants in the effective field theory, and the binding energies of Efimov states remains unresolved. In this Letter, we address this question through a comprehensive analysis of the Skorniakov-Ter-Martirosian equation with a finite cutoff. We establish an exact renormalization relation for the three-body parameter and determine its connection to the energies of Efimov bound states. These results are validated through high-precision numerical simulations. We expect our findings to be of fundamental interest across various fields, including atomic, nuclear, condensed matter, and particle physics, and to have broad applications in both few-body and many-body physics.