arXiv:1207.4535 · Journal of Computational and Theoretical Nanoscience

Comparing Algorithms for Graph Isomorphism Using Discrete- and Continuous-Time Quantum Random Walks

Kenneth Rudinger, John King Gamble, Eric Bach, Mark G. Friesen, Robert Joynt, S. N. Coppersmith

Published Jun 20, 2013• 19 citations

Abstract

Berry and Wang [Phys. Rev. A {\bf 83}, 042317 (2011)] show numerically that a discrete-time quantum random walk of two noninteracting particles is able to distinguish some non-isomorphic strongly regular graphs from the same family. Here we analytically demonstrate how it is possible for these walks to distinguish such graphs, while continuous-time quantum walks of two noninteracting particles cannot. We show analytically and numerically that even single-particle discrete-time quantum random walks can distinguish some strongly regular graphs, though not as many as two-particle noninteracting discrete-time walks. Additionally, we demonstrate how, given the same quantum random walk, subtle differences in the graph certificate construction algorithm can nontrivially impact the walk's distinguishing power. We also show that no continuous-time walk of a fixed number of particles can distinguish all strongly regular graphs when used in conjunction with any of the graph certificates we consider. We extend this constraint to discrete-time walks of fixed numbers of noninteracting particles for one kind of graph certificate; it remains an open question as to whether or not this constraint applies to the other graph certificates we consider.

DOI: 10.1166/jctn.2013.3105

Related papers

Noninteracting multiparticle quantum random walks applied to the graph isomorphism problem for strongly regular graphs

Kenneth Rudinger, John King Gamble, M. Wellons +4 more

We investigate the quantum dynamics of particles on graphs (``quantum random walks''), with the aim of developing quantum algorithms for determining if two graphs are isomorphic (related to each other by a relabeling of vertices). We focus on quantum random walks of multiple noninteracting particles on strongly regular graphs (SRGs), a class of graphs with high symmetry that is known to have pairs of graphs that are hard to distinguish. Previous work has already demonstrated analytically that two-particle noninteracting quantum walks cannot distinguish nonisomorphic SRGs of the same family. Here, we demonstrate numerically that three-particle noninteracting quantum walks have significant, but not universal, distinguishing power for pairs of SRGs, proving a fundamental difference between the distinguishing power of two-particle and three-particle noninteracting walks. We show analytically why this distinguishing power is possible, whereas it is forbidden for two-particle noninteracting walks. Based on sampling of SRGs with up to 64 vertices, we find no difference in the distinguishing power of bosonic and fermionic walks. In addition, we find that the four-fermion noninteracting walk has greater distinguishing power than the three-particle walk on SRGs, showing that increasing the particle number increases the distinguishing power. However, we also show analytically that no noninteracting walk with a fixed number of particles can distinguish all SRGs, thus demonstrating a potential fundamental difference in the distinguishing power of interacting versus noninteracting walks.

arXiv:1206.2999Physical Review AAug 27, 201240 citations

Two-particle quantum walks applied to the graph isomorphism problem

John King Gamble, Mark G. Friesen, Dong Zhou +2 more

We show that the quantum dynamics of interacting and noninteracting quantum particles are fundamentally different in the context of solving a particular computational problem. Specifically, we consider the graph isomorphism problem, in which one wishes to determine whether two graphs are isomorphic (related to each other by a relabeling of the graph vertices), and focus on a class of graphs with particularly high symmetry called strongly regular graphs (SRGs). We study the Green's functions that characterize the dynamical evolution single-particle and two-particle quantum walks on pairs of nonisomorphic SRGs and show that interacting particles can distinguish nonisomorphic graphs that noninteracting particles cannot. We obtain the following specific results. (1) We prove that quantum walks of two noninteracting particles, fermions or bosons, cannot distinguish certain pairs of nonisomorphic SRGs. (2) We demonstrate numerically that two interacting bosons are more powerful than single particles and two noninteracting particles, in that quantum walks of interacting bosons distinguish all nonisomorphic pairs of SRGs that we examined. By utilizing high-throughput computing to perform over 500 million direct comparisons between evolution operators, we checked all tabulated pairs of nonisomorphic SRGs, including graphs with up to 64 vertices. (3) By performing a short-time expansion of the evolution operator, we derive distinguishing operators that provide analytic insight into the power of the interacting two-particle quantum walk.

arXiv:1002.3003Physical Review AMay 13, 2010145 citations

Phase-modified CTQW unable to distinguish strongly regular graphs efficiently

Anuradha Mahasinghe, Josh Izaac, Jingbo B. Wang +1 more

Various quantum walk-based algorithms have been developed, aiming to distinguish non-isomorphic graphs with polynomial scaling, within both the discrete-time quantum walk (DTQW) and continuous-time quantum walk (CTQW) frameworks. Whilst both the single-particle DTQW and CTQW have failed to distinguish non-isomorphic strongly regular graph families (prompting the move to multi-particle graph isomorphism (GI) algorithms), the single-particle DTQW has been successfully modified by the introduction of a phase factor to distinguish a wide range of graphs in polynomial time. In this paper, we prove that an analogous phase modification to the single particle CTQW does not have the same distinguishing power as its discrete-time counterpart, in particular it cannot distinguish strongly regular graphs with the same family parameters with the same efficiency.

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and TheoreticalJun 8, 20158 citations

Two-particle quantum walks: Entanglement and graph isomorphism testing

Scott M. Berry, Jingbo B. Wang

We study discrete-time quantum walks on the line and on general undirected graphs with two interacting or noninteracting particles. We introduce two simple interaction schemes and show that they both lead to a diverse range of probability distributions that depend on the correlations and relative phases between the initial coin states of the two particles. We investigate the characteristics of these quantum walks and the time evolution of the entanglement between the two particles from both separable and entangled initial states. We also test the capability of two-particle discrete-time quantum walks to distinguish nonisomorphic graphs. For strongly regular graphs, we show that noninteracting discrete-time quantum walks can distinguish some but not all nonisomorphic graphs with the same family parameters. By incorporating an interaction between the two particles, all nonisomorphic strongly regular graphs tested are successfully distinguished.

Physical Review AApr 14, 2011153 citations

A Graph Isomorphism Algorithm based on Continuous-Time Quantum Walks

Zhan Li, Yang Wang, Xiaogang Qiang

Graph isomorphism is an essential problem in graph theory and widely used in a variety of applications. With graph size increasing, graph isomorphism become difficult for classical computation since there is no polynomial algorithm for general graphs yet. Considering the advantages of quantum computation over classical computation in various tasks, quantum graph isomorphism algorithms have been studied to explore the potentials of quantum computation in graph isomorphism. In this work, we propose a graph isomorphism algorithm based on continuous-time quantum walks, where we construct the graph certificates from the output probabilities of continuous-time quantum walks on the tested graphs with added self-loops to graph vertices, and distinguish graphs by comparing the graph certificates. Numerous tests on diverse graph classes demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed GI algorithm, which is not limited to a specific topological structure graph. Moreover, we test the proposed algorithm on classes of strongly regular graphs, and the results show that the distinguishing ability of the algorithm can be improved with the increasement of the added self-loops to distinct vertices.

International Conference on Computing, Communication, Perception and Quantum Technology (CCPQT)Aug 4, 20232 citations

Multiparticle quantum walks for distinguishing hard graphs

Sachin Kasture, Shaheen Acheche, Loïc Henriet +1 more

Quantum random walks have been shown to be powerful quantum algorithms for certain tasks on graphs like database searching, quantum simulations etc. In this work we focus on its applications for the graph isomorphism problem. In particular we look at how we can compare multi-particle quantum walks and well known classical WL tests and how quantum walks can be used to distinguish hard graphs like CFI graphs which k-WL tests cannot distinguish. We provide theoretical proofs and empirical results to show that a k-QW with input superposition states distinguishes k-CFI graphs. In addition we also prove that a k-1 QW with localized input states distinguishes k-CFI graphs. We also prove some additional results about strongly regular graphs (SRGs).

arXiv:2501.03683Jan 7, 20250 citations