Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1210.5147 · Journal of Mathematical Physics

Why there is no Efimov effect for four bosons and related results on the finiteness of the discrete spectrum

D. K. Gridnev

Published Apr 1, 2013• 9 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We consider a system of N pairwise interacting particles described by the Hamiltonian H, where σess(H) = [0, ∞) and none of the particle pairs has a zero energy resonance. The pair potentials are allowed to take both signs and obey certain restrictions regarding the fall off. It is proved that if N ⩾ 4 and none of the Hamiltonians corresponding to the subsystems containing N − 2 or less particles has an eigenvalue equal to zero then H has a finite number of negative energy bound states. This result provides a positive proof to a long-standing conjecture of Amado and Greenwood stating that four bosons with an empty negative continuous spectrum have at most a finite number of negative energy bound states. Additionally, we give a short proof to the theorem of Vugal'ter and Zhislin on the finiteness of the discrete spectrum and pose a conjecture regarding the existence of the “true” four-body Efimov effect.

DOI
10.1063/1.4800764

Related papers

Efimov pathology in effective two-body system

Heinrich Kroeger, R. Perne

Amado and Greenwood have shown that there is no Efimov effect for four or more particles. The present authors use an (n-1)-fold successive separable approximation (nssa) to the general n-body operator identities. They find that for the conditions considered the necessary condition for the existence of an infinite number of n-body bound levels (n > or = 4) is not violated. The nssa reduces the n-body to an effective two-body phase space. It is concluded that the appearance of the Efimov effect is not restricted to three-body systems. (RWR)

•Jan 1, 1980•0 citations

Absence of a four-body Efimov effect in the 2+2 fermionic problem

Shimpei Endo, Yvan Castin

In the free three-dimensional space, we consider a pair of identical $\ensuremath{\uparrow}$ fermions of some species or in some internal state and a pair of identical $\ensuremath{\downarrow}$ fermions of another species or in another state. There is a resonant $s$-wave interaction (that is, of zero range and infinite scattering length) between fermions in different pairs and no interaction within the same pair. We study whether this $2+2$ fermionic system can exhibit (as the $3+1$ fermionic system) a four-body Efimov effect in the absence of three-body Efimov effect, that is, the mass ratio $\ensuremath{\alpha}$ between $\ensuremath{\uparrow}$ and $\ensuremath{\downarrow}$ fermions and its inverse are both smaller than 13.6069\dots{}. For this purpose, we investigate scale invariant zero-energy solutions of the four-body Schr\"odinger equation, that is, positively homogeneous functions of the coordinates of degree $s\ensuremath{-}7/2$, where $s$ is a generalized Efimov exponent that becomes purely imaginary in the presence of a four-body Efimov effect. Using rotational invariance in momentum space, it is found that the allowed values of $s$ are such that $M(s)$ has a zero eigenvalue; here the operator $M(s)$, that depends on the total angular momentum $\ensuremath{\ell}$, acts on functions of two real variables (the cosine of the angle between two wave vectors and the logarithm of the ratio of their moduli), and we write it explicitly in terms of an integral matrix kernel. We have performed a spectral analysis of $M(s)$, analytical and for an arbitrary imaginary $s$ for the continuous spectrum and numerical and limited to $s=0$ and $\ensuremath{\ell}\ensuremath{\le}12$ for the discrete spectrum. We conclude that no eigenvalue of $M(0)$ crosses zero over the mass ratio interval $\ensuremath{\alpha}\ensuremath{\in}[1;13.6069\ensuremath{\cdots}]$, even if, in the parity sector ${(\ensuremath{-}1)}^{\ensuremath{\ell}}$, the continuous spectrum of $M(s)$ has everywhere a zero lower border. As a consequence, there is no possibility of a four-body Efimov effect for the $2+2$ fermions. We also enunciated a conjecture for the fourth virial coefficient of the unitary spin-$1/2$ Fermi gas, inspired from the known analytical form of the third cluster coefficient and involving the integral over the imaginary $s$ axis of $s$ times the logarithmic derivative of the determinant of $M(s)$ summed over all angular momenta. The conjectured value is in contradiction with the experimental results.

arXiv:1507.05580•Physical Review A•Nov 24, 2015•30 citations

On the Efimov Effect for Four Particles in Dimension Two

Jonathan Rau, Marvin R. Schulz

We prove that the Schrödinger operator describing four particles in two dimensions, interacting solely through short-range three-body forces, can possess infinitely many bound states. This holds under the assumption that each three-body subsystem has a virtual level at zero energy. Our result establishes an analog of the Efimov effect for such four-particle systems in two dimensions.

math-phCross-listedarXiv:2602.05942•Feb 6, 2026•0 citations

Three resonating fermions in flatland: proof of the super Efimov effect and the exact discrete spectrum asymptotics

D. K. Gridnev

We consider the system of three nonrelativistic spinless fermions in two dimensions, which interact through spherically-symmetric pair interactions. Recently, a claim has been made by Nishida et al for the existence of the so-called super Efimov effect by Nishida et al (2013 Phys. Rev. Lett. 110 235301 ). Namely, if the interactions in the system are fine-tuned to a p-wave resonance, an infinite number of bound states appears, whose negative energies are scaled according to the double exponential law. We present the mathematical proof that such a system indeed has an infinite number of bound levels. We also prove that , where N ( E ) is the number of bound states with the energy less than . The value of this limit is exactly equal to the value derived in Nishida et al using the renormalization group approach. Our proof resolves a recent controversy about the validity of results in Nishida et al (2013 Phys. Rev. Lett. 110 235301 ).

arXiv:1405.1787•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Nov 26, 2014•38 citations

Efimov's Effect: A New Pathology of Three-Particle Systems. II

R. D. Amado, Julian V. Noble

By studying the eigenvalue spectrum of the Faddeev kernel in a certain singular limit, we give an independent proof of an effect recently deduced by Efimov: When three identical particles interact via short-range pairwise potentials, the number of three-body bound states grows without limit when the pairwise scattering length $a$ becomes large. [The number of bound states is then roughly $(\frac{1}{\ensuremath{\pi}})\mathrm{ln}(\ensuremath{\Lambda}|a|)$, where $\ensuremath{\Lambda}$ is a momentum cutoff]. We extend our proof to the case where only two particles are identical and show that Efimov's effect persists in the special limiting cases with two heavy and one light particle, and with two light and one heavy particle.

Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•Apr 15, 1972•134 citations

There Is No Efimov Effect for Four or More Particles

Ralph D. Amado, F. C. Greenwood

We show that the existence of a zero-energy ($n\ensuremath{-}1$)-body bound state will not produce an infinite number of $n$-body bound states for $n\ensuremath{\ge}4$. We show this in particular for $n=4$, and sketch the proof for $n>4$.

Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•Apr 15, 1973•62 citations
We consider a system of N pairwise interacting particles described by the Hamiltonian H, where σess(H) = [0, ∞) and none of the particle pairs has a zero energy resonance. The pair potentials are allowed to take both signs and obey certain restrictions regarding the fall off. It is proved that if N ⩾ 4 and none of the Hamiltonians corresponding to the subsystems containing N − 2 or less particles has an eigenvalue equal to zero then H has a finite number of negative energy bound states. This result provides a positive proof to a long-standing conjecture of Amado and Greenwood stating that four bosons with an empty negative continuous spectrum have at most a finite number of negative energy bound states. Additionally, we give a short proof to the theorem of Vugal'ter and Zhislin on the finiteness of the discrete spectrum and pose a conjecture regarding the existence of the “true” four-body Efimov effect.
Amado and Greenwood have shown that there is no Efimov effect for four or more particles. The present authors use an (n-1)-fold successive separable approximation (nssa) to the general n-body operator identities. They find that for the conditions considered the necessary condition for the existence of an infinite number of n-body bound levels (n > or = 4) is not violated. The nssa reduces the n-body to an effective two-body phase space. It is concluded that the appearance of the Efimov effect is not restricted to three-body systems. (RWR)
In the free three-dimensional space, we consider a pair of identical $\ensuremath{\uparrow}$ fermions of some species or in some internal state and a pair of identical $\ensuremath{\downarrow}$ fermions of another species or in another state. There is a resonant sss-wave interaction (that is, of zero range and infinite scattering length) between fermions in different pairs and no interaction within the same pair. We study whether this 2+22+22+2 fermionic system can exhibit (as the 3+13+13+1 fermionic system) a four-body Efimov effect in the absence of three-body Efimov effect, that is, the mass ratio $\ensuremath{\alpha}$ between $\ensuremath{\uparrow}$ and $\ensuremath{\downarrow}$ fermions and its inverse are both smaller than 13.6069\dots{}. For this purpose, we investigate scale invariant zero-energy solutions of the four-body Schr\"odinger equation, that is, positively homogeneous functions of the coordinates of degree $s\ensuremath{-}7/2$, where sss is a generalized Efimov exponent that becomes purely imaginary in the presence of a four-body Efimov effect. Using rotational invariance in momentum space, it is found that the allowed values of sss are such that M(s)M(s)M(s) has a zero eigenvalue; here the operator M(s)M(s)M(s), that depends on the total angular momentum $\ensuremath{\ell}$, acts on functions of two real variables (the cosine of the angle between two wave vectors and the logarithm of the ratio of their moduli), and we write it explicitly in terms of an integral matrix kernel. We have performed a spectral analysis of M(s)M(s)M(s), analytical and for an arbitrary imaginary sss for the continuous spectrum and numerical and limited to s=0s=0s=0 and $\ensuremath{\ell}\ensuremath{\le}12$ for the discrete spectrum. We conclude that no eigenvalue of M(0)M(0)M(0) crosses zero over the mass ratio interval $\ensuremath{\alpha}\ensuremath{\in}[1;13.6069\ensuremath{\cdots}]$, even if, in the parity sector ${(\ensuremath{-}1)}^{\ensuremath{\ell}}$, the continuous spectrum of M(s)M(s)M(s) has everywhere a zero lower border. As a consequence, there is no possibility of a four-body Efimov effect for the 2+22+22+2 fermions. We also enunciated a conjecture for the fourth virial coefficient of the unitary spin-1/21/21/2 Fermi gas, inspired from the known analytical form of the third cluster coefficient and involving the integral over the imaginary sss axis of sss times the logarithmic derivative of the determinant of M(s)M(s)M(s) summed over all angular momenta. The conjectured value is in contradiction with the experimental results.
We consider the system of three nonrelativistic spinless fermions in two dimensions, which interact through spherically-symmetric pair interactions. Recently, a claim has been made by Nishida et al for the existence of the so-called super Efimov effect by Nishida et al (2013 Phys. Rev. Lett. 110 235301 ). Namely, if the interactions in the system are fine-tuned to a p-wave resonance, an infinite number of bound states appears, whose negative energies are scaled according to the double exponential law. We present the mathematical proof that such a system indeed has an infinite number of bound levels. We also prove that , where N ( E ) is the number of bound states with the energy less than . The value of this limit is exactly equal to the value derived in Nishida et al using the renormalization group approach. Our proof resolves a recent controversy about the validity of results in Nishida et al (2013 Phys. Rev. Lett. 110 235301 ).
By studying the eigenvalue spectrum of the Faddeev kernel in a certain singular limit, we give an independent proof of an effect recently deduced by Efimov: When three identical particles interact via short-range pairwise potentials, the number of three-body bound states grows without limit when the pairwise scattering length aaa becomes large. [The number of bound states is then roughly $(\frac{1}{\ensuremath{\pi}})\mathrm{ln}(\ensuremath{\Lambda}|a|)$, where $\ensuremath{\Lambda}$ is a momentum cutoff]. We extend our proof to the case where only two particles are identical and show that Efimov's effect persists in the special limiting cases with two heavy and one light particle, and with two light and one heavy particle.
We show that the existence of a zero-energy ($n\ensuremath{-}1$)-body bound state will not produce an infinite number of nnn-body bound states for $n\ensuremath{\ge}4$. We show this in particular for n=4n=4n=4, and sketch the proof for n>4n>4n>4.