Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1208.4834 · Physical Review B

Twist defects and projective non-Abelian braiding statistics

Maissam Barkeshli, Chao‐Ming Jian, Xiao-Liang Qi

Published Jan 31, 2013• 275 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

It has recently been realized that a general class of non-Abelian defects can be created in conventional topological states by introducing extrinsic defects, such as lattice dislocations or superconductor-ferromagnet domain walls in conventional quantum Hall states or topological insulators. In this paper, we begin by placing these defects within the broader conceptual scheme of extrinsic twist defects associated with symmetries of the topological state. We explicitly study several classes of examples, including ${Z}_{2}$ and ${Z}_{3}$ twist defects, where the topological state with $N$ twist defects can be mapped to a topological state without twist defects on a genus $g\ensuremath{\propto}N$ surface. To emphasize this connection we refer to the twist defects as genons. We develop methods to compute the projective non-Abelian braiding statistics of the genons, and we find the braiding is given by adiabatic modular transformations, or Dehn twists, of the topological state on the effective genus $g$ surface. We study the relation between this projective braiding statistics and the ordinary non-Abelian braiding statistics obtained when the genons become deconfined, finite-energy excitations. We find that the braiding is generally different, in contrast to the Majorana case, which opens the possibility for fundamentally novel behavior. We find situations where the genons have quantum dimension 2 and can be used for universal topological quantum computing (TQC), while the host topological state is by itself nonuniversal for TQC.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.87.045130

Related papers

Braiding statistics and congruent invariance of twist defects in bosonic bilayer fractional quantum Hall states

Jeffrey C. Y. Teo, Abhishek Roy, Xiao Chen

We describe the braiding statistics of topological twist defects in fractional quantum Hall (FQH) states. In particular, we study Abelian bosonic $(mmn)$ FQH states with bilayer symmetries. Twist defects are staircases that lift orbiting quasiparticles from one layer to another. These point defects exhibit semiclassical non-Abelian characteristics. We develop a procedure to evaluate consistent basis transformations ($F$ symbols) of the defect fusion theory. Unlike quantum anyonic excitations of a topological phase, the exchange and braiding statistics of twist defects is not characterized by modular transformations, but instead a subcollection known as congruent transformations. We also characterize the projective nature of unitary braiding operations and relate it to the global ${\mathbb{Z}}_{2}$ bilayer symmetry.

arXiv:1308.5984•Physical Review B•Oct 8, 2014•28 citations

Defects between gapped boundaries in two-dimensional topological phases of matter

Iris Cong, Meng Cheng, Zhenghan Wang

Defects between gapped boundaries provide a possible physical realization of projective non-Abelian braid statistics. A notable example is the projective Majorana/parafermion braid statistics of boundary defects in fractional quantum Hall/topological insulator and superconductor heterostructures. In this paper, we develop general theories to analyze the topological properties and projective braiding of boundary defects of topological phases of matter in two spatial dimensions. We present commuting Hamiltonians to realize defects between gapped boundaries in any $(2+1)D$ untwisted Dijkgraaf-Witten theory, and use these to describe their topological properties such as their quantum dimension. By modeling the algebraic structure of boundary defects through multifusion categories, we establish a bulk-edge correspondence between certain boundary defects and symmetry defects in the bulk. Even though it is not clear how to physically braid the defects, this correspondence elucidates the projective braid statistics for many classes of boundary defects, both amongst themselves and with bulk anyons. Specifically, three such classes of importance to condensed matter physics/topological quantum computation are studied in detail: (1) a boundary defect version of Majorana and parafermion zero modes, (2) a similar version of genons in bilayer theories, and (3) boundary defects in $\mathfrak{D}({S}_{3})$.

arXiv:1703.03564•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Nov 14, 2017•36 citations

Theory of defects in Abelian topological states

Maissam Barkeshli, Chao‐Ming Jian, Xiao-Liang Qi

The structure of extrinsic defects in topologically ordered states of matter is host to a rich set of universal physics. Extrinsic defects in $2+1$-dimensional topological states include linelike defects, such as boundaries between topologically distinct states, and pointlike defects, such as junctions between different line defects. Gapped boundaries in particular can themselves be topologically distinct, and the junctions between them can localize topologically protected zero modes, giving rise to topological ground-state degeneracies and projective non-Abelian statistics. In this paper, we develop a general theory of point defects and gapped line defects in $2+1$-dimensional Abelian topological states. We derive a classification of topologically distinct gapped boundaries in terms of certain maximal subgroups of quasiparticles with mutually bosonic statistics, called Lagrangian subgroups. The junctions between different gapped boundaries provide a general classification of point defects in topological states, including as a special case the twist defects considered in previous works. We derive a general formula for the quantum dimension of these point defects and a general understanding of their localized ``parafermion'' zero modes and we define a notion of projective non-Abelian statistics for them. The critical phenomena between topologically distinct gapped boundaries can be understood in terms of a general class of quantum spin chains or, equivalently, ``generalized parafermion'' chains. This provides a way of realizing exotic $1+1\mathrm{D}$ generalized parafermion conformal field theories in condensed-matter systems.

arXiv:1305.7203•Physical Review B•Dec 2, 2013•179 citations

Geometric defects in quantum Hall states

Andrey Gromov

We describe a geometric (or gravitational) analog of the Laughlin quasiholes in fractional quantum Hall states. Analogously to the quasiholes, these defects can be constructed by an insertion of an appropriate vertex operator into the conformal block representation of a trial wave function; however, unlike the quasiholes these defects are extrinsic and do not correspond to true excitations of the quantum fluid. We construct a wave function in the presence of such defects and explain how to assign an electric charge and a spin to each defect and calculate the adiabatic, non-Abelian statistics of the defects. The defects turn out to be equivalent to the genons in that their adiabatic exchange statistics can be described in terms of representations of the mapping class group of an appropriate higher genus Riemann surface. We present a general construction that, in principle, makes it possible to calculate the statistics of ${\mathbb{Z}}_{n}$ genons for any ``parent'' topological phase. We illustrate the construction on the example of the Laughlin state and perform an explicit calculation of the braiding matrices. In addition to non-Abelian statistics, geometric defects possess a universal Abelian overall phase, determined by the gravitational anomaly.

arXiv:1604.03988•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Aug 10, 2016•29 citations

Emergence of synthetic twist defects in the surface code under local perturbation

Paul Kairys, Phillip C. Lotshaw

Topologically-ordered quantum states with Abelian excitations can host defects that obey effective non-Abelian statistics, in principle allowing for quantum information processing via defect braiding. These extrinsic defects (or twists) are typically studied as static features of the lattice. However, an alternative proposal considers how an underlying topologically ordered quantum substrate can be locally perturbed to create and manipulate synthetic defects \cite{you_synthetic_2013}. Unfortunately, while largely referenced, elements of this proposal were never systematically studied. Understanding the energy spectrum is particularly important in finite size and finitely perturbed systems, which are crucial for experimental realizations. In this work we announce a significant step in this direction by explicitly constructing, simplifying, and numerically studying the spectral properties of synthetic defects in a model system. First, we introduce two alternative representations of this problem in both spin and Majorana languages. In the former we describe emergent virtual symmetries which constrain and simplify the problem and in the latter we show a direct connection to Kitaev's well-known Majorana chain. We utilize these simplifications to perform numerical calculations to indicate the location of the quantum phase transition driving the emergence of the synthetic defects. We conclude by discussing key steps for future work to more clearly and completely study this phenomena.

quant-pharXiv:2605.10839•May 12, 2026•0 citations

Anyonic symmetry and twist defects

Mayukh Nilay Khan

Non-Abelian excitations are sought after because of the promise they hold for topological quantum computation. However, in spite of many proposals of systems in which they can occur intrinsically, observation has proved to be elusive. In this thesis, we study ways in which we can engineer such excitations by combining two parent Abelian theories, and as a result allow for defects which host non-Abelian zero modes. We first formulate the symmetries of the anyonic excitations of Abelian topological states. Then, we study properties of semiclassical point defects, called twist defects, which permute orbiting anyons by their symmetries. We see how to realize these defects at domain walls on the gapped edges of non-chiral fractional quantum Hall states. We have distinct gapped edge phases in one to one correspondence with the anyonic symmetries. Non-Abelian twist defects appear between different gapped phases. We study the twist defects for a variety of bosonic ADE fractional quantum spin Hall systems for which the anyonic symmetries turn out to be given by their Dynkin diagrams. We also look at superconducting heterostructures with fermionic quantum Hall states and show the presence of anyonic symmetries and twist defects which physically correspond to a fermion parity flip. This can result in Majorana bound states at such defects instead of more exotic parafermions as was believed before. This is because the presence of the superconductor necessitates the consideration of a larger bosonic topological order. We then investigate the twist defects further by promoting the anyonic symmetries from global to local. This deconfines the defects and results in non-Abelian topological states called twist liquids. Finally, we study the emergence of new topological order from two constituent systems driven by the condensation of a composite boson. This allows us to study a variety of systems with non-Abelian excitations.

•Oct 13, 2017•0 citations
It has recently been realized that a general class of non-Abelian defects can be created in conventional topological states by introducing extrinsic defects, such as lattice dislocations or superconductor-ferromagnet domain walls in conventional quantum Hall states or topological insulators. In this paper, we begin by placing these defects within the broader conceptual scheme of extrinsic twist defects associated with symmetries of the topological state. We explicitly study several classes of examples, including Z2{Z}_{2}Z2​ and Z3{Z}_{3}Z3​ twist defects, where the topological state with NNN twist defects can be mapped to a topological state without twist defects on a genus g\ensuremath∝Ng\ensuremath{\propto}Ng\ensuremath∝N surface. To emphasize this connection we refer to the twist defects as genons. We develop methods to compute the projective non-Abelian braiding statistics of the genons, and we find the braiding is given by adiabatic modular transformations, or Dehn twists, of the topological state on the effective genus ggg surface. We study the relation between this projective braiding statistics and the ordinary non-Abelian braiding statistics obtained when the genons become deconfined, finite-energy excitations. We find that the braiding is generally different, in contrast to the Majorana case, which opens the possibility for fundamentally novel behavior. We find situations where the genons have quantum dimension 2 and can be used for universal topological quantum computing (TQC), while the host topological state is by itself nonuniversal for TQC.
We describe the braiding statistics of topological twist defects in fractional quantum Hall (FQH) states. In particular, we study Abelian bosonic (mmn)(mmn)(mmn) FQH states with bilayer symmetries. Twist defects are staircases that lift orbiting quasiparticles from one layer to another. These point defects exhibit semiclassical non-Abelian characteristics. We develop a procedure to evaluate consistent basis transformations (FFF symbols) of the defect fusion theory. Unlike quantum anyonic excitations of a topological phase, the exchange and braiding statistics of twist defects is not characterized by modular transformations, but instead a subcollection known as congruent transformations. We also characterize the projective nature of unitary braiding operations and relate it to the global Z2{\mathbb{Z}}_{2}Z2​ bilayer symmetry.
Defects between gapped boundaries provide a possible physical realization of projective non-Abelian braid statistics. A notable example is the projective Majorana/parafermion braid statistics of boundary defects in fractional quantum Hall/topological insulator and superconductor heterostructures. In this paper, we develop general theories to analyze the topological properties and projective braiding of boundary defects of topological phases of matter in two spatial dimensions. We present commuting Hamiltonians to realize defects between gapped boundaries in any (2+1)D(2+1)D(2+1)D untwisted Dijkgraaf-Witten theory, and use these to describe their topological properties such as their quantum dimension. By modeling the algebraic structure of boundary defects through multifusion categories, we establish a bulk-edge correspondence between certain boundary defects and symmetry defects in the bulk. Even though it is not clear how to physically braid the defects, this correspondence elucidates the projective braid statistics for many classes of boundary defects, both amongst themselves and with bulk anyons. Specifically, three such classes of importance to condensed matter physics/topological quantum computation are studied in detail: (1) a boundary defect version of Majorana and parafermion zero modes, (2) a similar version of genons in bilayer theories, and (3) boundary defects in D(S3)\mathfrak{D}({S}_{3})D(S3​).
The structure of extrinsic defects in topologically ordered states of matter is host to a rich set of universal physics. Extrinsic defects in 2+12+12+1-dimensional topological states include linelike defects, such as boundaries between topologically distinct states, and pointlike defects, such as junctions between different line defects. Gapped boundaries in particular can themselves be topologically distinct, and the junctions between them can localize topologically protected zero modes, giving rise to topological ground-state degeneracies and projective non-Abelian statistics. In this paper, we develop a general theory of point defects and gapped line defects in 2+12+12+1-dimensional Abelian topological states. We derive a classification of topologically distinct gapped boundaries in terms of certain maximal subgroups of quasiparticles with mutually bosonic statistics, called Lagrangian subgroups. The junctions between different gapped boundaries provide a general classification of point defects in topological states, including as a special case the twist defects considered in previous works. We derive a general formula for the quantum dimension of these point defects and a general understanding of their localized ``parafermion'' zero modes and we define a notion of projective non-Abelian statistics for them. The critical phenomena between topologically distinct gapped boundaries can be understood in terms of a general class of quantum spin chains or, equivalently, ``generalized parafermion'' chains. This provides a way of realizing exotic 1+1D1+1\mathrm{D}1+1D generalized parafermion conformal field theories in condensed-matter systems.
We describe a geometric (or gravitational) analog of the Laughlin quasiholes in fractional quantum Hall states. Analogously to the quasiholes, these defects can be constructed by an insertion of an appropriate vertex operator into the conformal block representation of a trial wave function; however, unlike the quasiholes these defects are extrinsic and do not correspond to true excitations of the quantum fluid. We construct a wave function in the presence of such defects and explain how to assign an electric charge and a spin to each defect and calculate the adiabatic, non-Abelian statistics of the defects. The defects turn out to be equivalent to the genons in that their adiabatic exchange statistics can be described in terms of representations of the mapping class group of an appropriate higher genus Riemann surface. We present a general construction that, in principle, makes it possible to calculate the statistics of Zn{\mathbb{Z}}_{n}Zn​ genons for any ``parent'' topological phase. We illustrate the construction on the example of the Laughlin state and perform an explicit calculation of the braiding matrices. In addition to non-Abelian statistics, geometric defects possess a universal Abelian overall phase, determined by the gravitational anomaly.
Topologically-ordered quantum states with Abelian excitations can host defects that obey effective non-Abelian statistics, in principle allowing for quantum information processing via defect braiding. These extrinsic defects (or twists) are typically studied as static features of the lattice. However, an alternative proposal considers how an underlying topologically ordered quantum substrate can be locally perturbed to create and manipulate synthetic defects \cite{you_synthetic_2013}. Unfortunately, while largely referenced, elements of this proposal were never systematically studied. Understanding the energy spectrum is particularly important in finite size and finitely perturbed systems, which are crucial for experimental realizations. In this work we announce a significant step in this direction by explicitly constructing, simplifying, and numerically studying the spectral properties of synthetic defects in a model system. First, we introduce two alternative representations of this problem in both spin and Majorana languages. In the former we describe emergent virtual symmetries which constrain and simplify the problem and in the latter we show a direct connection to Kitaev's well-known Majorana chain. We utilize these simplifications to perform numerical calculations to indicate the location of the quantum phase transition driving the emergence of the synthetic defects. We conclude by discussing key steps for future work to more clearly and completely study this phenomena.
Non-Abelian excitations are sought after because of the promise they hold for topological quantum computation. However, in spite of many proposals of systems in which they can occur intrinsically, observation has proved to be elusive. In this thesis, we study ways in which we can engineer such excitations by combining two parent Abelian theories, and as a result allow for defects which host non-Abelian zero modes. We first formulate the symmetries of the anyonic excitations of Abelian topological states. Then, we study properties of semiclassical point defects, called twist defects, which permute orbiting anyons by their symmetries. We see how to realize these defects at domain walls on the gapped edges of non-chiral fractional quantum Hall states. We have distinct gapped edge phases in one to one correspondence with the anyonic symmetries. Non-Abelian twist defects appear between different gapped phases. We study the twist defects for a variety of bosonic ADE fractional quantum spin Hall systems for which the anyonic symmetries turn out to be given by their Dynkin diagrams. We also look at superconducting heterostructures with fermionic quantum Hall states and show the presence of anyonic symmetries and twist defects which physically correspond to a fermion parity flip. This can result in Majorana bound states at such defects instead of more exotic parafermions as was believed before. This is because the presence of the superconductor necessitates the consideration of a larger bosonic topological order. We then investigate the twist defects further by promoting the anyonic symmetries from global to local. This deconfines the defects and results in non-Abelian topological states called twist liquids. Finally, we study the emergence of new topological order from two constituent systems driven by the condensation of a composite boson. This allows us to study a variety of systems with non-Abelian excitations.