Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1211.0261 · Physical Review A

Quantum sensors based on weak-value amplification cannot overcome decoherence

George C. Knee, G. Andrew D. Briggs, Simon C. Benjamin, Erik M. Gauger

Published Jan 16, 2013• 54 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Sensors that harness exclusively quantum phenomena (such as entanglement) can achieve superior performance compared to those employing only classical principles. Recently, a technique based on postselected, weakly performed measurements has emerged as a method of overcoming technical noise in the detection and estimation of small interaction parameters, particularly in optical systems. The question of which other types of noise may be combated remains open. We here analyze whether the effect can overcome decoherence in a typical field-sensing scenario. Benchmarking a weak, postselected measurement strategy against a strong, direct strategy, we conclude that no advantage is achievable, and that even a small amount of decoherence proves catastrophic to the weak-value amplification technique.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.87.012115

Related papers

Weak Value Amplification is Suboptimal for Estimation and Detection

Christopher Ferrie, Joshua Combes

We show by using statistically rigorous arguments that the technique of weak value amplification does not perform better than standard statistical techniques for the tasks of single parameter estimation and signal detection. Specifically, we prove that postselection, a necessary ingredient for weak value amplification, decreases estimation accuracy and, moreover, arranging for anomalously large weak values is a suboptimal strategy. In doing so, we explicitly provide the optimal estimator, which in turn allows us to identify the optimal experimental arrangement to be the one in which all outcomes have equal weak values (all as small as possible) and the initial state of the meter is the maximal eigenvalue of the square of the system observable. Finally, we give precise quantitative conditions for when weak measurement (measurements without postselection or anomalously large weak values) can mitigate the effect of uncharacterized technical noise in estimation.

arXiv:1307.4016•Physical Review Letters•Jan 31, 2014•213 citations

Optimal Settings for Amplification and Estimation Of Small Effects In Postselected Ensembles

A. M. Rostom

Abstract To describe the pre‐ and postselected quantum ensembles, a complex quantity called the weak value of an operator is used. The weak value is highly controversial due to the fact that it is not bounded by the possible eigenvalues of the corresponding operator. Nevertheless, the obtaining of the anomalous weak value is regarded as a powerful technique in the quantum interferometry nowadays. Here it is shown that the postselection of a quantum system recovers a completely hidden interference effect in the measurement apparatus. Studying the interference pattern shows the optimal settings for the amplification and the parameter estimation. It also proves that the weak value is not an element of reality. Using single photons, it is investigated how a postselected photon can impart a π phase shift (the peak of the amplification) to a photon interacting weakly with it in a nonlinear optical medium. The increasing of the degree of the entanglement lies behind the effectiveness of the postselection in the parameter estimation. In particular, arranging to postselect on pure entangled states can optimize the signal‐to‐noise ratio, allowing to achieve high‐sensitive measurements using low input power.

arXiv:2303.09786•Annalen der Physik•Dec 2, 2021•4 citations

Effects of phase fluctuations on weak-value-based quantum metrology

Qing-Lin Wu, Ke-Xuan Chen, Zi-Rui Zhong

Weak measurement has ignited extensive research and discussions in the field of quantum metrology due to its sufficient potential in quantum measurement applications. Recent studies demonstrate that weak measurement protocols, when integrated with quantum resources, can achieve Heisenberg scaling while maintaining technical noise advantages. However, scenarios involving dephasing noise have not been addressed, as such noise induces rapid degradation of Heisenberg scaling to the standard quantum limit. Here, we incorporate phase fluctuations, a typical dephasing noise, into three Heisenberg-scaling systems. We find that postselection invariably reduces the robustness of quantum systems. Compared to coherent pointer states, squeezed coherent pointer states can exhibit superior resilience against phase fluctuations through appropriate squeezing-parameter optimization. In addition, in entanglement-assisted systems, we can optimize the postselected angle to compensate for Fisher information loss induced by the postselection process. Our findings reveal that weak measurement exhibits inherent limitations in dephasing noise metrology compared to conventional measurement.

Journal of the Optical Society of America B•Aug 1, 2025•0 citations

Achieving metrological precision limits through postselection

G. B. Alves, Arthur Pimentel, Malena O. Hor-Meyll +3 more

Postselection strategies have been proposed with the aim of amplifying weak signals, which may help to overcome detection thresholds associated with technical noise in high-precision measurements. Here we use an optical setup to experimentally explore two different postselection protocols for the estimation of a small parameter: a weak-value amplification procedure and an alternative method that does not provide amplification but nonetheless is shown to be more robust for the sake of parameter estimation. Each technique leads approximately to the saturation of quantum limits for the estimation precision, expressed by the Cram\'er-Rao bound. For both situations, we show that parameter estimation is improved when the postselection statistics are considered together with the measurement device.

arXiv:1606.03478•Physical Review A•Jan 6, 2017•16 citations

Protecting weak measurements against systematic errors

Shengshi Pang, José Raúl González Alonso, Todd A. Brun +1 more

In this work, we consider the systematic error of quantum metrology by weak measurements under decoherence. We derive the systematic error of maximum likelihood estimation in general to the first-order approximation of a small deviation in the probability distribution and study the robustness of standard weak measurement and postselected weak measurements against systematic errors. We show that, with a large weak value, the systematic error of a postselected weak measurement when the probe undergoes decoherence can be significantly lower than that of a standard weak measurement. This indicates another advantage of weak-value amplification in improving the performance of parameter estimation. We illustrate the results by an exact numerical simulation of decoherence arising from a bosonic mode and compare it to the first-order analytical result we obtain.

arXiv:1605.09040•Physical Review A•Jul 18, 2016•44 citations

Realization of entanglement-assisted weak-value amplification in a photonic system

Jiangshan Chen, Bi‐Heng Liu, Mengjun Hu +4 more

Weak-value amplification has been used to enhance the sensitivity of a linear detector response to small interaction parameters. However, the generation of a large weak value gives rise to reduction in postselection probability, which restricts the feasibility of the weak-value amplification technique. Recently, theoretical works have shown that the use of entanglement can increase the efficiency of the weak-value amplification method. Specifically, it is proven that by entangling $n$ particles of a system, the maximum postselection probability scales quadratically with $n$ [Pang, Dressel, and Brun, Phys. Rev. Lett. 113, 030401 (2014)]. In this work, we demonstrate an experimental realization of entanglement-assisted weak-value amplification in a photonic system, which shows that importing quantum entanglement can indeed improve the efficiency of weak-value amplification.

Physical Review A•Mar 25, 2019•18 citations
Sensors that harness exclusively quantum phenomena (such as entanglement) can achieve superior performance compared to those employing only classical principles. Recently, a technique based on postselected, weakly performed measurements has emerged as a method of overcoming technical noise in the detection and estimation of small interaction parameters, particularly in optical systems. The question of which other types of noise may be combated remains open. We here analyze whether the effect can overcome decoherence in a typical field-sensing scenario. Benchmarking a weak, postselected measurement strategy against a strong, direct strategy, we conclude that no advantage is achievable, and that even a small amount of decoherence proves catastrophic to the weak-value amplification technique.
We show by using statistically rigorous arguments that the technique of weak value amplification does not perform better than standard statistical techniques for the tasks of single parameter estimation and signal detection. Specifically, we prove that postselection, a necessary ingredient for weak value amplification, decreases estimation accuracy and, moreover, arranging for anomalously large weak values is a suboptimal strategy. In doing so, we explicitly provide the optimal estimator, which in turn allows us to identify the optimal experimental arrangement to be the one in which all outcomes have equal weak values (all as small as possible) and the initial state of the meter is the maximal eigenvalue of the square of the system observable. Finally, we give precise quantitative conditions for when weak measurement (measurements without postselection or anomalously large weak values) can mitigate the effect of uncharacterized technical noise in estimation.
Abstract To describe the pre‐ and postselected quantum ensembles, a complex quantity called the weak value of an operator is used. The weak value is highly controversial due to the fact that it is not bounded by the possible eigenvalues of the corresponding operator. Nevertheless, the obtaining of the anomalous weak value is regarded as a powerful technique in the quantum interferometry nowadays. Here it is shown that the postselection of a quantum system recovers a completely hidden interference effect in the measurement apparatus. Studying the interference pattern shows the optimal settings for the amplification and the parameter estimation. It also proves that the weak value is not an element of reality. Using single photons, it is investigated how a postselected photon can impart a π phase shift (the peak of the amplification) to a photon interacting weakly with it in a nonlinear optical medium. The increasing of the degree of the entanglement lies behind the effectiveness of the postselection in the parameter estimation. In particular, arranging to postselect on pure entangled states can optimize the signal‐to‐noise ratio, allowing to achieve high‐sensitive measurements using low input power.
Weak measurement has ignited extensive research and discussions in the field of quantum metrology due to its sufficient potential in quantum measurement applications. Recent studies demonstrate that weak measurement protocols, when integrated with quantum resources, can achieve Heisenberg scaling while maintaining technical noise advantages. However, scenarios involving dephasing noise have not been addressed, as such noise induces rapid degradation of Heisenberg scaling to the standard quantum limit. Here, we incorporate phase fluctuations, a typical dephasing noise, into three Heisenberg-scaling systems. We find that postselection invariably reduces the robustness of quantum systems. Compared to coherent pointer states, squeezed coherent pointer states can exhibit superior resilience against phase fluctuations through appropriate squeezing-parameter optimization. In addition, in entanglement-assisted systems, we can optimize the postselected angle to compensate for Fisher information loss induced by the postselection process. Our findings reveal that weak measurement exhibits inherent limitations in dephasing noise metrology compared to conventional measurement.
Postselection strategies have been proposed with the aim of amplifying weak signals, which may help to overcome detection thresholds associated with technical noise in high-precision measurements. Here we use an optical setup to experimentally explore two different postselection protocols for the estimation of a small parameter: a weak-value amplification procedure and an alternative method that does not provide amplification but nonetheless is shown to be more robust for the sake of parameter estimation. Each technique leads approximately to the saturation of quantum limits for the estimation precision, expressed by the Cram\'er-Rao bound. For both situations, we show that parameter estimation is improved when the postselection statistics are considered together with the measurement device.
In this work, we consider the systematic error of quantum metrology by weak measurements under decoherence. We derive the systematic error of maximum likelihood estimation in general to the first-order approximation of a small deviation in the probability distribution and study the robustness of standard weak measurement and postselected weak measurements against systematic errors. We show that, with a large weak value, the systematic error of a postselected weak measurement when the probe undergoes decoherence can be significantly lower than that of a standard weak measurement. This indicates another advantage of weak-value amplification in improving the performance of parameter estimation. We illustrate the results by an exact numerical simulation of decoherence arising from a bosonic mode and compare it to the first-order analytical result we obtain.
Weak-value amplification has been used to enhance the sensitivity of a linear detector response to small interaction parameters. However, the generation of a large weak value gives rise to reduction in postselection probability, which restricts the feasibility of the weak-value amplification technique. Recently, theoretical works have shown that the use of entanglement can increase the efficiency of the weak-value amplification method. Specifically, it is proven that by entangling nnn particles of a system, the maximum postselection probability scales quadratically with nnn [Pang, Dressel, and Brun, Phys. Rev. Lett. 113, 030401 (2014)]. In this work, we demonstrate an experimental realization of entanglement-assisted weak-value amplification in a photonic system, which shows that importing quantum entanglement can indeed improve the efficiency of weak-value amplification.